is this fair?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by MarisaK Posted by Mikismom Posted by MarisaK Nothing is fair - IMO. It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life ....... But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone ....... Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid - I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate - I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation - I am sorry to say this, and I DON'T mean to be argumentative but this mentality amazes me. HE was SPEEDING (recklessly) he KILLED 3 people, kids will be kids does not cut it. I think this mentality (which I am sure alot of people share with you) is part of the reason that these young kids have a sense of entitlement, with NO consequences for doing the wrong thing.... He should serve jail time, no doubt about it...HE KILLED 3 PEOPLE BY ACTING LIKE A JACKAZZ I'm not saying 'Oh he's just a kid - let him off' .........I'm saying this was a tragic car accident that could have happened to anyone at any age - Anyone who tells me they've never done 80 mph is lying - You've never looked @ the speedometer & though "oh sh*t, I didn't realize I was going so fast" - Or been in a mad rush to get somewhere and drove like a lunatic? Is it SAFE, no, is it RESPONSIBLE, no .....but we have all done it. - And at the time, you're not thinking about the potential dangers of it - As a KID, you're REALLY not thinking about the dangers of youir actions - What I'm saying is, this kid no longer has the luxury of looking back on it and saying 'Thank God I didn't kill anyone/myself" - He has to live w/ the fact that his poor judgement caused an accident that killed 3 people - And I don't think he should spend the rest of his life in jail for it - Drunk Drivers don't serve lifetime sentences .......why should he? I don't see anywhere that I said he should serve life in prison but 30 days is LAUGHABLE and an INSULT to the people he killed, IMHO |
|
Posted 12/4/08 12:59 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: is this fair? Justice was NOT served here. It makes me sick...he should have gotten MANSLAUGHTER Message edited 2008-12-04 13:02:44.530000. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 1:02 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: is this fair? Posted by Mikismom I don't see anywhere that I said he should serve life in prison but 30 days is LAUGHABLE and an INSULT to the people he killed, IMHO really...making the jump from 30 days to LIFE is out of control. 2-3 years, minimum security. or PROBATION at the very least, with NO LICENSE until 21. the whole IDEA of criminally negligent homicide is that death was NOT intended but the result of engaging in behavior that had at least a reasonable expectation that death could occur (rough translation) how this doesnt' qualify is beyond me. and if you engage or have engaged in EQUALLY stupid of negligent behavior, consider yourself and the greater public LUCKY that you did not find yourself in the situation...but don't use that to take culpability from someone else. |
Posted 12/4/08 1:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? I'm not saying whether the judegment was right or wrong, but this kid is going to live with this pain for the rest of his life. He did not "murder" these kids. These were probably his best friends... they were probably having fun. He happend to be driving... maybe they took turns. It was an ACCIDENT. The results are tragic, but it was an ACCIDENT. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 1:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? I am sure his two other friends were thinking fun times. I think its a terrible accident. Maybe he should have a longer sentence, but I dont think he should serve life or years in prison. However, I hope to never be in this situation and I send prayers to everyone involved. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 1:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by KvsGrl I'm not saying whether the judegment was right or wrong, but this kid is going to live with this pain for the rest of his life. He did not "murder" these kids. These were probably his best friends... they were probably having fun. He happend to be driving... maybe they took turns. It was an ACCIDENT. The results are tragic, but it was an ACCIDENT. I have a friend who got into a car accident in high school and killed his two best friends. He went to jail for 3 years, but that is nothing compared to the pain that he feels every day. Thankfully, the parents did not scream at him. They pitied him because no punishment is as bad as the way he punishes himself. I feel the same way. It's just a no win situation. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 2:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? "Hinrichs said in a written decision that although Badke was accused of driving more than 80 mph and veering across the center line on Jericho Turnpike in Smithtown, his behavior didn't amount to criminal negligence. Criminally negligent homicide means that a person created risk, and didn't just fail to perceive it, Hinrichs said. Absent another factor, like running a red light, speeding is not enough, he said" |
|
Posted 12/4/08 2:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? He should've gotten at least a year or 2 to teach him a lesson....30 days is nothing! |
|
Posted 12/4/08 2:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? only 30 days is a slap in the face to the people who died... |
|
Posted 12/4/08 2:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by Blu-ize Posted by KvsGrl I'm not saying whether the judegment was right or wrong, but this kid is going to live with this pain for the rest of his life. He did not "murder" these kids. These were probably his best friends... they were probably having fun. He happend to be driving... maybe they took turns. It was an ACCIDENT. The results are tragic, but it was an ACCIDENT. I have a friend who got into a car accident in high school and killed his two best friends. He went to jail for 3 years, but that is nothing compared to the pain that he feels every day. Thankfully, the parents did not scream at him. They pitied him because no punishment is as bad as the way he punishes himself. I feel the same way. It's just a no win situation. I agree too. I have a similar story of a friend who killed a friend while driving in HS. Nothing will ease this pain for any side of this story. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? I think this kid should do hard time. Driving so selfishly and with such indifference to others is NOT something that everyione does. It needs to be something that everyone knows will get them hard time. Deaths and tragedies would be fewer and people would be forced to act with some thought and consideration--even if it's out of pure self-interest. People stink, and to the extent that this kid's too much of a "kid" to deal with the penalty--whatever it is--of killing 3 people--then we need to rethink the requisite age to drive, the blood alcohol level we deem "ok) (even though that wasn't implicated here), the penalties imposed, and whatever else needs to be rethought so that we can all use the roads without winding up living or dying at the whim of stupid people. Message edited 2008-12-04 18:55:45.750000. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 4:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? I am shocked and outraged that he got such a light sentence...30 days?!?!? What will that do? People who shoplift or do much, much less get that. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 4:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by kahlua716 No. He knowingly and willingly drove like a maniac. He should've gotten manslaughter. agreed |
|
Posted 12/4/08 6:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by Blu-ize Posted by KvsGrl I'm not saying whether the judegment was right or wrong, but this kid is going to live with this pain for the rest of his life. He did not "murder" these kids. These were probably his best friends... they were probably having fun. He happend to be driving... maybe they took turns. It was an ACCIDENT. The results are tragic, but it was an ACCIDENT. I have a friend who got into a car accident in high school and killed his two best friends. He went to jail for 3 years, but that is nothing compared to the pain that he feels every day. Thankfully, the parents did not scream at him. They pitied him because no punishment is as bad as the way he punishes himself. I feel the same way. It's just a no win situation. I agree as well. Yes, he ended up killing two of his friends and another teenager, but he did not INTEND to. Yes, his actions had horrible consequences, but he has to live with that agony for the rest of his life.. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 7:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? But a drunk driver doesn't necessarily intend to kill anyone. Nor does someone who fires a gun into the air or someone who throws a lit match and sets a house ablaze. These things may all be punishable though. It's not about intending to kill people. It's about acting in a way that surely will kill someone and not caring. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 7:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by KateDevine Yes, he ended up killing two of his friends and another teenager, but he did not INTEND to. Yes, his actions had horrible consequences, .. from Ophelia's post from above "the whole IDEA of criminally negligent homicide is that death was NOT intended but the result of engaging in behavior that had at least a reasonable expectation that death could occur (rough translation)" No one is saying that he intended to kill anyone, but what he did is still punishable |
|
Posted 12/4/08 8:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? I'm torn about the whole matter and as I've already said I have a personal connection to this story. What I think many may not realize, is the stretch of Jericho Tpk where this happened is wide open and while 80 is very fast, I believe the speed limit is 50 (I'm just guessing). I know I have caught myself easily picking up speed on that stretch of road. I still think 30 days is insufficient, but there really are no winners here. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? I just don't understand this. A former student of mine, a really good person, did something incredibly similar to what this person did. He was speeding; the car crashed, and his best friend, his one passenger, was killed. He, the driver, was in very bad shape (the first responders didn't think he'd make it). A year later, he was sentenced to 1 1/3 - 4 years in prison (I'm assuming based on behavior?). |
|
Posted 12/4/08 9:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? when I heard this it made me wonder how much $ his parents have. He shouldn't be in jail for years and years, but 30 days is so little, it's insulting. Almost like why even bother |
|
Posted 12/4/08 9:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by Ophelia Posted by MarisaK Nothing is fair - IMO. It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life ....... But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone ....... Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid - I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate - I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation - a "KID' shouldn't be given the PRIVILEGE to drive, but not be held RESPONSIBLE for his actions simply b/c he's young. 18 is "old" enough to vote, "old" enough to go to war...they are also "old" enough to know that the faster you drive, the more dangerous it is. that is why we have speed LIMITS in the first place. NOTHING will change on LI (or anywhere) if people keep using the "kids being kids" excuse. I'm sorry. If you can't anticipate ALL of the dangers that could present themselves when you are given a drivers license, you shouldn't be given one. I cannot understand how a JUDGE could sit there and say that a person driving 80 miles per hour is not or should not be aware that there is a DANGER and potential consequences in that. it's digusting. OMG...very well said I can not fathom the idea of thinking "hes just a kid" when the law states that he is old enough to drive. In that case up the law to 25...or 30...or whenever a person is "said" to be responsible... |
|
Posted 12/4/08 10:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by Mikismom Posted by KateDevine Yes, he ended up killing two of his friends and another teenager, but he did not INTEND to. Yes, his actions had horrible consequences, .. from Ophelia's post from above "the whole IDEA of criminally negligent homicide is that death was NOT intended but the result of engaging in behavior that had at least a reasonable expectation that death could occur (rough translation)" No one is saying that he intended to kill anyone, but what he did is still punishable But he IS being punished, 30 days in jail is the punishment. Not debating the length of time, just that it IS a punishment. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 10:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by KateDevine Posted by Mikismom Posted by KateDevine Yes, he ended up killing two of his friends and another teenager, but he did not INTEND to. Yes, his actions had horrible consequences, .. from Ophelia's post from above "the whole IDEA of criminally negligent homicide is that death was NOT intended but the result of engaging in behavior that had at least a reasonable expectation that death could occur (rough translation)" No one is saying that he intended to kill anyone, but what he did is still punishable But he IS being punished, 30 days in jail is the punishment. Not debating the length of time, just that it IS a punishment. and my ONLY debate is the length of the time....I think it is a travesty of "justice"
|
|
Posted 12/4/08 10:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? The 13 year old boy had some type of disability and his mom was taking him homer from therapy. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 11:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? It s**ks but nothing about when someone dies like that is fair. Its not fair that those people were killed. Its not fair that their families have to continue living with that pain. Its not fair that that kid must now live with such a brutally real consequence of a mistake that probably all of us have made at one point. Its not fair that 30 days is legally considered equal to his crime. |
|
Posted 12/4/08 11:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: is this fair? Posted by krissy888 when I heard this it made me wonder how much $ his parents have. He shouldn't be in jail for years and years, but 30 days is so little, it's insulting. Almost like why even bother My understanding is that the family is pretty middle class. I think the mother may be a teacher. I also believe that at least the passenger's deaths (Badke's friend's)were probably caused by them not using seat belts. They were thrown from the car which would not have happened if they were belted. Again, that doesn't necessarily justify the speed nor the punishment or argue against the fact that they could have died anyway, but I'm sure it was a factor. The larger problem in my mind is that these off campus lunch deaths have become to common and need to be addressed on a large scale basis. We all know that a couple of young kids in a car has the real potential to be bad news. |
|
Posted 12/5/08 10:59 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I. Hate. Science. Fair. | VirginiaDeb | 4/22/08 | 0 | Teachers |
| Who Says Women Aren't Funny? article (LONG) from the upcoming issue of "Vanity Fair." | GossipQueen | 3/4/08 | 0 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| UPDATED WITH PICS!!! Fair warning - there very well may be a PWI shortstuff tonight | Shorty | 10/27/07 | 53 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| what to you would be considered a fair salary for someone with 5 years exp in a corporation. | antoinette | 4/12/07 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Tyra Banks appears in the new issue of Vanity Fair in a Breakfast At Tiffany's inspired spread. | MrsQ | 1/5/07 | 10 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| MOST LIKELY NOT-But will anyone be going to China to the Canton or Hong Kong Fair? | aliasPook | 10/21/06 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
















