Madoff investers....

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

Ali1
Mommy

Member since 8/05

3116 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

While I feel truly sorry for these people and think Madoff should Rot for a long time I do take issue with something I read in Newsday this weekend and others have alluded to on this thread.

One couple lost what they claimed to be 1 million and that was what they are going to fight for, but their original investment was $10,000. I don't recall how many years there were investing but I have to assume a long time.

They stated they believe the government should recoup them for the $1 million and not just 10K. I have an issue with that. They should get their money back from the IRS for the gains they might have claimed and the original 10K, but not the other 990,000. Sorry.....you trusted one man to invest all your money. You clearly didn't research him too much because there were many people outspoken on the fact that this man was not on the up and up. Plus those "gains" are fabricated. Someone else who invested the same amount, probably didn't have constant 10% gains like Madoff was claiming these people had.

I feel it's like me asking the government to recoup my investments that i have lost in the past few months. If you invest (or even turn money over to someone to invest) in the stock market you are taking on risk. You can't expect the government to compensate you for what was an error in judgement by you.

So while I feel incredibly sad for these people and hope they can get back some of their money, I do believe their are some being a little greedy about what the government should recoup to them.

JMO...

Posted 3/16/09 4:02 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Ali1

While I feel truly sorry for these people and think Madoff should Rot for a long time I do take issue with something I read in Newsday this weekend and others have alluded to on this thread.

One couple lost what they claimed to be 1 million and that was what they are going to fight for, but their original investment was $10,000. I don't recall how many years there were investing but I have to assume a long time.

They stated they believe the government should recoup them for the $1 million and not just 10K. I have an issue with that. They should get their money back from the IRS for the gains they might have claimed and the original 10K, but not the other 990,000. Sorry.....you trusted one man to invest all your money. You clearly didn't research him too much because there were many people outspoken on the fact that this man was not on the up and up. Plus those "gains" are fabricated. Someone else who invested the same amount, probably didn't have constant 10% gains like Madoff was claiming these people had.

I feel it's like me asking the government to recoup my investments that i have lost in the past few months. If you invest (or even turn money over to someone to invest) in the stock market you are taking on risk. You can't expect the government to compensate you for what was an error in judgement by you.

So while I feel incredibly sad for these people and hope they can get back some of their money, I do believe their are some being a little greedy about what the government should recoup to them.

JMO...



I agree with this...I feel badly for these people....but I also think...what about "Diversify, diversify, diversify"?

Posted 3/16/09 4:16 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Ali1

While I feel truly sorry for these people and think Madoff should Rot for a long time I do take issue with something I read in Newsday this weekend and others have alluded to on this thread.

One couple lost what they claimed to be 1 million and that was what they are going to fight for, but their original investment was $10,000. I don't recall how many years there were investing but I have to assume a long time.

They stated they believe the government should recoup them for the $1 million and not just 10K. I have an issue with that. They should get their money back from the IRS for the gains they might have claimed and the original 10K, but not the other 990,000. Sorry.....you trusted one man to invest all your money. You clearly didn't research him too much because there were many people outspoken on the fact that this man was not on the up and up. Plus those "gains" are fabricated. Someone else who invested the same amount, probably didn't have constant 10% gains like Madoff was claiming these people had.

I feel it's like me asking the government to recoup my investments that i have lost in the past few months. If you invest (or even turn money over to someone to invest) in the stock market you are taking on risk. You can't expect the government to compensate you for what was an error in judgement by you.

So while I feel incredibly sad for these people and hope they can get back some of their money, I do believe their are some being a little greedy about what the government should recoup to them.

JMO...



I agree with this.

I can't (and won't comment) on anything about the case, however, there is no way people should be recouped for the total amount they believed they gained on the investment.

if ANYTHING, and average rate of return over similar funds for the duration of the scam should be calculated, and then applied to the original investment...essentially try to figure out how much the average person would have gained if they had invested in a fund that was NOT a Ponzi from the point of their initial investment.

ETA: for me, it's not even that they were wrong to sink it all into one fund...it's just that the ROR promised by Madoff was a fiction...so the actual losses suffered should be calculated by FACT.

Message edited 2009-03-16 16:19:39.420000.

Posted 3/16/09 4:18 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Ali1

While I feel truly sorry for these people and think Madoff should Rot for a long time I do take issue with something I read in Newsday this weekend and others have alluded to on this thread.

One couple lost what they claimed to be 1 million and that was what they are going to fight for, but their original investment was $10,000. I don't recall how many years there were investing but I have to assume a long time.

They stated they believe the government should recoup them for the $1 million and not just 10K. I have an issue with that. They should get their money back from the IRS for the gains they might have claimed and the original 10K, but not the other 990,000. Sorry.....you trusted one man to invest all your money. You clearly didn't research him too much because there were many people outspoken on the fact that this man was not on the up and up. Plus those "gains" are fabricated. Someone else who invested the same amount, probably didn't have constant 10% gains like Madoff was claiming these people had.

I feel it's like me asking the government to recoup my investments that i have lost in the past few months. If you invest (or even turn money over to someone to invest) in the stock market you are taking on risk. You can't expect the government to compensate you for what was an error in judgement by you.

So while I feel incredibly sad for these people and hope they can get back some of their money, I do believe their are some being a little greedy about what the government should recoup to them.

JMO...



The guy was convicted of a crime. It's not the same as you lost money in your investments and you're asking the gov't to bail you out. He took everyone's money and lived the high life. He drew up this whole thing based on lies but made it look like it was legit. He misled people for decades..smart financially saavy people..foundations, corporation with financial people at the helm. He was very good at making everything look legit. He's a sociopath and had everyone fooled and the regulatory arm of our government didn't oversee his firm.

At the end of the day people will only get pennies on the dollar anyway..they won't even get their initial investments so it doesn't matter what they should get back. Taxes on gains are substantial, especially over certain thresholds.

I know people who personally lost money and they did investigate him..they did their due diligence. Not one red flag came up for anyone.

Easy to be a Monday quarterback, but nobody saw just how much of a crook this guy was. I still think he and his firm believe they did nothing wrong.

They guy is a criminal, he has been found guilty, he confessed, it's not the same as you made a bad investment. The government didn't oversee or regulate his dealings..they are partially responsible.


Posted 3/16/09 4:31 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Madoff investers....

I am not sure why any investers should be called a greedy SOB.

In that case anyone with a saving account, CD, 401K, bonds, or interest yielding type account should be called a greedy SOB.

The problem is not about bad investments that Madoff made. It's about "fake" representations. He took the money for his own use. There was no investment. He took people's money. He did not invest the money.

Message edited 2009-03-16 18:53:03.720000.

Posted 3/16/09 6:48 PM
 

Ali1
Mommy

Member since 8/05

3116 total posts

Name:

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by Blu-ize

The guy was convicted of a crime. It's not the same as you lost money in your investments and you're asking the gov't to bail you out. He took everyone's money and lived the high life. He drew up this whole thing based on lies but made it look like it was legit. He misled people for decades..smart financially saavy people..foundations, corporation with financial people at the helm. He was very good at making everything look legit. He's a sociopath and had everyone fooled and the regulatory arm of our government didn't oversee his firm.

At the end of the day people will only get pennies on the dollar anyway..they won't even get their initial investments so it doesn't matter what they should get back. Taxes on gains are substantial, especially over certain thresholds.

I know people who personally lost money and they did investigate him..they did their due diligence. Not one red flag came up for anyone.

Easy to be a Monday quarterback, but nobody saw just how much of a crook this guy was. I still think he and his firm believe they did nothing wrong.

They guy is a criminal, he has been found guilty, he confessed, it's not the same as you made a bad investment. The government didn't oversee or regulate his dealings..they are partially responsible.





Not contesting the fact he is a criminal, and the worst type at that. What I am saying is that I think these people are being greedy to believe that the Government should pay them back for the $$$ they thought they were making off their original investment. I understand the thought that if this guy was not a crook or they invested the $$$ somewhere else they probably would have made more $$$ then their original investment. However, they took a risk investing their money with anyone.......does it suck, yes...but it was a risk. They could have invested with a guy who lost all their money, but who was not a crook....they still would not deserve to get that money back.

And I am still SHOCKED at how many people, charities, etc. invested everything with this guy and did not diversify. DH and I would never do that.......I don't care how much money one person or company is cliaming they are making for us.

And as for the mention that no one had any idea that this was a crook....there were grumblings about this guy since 1999.

Posted 3/16/09 10:23 PM
 

wannabemom
look who's freshly baked!

Member since 12/07

7364 total posts

Name:
aka marriedinportjeff

Re: Madoff investers....

ok, to play devil's advocate here.... I DO know why some would call the investors greedy. It has nothing to do with their degree of wealth (as many charities and middle class people were swindled).... it has to do with what they invested IN..... that 'fund' had significantly higher (and many say unreasonably higher) rates of return than all other funds....

If a person is cautious, the super-duper fund should seem suspicious to them. Sort of like a more sophistocated version of "you just won a carribean vacation... just call this # with you personal info"

OK, done playing devil's advocate...
Would I have fallen for such a set-up? most definitely I would have... Would I be PO'ed? Sure. That man's entire extended family and most of his employees should probably go to jail and have all their assets seized.

oh, and as for the gov't should bail them out.... nope, it's not FDIC insured, and they knew they were risking their $....

I will say, however, that the SEC is shameful. they knew about this situation for a decade and did NADA. If it were me, I might sue the US gov't becuase of that... I'm sure a good lawyer could come up with a legit accusation... by inaction they failed their responsibilties and are almost co-conspirators, if you know what I mean....

Message edited 2009-03-17 00:13:53.683000.

Posted 3/17/09 12:09 AM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Madoff investers....

Posted by wannabemom

ok, to play devil's advocate here.... I DO know why some would call the investors greedy. It has nothing to do with their degree of wealth (as many charities and middle class people were swindled).... it has to do with what they invested IN..... that 'fund' had significantly higher (and many say unreasonably higher) rates of return than all other funds....

If a person is cautious, the super-duper fund should seem suspicious to them. Sort of like a more sophistocated version of "you just won a carribean vacation... just call this # with you personal info"

OK, done playing devil's advocate...
Would I have fallen for such a set-up? most definitely I would have... Would I be PO'ed? Sure. That man's entire extended family and most of his employees should probably go to jail and have all their assets seized.

oh, and as for the gov't should bail them out.... nope, it's not FDIC insured, and they knew they were risking their $....

I will say, however, that the SEC is shameful. they knew about this situation for a decade and did NADA. If it were me, I might sue the US gov't becuase of that... I'm sure a good lawyer could come up with a legit accusation... by inaction they failed their responsibilties and are almost co-conspirators, if you know what I mean....



In defence of the victims, Madoff had a lot of help from others. The guy on LI that was arrested is linked to it. One of our friend used to work next to him in a brokerage firm. He would have never guessed the guy could be in this scam. It involves people that work in the investment field for years. It's also a World of work by reputation and referal. That's what happened. Friend of a friend told them about it, etc... Brokers who they sought were ethical.

Message edited 2009-03-17 08:22:52.913000.

Posted 3/17/09 8:22 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ex-financier Madoff pleads guilty to all charges Disgraced investor jailed until sentencing, says ‘deeply sorry,’ ‘ashamed’ HoneyBadger 3/12/09 8 Families Helping Families ™
Madoff files appeal to get out of jail SweetestOfPeas 3/13/09 12 Families Helping Families ™
house arrest for Madoff in $7M park ave apt, instead of jail evnme 12/17/08 20 Families Helping Families ™
Madoff scam lipglossjunky73 12/12/08 7 Families Helping Families ™