LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5

McSullivan
.

Member since 5/05

1573 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by alli3131
SO BLAME THE MTA.



Thank you, but I will blame both of you! How dare you both treat the commuters like pawns in your stupid quest for more money, when that additional money comes from the people you are screwing.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Whoever wins in this entire debacle, it's the commuter that loses. We're being held over a barrel and have no control over what happens.

Posted 7/15/14 10:15 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by luvmotherhood

The big picture here is union vs non union. I am non union, Dh is union.
In my private sector job, we haven't gotten a raise in over four years.
Dh in union has also not received a raise and has been workin without a contract. He is not permitted to strike. The point is- costs keep rising and us middle class are getting screwed. Middle class will die out. I say let them strike. I certainly can't. But why shouldn't they fight for what they deserve? Maybe it will help the middle class out in the long run.
Lots of resentment on this post ladies.
Lirr workers aren't rich.



At THIS point they are NOT striking for "what they deserve".

My understanding, and tell me if I am wrong is that they have basically agreed to everything except the new hires.

Right now the sticking point ONLY is "new Hires" or as they say "unborn".

Its mind numbing to think that the union of today THINKS the union of TOMORROW deserves the exact same benefits they have.

The union and their members HAVE to adjust to the times.

So what if the new hires have to pay more into their OWN pension and their OWN medical. That's not unreasonable for the MTA to ask for.

The union CANT expect that their members will have the same benefits forever.

And I don't think anyone is saying people who work in the union are rich. They are, for the most part, middle class like most of us.

But NEW hires sure as hell can pay their fair share as costs go up. I am CERTAINLY asked to pay MY fair share in my ticket price. Actually, I am FORCED to pay what the MTA says I have to pay with no say in the matter.

My say is the union is unreasonable in holding out for new hires.

And I will say again that the MTA is not rainbows and ice cream. They run the worst operation with exceptional mismanagement which is ALSO causing the problem.

But right now its the Union. New members should pay for their medical and pension just like I have to pay for mine...and theirs.

Posted 7/15/14 10:28 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Why is the fault of the striking union members who have been without a contract for years, who were supposed to strike in March but delayed it until the summer for the MTA to come to terms that TWO INDEPENDENT MEDIATORS put out as reasonable?

My understanding is mediation means both sides come to the middle on terms. If there was no mediation, I could see blaming the union here.

Posted 7/15/14 11:28 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by Paramount

************************************************Observation************

So I have spoken to all the conductors on my trains for the past 2/3 days. EVERY one. ( I take the same train in AM and PM, but take different trains to Jamaica from Penn, so I speak to a bunch of different conductors)

EVERY ONE says "I don't know anything about the strike. I just do what I'm told. I know what you know from the papers just like you."

REALLY?

It’s unbelievable. They are all ready to strike but yet have NO idea what is being fought for, for THEM, or what is being negotiated ON THEIR BEHALF??????

Or what THEIR representatives are discussing FOR them???????

UNBELIEVABLE!!!!




They were obviously instructed to say this and not to speculate in front of the commuters, considering they are all saying the same thing. The conductor on my train this morning said the same EXACT thing.

Posted 7/15/14 11:36 AM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by hmm

all I can say after reading all this is Im exhausted. I work for a union and cant say I like it, I don't like paying dues or having someone suggest who I should vote for. Unions prevent me from getting the pay I should be getting, because we all must make the same. I can be 10x better then joe smith but it doesn't matter.Even though I have grad degree and still paying off the loans. This is truly a hot topic.



This is interesting to me because I also work for a professional union and I see first-hand a lot of union-blaming that goes on in our place of business. The members of often mis-informed about things like raises. Sure, we all make the same if we are at the same pay grade if we all start at the salary minimums outlined by the union contract. However, they are just minimums. Management could pay anyone as much as they want - MORE THAN THE MINS - or give merit raises at their disecretion. Guess what. That NEVER happens. So, what I've come to learn, is that if the union wasn't in place, none of us would be making anywhere near even the minimums. They have options to reward good employees or to pay people more but they don't do it. Of course. Just a personal rant about how people think a union is holding them back, but really, it's not the case. At my place of work, at least.

ETA: when I started at my job, I had a higher salary requirement and was told by my HR that they couldn't pay me that because salaries were dicated by the union. Right of the bat presenting the union in a negative light. It's wrong, because they could have paid me what I wanted, they didn't want to. And easy to blame the union.

Message edited 2014-07-15 11:44:26.737000.

Posted 7/15/14 11:41 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Paramount

************************************************Observation************

So I have spoken to all the conductors on my trains for the past 2/3 days. EVERY one. ( I take the same train in AM and PM, but take different trains to Jamaica from Penn, so I speak to a bunch of different conductors)

EVERY ONE says "I don't know anything about the strike. I just do what I'm told. I know what you know from the papers just like you."

REALLY?

It’s unbelievable. They are all ready to strike but yet have NO idea what is being fought for, for THEM, or what is being negotiated ON THEIR BEHALF??????

Or what THEIR representatives are discussing FOR them???????

UNBELIEVABLE!!!!




They were obviously instructed to say this and not to speculate in front of the commuters, considering they are all saying the same thing. The conductor on my train this morning said the same EXACT thing.



I agree. And they are not in the actual meetings and know the specifics.

Plus think of it much like how we elect people. We don't know the exact things going on in the government but we elect people to look out of our best interests. The union officials are acting much like our elected officials....and lets keep the comments about our feelings on the gift out of it...I am just using it as an example of how it works

Message edited 2014-07-15 11:43:33.013000.

Posted 7/15/14 11:41 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by nrthshgrl

Why is the fault of the striking union members who have been without a contract for years, who were supposed to strike in March but delayed it until the summer for the MTA to come to terms that TWO INDEPENDENT MEDIATORS put out as reasonable?

My understanding is mediation means both sides come to the middle on terms. If there was no mediation, I could see blaming the union here.




Just because a mediator said it doesn't make it right.

The LIRR is in serious trouble, fares are rising past inflation and it's going to cripple the island. The latest proposal by the MTA was more than fair yet the Union doesn't want to accept it.

Posted 7/15/14 11:42 AM
 

McSullivan
.

Member since 5/05

1573 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Chat Icon

Posted 7/15/14 12:15 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by alli3131

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Paramount

************************************************Observation************

So I have spoken to all the conductors on my trains for the past 2/3 days. EVERY one. ( I take the same train in AM and PM, but take different trains to Jamaica from Penn, so I speak to a bunch of different conductors)

EVERY ONE says "I don't know anything about the strike. I just do what I'm told. I know what you know from the papers just like you."

REALLY?

It’s unbelievable. They are all ready to strike but yet have NO idea what is being fought for, for THEM, or what is being negotiated ON THEIR BEHALF??????

Or what THEIR representatives are discussing FOR them???????

UNBELIEVABLE!!!!




They were obviously instructed to say this and not to speculate in front of the commuters, considering they are all saying the same thing. The conductor on my train this morning said the same EXACT thing.



I agree. And they are not in the actual meetings and know the specifics.

Plus think of it much like how we elect people. We don't know the exact things going on in the government but we elect people to look out of our best interests. The union officials are acting much like our elected officials....and lets keep the comments about our feelings on the gift out of it...I am just using it as an example of how it works



Fair enough.

Posted 7/15/14 12:17 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by ave1024

Posted by nrthshgrl

Why is the fault of the striking union members who have been without a contract for years, who were supposed to strike in March but delayed it until the summer for the MTA to come to terms that TWO INDEPENDENT MEDIATORS put out as reasonable?

My understanding is mediation means both sides come to the middle on terms. If there was no mediation, I could see blaming the union here.




Just because a mediator said it doesn't make it right.

The LIRR is in serious trouble, fares are rising past inflation and it's going to cripple the island. The latest proposal by the MTA was more than fair yet the Union doesn't want to accept it.



Then I guess my definition of mediation isn't your definition.

What is "more than fair"?


Edited to add:

If I was a conductor, I wouldn't engage in conversations with passengers over this. While someone people are sympathetic towards them, plenty of people are hostile.

Message edited 2014-07-15 12:19:39.700000.

Posted 7/15/14 12:18 PM
 

w8andsee
LIF Adult

Member since 10/09

1193 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by Paramount


Its mind numbing to think that the union of today THINKS the union of TOMORROW deserves the exact same benefits they have.




The reasoning behind it is that when you eventually have union members with different contracts it creates a rift and resentment within the union. You are suppose to be all the same, receiving the same benefits. Without solidarity you are basically weakening the union and that's what they are afraid of. Its happened to other unions, for example the airlines.

Message edited 2014-07-15 12:20:27.590000.

Posted 7/15/14 12:19 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by w8andsee

Posted by Paramount


Its mind numbing to think that the union of today THINKS the union of TOMORROW deserves the exact same benefits they have.




The reasoning behind it is that when you eventually have union members with different contracts it creates a rift and resentment within the union. You are suppose to be all the same, receiving the same benefits. Without solidarity you are basically weakening the union and that's what they are afraid of. Its happened to other unions, for example the airlines.



I'm sorry but that reasoning is ridiculous. And so what if the union weakens and, gasp, becomes undone. With OSHA, DOL, and various other agencies, I"m not so sure how relevant or needed unions are today.

Plus, there are plenty of unions where new members are not afforded the same benefits of older members. It's how it goes. And it's reasonable.

Someone a few pages back mentioned that benefits where why people took public sector jobs because they don't pay as well as private sector...well guess what, there is very little, if none on a mean basis, in the differences between private and public sector jobs in pay.

And this isn't about since I have crappy benefits, so should everyone else. It's about efficiently operating businesses in the world economy of today. Both private and public businesses need to adapt to the changing world economy and environment. Public sector businesses are so inefficient, poorly managed and corrupt businesses there are today. That is because they rely on taxes, rate hikes, etc to overcome that mismanagement. Private sector tends to not be able to sustain that so they tend to run more efficiently. Perhaps it's time to privatize again.

Posted 7/15/14 12:46 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by CookiePuss

I'm sorry but that reasoning is ridiculous. And so what if the union weakens and, gasp, becomes undone. With OSHA, DOL, and various other agencies, I"m not so sure how relevant or needed unions are today.

Plus, there are plenty of unions where new members are not afforded the same benefits of older members. It's how it goes. And it's reasonable.

Someone a few pages back mentioned that benefits where why people took public sector jobs because they don't pay as well as private sector...well guess what, there is very little, if none on a mean basis, in the differences between private and public sector jobs in pay.

And this isn't about since I have crappy benefits, so should everyone else. It's about efficiently operating businesses in the world economy of today. Both private and public businesses need to adapt to the changing world economy and environment. Public sector businesses are so inefficient, poorly managed and corrupt businesses there are today. That is because they rely on taxes, rate hikes, etc to overcome that mismanagement. Private sector tends to not be able to sustain that so they tend to run more efficiently. Perhaps it's time to privatize again.



So what if it weakens & erodes the union? I would think the union & its members would care deeply about that. It weakens their bargaining position going forward - which means more concessions on the union members parts every time they need to go to the table.

That's exactly why they won't do it. You are asking the union to self destruct itself. Who would try to ensure that their kids will have a lower standard of living then they have now?

As for the MTA AND LIRR, there is NO QUESTION it is mismanaged. I worked for an attorney that represented many railroads. The biggest & best thing they could do to offset their costs is to move freight - which happens minimally.

Message edited 2014-07-15 13:11:44.110000.

Posted 7/15/14 1:11 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by nrthshgrl

So what if it weakens & erodes the union? I would think the union & its members would care deeply about that. It weakens their bargaining position going forward - which means more concessions on the union members parts every time they need to go to the table.




They should not expect to get the EXACT same thing every time they go to the table. That is our point.

They CANT expect that the union of 2020 will have the same benefits. Its unrealistic.

And by "giving in" it makes them weaker? You don't have a weaker union because their members pay more for the benefits they receive. (But I do know you mean the power to negotiate).

Again, *I* am going to be forced to pay for their pension and medical. I am held hostage by their bargaining. I am forced to pay whatever the price is set by the MTA with no say at all. My say is let the unions pay more for their own services, therefore keeping the ridership's money in the ridership's pocket.

And again, we ALL agree and I will absolutely say that the mismanagement of the MTA is equally to blame for this.

but right now it stands squarely on the shoulders of the Union.

Both sides suck.

Posted 7/15/14 1:18 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by Paramount



but right now it stands squarely on the shoulders of the Union.

Both sides suck.



But why the union? I'm just trying to understand.

again there were two proposals that were accepted by Federal mediators as to what they thought was "fair" & the MTA rejected them.

I'm also curious as to what the F both sides have been doing for the past 4 months because it shouldnt' come down to the wire.

As for the MTA's contigency plan, it's a complete cluster fluck.

Posted 7/15/14 1:23 PM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by Paramount



but right now it stands squarely on the shoulders of the Union.

Both sides suck.



But why the union? I'm just trying to understand.

again there were two proposals that were accepted by Federal mediators as to what they thought was "fair" & the MTA rejected them.

I'm also curious as to what the F both sides have been doing for the past 4 months because it shouldnt' come down to the wire.

As for the MTA's contigency plan, it's a complete cluster fluck.



I agree, why the union? Because they should just give in?

Posted 7/15/14 1:26 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by Straightarrow

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by Paramount



but right now it stands squarely on the shoulders of the Union.

Both sides suck.



But why the union? I'm just trying to understand.

again there were two proposals that were accepted by Federal mediators as to what they thought was "fair" & the MTA rejected them.

I'm also curious as to what the F both sides have been doing for the past 4 months because it shouldnt' come down to the wire.

As for the MTA's contigency plan, it's a complete cluster fluck.



I agree, why the union? Because they should just give in?



I see this as being at the point where the MTA is saying "we cant afford it".

The union went into the meeting yesterday and walked out after 5 min. The MTA said what the union proposed is like .15% savings to the MTA.

The union wont budge on new hires. So no, they should not "give in". However they are probably being unreasonable in their demands. A PP said before. The Union HAS to expect that circumstances WILL change and that their demands cant be sustained.

(And the MTA sucks ass)

Posted 7/15/14 1:40 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by Paramount

I see this as being at the point where the MTA is saying "we cant afford it".

The union went into the meeting yesterday and walked out after 5 min. The MTA said what the union proposed is like .15% savings to the MTA.

The union wont budge on new hires. So no, they should not "give in". However they are probably being unreasonable in their demands. A PP said before. The Union HAS to expect that circumstances WILL change and that their demands cant be sustained.

(And the MTA sucks ass)



I thought the union accepted some of the terms?

Also why is it "probably" being unreasonable? Do they have a history of it?

I'm not sure I believe either side's version of what is happening at the tables. I believe that's just the PR machines working.

Posted 7/15/14 1:54 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by CookiePuss

I'm sorry but that reasoning is ridiculous. And so what if the union weakens and, gasp, becomes undone. With OSHA, DOL, and various other agencies, I"m not so sure how relevant or needed unions are today.

Plus, there are plenty of unions where new members are not afforded the same benefits of older members. It's how it goes. And it's reasonable.

Someone a few pages back mentioned that benefits where why people took public sector jobs because they don't pay as well as private sector...well guess what, there is very little, if none on a mean basis, in the differences between private and public sector jobs in pay.

And this isn't about since I have crappy benefits, so should everyone else. It's about efficiently operating businesses in the world economy of today. Both private and public businesses need to adapt to the changing world economy and environment. Public sector businesses are so inefficient, poorly managed and corrupt businesses there are today. That is because they rely on taxes, rate hikes, etc to overcome that mismanagement. Private sector tends to not be able to sustain that so they tend to run more efficiently. Perhaps it's time to privatize again.



So what if it weakens & erodes the union? I would think the union & its members would care deeply about that. It weakens their bargaining position going forward - which means more concessions on the union members parts every time they need to go to the table.

That's exactly why they won't do it. You are asking the union to self destruct itself. Who would try to ensure that their kids will have a lower standard of living then they have now?

As for the MTA AND LIRR, there is NO QUESTION it is mismanaged. I worked for an attorney that represented many railroads. The biggest & best thing they could do to offset their costs is to move freight - which happens minimally.



I tthink we, as a country are past that point. Unions and their bargining power has steadily been eroded over time through the Right to Work laws.

Unions won't insure that my children will have a better standard of living them me because of them since less then 12% of the work force is union. Today's work force doesn't need a union to insure it's treated fairly as it did 70 plus years ago.

Unions are disruptive and only flurish when they make themselves relevant and that it usually by driving a wedge between management and workers.

The LIRR doesn't want for workers. There are plenty of tri staters that would glady work for the LIRR if it were to remain unionized or privatized.

Message edited 2014-07-15 14:23:44.510000.

Posted 7/15/14 1:56 PM
 

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by luvmotherhood

The big picture here is union vs non union. I am non union, Dh is union.
In my private sector job, we haven't gotten a raise in over four years.
Dh in union has also not received a raise and has been workin without a contract. He is not permitted to strike. The point is- costs keep rising and us middle class are getting screwed. Middle class will die out. I say let them strike. I certainly can't. But why shouldn't they fight for what they deserve? Maybe it will help the middle class out in the long run.
Lots of resentment on this post ladies.
Lirr workers aren't rich.

Chat Icon

Posted 7/15/14 1:58 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by nrthshgrl


I'm not sure I believe either side's version of what is happening at the tables. I believe that's just the PR machines working.



I think we all agree on that.

Honestly at this point we can argue until we are blue in the face.

Ultimately both sides SUCK.

They are both holding us hostage. In the end the ridership always endss up paying for both sides.

Message edited 2014-07-15 14:19:56.240000.

Posted 7/15/14 2:18 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by Jacksmommy

Posted by luvmotherhood

The big picture here is union vs non union. I am non union, Dh is union.
In my private sector job, we haven't gotten a raise in over four years.
Dh in union has also not received a raise and has been workin without a contract. He is not permitted to strike. The point is- costs keep rising and us middle class are getting screwed. Middle class will die out. I say let them strike. I certainly can't. But why shouldn't they fight for what they deserve? Maybe it will help the middle class out in the long run.
Lots of resentment on this post ladies.
Lirr workers aren't rich.

Chat Icon



I feel for the LIRR workers. I believe that they just want to support themselves and their families. They are also caught in the middle of this pissing match.

Posted 7/15/14 2:22 PM
 

b2b777
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

4474 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Im not a union member, and I do ride the LIRR everyday (so i will be affected by this and pay into it), but I agree with some of the PP who feel for union members. Why should they back down? If more of our unions held strong over the years, more of us (middle classers) would be in the position to have better pay and BENEFITS like pensions which no longer exist for most of us. Why should we back down to corporate america and be okay with killing ourselves for a fair wage, and retirement. Right now 99% of our money is tied up with 1% of the population. It just is not right. All of our jobs are overseas, and nothing is regulated. Say bye bye to the middle class and the things we work for in the private sector will only get worse as things for ppl in unions get worse over time.

Posted 7/15/14 3:20 PM
 

lilqtny
-Crossfit & pitbull addict

Member since 7/06

2830 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted by b2b777

Im not a union member, and I do ride the LIRR everyday (so i will be affected by this and pay into it), but I agree with some of the PP who feel for union members. Why should they back down? If more of our unions held strong over the years, more of us (middle classers) would be in the position to have better pay and BENEFITS like pensions which no longer exist for most of us. Why should we back down to corporate america and be okay with killing ourselves for a fair wage, and retirement. Right now 99% of our money is tied up with 1% of the population. It just is not right. All of our jobs are overseas, and nothing is regulated. Say bye bye to the middle class and the things we work for in the private sector will only get worse as things for ppl in unions get worse over time.



Exactly this. And to respond to your observation. 1. They aren't really allowed to talk so whether they know and are being quiet or truly don't know is questionable. 2. It's not uncommon. I mean NYC teachers really didn't "see" our contract until after it paws rarified.

Posted 7/15/14 4:27 PM
 

MK2010
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

401 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

In response to the observation update in the original post - I see what you are saying - but regardless of what side someone falls on - if I were punching tickets on the LIRR, there is no way I would volunteer my opinions on the situation. The topic gets way too heated and the last thing they need is to cause a ruckus on the train. Chat Icon

Posted 7/15/14 4:38 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5