Isn't this illegal?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

BunnyBaby
Loving Motherhood!!!

Member since 11/07

1238 total posts

Name:
Audrina

Isn't this illegal?

Let me preface here by saying that I am not intending to start any drama today. I just read an article (below) that had me Chat Icon

Isn't this illegal? Please share your thoughts, because this is not making any sense to me at all! Its kind of like me selling my house, but encouraging anyone but a certain ethnic group.

Westchester County to market housing to nonwhites

by Associated Press Monday August 10, 2009, 7:14 PM
The suburban county just north of New York City agreed Monday to create hundreds of affordable homes in heavily white communities and encourage nonwhites to move in.

The federal Department of Housing and Urban Development, which brokered the settlement with Westchester County, called it a landmark agreement that could have far-reaching national consequences. Officials said it signaled a new commitment to fair housing by the Obama administration.

"We're clearly messaging other jurisdictions across the country that there has been a significant change in the Department of Housing and Urban Development and we're going to ask them to pursue similar goals as well," said deputy secretary Ron Sims. He said Westchester "can serve as a model for building strong, inclusive, sustainable communities in suburban areas across the entire United States."

Westchester has dense urban areas but is best known for such suburban bedroom communities as Scarsdale and Chappaqua, where former President Bill Clinton and Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton live. Most of those villages are heavily white.

The agreement, filed and approved in federal court Monday, settled a $180 million lawsuit brought by the Anti-Discrimination Center of Metro New York. The lawsuit alleged that Westchester failed to build affordable housing and reduce segregation in some of the county's more affluent communities.

"Westchester can no longer hide from the ugly reality of continuing residential segregation," said Craig Gurian, the anti-discrimination center's executive director, after the settlement was announced.

The county's Legislature must approve the agreement.

A federal judge ruled in February that when Westchester sought federal housing and development funds, it failed to analyze, as required, how race could affect access to fair housing.

Westchester admitted no wrongdoing, but the ruling apparently spurred the county to involve the federal government and settle with the Justice Department when it intervened.

Westchester said it will build or acquire 750 apartments or houses in its towns and villages in the next seven years. Of that number, 630 are to be built in neighborhoods that are less than 3 percent black and 7 percent Hispanic.

The county's population is just less than 1 million.

Whites cannot be excluded from buying or renting the homes, but the agreement calls for Westchester to market them throughout the county and in nearby areas with large nonwhite populations. That includes New York City, which abuts Westchester along the Bronx line.

The agreement also calls for Westchester to pay the federal government $21.6 million, which the government will then return to the county to help pay for the housing. The county will add $30 million to its capital budget for housing. An additional $10.9 million will be paid to the anti-discrimination center, its lawyers and the government.

Westchester's deputy county executive, Susan Tolchin, said the agreement recognizes that the county does not control local zoning and the monitor would be permitted to "give us some flexibility about the (seven-year) deadline."

County Executive Andrew Spano said the county has built more than 1,700 units of affordable housing in the last decade, but some communities have resisted affordable housing with zoning and other regulations.

"We're looking for new, innovative, creative ways of doing this with acquiescence from those communities," he said. "We'd rather not do it by litigation."

Posted 8/12/09 12:25 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

evnme
My little lamb

Member since 8/05

12633 total posts

Name:
aka momma2b

Re: Isn't this illegal?

i dont know if it's illegal, but it sure smells of reverse racism!

what about whites who want to live in westchester, but are priced out of the current market? what about affordable housing for them?

it kinda goes along w/ the gov't giving scholarships to minorities to go to med school who come from poor areas and then expecting them to ONLY work in hospitals in those same poor areas.

it's racism no matter which way you slice it.

Posted 8/12/09 12:35 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Isn't this illegal?

if it's not illegal it's close

Posted 8/12/09 12:40 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

I don't think it's illegal since they are just marketing it in areas that are non-white, but can not prevent whites from buying in. There are plenty of products that are available to everyone but the advertising is targeted to a certain segment of the population.

ETA: I don't like the idea of how they are marketing it, but it's perfectly legal. I am interested to see what they consider "affordable housing" to be price wise.

Message edited 2009-08-12 12:43:49.803000.

Posted 8/12/09 12:41 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by BunnyBaby

Whites cannot be excluded from buying or renting the homes, but the agreement calls for Westchester to market them throughout the county and in nearby areas with large nonwhite populations. That includes New York City, which abuts Westchester along the Bronx line.



Not illegal--they are not discriminating, just trying to open up the applicant pool.

I think the assumptionis that if you build this affordable housing in a white area, of course white people will know about it it, b/c those in that aera will see it, but if they advertise it in other areas, they will get a more diverse group of applicants.

Posted by CathyB
I am interested to see what they consider "affordable housing" to be price wise.



Me too!

Message edited 2009-08-12 12:58:50.600000.

Posted 8/12/09 12:57 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Isn't this illegal?

I think the article answers your question:

The agreement, filed and approved in federal court Monday, settled a $180 million lawsuit brought by the Anti-Discrimination Center of Metro New York. The lawsuit alleged that Westchester failed to build affordable housing and reduce segregation in some of the county's more affluent communities.

Posted 8/12/09 12:57 PM
 

BunnyBaby
Loving Motherhood!!!

Member since 11/07

1238 total posts

Name:
Audrina

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Kara

I think the article answers your question:

The agreement, filed and approved in federal court Monday, settled a $180 million lawsuit brought by the Anti-Discrimination Center of Metro New York. The lawsuit alleged that Westchester failed to build affordable housing and reduce segregation in some of the county's more affluent communities.




Okay, maybe I should have phrased the question better-

Does this SEEM illegal?
why the need for the government to meddle into where people move to? For years ethnic groups have moved to areas where other similar ethnic groups have already set up. people of what ever part of the world always move to areas where their countrymen have settled.How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!
Where is it written that there has to be ‘x’ number of race representation in a community? As long as there isn’t blatant discrimination, it shouldn’t matter how many of who there is. Maybe they should figure out why these neighborhoods are more desirable than minority neighborhoods? Just a thought.

Posted 8/12/09 1:11 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

wow i can't afford to move to beverly hills - all these years i thought that it was just because i didnt make enough money. . .who knew it was discrimination?!

Posted 8/12/09 1:12 PM
 

evnme
My little lamb

Member since 8/05

12633 total posts

Name:
aka momma2b

Re: Isn't this illegal?

my DH lost a promotion once b/c of race quotas. he was more qualified and did better on the exam, but b/c the runner up was a black woman and they had quotas to fiill, she got the job instead of him.

it's reverse racism.

Posted 8/12/09 1:20 PM
 

JP826
=)

Member since 9/06

10903 total posts

Name:
Me!! All about ME!

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by evnme

my DH lost a promotion once b/c of race quotas. he was more qualified and did better on the exam, but b/c the runner up was a black woman and they had quotas to fiill, she got the job instead of him.

it's reverse racism.



Wow... That is completely unacceptable in every way.

Did he just walk away, or did he take further action to try to appeal that decision?

Posted 8/12/09 1:23 PM
 

evnme
My little lamb

Member since 8/05

12633 total posts

Name:
aka momma2b

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by SIBride06

Posted by evnme

my DH lost a promotion once b/c of race quotas. he was more qualified and did better on the exam, but b/c the runner up was a black woman and they had quotas to fiill, she got the job instead of him.

it's reverse racism.



Wow... That is completely unacceptable in every way.

Did he just walk away, or did he take further action to try to appeal that decision?



he didn't do anything about it. he didn't stay much longer at the job b/c he got into law school and went that route instead of staying in the other career. the woman that got the job was just awful to him for the few months between the promotion and when he left.

Posted 8/12/09 1:27 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by BunnyBaby

Posted by Kara

I think the article answers your question:

The agreement, filed and approved in federal court Monday, settled a $180 million lawsuit brought by the Anti-Discrimination Center of Metro New York. The lawsuit alleged that Westchester failed to build affordable housing and reduce segregation in some of the county's more affluent communities.




Okay, maybe I should have phrased the question better-

Does this SEEM illegal?
why the need for the government to meddle into where people move to? For years ethnic groups have moved to areas where other similar ethnic groups have already set up. people of what ever part of the world always move to areas where their countrymen have settled.How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!
Where is it written that there has to be ‘x’ number of race representation in a community? As long as there isn’t blatant discrimination, it shouldn’t matter how many of who there is. Maybe they should figure out why these neighborhoods are more desirable than minority neighborhoods? Just a thought.



This is part of a settlement agreement for a lawsuit. The government didn't just decide that housing in a particular area could only be marketed to non-whites. Westchester sought federal funds for housing and the court found that they weren't meeting the federal guidelines for receipt of that money. This is the settlement deal that was brokered.

Maybe I am mis-reading the article, but I also don't see where the article says that the homes will ONLY be marketed to non-whites. It just said that Westchester agreed to market the homes to people living in mostly non-white neighborhoods.

Posted 8/12/09 1:30 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Isn't this illegal?

i think it is fine to advertise to bring in anyone into a affordable housing program. that is the point, to open it up to all. And just to make things clear affordable housing doesn't mean that you let anyone in. You have forms/applications to fill out, background checks, every financial aspect of your life examined in order to be considered for affordable house. I think to say we are now only going to advertise to minorities is racist, but from what I get from it is that they are now forced to advertise to EVERYONE. They were only catering to white applicants and trying to get white affordable housing individuals in that particular neighborhood. Now that is wrong.

Posted 8/12/09 1:31 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Isn't this illegal?

this post is about advertising on established affordable housing in a affluent neighborhood. I do not think we should turn this into a battle over affirmative action because that is when it will turn ugly. the buildings exist and more are sanctioned to be built the problem was they were not advertising to all groups of people only a selection which is flat out racist.

Posted 8/12/09 1:34 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

OK the title itself irks me... so only "nonwhites" need affordable housing? Why bring race into it... just make affordable housing.

Posted 8/12/09 1:50 PM
 

BigB
C & J are 10!

Member since 6/05

5914 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Steering is illegal....it doesn't matter which way you are steering, but it is illegal!

Posted 8/12/09 2:07 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by BunnyBaby

The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!



I think the fact that Westchester is predominantly white has to do with the fact that it costs so much $$ to live in certain parts of it - NOTHING to do with 'effort, hard work and achievement'

Yes, no one said minorities can't move there - but when you set pricing as high as it is, you automatically exclude less fortunate people, who may be minorities. So, working hard has nothing to do with it.
It's covert racism rather than blatant racism.

Now, the gov. is just telling Westchester that they need to widen the area that they market to, to give people opportunities to move to these communities that may have never even known about them previously.
I don't see anything wrong with that.
No different than choosing where to place an ad to reach the most people

Posted 8/12/09 2:10 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by evnme

my DH lost a promotion once b/c of race quotas. he was more qualified and did better on the exam, but b/c the runner up was a black woman and they had quotas to fiill, she got the job instead of him.

it's reverse racism.




So ridiculous! Just like the issue they have with the NYFD exam b/c supposably the test was racist against hispanic and black people Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

People get carries away with this stuff!

Posted 8/12/09 2:13 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by BunnyBaby

The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!



I think the fact that Westchester is predominantly white has to do with the fact that it costs so much $$ to live in certain parts of it - NOTHING to do with 'effort, hard work and achievement'

Yes, no one said minorities can't move there - but when you set pricing as high as it is, you automatically exclude less fortunate people, who may be minorities. So, working hard has nothing to do with it.
It's covert racism rather than blatant racism.

Now, the gov. is just telling Westchester that they need to widen the area that they market to, to give people opportunities to move to these communities that may have never even known about them previously.
I don't see anything wrong with that.
No different than choosing where to place an ad to reach the most people




I probably couldnt afford to live in Westchester and DH and I are white. Should we file a lawsuit that they should make housing more affordable for us? Chat Icon

Posted 8/12/09 2:14 PM
 

amish089
LIF Zygote

Member since 8/09

1 total post

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?


The suburban county just north of New York City agreed Monday to create hundreds of affordable homes in heavily white communities and [b] encourage[/b] nonwhites to move in.

The federal Department of Housing and Urban Development, which brokered the settlement with Westchester County, called it a landmark agreement that could have far-reaching national consequences. Officials said it signaled a new commitment to fair housing by the Obama administration.



Non-whites would be encouraged to move in. It doesn't say only non-whites [will] move in and no one else is allowed. And it is a settlement of a lawsuit, which means that it is a reaction and reparation for harms done, ie discrimination to non-whites. So no-- it is not illegal.

So I don't understand whatall this fuss is about. Have you all not studied history, for years non-whites have been discriminated against and kept out of neighborhoods. Hear of Red-lining? ... Look it up.
Not to mention, many of the white families that live in these neighborhoods couldn't afford these homes today if they hadn't bought in to the neighborhood before the real estate boom.

Reverse Racism doesn't exist. It is simply a term white people came up with when non-whites were provided a level playing field.

Nobody is taking away your home, so why should it bother you that new affordable housing will be provided for people less fortunate. Only wealthy people can live in Westechester? My question is -- Is that legal?

Posted 8/12/09 2:22 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Kara

This is part of a settlement agreement for a lawsuit. The government didn't just decide that housing in a particular area could only be marketed to non-whites. Westchester sought federal funds for housing and the court found that they weren't meeting the federal guidelines for receipt of that money. This is the settlement deal that was brokered.

Maybe I am mis-reading the article, but I also don't see where the article says that the homes will ONLY be marketed to non-whites. It just said that Westchester agreed to market the homes to people living in mostly non-white neighborhoods.



agreed. the way the article is framing it makes it seem like it is racially motivated when this is really an issue of whether or not the County of Westchester is providing adequate amounts of affordable housing.

it's like when you are looking to hire from a more diverse pool of job applicants. You can't outright say you are looking to hire minorities, but you can target where you advertise your job listing. No different in this instance.

i think the way the article is stating the issue in a way to incite drama, for lack of a better word. nothing more. these lawsuits happen all over the country all the time.

Posted 8/12/09 2:24 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by BunnyBaby

[Does this SEEM illegal?
why the need for the government to meddle into where people move to? For years ethnic groups have moved to areas where other similar ethnic groups have already set up. people of what ever part of the world always move to areas where their countrymen have settled.How dare the government or anyone tell residents who are more fortunate that less fortunate people will be moving into your area, bringing down your property value, increasing crime. Maybe they should worry about cleaning up the comunities they're already in instead of looking to ruin nicer neighborhoods. The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!
Where is it written that there has to be ‘x’ number of race representation in a community? As long as there isn’t blatant discrimination, it shouldn’t matter how many of who there is. Maybe they should figure out why these neighborhoods are more desirable than minority neighborhoods? Just a thought.





I'm sorry but personally, I find the above statements offensive. I'm sure that I could not afford to buy in a Westchester bedroom community right now. That does not make me less fortunate nor does it mean that if I did move in, that I would drive down property values or increase crime. Just because someone may be "less fortunate" or a minority does not mean they are criminals or low-lifes.

Posted 8/12/09 2:33 PM
 

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by amish089

Only wealthy people can live in Westechester? My question is -- Is that legal?



Huh? Only wealthy people can live in Oyster Bay Cove, only wealthy people can buy a jet, only wealthy people can send their kids to London once a month for shitss and giggles, only wealthy people can spend $3500 on a handbag...

I don't understand your question. Is that legal? Where are you going with that?

How is expensive housing discriminatory against non-whites? It's discriminatory against low-income PEOPLE, not just one group.

This is ridiculous. Are they going to start building affordable housing in every wealthy community in the US?

I really just don't get this article at all.

eta: is it because there is no affordable housing throughout the COUNTY?

Message edited 2009-08-12 14:38:43.037000.

Posted 8/12/09 2:37 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by mrswask

I'm sorry but personally, I find the above statements offensive. I'm sure that I could not afford to buy in a Westchester bedroom community right now. That does not make me less fortunate nor does it mean that if I did move in, that I would drive down property values or increase crime. Just because someone may be "less fortunate" or a minority does not mean they are criminals or low-lifes.



ITA.

Posted 8/12/09 2:37 PM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: Isn't this illegal?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by BunnyBaby

The fact that these targeted communitities are predominantly white has more to do with effort, hard work, and achievement, than it does with the color of their skin. No one said minirities couldn't move there, and no one said those neighborhoods they currently populate have to be hellholes. Work hard and achieve like these other people did and you can live wherever you want!



I think the fact that Westchester is predominantly white has to do with the fact that it costs so much $$ to live in certain parts of it - NOTHING to do with 'effort, hard work and achievement'

Yes, no one said minorities can't move there - but when you set pricing as high as it is, you automatically exclude less fortunate people, who may be minorities. So, working hard has nothing to do with it.
It's covert racism rather than blatant racism.

Now, the gov. is just telling Westchester that they need to widen the area that they market to, to give people opportunities to move to these communities that may have never even known about them previously.
I don't see anything wrong with that.
No different than choosing where to place an ad to reach the most people



That is insane.
So the people who live in Westchester are rich people and typically rich people are white but...not necessarily hard workers but they are rich and can live in High priced areas. Therefore it is not fair to the people who cannot afford those areas (minorities, which in this case we would all be included if it is based on finances). Wow!
I completely disagree with this outlook.

When did the government get the right to determine which residential areas should be "widened" due to ethinic background? Maybe next it will be the Hamptons, certain streets in NYC, heck why is their not affordable housing next to the White House?

Posted 8/12/09 2:38 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is this illegal? nov04libride 6/15/06 11 Families Helping Families ™
Using illegal drugs... Stefanie 3/26/06 48 Families Helping Families ™
Illegal immigration debate Shanti 3/26/06 199 Families Helping Families ™
Would it be illegal... Mrs-Boop 2/22/06 15 Families Helping Families ™
renting an illegal apt...need real estate agents help bklyngirl 11/12/05 3 Home
When was the last time that you did illegal drugs DebG 9/2/05 25 Families Helping Families ™