Isn't this illegal?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 | |
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? sorry you are right I shouldn't discriminate. Message edited 2009-08-12 15:36:33.990000. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:35 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news. being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate? They have to chose towns with less than 3% minorities residing in them - the 18 towns that have less than 3% minorities also happen to be some of the wealthies. have a link? |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news. being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate? They have to chose towns with less than 3% minorities residing in them - the 18 towns that have less than 3% minorities also happen to be some of the wealthies. ETA: The county will pays the feds 21 million and the feds will pay it back trhough HUD for the county to build the housing. The county also needs to set aside 30 million to build affordable housing in the next 7 years and pay 8.4 million to the fed gov.- 2.5 mill will go to pay the Anti-Disciminatory Center for legal fees. There is no indication that the towns/county will get a tax rebate - |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news. being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate? They have to chose towns with less than 3% minorities residing in them - the 18 towns that have less than 3% minorities also happen to be some of the wealthies. have a link? I will try and find one - it is all over the local tv |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Message edited 2009-08-12 15:48:12.647000. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news. being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate? They have to chose towns with less than 3% minorities residing in them - the 18 towns that have less than 3% minorities also happen to be some of the wealthies. have a link? I will try and find one - it is all over the local tv thanks. this is what i found on the times and WJN: NYT Editorial NYT Article Westchester Journal News Article Qutoe through from the Times article: "No communities have been chosen to receive the homes, officials said. But according to the Anti-Discrimination Center, more than two dozen predominantly white towns or villages are eligible, including Bedford, Bronxville, Eastchester, Hastings-on-Hudson, Harrison, Larchmont, Mamaroneck, New Castle, Pelham Manor, Rye and Scarsdale." |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news. being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate? They have to chose towns with less than 3% minorities residing in them - the 18 towns that have less than 3% minorities also happen to be some of the wealthies. have a link? http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/11/nyregion/11settle.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=westchester%20desegregation&st=cse I can't log on to the local paper which had better info, but here is a ny times article |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by mrsej They chose 18 possible towns - they happen to be high income areas - Chappaqua, Rye, Scarsdale etc. You are totally right that the towns will be fighting this and will complain about zoning, traffic, etc. It wasn't in this article, but the areas they have slated were shown on local 12 Westchester news. being OOS, i can't see that. what was the Co Exec's reasoning for targetting those towns? Do those towns get some kind of monetary housing funding from the County? Some kind of tax rebate? They have to chose towns with less than 3% minorities residing in them - the 18 towns that have less than 3% minorities also happen to be some of the wealthies. have a link? I will try and find one - it is all over the local tv thanks. this is what i found on the times and WJN: NYT Editorial NYT Article Westchester Journal News Article Qutoe through from the Times article: "No communities have been chosen to receive the homes, officials said. But according to the Anti-Discrimination Center, more than two dozen predominantly white towns or villages are eligible, including Bedford, Bronxville, Eastchester, Hastings-on-Hudson, Harrison, Larchmont, Mamaroneck, New Castle, Pelham Manor, Rye and Scarsdale." The wealthiest towns in westchester...I couldn't afford a mound of dirt in those towns! |
|
Posted 8/12/09 3:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by mrsej The wealthiest towns in westchester...I couldn't afford a mound of dirt in those towns! i'm sure they are, but they are "included" amongst the full list of elligible towns. the list isn't exclusively those towns. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Wow. Just... WOW. I don't know if I necessarily agree with what the government is mandating, though I see how they can legally do it because, if they are providing federal funds, they can require whatever they want of the County. But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by mrswask Posted by BunnyBaby [Does this SEEM illegal? why the need for the government to meddle into where people move to? For years ethnic groups have moved to areas where other similar ethnic groups have already set up. people of what ever part of the world always move to areas where their countrymen have settled.How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Where is it written that there has to be ‘x’ number of race representation in a community? As long as there isn’t blatant discrimination, it shouldn’t matter how many of who there is. Maybe they should figure out why these neighborhoods are more desirable than minority neighborhoods? Just a thought. I'm sorry but personally, I find the above statements offensive. I'm sure that I could not afford to buy in a Westchester bedroom community right now. That does not make me less fortunate nor does it mean that if I did move in, that I would drive down property values or increase crime. Just because someone may be "less fortunate" or a minority does not mean they are criminals or low-lifes. I thought I was the only one. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Wow. Just... WOW. I don't know if I necessarily agree with what the government is mandating, though I see how they can legally do it because, if they are providing federal funds, they can require whatever they want of the County. But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... ITA! I thought I read it wrong. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? From Lohud.com/NY journals News Message edited 2009-08-12 16:37:52.020000. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Wow. Just... WOW. I don't know if I necessarily agree with what the government is mandating, though I see how they can legally do it because, if they are providing federal funds, they can require whatever they want of the County. But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... Oh please. Give me a break. But calling Westchester a "WASP" community is not discrimination? I was not trying to be derogatory in any shape or form. Just to add... I can bet any amount of money that you live in a beautiful neighborhood without any low icome housing that was government funded. I've seen many beautiful neighborhoods (including the one I gre up in) turn to crap because the government felt they had to cater to the less fortunate. Message edited 2009-08-12 16:52:10.850000. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Blu-ize Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Wow. Just... WOW. I don't know if I necessarily agree with what the government is mandating, though I see how they can legally do it because, if they are providing federal funds, they can require whatever they want of the County. But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... ITA! I thought I read it wrong. I also agree. In the past few weeks I have read some posts on here that have truly shocked and saddened me. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... I agree completely. Sickening. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Cpt2007 Posted by Otherme Posted by Ophelia Posted by Cpt2007 Again, the issue here is that the County of Westchester was applying for funds available under 42 USC Sec 130. Upon investigation by HUD doing their due dilligence to make sure that Westchester was living up to the funds eligibility requirements, HUD found that they were NOT complying with the elligibility requirements to get the funds. Westchester sought legal opinion and this is what they got. Nowhere in this case does it say that someone has a right to a certain area. What this case says is that Westchester wanted funding under this portion of the USC and they weren't elligible so now they are trying to get into compliance so they can get the funds. Link to the applicable provision of the USC. I think this article is blowing this whole thing out of proportion. I think this article and most readers are blowing it out of proportion. But, seems to be the trend lately (healthcare anyone?) seriously. how many more times can we people are going to read what they want to read, regardless of what something is ACTUALLY about. Abso-frickin-lutely agree. People have very little regard fot FACTS. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Wow. Just... WOW. I don't know if I necessarily agree with what the government is mandating, though I see how they can legally do it because, if they are providing federal funds, they can require whatever they want of the County. But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... Beth
|
|
Posted 8/12/09 4:57 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by BunnyBaby Oh please. Give me a break. But calling Westchester a "WASP" community is not discrimination? I was not trying to be derogatory in any shape or form. Just to add... I can bet any amount of money that you live in a beautiful neighborhood without any low icome housing that was government funded. I've seen many beautiful neighborhoods (including the one I gre up in) turn to crap because the government felt they had to cater to the less fortunate. I grew up in park slope brooklyn. arguably beautiful, definitely desireable. there is a very large "project" that has been there as long as I can remember...and I went to school with people who lived there *gasp* it doesn't HAVE to be the way you describe. I live in a building in Brooklyn of mostly rent controlled people. some of the most decent, respectful, hardworking people I have EVER known (and, double gasp, they are immigrants) none of what you described is mutually inclusive of each other (low income, not hard working, criminals). I am not going to comment on the actual matter at hand....just the idea of what you have described. I am sure most people didn't even know that park slope HAS a "project" in it. and conversely, what about the thousands of people who were priced out of their apts/homes in "desirable" nabes in the city b/c of the "boom" in the market a few years ago. rents tripled, home prices skyrocketed. people living and working (sometimes even HARD) in areas surrounding these "desireable" areas that are now displaced b/c people with more money to spend want to move in. how is any of THAT fair? Message edited 2009-08-12 17:04:21.363000. |
Posted 8/12/09 5:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? I think Westchester has to be more organized and have a plan when they create this housing - when they did it in Yonkers, it was a disaster. What was supposed to be safe, affordable, better living for people turned into the opposite. I just hope the government tries to examine what went wrong there and do it the right way - make sure there are services, support systems for the people in these areas - make them close to public transportation (big disaster in some of the yonkers housing - people had no way of getting around). Hopefully the county will do a better job this time. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 5:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by BunnyBaby Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Wow. Just... WOW. I don't know if I necessarily agree with what the government is mandating, though I see how they can legally do it because, if they are providing federal funds, they can require whatever they want of the County. But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... Oh please. Give me a break. But calling Westchester a "WASP" community is not discrimination? I was not trying to be derogatory in any shape or form. Just to add... I can bet any amount of money that you live in a beautiful neighborhood without any low icome housing that was government funded. I've seen many beautiful neighborhoods (including the one I gre up in) turn to crap because the government felt they had to cater to the less fortunate. Wow.. I think you are making an awful lot of assumptions about people and where they do or don't live when you have NO idea. Not a good way to get people to listen to your ideas |
|
Posted 8/12/09 5:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Political correctness aside, can anyone here argue that the crime rates are not indeed higher in lower income neighborhoods than upper income areas? |
|
Posted 8/12/09 5:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by Otherme Posted by BunnyBaby Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by BunnyBaby How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want! Wow. Just... WOW. I don't know if I necessarily agree with what the government is mandating, though I see how they can legally do it because, if they are providing federal funds, they can require whatever they want of the County. But my opinion aside, when I read this post, my skin brustled to see such blatant discrimination verbalized on here. What a horrific presumption to state that all who are "less fortunate" increase crime, create hellholes for their own communities, and that the only reason for their misfortune is that they work less hard. Truly saddens me... Oh please. Give me a break. But calling Westchester a "WASP" community is not discrimination? I was not trying to be derogatory in any shape or form. Just to add... I can bet any amount of money that you live in a beautiful neighborhood without any low icome housing that was government funded. I've seen many beautiful neighborhoods (including the one I gre up in) turn to crap because the government felt they had to cater to the less fortunate. Wow.. I think you are making an awful lot of assumptions about people and where they do or don't live when you have NO idea. Not a good way to get people to listen to your ideas In her defense just look at what the government has done to Mastic/Shirley. Shirley used to be a nice place to live in till the government thought it would be a great area for low income housing and a wonderful place to house sex offenders. The folks in Shirley should be up in arms over how thay are treated by their leaders |
|
Posted 8/12/09 5:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by annoyedTTCer In her defense just look at what the government has done to Mastic/Shirley. Shirley used to be a nice place to live in till the government thought it would be a great area for low income housing and a wonderful place to house sex offenders. The folks in Shirley should be up in arms over how thay are treated by their leaders Please leave Mastic/Shirley out of this mess. I live there, grew up here, and I still think it is a GREAT place to live. And what "happened" here is much different then what they are talking about in Westchester. This community became a beacon for slum lords FIRST, after a recession very similar to the one we have now. It was then that it took a turn for the worse. And housing sex offenders is MUCH different then affordable housing options for the working/true middle class. Go back to your ivory tower far away from Mastic/Shirley, please! Oh and before you get on your "we must be poor/lower class kick", for the record my Dad, the sole income for my parents (who still live in Mastic) makes well over 150K as do my husband and I... |
|
Posted 8/12/09 7:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Isn't this illegal? Posted by BunnyBaby Oh please. Give me a break. But calling Westchester a "WASP" community is not discrimination? I was not trying to be derogatory in any shape or form. Just to add... I can bet any amount of money that you live in a beautiful neighborhood without any low icome housing that was government funded. I've seen many beautiful neighborhoods (including the one I gre up in) turn to crap because the government felt they had to cater to the less fortunate. I have to say if you weren't trying to be derogatory, you really missed your mark. You made a lot of un-true assumptions in what you said earlier. As for affordable housing, it is not the same as "low income" housing. It usually just has smaller % on the size of the down payment, has to be a conventional mortgage and is slightly below market value. AND there are usually restrictions of the homeowner having to remain in the home for X amount of years or pay the sale profits to the agency (or gov't) that allowed for the sale price to be lower to begin with. Again, a far cry from "low income" and "catering" to anyone. |
|
Posted 8/12/09 7:17 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Is this illegal? | nov04libride | 6/15/06 | 11 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Using illegal drugs... | Stefanie | 3/26/06 | 48 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Illegal immigration debate | Shanti | 3/26/06 | 199 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Would it be illegal... | Mrs-Boop | 2/22/06 | 15 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| renting an illegal apt...need real estate agents help | bklyngirl | 11/12/05 | 3 | Home |
| When was the last time that you did illegal drugs | DebG | 9/2/05 | 25 | Families Helping Families ™ |














