Re: Madoff investers....
Posted 3/16/2009 1:03:06 PM by Kara
Posted by Pumpkin1
Posted by Christine
That is like saying I didn't really lose 50% of my 401k plan since a lot of that loss was from gains on investments, not from contributions.
The people that invested with Madoff thought their money was invested. They paid taxes on any realized gains. They did not think their money was sitting in Madoff's personal account funding his extravagant lifestyle. I don't know how it's possible to gloss over the fact that the investors were robbed.
Please don't misunderstand me, these investors were robbed and there is no question about that. Madoff is a theif and he deserves everything he is getting. All of these investors suffered tremendous losses which is a travesty.
That being said, I have read that the "returns" that Madoff showed and promised were a fiction and were "just too good to be true." If that is true, a portion of these investors' "losses" fall under that "too good to be true" category.
To be clear, the %age of returns was not really "too good to be true." What WAS too good to be true was that Madoff's investors were apparently making decent returns (though not unusually high) very consistently. It was the consistency that was too good to be true, not the retuns themselves.
Regardless, wanting to make a high return on investment dollars does not make someone greedy. Plenty of people were doing a lot better in the market than Madoff's returns. They just likely weren't getting the same, consistent returns year after year.
ETA -- I was clarifying the "too good to be true" remark for the benefit of those who did not know. I wasn't saying you were implying something else.
|