Re: is this fair?
Posted 12/4/2008 10:55:04 AM by JennyPenny


Posted by MarisaK

Nothing is fair - IMO.

It wasn't fair for those families to lose their sons to a car accident and I'm sure if I were in their position, I'd want that kid to rot in jail for the rest of his life .......

But from a different POV, he's a kid. Most of us, as kids did something less than responsible while driving w/ our friends in the car - Something that we now look back on and think about how stupid and irresponsible we were and LUCKY to not have hurt anyone .......

Unfortunately, this kid was not so lucky and has to live every day for the rest of his life knowing his lapse in judgement took the lives of two of his friends, as well as another 13 year old kid -

I personally don't think putting him in jail for the rest of his life would be appropriate -

I didn't see anything about alcohol being involved, or that would change my entire opinion of the situation -



I have to agree with this. Kids think they are invinvcible- unfortunately. I think if alcohol or drag racing or something like THAT were involved- then yes, I would feel differently. But this kid probably feels absolutely horrible about what he's done.

I would probably go a couple years of jail, though. Not just 30 days.
Print Post      Close Window