|
Re: is this fair?
Posted 12/4/2008 9:27:11 PM by nel I just don't understand this. A former student of mine, a really good person, did something incredibly similar to what this person did. He was speeding; the car crashed, and his best friend, his one passenger, was killed. He, the driver, was in very bad shape (the first responders didn't think he'd make it). A year later, he was sentenced to 1 1/3 - 4 years in prison (I'm assuming based on behavior?). He's there now. He writes to me. He feels incredibly guilty and he plead guilty, feeling that he deserved whatever punishment he got. I don't think he deserved life; I hate thinking he deserves any kind of punishment, but I know he does. It's a terrible thing that happened, but it was an accident. If he'd gotten 30 days, though, I think I wouldn't have felt that justice was served... and I don't think he would have either. He is willingly serving this sentence; he thinks it's the least he deserves for what he did. He didn't mean for this to happen, but that doesn't mean he shouldn't pay the consequences. I hate having to write to him in jail, and I don't understand why this person only gets 30 days while my former student gets years and the circumstances were nearly identical (except with one fatality as opposed to three). I'm not saying my student should have had a lighter sentence; I don't think he necessarily should. But this sentence should NOT have been for only thirty days. It just ISN'T fair. Sorry so long... this really hit a nerve. |