is this fair?
Posted 12/4/2008 9:38:18 AM by headoverheels

Smithtown teen who killed 3 in crash gets 30 days



The Smithtown teen who crashed his car and killed three people received a 30-day jail sentence Wednesday in Riverhead after pleading guilty to reckless driving, bringing to a close an emotional case that saw homicide charges dismissed when a judge ruled the facts didn't fit the crime.

Steven Badke, 18, had initially faced three counts of criminally negligent homicide, but Suffolk County Court Judge C. Randall Hinrichs threw out the felony charges in September.

Hinrichs said in a written decision that although Badke was accused of driving more than 80 mph and veering across the center line on Jericho Turnpike in Smithtown, his behavior didn't amount to criminal negligence. Criminally negligent homicide means that a person created risk, and didn't just fail to perceive it, Hinrichs said. Absent another factor, like running a red light, speeding is not enough, he said.

"This decision in no way should be interpreted as condoning the defendant's actions," Hinrichs said in court Wednesday, before denying Badke's request to be treated as a youthful offender.

Hinrichs also ordered that Badke begin serving his sentence immediately and pay $900 in fines for several traffic violations connected with the accident.

According to police, Badke's 2004 Honda Civic swerved across the lines and slammed into a minivan driven by June Aruanno, 48, of Smithtown. Her son, John Aruanno, 13, a passenger in the van, died from his injuries.

Daniel DiStefano of Nesconset and Michael Western of Smithtown, both 17, also died after they were thrown from Badke's car.

In an anguished, piercing statement in court, Western's mother, Janet, said she believed Badke had "murdered" her son on Oct. 31, 2007.

"Can you still hear my son scream? Can you still see him lying there?" she said, her voice rising until Hinrichs interrupted, asking her not to shout. "I want you to remember these words each and every time you close your eyes."

Outside court, Janet Western said she hopes Badke lives a "long, miserable life," adding that "he should rot in hell."

As relatives of the dead voiced their grief in court, Badke, a lanky teen with shaggy brown hair, stood motionless, arms limply at his side. Badke declined to speak, but his lawyer, Dennis Lemke of Mineola, said his client's stoic demeanor concealed deep sorrow.

Badke pleaded guilty to spare the grieving families the pain of a trial, he said.

"He is extremely remorseful," Lemke said. "He lives with this every day and he will for the rest of his life."

Court officers placed handcuffs on Badke as several relatives of the victims nodded approvingly. Then Janet Western, palm out, fluttered her right hand twice, waving as the teen was led to jail.
Print Post      Close Window