Isn't this illegal?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Jenn627


eta: is it because there is no affordable housing throughout the COUNTY?



bingo. this isn't targetted at Scarsdale or Chappaqua, this is a judgement against the ENTIRE county of Westchester.

Posted 8/12/09 2:46 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Why does Westchester need to build affordable housing?
What happened to supply and demand?

More importantly, why do the nicest towns need to build affordable housing?

What is wrong with people buying in areas they can afford like Hartsdale, Elmont, Croton, Port Chester, Valhalla?

Who said anyone has a god given right to live in Rye?

Posted 8/12/09 2:47 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Isn't this illegal?

gov't is allowed to step in about affordable house when the community is asking for tax breaks and financial aid for it. Westchester asked for aid, they received and they need to follow the rules in order to keep that aid which is allowing ANYONE to access those homes that meet the criteria.

Posted 8/12/09 2:48 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by BunnyBaby

The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!



I think the fact that Westchester is predominantly white has to do with the fact that it costs so much $$ to live in certain parts of it - NOTHING to do with 'effort, hard work and achievement'

Yes, no one said minorities can't move there - but when you set pricing as high as it is, you automatically exclude less fortunate people, who may be minorities. So, working hard has nothing to do with it.
It's covert racism rather than blatant racism.

Now, the gov. is just telling Westchester that they need to widen the area that they market to, to give people opportunities to move to these communities that may have never even known about them previously.
I don't see anything wrong with that.
No different than choosing where to place an ad to reach the most people



How exactly does Westchester reach out to these people?

Isn't it real estate agents and home owners that place the for sale listings?

Is the county supposed to get into the real estate listing business just to make some special interest groups happy?

Posted 8/12/09 2:50 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by twiceasnice

Posted by Otherme

Posted by BunnyBaby

The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!



I think the fact that Westchester is predominantly white has to do with the fact that it costs so much $$ to live in certain parts of it - NOTHING to do with 'effort, hard work and achievement'

Yes, no one said minorities can't move there - but when you set pricing as high as it is, you automatically exclude less fortunate people, who may be minorities. So, working hard has nothing to do with it.
It's covert racism rather than blatant racism.

Now, the gov. is just telling Westchester that they need to widen the area that they market to, to give people opportunities to move to these communities that may have never even known about them previously.
I don't see anything wrong with that.
No different than choosing where to place an ad to reach the most people



That is insane.
So the people who live in Westchester are rich people and typically rich people are white but...not necessarily hard workers but they are rich and can live in High priced areas. Therefore it is not fair to the people who cannot afford those areas (minorities, which in this case we would all be included if it is based on finances). Wow!
I completely disagree with this outlook.

When did the government get the right to determine which residential areas should be "widened" due to ethinic background? Maybe next it will be the Hamptons, certain streets in NYC, heck why is their not affordable housing next to the White House?



I was disagreeing with the OP's statement that Westchester is filled with white people because they work hard and show effort. Also her statement 'Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!'
- implying that minorities don't.

And i stand by my statement that i don't see anything wrong with the article. The 'government' is not telling anyone (white or not white) where they can or can't live - they're simply requiring Westchester county to make the advertising for these homes available to a wider audience.

Posted 8/12/09 2:53 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.

Posted 8/12/09 2:54 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Nifheim

gov't is allowed to step in about affordable house when the community is asking for tax breaks and financial aid for it. Westchester asked for aid, they received and they need to follow the rules in order to keep that aid which is allowing ANYONE to access those homes that meet the criteria.



If you can afford to live in Rye by all means move there, if you cannot then look further north. Not sure why the feds are involved here, seems a simple concept for all to live by.

Did Westchester ask for the aid or did these specific towns ask for aid?

Is westchester supposed to buy the land and then build and sell homes at a loss to make DC happy?

How exactly is Westchester blocking access to these homes?


Posted 8/12/09 2:54 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Isn't this illegal?

As someone that lives in Westchester, I find this lawsuit and settlement absurd. I would love to live in Rye and/or Chappaqua, but I can't afford it. That is life. It sucks, but if i want to live there, I need to work harder and make more money or win the lottery. While the underlying argument is that they want to "desegregate" certain towns in Westchester, it is more about affordability. Since when do we say "the government feels bad that you can't afford to live here, we will make sure that the government pays for affordable housing so you can". What about other towns in the country - Greenwich, Santa Barbara, Beverly Hills - are those counties going to do the same. Westchester did this more than 20 years ago with Yonkers and it adversely affected that city. They started bussing and affordable housing and property values went down and the school system fell apart. There is now gang violence, a huge crime problem and major problems in certain partsof Yonkers. I think it screams "unconstitutional".

ETA: the issue is that Westchester is going to have a hard time requiring certain towns to build this housing - they are going to sue in order to prevent this.

Message edited 2009-08-12 15:00:25.583000.

Posted 8/12/09 2:58 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Cpt2007

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.



Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/09 2:58 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Cpt2007

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.



Chat Icon



I think this article and most readers are blowing it out of proportion.

But, seems to be the trend lately (healthcare anyone?)

Posted 8/12/09 3:02 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Tilde

wow i can't afford to move to beverly hills - all these years i thought that it was just because i didnt make enough money. . .who knew it was discrimination?!



yeah right?Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/09 3:02 PM
 

anonttcer
BOOOO for fall!

Member since 7/06

10082 total posts

Name:
Meaning a NON ttcer!

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by SIBride06

Posted by evnme

my DH lost a promotion once b/c of race quotas. he was more qualified and did better on the exam, but b/c the runner up was a black woman and they had quotas to fiill, she got the job instead of him.

it's reverse racism.



Wow... That is completely unacceptable in every way.

Did he just walk away, or did he take further action to try to appeal that decision?



Sadly, this is very common in police and fire department tests as well...reverse discrimination at it's finest...

Posted 8/12/09 3:02 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Cpt2007

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.



Chat Icon



I think this article and most readers are blowing it out of proportion.

But, seems to be the trend lately (healthcare anyone?)



Come to yonkers - it totally failed miserably when they did this exact same thing 20 years ago

Posted 8/12/09 3:03 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Jenn627

Posted by amish089

Only wealthy people can live in Westechester? My question is -- Is that legal?



Huh? Only wealthy people can live in Oyster Bay Cove, only wealthy people can buy a jet, only wealthy people can send their kids to London once a month for shitss and giggles, only wealthy people can spend $3500 on a handbag...

I don't understand your question. Is that legal? Where are you going with that?

How is expensive housing discriminatory against non-whites? It's discriminatory against low-income PEOPLE, not just one group.

This is ridiculous. Are they going to start building affordable housing in every wealthy community in the US?

I really just don't get this article at all.

eta: is it because there is no affordable housing throughout the COUNTY?



Exactly...great points. Such is life.

Posted 8/12/09 3:05 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Cpt2007

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.



Chat Icon



I think this article and most readers are blowing it out of proportion.

But, seems to be the trend lately (healthcare anyone?)



seriously. how many more times can we Chat Icon

people are going to read what they want to read, regardless of what something is ACTUALLY about.

Posted 8/12/09 3:13 PM
 

MissingLI
Such a Big Boy!

Member since 1/06

1602 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Cpt2007

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.



Chat Icon



Double Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/09 3:14 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Cpt2007

Posted by Otherme

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Cpt2007

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.



Chat Icon



I think this article and most readers are blowing it out of proportion.

But, seems to be the trend lately (healthcare anyone?)



seriously. how many more times can we Chat Icon

people are going to read what they want to read, regardless of what something is ACTUALLY about.



If I lived in these areas, spent millions of dollars on my house, paid $25,000 in taxes a year and then there is "affordable" housing built next to your home where the individuals will also get tax breaks, I would totally be pizzed. It is the governments fault for accepting the federal money, but people who had no say in the matter are going to be penalized.

Posted 8/12/09 3:17 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by mrsej

If I lived in these areas, spent millions of dollars on my house, paid $25,000 in taxes a year and then there is "affordable" housing built next to your home where the individuals will also get tax breaks, I would totally be pizzed. It is the governments fault for accepting the federal money, but people who had no say in the matter are going to be penalized.



And residents in those areas have recourse-- hearings at zoning boards, letter writing campaigns, etc. Again, unless I was missing entire sentences, I didn't see that article say they were popping up garden style Section 8 housing in Chappaqua. If I missed it, please point it out for me.

I'll say it again, this is a COUNTY-WIDE issue. It's not localized to specific high-income towns inside the County.

Posted 8/12/09 3:22 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Cpt2007

Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got.

Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds.

Link to the applicable provision of the USC.

I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion.



OMG THANK YOU!

Posted 8/12/09 3:23 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Cpt2007

Posted by mrsej

If I lived in these areas, spent millions of dollars on my house, paid $25,000 in taxes a year and then there is "affordable" housing built next to your home where the individuals will also get tax breaks, I would totally be pizzed. It is the governments fault for accepting the federal money, but people who had no say in the matter are going to be penalized.



And residents in those areas have recourse-- hearings at zoning boards, letter writing campaigns, etc. Again, unless I was missing entire sentences, I didn't see that article say they were popping up garden style Section 8 housing in Chappaqua. If I missed it, please point it out for me.

I'll say it again, this is a COUNTY-WIDE issue. It's not localized to specific high-income towns inside the County.



They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news.

Posted 8/12/09 3:25 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by mrsej

They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news.



being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate?

Posted 8/12/09 3:29 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Nothing like a WASP town god forbid the servants live among the masters. Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/09 3:30 PM
 

JP826
=)

Member since 9/06

10903 total posts

Name:
Me!! All about ME!

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Nifheim

Nothing like a WASP town god forbid the servants live among the masters. Chat Icon



Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/09 3:31 PM
 

evnme
My little lamb

Member since 8/05

12633 total posts

Name:
aka momma2b

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by SIBride06

Posted by Nifheim

Nothing like a WASP town god forbid the servants live among the masters. Chat Icon



Chat Icon



whoah there girlfriend!
you may have been joking w/ that statement, but those towns also have very large and affluent jewish populations.

Posted 8/12/09 3:33 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Cpt2007

Posted by mrsej

They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news.



being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate?



They have to chose towns with less than 3% minorities residing in them - the 18 towns that have less than 3% minorities also happen to be some of the wealthies.

Posted 8/12/09 3:35 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is this illegal? nov04libride 6/15/06 11 Families Helping Families ™
Using illegal drugs... Stefanie 3/26/06 48 Families Helping Families ™
Illegal immigration debate Shanti 3/26/06 199 Families Helping Families ™
Would it be illegal... Mrs-Boop 2/22/06 15 Families Helping Families ™
renting an illegal apt...need real estate agents help bklyngirl 11/12/05 3 Home
When was the last time that you did illegal drugs DebG 9/2/05 25 Families Helping Families ™