Re: Madoff investers....
Posted 3/16/2009 1:10:43 PM by Bxgell2


Posted by Pumpkin1


Posted by Christine

That is like saying I didn't really lose 50% of my 401k plan since a lot of that loss was from gains on investments, not from contributions.

The people that invested with Madoff thought their money was invested. They paid taxes on any realized gains. They did not think their money was sitting in Madoff's personal account funding his extravagant lifestyle. I don't know how it's possible to gloss over the fact that the investors were robbed.



Please don't misunderstand me, these investors were robbed and there is no question about that. Madoff is a theif and he deserves everything he is getting. All of these investors suffered tremendous losses which is a travesty.

That being said, I have read that the "returns" that Madoff showed and promised were a fiction and were "just too good to be true." If that is true, a portion of these investors' "losses" fall under that "too good to be true" category.



I completely disagree.

The point of investing in the market is that it's a risk - but with that risk comes the potential for big profits, just as much as there is a risk for big losses.

His returns weren't extravagant - obviously not so much as to alert the SEC. And trust me, my husband owns a small mutual fund that's put through the ringer every 6 months by the SEC.

His company had been existence for almost 50 years, which could easily lead an investor astray in thinking it was stable, solid and secure. The SEC has its hands in every fund traded on the US stock exchange, so I would also presume, as a prudent investor, that, if it was in existence for almost 50 years, and continually monitored by the SEC, which it is supposed to do, that it was a solid investment. In fact, Madoff himself was the former chairperson of the NASDQ stock exchange!

I can EASILY see how many invested in his company with good reason, without characterizing them as greedy.

ETA - and take a look at the victim list. It consists mostly of organizations, including investment firms, banks, pension funds, charitable trusts, etc. Most of these are not individuals looking to make big bucks off the market - I'd venture to say most of the individuals impacted were those invested in the investment firms that decided to invest with Madoff, and it wasn't even their choice.

Investment victims
Print Post      Close Window