is this fair?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

is this fair?

Smithtown teen who killed 3 in crash gets 30 days



The Smithtown teen who crashed his car and killed three people received a 30-day jail sentence Wednesday in Riverhead after pleading guilty to reckless driving, bringing to a close an emotional case that saw homicide charges dismissed when a judge ruled the facts didn't fit the crime.

Steven Badke, 18, had initially faced three counts of criminally negligent homicide, but Suffolk County Court Judge C. Randall Hinrichs threw out the felony charges in September.

Hinrichs said in a written decision that although Badke was accused of driving more than 80 mph and veering across the center line on Jericho Turnpike in Smithtown, his behavior didn't amount to criminal negligence. Criminally negligent homicide means that a person created risk, and didn't just fail to perceive it, Hinrichs said. Absent another factor, like running a red light, speeding is not enough, he said.

"This decision in no way should be interpreted as condoning the defendant's actions," Hinrichs said in court Wednesday, before denying Badke's request to be treated as a youthful offender.

Hinrichs also ordered that Badke begin serving his sentence immediately and pay $900 in fines for several traffic violations connected with the accident.

According to police, Badke's 2004 Honda Civic swerved across the lines and slammed into a minivan driven by June Aruanno, 48, of Smithtown. Her son, John Aruanno, 13, a passenger in the van, died from his injuries.

Daniel DiStefano of Nesconset and Michael Western of Smithtown, both 17, also died after they were thrown from Badke's car.

In an anguished, piercing statement in court, Western's mother, Janet, said she believed Badke had "murdered" her son on Oct. 31, 2007.

"Can you still hear my son scream? Can you still see him lying there?" she said, her voice rising until Hinrichs interrupted, asking her not to shout. "I want you to remember these words each and every time you close your eyes."

Outside court, Janet Western said she hopes Badke lives a "long, miserable life," adding that "he should rot in hell."

As relatives of the dead voiced their grief in court, Badke, a lanky teen with shaggy brown hair, stood motionless, arms limply at his side. Badke declined to speak, but his lawyer, Dennis Lemke of Mineola, said his client's stoic demeanor concealed deep sorrow.

Badke pleaded guilty to spare the grieving families the pain of a trial, he said.

"He is extremely remorseful," Lemke said. "He lives with this every day and he will for the rest of his life."

Court officers placed handcuffs on Badke as several relatives of the victims nodded approvingly. Then Janet Western, palm out, fluttered her right hand twice, waving as the teen was led to jail.

Posted 12/4/08 9:38 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: is this fair?

No. He knowingly and willingly drove like a maniac. He should've gotten manslaughter.

Posted 12/4/08 9:43 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: is this fair?

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -

Posted 12/4/08 9:46 AM
 

Tulips915
................

Member since 8/08

6851 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: is this fair?

Posted by kahlua716

No. He knowingly and willingly drove like a maniac. He should've gotten manslaughter.

I agree.

Posted 12/4/08 9:48 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: is this fair?

I do think it is fair. I think the accident is tragic and awful, but I also think the driver was 18 and didn't foresee what his actions could do. You see people driving 80 on the highway everyday, it is a stupid move and with the inexperience of a new driver deadly, but I don't think it is manslaughter.

Posted 12/4/08 9:48 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: is this fair?

80 mph on Jericho is not just "speeding". That is blatant, reckless, and felony homicide. He should have gotten a few decades.... Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/08 9:49 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: is this fair?

Posted by MarisaK

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -



I agree.

I'm also not sure I wouldn't be the devastated, screaming mom if it were my kids.

While I can't imagine that kid would even want to drive again after killing 2 of his friends & a little boy, I think 30 days may be too lenient. It's one of those cases where there is no justice for any of the parties involved.Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/08 10:03 AM
 

EckoRed81504
We are complete <3

Member since 12/07

6299 total posts

Name:
April

Re: is this fair?

Not at all. Kid or not, you know the laws and limits.

Posted 12/4/08 10:16 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: is this fair?

Posted by headoverheels

Criminally negligent homicide means that a person created risk, and didn't just fail to perceive it, Hinrichs said. Absent another factor, like running a red light, speeding is not enough, he said.



I don't understand how crossing the divider line is not "another factor" that created risk.

Posted 12/4/08 10:18 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: is this fair?

Posted by MarisaK

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -



a "KID' shouldn't be given the PRIVILEGE to drive, but not be held RESPONSIBLE for his actions simply b/c he's young.

18 is "old" enough to vote, "old" enough to go to war...they are also "old" enough to know that the faster you drive, the more dangerous it is.

that is why we have speed LIMITS in the first place.

NOTHING will change on LI (or anywhere) if people keep using the "kids being kids" excuse. I'm sorry.

If you can't anticipate ALL of the dangers that could present themselves when you are given a drivers license, you shouldn't be given one.

I cannot understand how a JUDGE could sit there and say that a person driving 80 miles per hour is not or should not be aware that there is a DANGER and potential consequences in that.

it's digusting.

Posted 12/4/08 10:26 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: is this fair?

Posted by tourist

Posted by headoverheels

Criminally negligent homicide means that a person created risk, and didn't just fail to perceive it, Hinrichs said. Absent another factor, like running a red light, speeding is not enough, he said.



I don't understand how crossing the divider line is not "another factor" that created risk.

good point!

i am so torn on how i feel about this. basically it comes down to accountability. is 30 days in jail really going to affect this man (because at 18 he IS an adult)? is it going to make a difference in his life? because that is the ultimate goal of any sentence of jail time - to REHABILITATE the offender, not just punish him.

IMO, 30 days just isn't enough to rehabilitate anyone.

but who knows? maybe i am wrong. but i still think this is a slap on the wrist.

Posted 12/4/08 10:29 AM
 

Tulips915
................

Member since 8/08

6851 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: is this fair?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by MarisaK

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -



a "KID' shouldn't be given the PRIVILEGE to drive, but not be held RESPONSIBLE for his actions simply b/c he's young.

18 is "old" enough to vote, "old" enough to go to war...they are also "old" enough to know that the faster you drive, the more dangerous it is.

that is why we have speed LIMITS in the first place.

NOTHING will change on LI (or anywhere) if people keep using the "kids being kids" excuse. I'm sorry.

If you can't anticipate ALL of the dangers that could present themselves when you are given a drivers license, you shouldn't be given one.

I cannot understand how a JUDGE could sit there and say that a person driving 80 miles per hour is not or should not be aware that there is a DANGER and potential consequences in that.

it's digusting.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/08 10:35 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: is this fair?

I don't care if he was 18 or not--he was being reckless--and he got 30 days for 3 deaths. That means 10 days per life he has taken. That is absolutely disgusting.


Saying that he was a "kid" and that he didn't know any better is an excuse that shouldn't even be used...he just didn't care about his actions and now paying $900 (again each life is worth $300 in fines!) and spending a month in jail is supposed to be a lesson for him? Come on!!!

Posted 12/4/08 10:43 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: is this fair?

Posted by SB7308

Posted by kahlua716

No. He knowingly and willingly drove like a maniac. He should've gotten manslaughter.

I agree.



I agree 100%...what a travesty. He gets to live his life with NO consequences for his actions....reprehensible Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/08 10:50 AM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: is this fair?

Posted by MarisaK

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -



I have to agree with this. Kids think they are invinvcible- unfortunately. I think if alcohol or drag racing or something like THAT were involved- then yes, I would feel differently. But this kid probably feels absolutely horrible about what he's done.

I would probably go a couple years of jail, though. Not just 30 days.

Posted 12/4/08 10:55 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: is this fair?

Posted by MarisaK

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -



I am sorry to say this, and I DON'T mean to be argumentative but this mentality amazes me. HE was SPEEDING (recklessly) he KILLED 3 people, kids will be kids does not cut it. I think this mentality (which I am sure alot of people share with you) is part of the reason that these young kids have a sense of entitlement, with NO consequences for doing the wrong thing....

He should serve jail time, no doubt about it...HE KILLED 3 PEOPLE BY ACTING LIKE A JACKAZZ

Posted 12/4/08 10:57 AM
 

Phyl
R.I.P. Sweet Mia &hearts;

Member since 5/06

28918 total posts

Name:
The Mystical Azzhorse! ™

Re: is this fair?

Posted by headoverheels



In an anguished, piercing statement in court, Western's mother, Janet, said she believed Badke had "murdered" her son on Oct. 31, 2007.

"Can you still hear my son scream? Can you still see him lying there?" she said, her voice rising until Hinrichs interrupted, asking her not to shout. "I want you to remember these words each and every time you close your eyes."
--------------------------------------------------------

I think the whole thing is heartbreaking.

It really made me angry when the judge
interrupted the Mother of the 13 y/o to tell her to quit shouting.Chat Icon I would have lost it right there. Show some compassion at least Judge Dread.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-12-04 11:01:17.420000.

Posted 12/4/08 10:59 AM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: is this fair?

Posted by GoldenRod

80 mph on Jericho is not just "speeding". That is blatant, reckless, and felony homicide. He should have gotten a few decades.... Chat Icon


I agree!
I feel no pity for him, I don't care how old he is.

Posted 12/4/08 10:59 AM
 

sleepie76
enjoying every minute

Member since 12/07

3881 total posts

Name:

Re: is this fair?

I agree 30 days is not long enough.


However, I remember being 18 in cars with other kids, driving too fast, thinking you are invincible. Not realizing how our vehicle could be so dangerous.


It's a horrible, horrible thing that happened.

But I don't think that sending an 18 year old to jail for a long period of time is the answer.

I think he lives with this everyday. Killing his 2 best friends and another person's child.It's a mistake he can't take back.

I know It would haunt me forever.

Posted 12/4/08 11:00 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: is this fair?

Posted by sleepie76

I agree 30 days is not long enough.


However, I remember being 18 in cars with other kids, driving too fast, thinking you are invincible. Not realizing how our vehicle could be so dangerous.


It's a horrible, horrible thing that happened.

But I don't think that sending an 18 year old to jail for a long period of time is the answer.

I think he lives with this everyday. Killing his 2 best friends and another person's child.It's a mistake he can't take back.

I know It would haunt me forever.



if the law relied on how we THINK people FELT after committing a crime, no one would be in jail.

now, I have read Dostoevsky...I understand the power of guilt...but even Raskolnikov felt enough guilt and turned himself in TO BE PUNISHED.

what will people say if this "kid" does NOT learn from this.

how many drunk drivers are caught only to DO IT AGAIN.

where is the blood saturation point???? when do we DEMAND that people MAN UP and BE HELD responsible.

Posted 12/4/08 11:12 AM
 

MissRadiant
Happily Ever After

Member since 9/08

2534 total posts

Name:
N

Re: is this fair?

Posted by Ophelia


I cannot understand how a JUDGE could sit there and say that a person driving 80 miles per hour is not or should not be aware that there is a DANGER and potential consequences in that.

it's digusting.



I agree with this to an extent. I think that bc the guy (not calling him a kid, because he's not) was driving on Jericho Tpke going 80 is really a ridiculously fast speed. Isn't the speed limit on Jericho Turnpike around 35 or something really low like that? If the person had been going 80 on the LIE I could understand not realizing the danger a little bit more.
I think 30 days is definitely not enough time, granted it was an accident and he had no intentions of muder- but maybe he should be made to some sort of program for a year or 2. I do think that the emotional anguish that he will face knowing that because of him 3 people died, is more punishment then any court can give.

Posted 12/4/08 11:25 AM
 

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: is this fair?

As a lawyer, as a mother and as someone who knows Janet Western personally (her younger son has been in my daughter's class for five years running), I just don't think its enough. I haven't read the story yet but even assuming his finding regarding neglience was correct (which I happen to disagree with), was this the maximum legal sentence???? I'm at work now, but will definitely look into this when I have some time.

Posted 12/4/08 11:30 AM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: is this fair?

I don't understand how the judge decided it wasn't criminally negligent. He drove over 80 mph on Jericho Tpke, not the highway! Driving that fast and crossing the divider isn't "creating risk"??? Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/08 11:39 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: is this fair?

Posted by Mikismom

Posted by MarisaK

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -



I am sorry to say this, and I DON'T mean to be argumentative but this mentality amazes me. HE was SPEEDING (recklessly) he KILLED 3 people, kids will be kids does not cut it. I think this mentality (which I am sure alot of people share with you) is part of the reason that these young kids have a sense of entitlement, with NO consequences for doing the wrong thing....

He should serve jail time, no doubt about it...HE KILLED 3 PEOPLE BY ACTING LIKE A JACKAZZ



I'm not saying 'Oh he's just a kid - let him off' .........I'm saying this was a tragic car accident that could have happened to anyone at any age -
Anyone who tells me they've never done 80 mph is lying -
You've never looked @ the speedometer & though "oh sh*t, I didn't realize I was going so fast" - Or been in a mad rush to get somewhere and drove like a lunatic? Is it SAFE, no, is it RESPONSIBLE, no .....but we have all done it. - And at the time, you're not thinking about the potential dangers of it - As a KID, you're REALLY not thinking about the dangers of youir actions -

What I'm saying is, this kid no longer has the luxury of looking back on it and saying 'Thank God I didn't kill anyone/myself" - He has to live w/ the fact that his poor judgement caused an accident that killed 3 people - And I don't think he should spend the rest of his life in jail for it -
Drunk Drivers don't serve lifetime sentences .......why should he?

Posted 12/4/08 12:14 PM
 

RadioLau
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2179 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: is this fair?

I heard about this on the radio this morning and I think it is absolutely ridiculous.

Posted 12/4/08 12:47 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I. Hate. Science. Fair. VirginiaDeb 4/22/08 0 Teachers
Who Says Women Aren't Funny? article (LONG) from the upcoming issue of "Vanity Fair." GossipQueen 3/4/08 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
UPDATED WITH PICS!!! Fair warning - there very well may be a PWI shortstuff tonight Shorty 10/27/07 53 Families Helping Families ™
what to you would be considered a fair salary for someone with 5 years exp in a corporation. antoinette 4/12/07 10 Families Helping Families ™
Tyra Banks appears in the new issue of Vanity Fair in a Breakfast At Tiffany's inspired spread. MrsQ 1/5/07 10 Celebrities & Entertainment
MOST LIKELY NOT-But will anyone be going to China to the Canton or Hong Kong Fair? aliasPook 10/21/06 1 Families Helping Families ™