LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Jenhos

I think you would be surprised at what some bank people make. Not everyone makes 6 fugures and gets tens of thousand in bonus every year.

I know a guy that works for the LIRR and makes six figures and lots of overtime and time and a half. And most of that is during his regular shifts!



But many do. I know 3 people who work in a bank and their bonuses are almost as much as half their salary for they year!

Posted 7/14/14 9:21 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by alli3131

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by Jenhos

Sorry but the fact that you can retire after 25 years is insane to me. People who started in a union can retire at say 45 or 50 years old??? Full pensions.... Then since they are so young continue to work taking jobs away from other people.

We bank people that everyone loves to hate don't have pensions and will more than likely need to retire at 62-65 and HOPE we have enough in our 401k's to live out our lives.



Let's not forget that some people who retired in their early/mid-fifties will collect their pension for longer than they actually worked!!!!



This is a HUGE problem. You can work 30 years and collect your pension for 30 years. I don't know the details of the current LIRR contract, but I assume your pension is based on the last few years of your salary (you know when you make the most!!). You're collecting more than you ever put in....these pensions are way underfunded (even as the stock market is at it's highest level ever)

Something needs to change....especially as telecommuting becomes even more customary ridership will be way down if they just keep Jackiing up prices with crappy delayed trains



But why not ***** about the cops and firemen and even correction officers cause it's all the same. This is a benefit of the union. Why blame the workers. It's not them.

Eta or the teachers. They work for more years but my mom has one hell of a pension from teaching.

We ***** cause we dont have it. But if we did we sure as hell would fight to keep it.



Cops, firefighters and teachers are not safe on this board. Chat Icon

Posted 7/14/14 9:22 PM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Jacksmommy

Posted by Jenhos

I think you would be surprised at what some bank people make. Not everyone makes 6 fugures and gets tens of thousand in bonus every year.

I know a guy that works for the LIRR and makes six figures and lots of overtime and time and a half. And most of that is during his regular shifts!



But many do. I know 3 people who work in a bank and their bonuses are almost as much as half their salary for they year!



I work in banking id love to know what banks these are Chat Icon

Posted 7/14/14 9:24 PM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by MegZee
But many do. I know 3 people who work in a bank and their bonuses are almost as much as half their salary for they year!



I work in banking id love to know what banks these are Chat Icon

Exactly. My DH works in a bank (he's a VP), get a 15% bonus max each year and his new hires make about $40k per year.

Message edited 2014-07-14 21:27:59.320000.

Posted 7/14/14 9:27 PM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Mill188

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by Jenhos

Sorry but the fact that you can retire after 25 years is insane to me. People who started in a union can retire at say 45 or 50 years old??? Full pensions.... Then since they are so young continue to work taking jobs away from other people.

We bank people that everyone loves to hate don't have pensions and will more than likely need to retire at 62-65 and HOPE we have enough in our 401k's to live out our lives.



Let's not forget that some people who retired in their early/mid-fifties will collect their pension for longer than they actually worked!!!!


Interesting- like I said above I didn't know the details of lirr pensions....if they are self funded why is their so much fr
This is a HUGE problem. You can work 30 years and collect your pension for 30 years. I don't know the details of the current LIRR contract, but I assume your pension is based on the last few years of your salary (you know when you make the most!!). You're collecting more than you ever put in....these pensions are way underfunded (even as the stock market is at it's highest level ever)

Something needs to change....especially as telecommuting becomes even more customary ridership will be way down if they just keep Jackiing up prices with crappy delayed trains




This is incorrect. The "pension" part of LIRR retirement is very small. The largest part of the retirement package is federal railroad retirement fund which is 100% funded by the employees. It is basically privatized social security. In addition employees can contribute to a 401(k). The "free" pension part doesn't amount to much. Th employee funded retirement is much greater.



Interesting- so why is there so much pension fraud there? And if it's 100% funded by employees....as there are more retirees do the current employees pay more? How does that work

Posted 7/14/14 9:27 PM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Mill188

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by Jenhos

Sorry but the fact that you can retire after 25 years is insane to me. People who started in a union can retire at say 45 or 50 years old??? Full pensions.... Then since they are so young continue to work taking jobs away from other people.

We bank people that everyone loves to hate don't have pensions and will more than likely need to retire at 62-65 and HOPE we have enough in our 401k's to live out our lives.



Let's not forget that some people who retired in their early/mid-fifties will collect their pension for longer than they actually worked!!!!


Interesting- like I said above I didn't know the details of lirr pensions....if they are self funded why is their so much fr
This is a HUGE problem. You can work 30 years and collect your pension for 30 years. I don't know the details of the current LIRR contract, but I assume your pension is based on the last few years of your salary (you know when you make the most!!). You're collecting more than you ever put in....these pensions are way underfunded (even as the stock market is at it's highest level ever)

Something needs to change....especially as telecommuting becomes even more customary ridership will be way down if they just keep Jackiing up prices with crappy delayed trains




This is incorrect. The "pension" part of LIRR retirement is very small. The largest part of the retirement package is federal railroad retirement fund which is 100% funded by the employees. It is basically privatized social security. In addition employees can contribute to a 401(k). The "free" pension part doesn't amount to much. Th employee funded retirement is much greater.



Interesting- so why is there so much pension fraud there? And if it's 100% funded by employees....as there are more retirees do the current employees pay more? How does that work



that's why the pensions funds are underfunded and 75% of rate hikes to go making up the difference.

Posted 7/14/14 9:29 PM
 

SlurpeeDad
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

713 total posts

Name:
SlurpeeDad

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Mill188

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by Jenhos

Sorry but the fact that you can retire after 25 years is insane to me. People who started in a union can retire at say 45 or 50 years old??? Full pensions.... Then since they are so young continue to work taking jobs away from other people.

We bank people that everyone loves to hate don't have pensions and will more than likely need to retire at 62-65 and HOPE we have enough in our 401k's to live out our lives.



Let's not forget that some people who retired in their early/mid-fifties will collect their pension for longer than they actually worked!!!!


Interesting- like I said above I didn't know the details of lirr pensions....if they are self funded why is their so much fr
This is a HUGE problem. You can work 30 years and collect your pension for 30 years. I don't know the details of the current LIRR contract, but I assume your pension is based on the last few years of your salary (you know when you make the most!!). You're collecting more than you ever put in....these pensions are way underfunded (even as the stock market is at it's highest level ever)

Something needs to change....especially as telecommuting becomes even more customary ridership will be way down if they just keep Jackiing up prices with crappy delayed trains




This is incorrect. The "pension" part of LIRR retirement is very small. The largest part of the retirement package is federal railroad retirement fund which is 100% funded by the employees. It is basically privatized social security. In addition employees can contribute to a 401(k). The "free" pension part doesn't amount to much. Th employee funded retirement is much greater.



Interesting- so why is there so much pension fraud there? And if it's 100% funded by employees....as there are more retirees do the current employees pay more? How does that work



Excellent point. Maybe they should have all the people that are guilty of fraud pay back their money at an actual rate instead of $25 per month for the rest of their lives.

Posted 7/14/14 9:33 PM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Mill188

Posted by MegZee

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by Jenhos

Sorry but the fact that you can retire after 25 years is insane to me. People who started in a union can retire at say 45 or 50 years old??? Full pensions.... Then since they are so young continue to work taking jobs away from other people.

We bank people that everyone loves to hate don't have pensions and will more than likely need to retire at 62-65 and HOPE we have enough in our 401k's to live out our lives.



Let's not forget that some people who retired in their early/mid-fifties will collect their pension for longer than they actually worked!!!!


Interesting- like I said above I didn't know the details of lirr pensions....if they are self funded why is their so much fr
This is a HUGE problem. You can work 30 years and collect your pension for 30 years. I don't know the details of the current LIRR contract, but I assume your pension is based on the last few years of your salary (you know when you make the most!!). You're collecting more than you ever put in....these pensions are way underfunded (even as the stock market is at it's highest level ever)

Something needs to change....especially as telecommuting becomes even more customary ridership will be way down if they just keep Jackiing up prices with crappy delayed trains




This is incorrect. The "pension" part of LIRR retirement is very small. The largest part of the retirement package is federal railroad retirement fund which is 100% funded by the employees. It is basically privatized social security. In addition employees can contribute to a 401(k). The "free" pension part doesn't amount to much. Th employee funded retirement is much greater.



Interesting- so why is there so much pension fraud there? And if it's 100% funded by employees....as there are more retirees do the current employees pay more? How does that work



that's why the pensions funds are underfunded and 75% of rate hikes to go making up the difference.



Right...the PP alluded that the employees funded it 100%....I'd love to know how it works; it would change the financial dynamics of raises for sure. And my meaningless opinion on the matter!

Posted 7/14/14 9:34 PM
 

Mill188
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

3073 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

There isn't pension fraud. There is disability fraud. Disability and pensions are different funds.

Disability payments are higher than pension payments - that's why some scum try to scam the system.

Disability payments are not part of these contract negotiations.

Posted 7/14/14 9:48 PM
 

MegZee
My bunny

Member since 5/06

8777 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Mill188

There isn't pension fraud. There is disability fraud. Disability and pensions are different funds.

Disability payments are higher than pension payments - that's why some scum try to scam the system.

Disability payments are not part of these contract negotiations.



It's the same fund though isn't it?

Posted 7/14/14 9:57 PM
 

hmm
Sweet

Member since 1/14

8016 total posts

Name:

LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

all I can say after reading all this is Im exhausted. I work for a union and cant say I like it, I don't like paying dues or having someone suggest who I should vote for. Unions prevent me from getting the pay I should be getting, because we all must make the same. I can be 10x better then joe smith but it doesn't matter.Even though I have grad degree and still paying off the loans. This is truly a hot topic.

Posted 7/14/14 10:16 PM
 

Mill188
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

3073 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Disability is the same fund as railroad retirement. It is not the same fund as the pension fund.

Posted 7/14/14 10:38 PM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?

Message edited 2014-07-15 08:28:44.053000.

Posted 7/15/14 8:25 AM
 

LotsaLuv
Us

Member since 6/10

4094 total posts

Name:
F

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.

Posted 7/15/14 9:04 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.



Based on your argument, I shouldn't care about the union members or their families because they are strangers to me. They don't have to strike, but they will to further their own cause and will screw the public to get it. And, exactly why should I have any sympathy for them, since I too need to provide for my family? Your argument sounds like greed in its purest form.

Posted 7/15/14 9:10 AM
 

LotsaLuv
Us

Member since 6/10

4094 total posts

Name:
F

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.



Based on your argument, I shouldn't care about the union members or their families because they are strangers to me. They don't have to strike, but they will to further their own cause and will screw the public to get it. And, exactly why should I have any sympathy for them, since I too need to provide for my family? Your argument sounds like greed in its purest form.



My argument is why shouldn't they be allowed to fight for more when they are int he same position as us????? Yes, the commuter is going to suffer for this, but if the suits took cuts and freezes, than the commuter wouldn't have to suffer, and the MIDDLE CLASS LIRR EMPLOYEE could also make a little more to provide for his/her family.

ETA: TRICKLE DOWN EFFECT!!!!!!! What is happening is the guys at the top make more, we pay more, middle class dieing out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Message edited 2014-07-15 09:16:11.133000.

Posted 7/15/14 9:15 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.



Based on your argument, I shouldn't care about the union members or their families because they are strangers to me. They don't have to strike, but they will to further their own cause and will screw the public to get it. And, exactly why should I have any sympathy for them, since I too need to provide for my family? Your argument sounds like greed in its purest form.



My argument is why shouldn't they be allowed to fight for more when they are int he same position as us????? Yes, the commuter is going to suffer for this, but if the suits took cuts and freezes, than the commuter wouldn't have to suffer, and the MIDDLE CLASS LIRR EMPLOYEE could also make a little more to provide for his/her family.

ETA: TRICKLE DOWN EFFECT!!!!!!! What is happening is the guys at the top make more, we pay more, middle class dieing out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I'm sorry, but there has to be other ways than striking. Crippling the commuter rail system and putting commuters in this position is not right. Commuters deserve to be treated fairly as well. Also, LIRR salaries are $85k on average, which is a far higher salary than most private industry works make, it makes this strike even more unfair. My husband may have to stay in a hotel from Saturday evening until this strike ends, which means that he will lose time with my family. That also means, that I will have to work from home and, since my job really requires me to be in the office, I will not be as productive as I could be. While the union scream about "brotherhood" and "fairness," they are treating the commuters like crap!

Posted 7/15/14 9:33 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

My DH works for a union and they have been w/o a contract for years. It is un lawful for them to strike. I think in a situation like this where it is basically a monopoly like the LIRR they should not be allowed to strike due to the economic toll it will take, JMO. With regards to new incoming hires , there is always someone that is going to be willing to take the job...

Posted 7/15/14 9:38 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.



Based on your argument, I shouldn't care about the union members or their families because they are strangers to me. They don't have to strike, but they will to further their own cause and will screw the public to get it. And, exactly why should I have any sympathy for them, since I too need to provide for my family? Your argument sounds like greed in its purest form.



My argument is why shouldn't they be allowed to fight for more when they are int he same position as us????? Yes, the commuter is going to suffer for this, but if the suits took cuts and freezes, than the commuter wouldn't have to suffer, and the MIDDLE CLASS LIRR EMPLOYEE could also make a little more to provide for his/her family.

ETA: TRICKLE DOWN EFFECT!!!!!!! What is happening is the guys at the top make more, we pay more, middle class dieing out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I'm sorry, but there has to be other ways than striking. Crippling the commuter rail system and putting commuters in this position is not right. Commuters deserve to be treated fairly as well. Also, LIRR salaries are $85k on average, which is a far higher salary than most private industry works make, it makes this strike even more unfair. My husband may have to stay in a hotel from Saturday evening until this strike ends, which means that he will lose time with my family. That also means, that I will have to work from home and, since my job really requires me to be in the office, I will not be as productive as I could be. While the union scream about "brotherhood" and "fairness," they are treating the commuters like crap!



But what people keep forgetting is that the MTA can end this now by actually negotiating. They have failed to budge. The unions have and this latest talks on Monday The MTA failed to move a smudge. The unions do not want to strike until all ease fails. And the MTA has refused to budge. 2 govt advisory panels (or whatever they are called) said the unions demands are fair. The MTA rejected both, the unions budged and the MTA is basically saying a BIG F YOU to the unions. SO if you want to blame people blame the MTA not the little guy.

Once again the MTA is the winner in all of this.....they save millions a day by not operating. They already have the money from our tix, they don't pay wages during a strike and don t have the other operating costs of running the trains....and its not like we will stop using the RR when this is all done. We will get right back on the train and pay next month's ticket.

SO BLAME THE MTA.

Posted 7/15/14 9:43 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by alli3131
SO BLAME THE MTA.



Thank you, but I will blame both of you! How dare you both treat the commuters like pawns in your stupid quest for more money, when that additional money comes from the people you are screwing.

Posted 7/15/14 9:47 AM
 

LotsaLuv
Us

Member since 6/10

4094 total posts

Name:
F

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.



Based on your argument, I shouldn't care about the union members or their families because they are strangers to me. They don't have to strike, but they will to further their own cause and will screw the public to get it. And, exactly why should I have any sympathy for them, since I too need to provide for my family? Your argument sounds like greed in its purest form.



My argument is why shouldn't they be allowed to fight for more when they are int he same position as us????? Yes, the commuter is going to suffer for this, but if the suits took cuts and freezes, than the commuter wouldn't have to suffer, and the MIDDLE CLASS LIRR EMPLOYEE could also make a little more to provide for his/her family.

ETA: TRICKLE DOWN EFFECT!!!!!!! What is happening is the guys at the top make more, we pay more, middle class dieing out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I'm sorry, but there has to be other ways than striking. Crippling the commuter rail system and putting commuters in this position is not right. Commuters deserve to be treated fairly as well. Also, LIRR salaries are $85k on average, which is a far higher salary than most private industry works make, it makes this strike even more unfair. My husband may have to stay in a hotel from Saturday evening until this strike ends, which means that he will lose time with my family. That also means, that I will have to work from home and, since my job really requires me to be in the office, I will not be as productive as I could be. While the union scream about "brotherhood" and "fairness," they are treating the commuters like crap!



Well we will agree to disagree. In todays world and economy you have to fight for what you want because it is not given away. I do not agree with anything you are saying because the guy is maybe making 100k. 100k does not go very far in the tristate area, esp when the suits are making well over that. I cannot accept or understand the mentality that a middle class worker should not fight for more and should lay down and take it while the rich get richer. This country is crumbling because of it, and all we do is argue and fight within our own class. The money is not coming to us people, everything is going up except our pay. Look towards the future, we are a dieing class with a joke for a leader.
The LIRR employee wants a little more, and they are entitled to it, go after the suits, they didn't even counter the union offers yesterday. Now that's a fuching disgrace. They are making no attempt to resolve this. Why because no matter what they will still get a nice raise in January.

Posted 7/15/14 9:48 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by alli3131
SO BLAME THE MTA.



Thank you, but I will blame both of you! How dare you both treat the commuters like pawns in your stupid quest for more money, when that additional money comes from the people you are screwing.



Don't blame me...Im a commuter that will be happily working from home in my backyardChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/15/14 9:51 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.



Based on your argument, I shouldn't care about the union members or their families because they are strangers to me. They don't have to strike, but they will to further their own cause and will screw the public to get it. And, exactly why should I have any sympathy for them, since I too need to provide for my family? Your argument sounds like greed in its purest form.



My argument is why shouldn't they be allowed to fight for more when they are int he same position as us????? Yes, the commuter is going to suffer for this, but if the suits took cuts and freezes, than the commuter wouldn't have to suffer, and the MIDDLE CLASS LIRR EMPLOYEE could also make a little more to provide for his/her family.

ETA: TRICKLE DOWN EFFECT!!!!!!! What is happening is the guys at the top make more, we pay more, middle class dieing out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I'm sorry, but there has to be other ways than striking. Crippling the commuter rail system and putting commuters in this position is not right. Commuters deserve to be treated fairly as well. Also, LIRR salaries are $85k on average, which is a far higher salary than most private industry works make, it makes this strike even more unfair. My husband may have to stay in a hotel from Saturday evening until this strike ends, which means that he will lose time with my family. That also means, that I will have to work from home and, since my job really requires me to be in the office, I will not be as productive as I could be. While the union scream about "brotherhood" and "fairness," they are treating the commuters like crap!



Well we will agree to disagree. In todays world and economy you have to fight for what you want because it is not given away. I do not agree with anything you are saying because the guy is maybe making 100k. 100k does not go very far in the tristate area, esp when the suits are making well over that. I cannot accept or understand the mentality that a middle class worker should not fight for more and should lay down and take it while the rich get richer. This country is crumbling because of it, and all we do is argue and fight within our own class. The money is not coming to us people, everything is going up except our pay. Look towards the future, we are a dieing class with a joke for a leader.
The LIRR employee wants a little more, and they are entitled to it, go after the suits, they didn't even counter the union offers yesterday. Now that's a fuching disgrace. They are making no attempt to resolve this. Why because no matter what they will still get a nice raise in January.



So, what do the "suits" at the union make?

Posted 7/15/14 9:52 AM
 

luvmotherhood
california dreamin'

Member since 2/13

1443 total posts

Name:
love my family!

LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

The big picture here is union vs non union. I am non union, Dh is union.
In my private sector job, we haven't gotten a raise in over four years.
Dh in union has also not received a raise and has been workin without a contract. He is not permitted to strike. The point is- costs keep rising and us middle class are getting screwed. Middle class will die out. I say let them strike. I certainly can't. But why shouldn't they fight for what they deserve? Maybe it will help the middle class out in the long run.
Lots of resentment on this post ladies.
Lirr workers aren't rich.

Posted 7/15/14 9:52 AM
 

LotsaLuv
Us

Member since 6/10

4094 total posts

Name:
F

Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Posted by Pumpkin1

Posted by LotsaLuv

Why are we hating on the working union members???? What about these dip shits at the top who make crazy money and do not have to give up anything. Why is the middle class constantly suffering. Everything is going up, these working middle class LIRR employees need to afford to live too. How would they ever get anything without fighting for it.

AND the reason talks ended was b/c management didn't come to the table with anything today. NO COUNTER, what a slap in the face when these top guys have fuch you money, and they don't take a salary cut or freeze.




Do you mean the employed union members who are putting the wants and needs of future union members above those of the commuters? You know, the public for which they claim to serve and whose commuting costs pay their salaries?



Me being able to make enough money to provide for my family trumps a bunch of strangers. Let's face it most of these workers are not making much over 100k, if they are even making that. I would assume most live within the tri-state area. Are they supposed to move to bumblefuch so the CEO's and the suits of the LIRR can live in their mansions and live a more than comfortable life?
All I am saying is, instea dof getting on the union worker, the middle class guy, the guy who is in the same position as us, why are we not asking the suits to take pay cuts, pay freezes, give up salary. Nothing trickles down anymore. Our sytem works off the trickle down effect, without that, the middle class is going Bye Bye.



Based on your argument, I shouldn't care about the union members or their families because they are strangers to me. They don't have to strike, but they will to further their own cause and will screw the public to get it. And, exactly why should I have any sympathy for them, since I too need to provide for my family? Your argument sounds like greed in its purest form.



My argument is why shouldn't they be allowed to fight for more when they are int he same position as us????? Yes, the commuter is going to suffer for this, but if the suits took cuts and freezes, than the commuter wouldn't have to suffer, and the MIDDLE CLASS LIRR EMPLOYEE could also make a little more to provide for his/her family.

ETA: TRICKLE DOWN EFFECT!!!!!!! What is happening is the guys at the top make more, we pay more, middle class dieing out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I'm sorry, but there has to be other ways than striking. Crippling the commuter rail system and putting commuters in this position is not right. Commuters deserve to be treated fairly as well. Also, LIRR salaries are $85k on average, which is a far higher salary than most private industry works make, it makes this strike even more unfair. My husband may have to stay in a hotel from Saturday evening until this strike ends, which means that he will lose time with my family. That also means, that I will have to work from home and, since my job really requires me to be in the office, I will not be as productive as I could be. While the union scream about "brotherhood" and "fairness," they are treating the commuters like crap!



Well we will agree to disagree. In todays world and economy you have to fight for what you want because it is not given away. I do not agree with anything you are saying because the guy is maybe making 100k. 100k does not go very far in the tristate area, esp when the suits are making well over that. I cannot accept or understand the mentality that a middle class worker should not fight for more and should lay down and take it while the rich get richer. This country is crumbling because of it, and all we do is argue and fight within our own class. The money is not coming to us people, everything is going up except our pay. Look towards the future, we are a dieing class with a joke for a leader.
The LIRR employee wants a little more, and they are entitled to it, go after the suits, they didn't even counter the union offers yesterday. Now that's a fuching disgrace. They are making no attempt to resolve this. Why because no matter what they will still get a nice raise in January.



So, what do the "suits" at the union make?



I can't give you exact numbers, but I can take a very educated guess, at A LOT MORE THAN YOU OR I. The top guys are probably making more than the LI superintendants who collect cushy pensions for the rest of their lives Chat Icon

Posted 7/15/14 9:55 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5