Madoff investers....

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Blu-ize
they lost time and money. Money over time would have produced x amount of dollars. They were bamboozled into thinking their money was invested. It wasn't. It doesn't matter the amount, they thought their money was invested in a fund, Madoff produced statements, they were a lie. The amount is irrelevant..it was their money and over so many years it could have earning a modest amount..now they have nothing and some really need it just to eat, pay for medication or anything else.



Exactly. Even if someone started with a $10k initial investment, with the average return from market investments of %6 per year, over the life of the fund, which started in 1960, so that's almost 50 years invested with a 6% return, that $10k investment can turn into a nice little retirement package.

If these people had known that their money was NEVER invested and wasn't making ANY returns, they would have pulled that $ out and put it in something else.

It's NOT greed - it's actually a simple legal principle of reliance. They relied on his false returns, and in doing that, they lost more than just their initial investments.

Posted 3/16/09 12:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Pumpkin1

I *think* I know what you are asking. Here is my issue with the Madoff investors: Many people are claiming that they lost huge amounts of money when it is unclear what their initial investment was. By illustration, let's say that the investor's Madoff statement said that their fund had a $1M, but their initial investment was $10K. IMO, that investor lost something closer to $15K ($10K with interest) and not $1M. (I hope this makes sense).



That is like saying I didn't really lose 50% of my 401k plan since a lot of that loss was from gains on investments, not from contributions.

The people that invested with Madoff thought their money was invested. They paid taxes on any realized gains. They did not think their money was sitting in Madoff's personal account funding his extravagant lifestyle. I don't know how it's possible to gloss over the fact that the investors were robbed.

Posted 3/16/09 12:18 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Madoff investers....

I just wanted to add that what they thought was money to retire on was false. Over the years they made financial decisions based on what they thought they had. I'm sure if they knew their money was not being invested they would have pulled it out and invested in something that was a solid investment.

Posted 3/16/09 12:47 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by jana

Posted by Pumpkin1

I *think* I know what you are asking. Here is my issue with the Madoff investors: Many people are claiming that they lost huge amounts of money when it is unclear what their initial investment was. By illustration, let's say that the investor's Madoff statement said that their fund had a $1M, but their initial investment was $10K. IMO, that investor lost something closer to $15K ($10K with interest) and not $1M. (I hope this makes sense).



Makes sense to me.



No, they lost a LOT more than their initial investment. They lost out on ACTUAL gains on that money over a period of years.

Posted 3/16/09 12:52 PM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Christine

That is like saying I didn't really lose 50% of my 401k plan since a lot of that loss was from gains on investments, not from contributions.

The people that invested with Madoff thought their money was invested. They paid taxes on any realized gains. They did not think their money was sitting in Madoff's personal account funding his extravagant lifestyle. I don't know how it's possible to gloss over the fact that the investors were robbed.



Please don't misunderstand me, these investors were robbed and there is no question about that. Madoff is a theif and he deserves everything he is getting. All of these investors suffered tremendous losses which is a travesty.

That being said, I have read that the "returns" that Madoff showed and promised were a fiction and were "just too good to be true." If that is true, a portion of these investors' "losses" fall under that "too good to be true" category.

Posted 3/16/09 12:54 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by Christine

That is like saying I didn't really lose 50% of my 401k plan since a lot of that loss was from gains on investments, not from contributions.

The people that invested with Madoff thought their money was invested. They paid taxes on any realized gains. They did not think their money was sitting in Madoff's personal account funding his extravagant lifestyle. I don't know how it's possible to gloss over the fact that the investors were robbed.



Please don't misunderstand me, these investors were robbed and there is no question about that. Madoff is a theif and he deserves everything he is getting. All of these investors suffered tremendous losses which is a travesty.

That being said, I have read that the "returns" that Madoff showed and promised were a fiction and were "just too good to be true." If that is true, a portion of these investors' "losses" fall under that "too good to be true" category.



To be clear, the %age of returns was not really "too good to be true." What WAS too good to be true was that Madoff's investors were apparently making decent returns (though not unusually high) very consistently. It was the consistency that was too good to be true, not the retuns themselves.

Regardless, wanting to make a high return on investment dollars does not make someone greedy. Plenty of people were doing a lot better in the market than Madoff's returns. They just likely weren't getting the same, consistent returns year after year.

ETA -- I was clarifying the "too good to be true" remark for the benefit of those who did not know. I wasn't saying you were implying something else.

Message edited 2009-03-16 13:04:34.037000.

Posted 3/16/09 1:03 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by Christine

That is like saying I didn't really lose 50% of my 401k plan since a lot of that loss was from gains on investments, not from contributions.

The people that invested with Madoff thought their money was invested. They paid taxes on any realized gains. They did not think their money was sitting in Madoff's personal account funding his extravagant lifestyle. I don't know how it's possible to gloss over the fact that the investors were robbed.



Please don't misunderstand me, these investors were robbed and there is no question about that. Madoff is a theif and he deserves everything he is getting. All of these investors suffered tremendous losses which is a travesty.

That being said, I have read that the "returns" that Madoff showed and promised were a fiction and were "just too good to be true." If that is true, a portion of these investors' "losses" fall under that "too good to be true" category.



I completely disagree.

The point of investing in the market is that it's a risk - but with that risk comes the potential for big profits, just as much as there is a risk for big losses.

His returns weren't extravagant - obviously not so much as to alert the SEC. And trust me, my husband owns a small mutual fund that's put through the ringer every 6 months by the SEC.

His company had been existence for almost 50 years, which could easily lead an investor astray in thinking it was stable, solid and secure. The SEC has its hands in every fund traded on the US stock exchange, so I would also presume, as a prudent investor, that, if it was in existence for almost 50 years, and continually monitored by the SEC, which it is supposed to do, that it was a solid investment. In fact, Madoff himself was the former chairperson of the NASDQ stock exchange!

I can EASILY see how many invested in his company with good reason, without characterizing them as greedy.

ETA - and take a look at the victim list. It consists mostly of organizations, including investment firms, banks, pension funds, charitable trusts, etc. Most of these are not individuals looking to make big bucks off the market - I'd venture to say most of the individuals impacted were those invested in the investment firms that decided to invest with Madoff, and it wasn't even their choice.

Investment victims

Message edited 2009-03-16 13:14:18.530000.

Posted 3/16/09 1:10 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

I read the opposite somewhere - that he reported more modest gains to avoid suspicion. I'll have to look it up again.

I also read an article where the people that took withdrawls could possibly have to pay it back since that money was basically stolen from someone else.

Posted 3/16/09 1:15 PM
 

Lizzie217
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/09

611 total posts

Name:
elizabeth

Re: Madoff investers....

I certaintly have sympathy for those people who lost their lifes saving. It IS awful.

HOWEVER when you are gettin 10% and every other fund is in the red, dont you ask? investigate? During the 90's when the dot com bubble burst(or whatever that was I was too young lol) and you are getting 10% while everyone is going broke ....

dont you say Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon no these people were happy they were makingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and it never occured to them that hey where is the paper work, proof?

They blindly trusted, turned the other way to a "fishy" operation and ultimatley it as "too good to b true"

I feel sorry for them yes, but I cant help but wonder how they thought THEY were making all this $$$ while everyone was going broke

Posted 3/16/09 1:16 PM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by mrswask

Posted by dottiemchugh

I really don't understand the feeling in this country, that if you are wealthy, you are greedy. It really bugs me.





It's called jealousyChat Icon



ding ding ding...you hit it right on the head

Its so sad....Chat Icon

Posted 3/16/09 1:18 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by BlovesE

I certaintly have sympathy for those people who lost their lifes saving. It IS awful.

HOWEVER when you are gettin 10% and every other fund is in the red, dont you ask? investigate? During the 90's when the dot com bubble burst(or whatever that was I was too young lol) and you are getting 10% while everyone is going broke ....

dont you say Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon no these people were happy they were makingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and it never occured to them that hey where is the paper work, proof?

They blindly trusted, turned the other way to a "fishy" operation and ultimatley it as "too good to b true"

I feel sorry for them yes, but I cant help but wonder how they thought THEY were making all this $$$ while everyone was going broke



Average return on the stock market is 6% - what he was reporting wasn't that much significantly higher, and the truth is, in ANY given market, some funds and investments do bad, while others do well, even during bad times, like a recession. Even NOW, there are cetain investments that are making good returns.

So, what, now we are going to place the onus and the burden on the individual to presume fraud with EVERY investment that makes a good return? That's ridiculous, particularly when we have a federal agency that is supposed to regulate these things.

Posted 3/16/09 1:19 PM
 

JenG
Love my little boy!

Member since 6/05

2489 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by libby2595

...

greedy s. o. b.s and this is par of the course





greedy sob's? WHAT? not even a term that would come to mind or that should even be used.

just people like you and i investing money

Posted 3/16/09 1:22 PM
 

mtnmama

Member since 5/06

4794 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by BlovesE

I certaintly have sympathy for those people who lost their lifes saving. It IS awful.

HOWEVER when you are gettin 10% and every other fund is in the red, dont you ask? investigate? During the 90's when the dot com bubble burst(or whatever that was I was too young lol) and you are getting 10% while everyone is going broke ....

dont you say Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon no these people were happy they were makingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and it never occured to them that hey where is the paper work, proof?

They blindly trusted, turned the other way to a "fishy" operation and ultimatley it as "too good to b true"

I feel sorry for them yes, but I cant help but wonder how they thought THEY were making all this $$$ while everyone was going broke

I'm an accountant, I was an auditor for 10 years. This is what I can't wrap my head around. How can you invest in something and not see exactly where your money is going into and where the returns are coming from? Maybe I am just skeptical b/c of my profession.

Message edited 2009-03-16 13:24:39.027000.

Posted 3/16/09 1:22 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by BlovesE

I certaintly have sympathy for those people who lost their lifes saving. It IS awful.

HOWEVER when you are gettin 10% and every other fund is in the red, dont you ask? investigate? During the 90's when the dot com bubble burst(or whatever that was I was too young lol) and you are getting 10% while everyone is going broke ....

dont you say Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon no these people were happy they were makingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and it never occured to them that hey where is the paper work, proof?

They blindly trusted, turned the other way to a "fishy" operation and ultimatley it as "too good to b true"

I feel sorry for them yes, but I cant help but wonder how they thought THEY were making all this $$$ while everyone was going broke



Average return on the stock market is 6% - what he was reporting wasn't that much significantly higher, and the truth is, in ANY given market, some funds and investments do bad, while others do well, even during bad times, like a recession. Even NOW, there are cetain investments that are making good returns.

So, what, now we are going to place the onus and the burden on the individual to presume fraud with EVERY investment that makes a good return? That's ridiculous, particularly when we have a federal agency that is supposed to regulate these things.



so stuff your money in your mattress...is that the answer?

There were many non tech funds that made money in the 90s. I was diversified. I didn't lose anything then. I had very little tech. My financial advisor shifted my investments to hedge against losing everything and made sure I was diversified. He was a real financial advisor with my best interests in mind.

The too good to be true argument doesn't hold up. People today are still making money even with the market down. So if lots of folks around me are losing money and I'm making money I should investigage my investments for fraud?

Message edited 2009-03-16 13:26:37.043000.

Posted 3/16/09 1:25 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by cpanyc

Posted by BlovesE

I certaintly have sympathy for those people who lost their lifes saving. It IS awful.

HOWEVER when you are gettin 10% and every other fund is in the red, dont you ask? investigate? During the 90's when the dot com bubble burst(or whatever that was I was too young lol) and you are getting 10% while everyone is going broke ....

dont you say Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon no these people were happy they were makingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and it never occured to them that hey where is the paper work, proof?

They blindly trusted, turned the other way to a "fishy" operation and ultimatley it as "too good to b true"

I feel sorry for them yes, but I cant help but wonder how they thought THEY were making all this $$$ while everyone was going broke

I'm an accountant, I was an auditor for 10 years. This is what I can't wrap my head around. How can you invest in something and not see exactly where your money is going into and where the returns are coming from? Maybe I am just skeptical b/c of my profession.



Actually, I thought the investors got detailed statements. I'm pretty sure he used actual stock prices on actual dates and made it look like he made those transactions. Obviously, however, he was working backwards, with the aid of hindsight... Correct me if I am wrong... I just thought I heard on the news that the investors always got detailed statements showing where their money supposedly was.

Posted 3/16/09 1:55 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Blu-ize

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by BlovesE

I certaintly have sympathy for those people who lost their lifes saving. It IS awful.

HOWEVER when you are gettin 10% and every other fund is in the red, dont you ask? investigate? During the 90's when the dot com bubble burst(or whatever that was I was too young lol) and you are getting 10% while everyone is going broke ....

dont you say Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon no these people were happy they were makingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and it never occured to them that hey where is the paper work, proof?

They blindly trusted, turned the other way to a "fishy" operation and ultimatley it as "too good to b true"

I feel sorry for them yes, but I cant help but wonder how they thought THEY were making all this $$$ while everyone was going broke



Average return on the stock market is 6% - what he was reporting wasn't that much significantly higher, and the truth is, in ANY given market, some funds and investments do bad, while others do well, even during bad times, like a recession. Even NOW, there are cetain investments that are making good returns.

So, what, now we are going to place the onus and the burden on the individual to presume fraud with EVERY investment that makes a good return? That's ridiculous, particularly when we have a federal agency that is supposed to regulate these things.



so stuff your money in your mattress...is that the answer?

There were many non tech funds that made money in the 90s. I was diversified. I didn't lose anything then. I had very little tech. My financial advisor shifted my investments to hedge against losing everything and made sure I was diversified. He was a real financial advisor with my best interests in mind.

The too good to be true argument doesn't hold up. People today are still making money even with the market down. So if lots of folks around me are losing money and I'm making money I should investigage my investments for fraud?



Seriously. Now in addition to bailing out those who got in over their heads, we should looks askance at those who seem to have generated some success and ask why they didn't push back?????

Posted 3/16/09 1:57 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Kara
Actually, I thought the investors got detailed statements. I'm pretty sure he used actual stock prices on actual dates and made it look like he made those transactions. Obviously, however, he was working backwards, with the aid of hindsight... Correct me if I am wrong... I just thought I heard on the news that the investors always got detailed statements showing where their money supposedly was.



This is what the news s reporting - he sent fraudulent monthly account statements to all his investors, including trade confirmations. This is why they think he didn't act alone, that it was WAY too elaborate a scheme for an individual to maintain.

And seriously, how many people who invest, whether through a retirement plan or individuallly, do more than review their quarterly statements? Why on earth would we put the burden on the investor if everything appeared kosher? It was a solid standing investment company in existence for over 40 years, was regulated by the SEC, with a president who used to be the NASDAQ chairperson...

Posted 3/16/09 2:05 PM
 

HarleyGirlFLA
Come on in

Member since 5/05

9674 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Madoff investers....

My old neighbor worked for Madoff. She invested 30 years of not just dedicated employement but was also an investor. She lost her job, her pension, her investment, everything. She lost over 10 million dollars.

I honestly hope she is able to get something back.

Posted 3/16/09 2:14 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Madoff investers....

Forty years ago, my grandmas accountant recomended she invest with his son in law. Bernie Madoff. She did, and saw it worked well for her. She was a teacher, my grandpa worked until the day he died. My dad also invested with him because of my grandma. They saw how much they were getting, and were pleased. My family is not greedy. They were planning on this money being my inheritance. I was hoping this money I inherited would put my kid in college someday.

Posted 3/16/09 2:15 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by Kara
Actually, I thought the investors got detailed statements. I'm pretty sure he used actual stock prices on actual dates and made it look like he made those transactions. Obviously, however, he was working backwards, with the aid of hindsight... Correct me if I am wrong... I just thought I heard on the news that the investors always got detailed statements showing where their money supposedly was.



This is what the news s reporting - he sent fraudulent monthly account statements to all his investors, including trade confirmations. This is why they think he didn't act alone, that it was WAY too elaborate a scheme for an individual to maintain.

And seriously, how many people who invest, whether through a retirement plan or individuallly, do more than review their quarterly statements? Why on earth would we put the burden on the investor if everything appeared kosher? It was a solid standing investment company in existence for over 40 years, was regulated by the SEC, with a president who used to be the NASDAQ chairperson...



I completely agree, Beth. I'm not talking about this board, but just generally, I think it's mainly people who don't invest who are having the most trouble understanding how people got scammed out of so much money...

Posted 3/16/09 2:16 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Kara

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by Kara
Actually, I thought the investors got detailed statements. I'm pretty sure he used actual stock prices on actual dates and made it look like he made those transactions. Obviously, however, he was working backwards, with the aid of hindsight... Correct me if I am wrong... I just thought I heard on the news that the investors always got detailed statements showing where their money supposedly was.



This is what the news s reporting - he sent fraudulent monthly account statements to all his investors, including trade confirmations. This is why they think he didn't act alone, that it was WAY too elaborate a scheme for an individual to maintain.

And seriously, how many people who invest, whether through a retirement plan or individuallly, do more than review their quarterly statements? Why on earth would we put the burden on the investor if everything appeared kosher? It was a solid standing investment company in existence for over 40 years, was regulated by the SEC, with a president who used to be the NASDAQ chairperson...



I completely agree, Beth. I'm not talking about this board, but just generally, I think it's mainly people who don't invest who are having the most trouble understanding how people got scammed out of so much money...



Agreed. That's what I'm getting from this thread. There's risk associated with investing but the rewards can be worth the risk.

Yes, statements, trade confirmations and settlements were sent out to the investors according to what I've read.

Posted 3/16/09 2:34 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Madoff investers....

These people also paid taxes on these "returns" - it is like pouring salt on the wounds!

Posted 3/16/09 2:35 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Madoff investers....

My dad told me the day he heard the news- before anyone heard it through media- that he was just looking over the report the day before and thought, wow, this guy is a genius. In a time where there are honest people who genuinely good At what they do, my dad had faith in this man. He owns his own business, and certainly didn't have all his eggs there, but he lost a significant portion of his retirement money.

Posted 3/16/09 2:36 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Madoff investers....

I also think people in general need to realize that not everyone who invested with Madoff were really wealthy. A lot of them just invested their retirement money with him - and worked "normal" jobs and relied on his good investing skills (Chat Icon) to obtain them a secure retirement. My father is friendly with a man who falls right into this category... worked a civil service job, never made a whole lot of money, and was just trying to secure a nice retirement for him and his wife. Now, because of Madoff, he has nothing and has to go try to find part-time work just to get by when he is in his 60's.

I just think that, in addition to everything else that was said here, people in general need to realize that there were a lot of stories like you see above - not just ultra wealthy people (not that they deserve it either). But, when I hear people talking about wealthy people like they aren't real people and scoffing that "they have SO much anyway it won't make a difference" it just makes me shake my head. Chat Icon

Posted 3/16/09 2:37 PM
 

ILJ619
LIF Adult

Member since 6/06

1985 total posts

Name:
Irene

Re: Madoff investers....

If I were in an investor in his fund I would hope to get as much back as possible, more than my initial investment for sure. But I do think that SOME people who say they lost millions are basing it on their last statement so the return was bogus and unfortunately will have to make do with 500K. Its going to be hard to pay back people's initial investment plus a 10% return each year they had an account with Madoff. Its a sad situation and I especially feel bad for the elderly, not so much for the hedge funds or corporations but the actual individuals who invested their life savings. I think the fact that he is sequestered in his penthouse is ridiculous though.

Posted 3/16/09 3:06 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ex-financier Madoff pleads guilty to all charges Disgraced investor jailed until sentencing, says ‘deeply sorry,’ ‘ashamed’ HoneyBadger 3/12/09 8 Families Helping Families ™
Madoff files appeal to get out of jail SweetestOfPeas 3/13/09 12 Families Helping Families ™
house arrest for Madoff in $7M park ave apt, instead of jail evnme 12/17/08 20 Families Helping Families ™
Madoff scam lipglossjunky73 12/12/08 7 Families Helping Families ™