Re: LIRR- Talks break down..AGAIN: Small observation in first post
Posted 7/15/2014 1:11:05 PM by nrthshgrl
Posted by CookiePuss
I'm sorry but that reasoning is ridiculous. And so what if the union weakens and, gasp, becomes undone. With OSHA, DOL, and various other agencies, I"m not so sure how relevant or needed unions are today.
Plus, there are plenty of unions where new members are not afforded the same benefits of older members. It's how it goes. And it's reasonable.
Someone a few pages back mentioned that benefits where why people took public sector jobs because they don't pay as well as private sector...well guess what, there is very little, if none on a mean basis, in the differences between private and public sector jobs in pay.
And this isn't about since I have crappy benefits, so should everyone else. It's about efficiently operating businesses in the world economy of today. Both private and public businesses need to adapt to the changing world economy and environment. Public sector businesses are so inefficient, poorly managed and corrupt businesses there are today. That is because they rely on taxes, rate hikes, etc to overcome that mismanagement. Private sector tends to not be able to sustain that so they tend to run more efficiently. Perhaps it's time to privatize again.
So what if it weakens & erodes the union? I would think the union & its members would care deeply about that. It weakens their bargaining position going forward - which means more concessions on the union members parts every time they need to go to the table.
That's exactly why they won't do it. You are asking the union to self destruct itself. Who would try to ensure that their kids will have a lower standard of living then they have now?
As for the MTA AND LIRR, there is NO QUESTION it is mismanaged. I worked for an attorney that represented many railroads. The biggest & best thing they could do to offset their costs is to move freight - which happens minimally.
|