I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

i saw that show last night and i was shocked ppl were just walking by and didnt even bother to call 911...
A few years back i was in the subway during rush hr and i completly passed out against the doors. A few people helped me out of the train and called 911 for me. I came to with cops, EMS and 2 people who helped me out of the train. I cant imagine if the doors opened and i fell out. There are a few good people out there but unfortunatly ur right when it comes to the homeless people tend to look the other way. If people are afraid its a plot for a robbery why cant they just call 911?????

Posted 3/11/09 1:05 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by Mikismom

Posted by PrincessP

question, helped them in terms of calling the cops?



helping like calling the cops, helping like going up to them to see if they are okay (if you are not comfortable doing that, calling 911 is a good step)

helping in any way you see fit , but NOT ignoring them and walking by while someone lays on the street



Yes, I would call the cops. NO...I would not go up to them in their face and see if they are ok.

Posted 3/11/09 1:06 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by PrincessP


I dont think its just about the Booze...
There could be some MAJOR issues that brought that person to the street.



I don't understand what you mean? do you mean major issues for their homelessness? or major issues they have that would prevent people from helping???

sorry, I am not all there today.



Mental issue is one of those things. I mean I'm sorry, as an everyday commuter on the MTA subway, I would most likely just call the cops or alert the booth clerk, but I would not go up to them...I'm sorry but thats just me. I've seen waaay too many things for me to risk my safety like that.

On the other hand, I did help a woman the other on the platform who passed out and crashed her skull on the ground...I ran and alerted the booth clerk to call the ambulance and then a bunch of us stayed with her until the ambulance came.

Posted 3/11/09 1:10 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

I don't watch the show. But I do have a comment about this post. Please don't flame me about this. Its just an honest opinion.

I once fell in the street in a cross-walk right when the light was changing to green. Three people lifted me up and carried me to safety- offering to call 911. I was fine. When I was knocked into at Penn Station and my foot fell in teh gap while I was 7 months pregnant, many people helped me. I do have faith in the goodness of people.

Regarding the homeless situation, its so sad. My heart does break everytime I see someone on the street. But living in the city for 11 years, you do get a little numb to it.

When I first moved here, I tried to give every homeless person I saw money. I was just a student and realized I just coudln't do that. There are so many people asking for money. I certainly can't help them all. When I offered a homeless man my diet coke and some food (I was bringing it to school), he turned me down. I've heard people begging for money for a metrocard to get home and when I offer them a swipe from my unlimited- they turn me down (this happened last month). Its the money they want, not to get home. And frankly, some people are dangerous- that goes for homeless or not. Now I'm sure there are plenty of people who would be greatful for what I coudl offer, but there are many that aren't. Some are addicts looking to score. Some are scammers. And some are genuninely asking for help. Its hard to know the difference.

There is a church where I often see people sleeping outside. Whenever I have extra food from an event, I always bring it there. If I saw someone fall, that would be one thing. But honestly, I see homeless people sleeping often, and I figure they are just sleeping. I've seen people sleeping on the subway, in Penn Station, on the street, etc... Its hard to know if someone is sick, or just sleeping. Honestly, if I called 911 everyone I thought I saw someone sleeping on the street, I think I would get in trouble. Not to mention- what happens when you do call 911 and it turns out they don't need medical attention and were just asleep? Is it better or worse?

Its very sad, I know. I wish there was more I can do. Before DD I served food at a shelter from time to time, and when DD is older, I expect to resume it with her helping me. While its sad, I think good people, like me, sometimes just don't know what to do.

Message edited 2009-03-11 13:16:41.327000.

Posted 3/11/09 1:14 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by Shelly

I don't watch the show. But I do have a comment about this post. Please don't flame me about this. Its just an honest opinion.

I once fell in the street in a cross-walk right when the light was changing to green. Three people lifted me up and carried me to safety- offering to call 911. I was fine. When I was knocked into at Penn Station and my foot fell in teh gap while I was 7 months pregnant, many people helped me. I do have faith in the goodness of people.

Regarding the homeless situation, its so sad. My heart does break everytime I see someone on the street. But living in the city for 11 years, you do get a little numb to it.

When I first moved here, I tried to give every homeless person I saw money. I was just a student and realized I just coudln't do that. There are so many people asking for money. I certainly can't help them all. When I offered a homeless man my diet coke and some food (I was bringing it to school), he turned me down. I've heard people begging for money for a metrocard to get home and when I offer them a swipe from my unlimited- they turn me down (this happened last month). Its the money they want, not to get home. And frankly, some people are dangerous- that goes for homeless or not. Now I'm sure there are plenty of people who would be greatful for what I coudl offer, but there are many that aren't. Some are addicts looking to score. Some are scammers. And some are genuninely asking for help. Its hard to know the difference.

There is a church where I often see people sleeping outside. Whenever I have extra food from an event, I always bring it there. If I saw someone fall, that would be one thing. But honestly, I see homeless people sleeping often, and I figure they are just sleeping. I've seen people sleeping on the subway, in Penn Station, on the street, etc... Its hard to know if someone is sick, or just sleeping. Honestly, if I called 911 everyone I thought I saw someone sleeping on the street, I think I would get in trouble. Not to mention- what happens when you do call 911 and it turns out they don't need medical attention and were just asleep? Is it better or worse?

Its very sad, I know. I wish there was more I can do. Before DD I served food at a shelter from time to time, and when DD is older, I expect to resume it with her helping me. While its sad, I think good people, like me, sometimes just don't know what to do.



very well stated. This is how I feel as well.

Posted 3/11/09 1:17 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Something similar happened in Hartford last year. A man was hit by a car and lying in the street. Many cars and pedestrians passed by without any attempt to help him or call 911. Finally, a police car responding to an unrelated call saw the man and helped him. The man ended up being paralyzed. It's sad how people are unwilling to even make a phone call to help a person who was injured.

Posted 3/11/09 1:24 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by Mikismom

Posted by PrincessP

question, helped them in terms of calling the cops?



helping like calling the cops, helping like going up to them to see if they are okay (if you are not comfortable doing that, calling 911 is a good step)

helping in any way you see fit , but NOT ignoring them and walking by while someone lays on the street



Yes, I would call the cops. NO...I would not go up to them in their face and see if they are ok.



I think calling the cops is a good thing....some people will just walk right by

Posted 3/11/09 1:25 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Yes, it's really hard to know what to do with homeless people. If they were noticablly hurt, I would call the police, but I would not go to help them up, especially if it's a man. If it was a homeless woman, I would probably go to help them. I've just seen way too many crazies in NYC and they scare me.

BUT I always always help other strangers. My friend and I were at a bar one night and when we went to leave there were 4 or 5 young guys surrounding this middle aged woman who was obviously drunk and they were kicking her and shoving her face in a plant and throwing dirt into her mouth and all over her. My guess is that she made a move on one of the guys and they thought they would abuse her for the fun of it. I was sick to my stomach, my friend and I went over and started yelling at them to leave her alone and get out of here and telling them how disgusting they are and they should be ashamed of themselves. They backed off and drove away. We helped her up and cleaned her off and actually drove her home, she was living in a trailer park. This all happened in LI. We felt so bad for her, and couldn't believe people could do something like that.

Posted 3/11/09 1:30 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by shiv

Yes, it's really hard to know what to do with homeless people. If they were noticablly hurt, I would call the police, but I would not go to help them up, especially if it's a man. If it was a homeless woman, I would probably go to help them. I've just seen way too many crazies in NYC and they scare me.

BUT I always always help other strangers. My friend and I were at a bar one night and when we went to leave there were 4 or 5 young guys surrounding this middle aged woman who was obviously drunk and they were kicking her and shoving her face in a plant and throwing dirt into her mouth and all over her. My guess is that she made a move on one of the guys and they thought they would abuse her for the fun of it. I was sick to my stomach, my friend and I went over and started yelling at them to leave her alone and get out of here and telling them how disgusting they are and they should be ashamed of themselves. They backed off and drove away. We helped her up and cleaned her off and actually drove her home, she was living in a trailer park. This all happened in LI. We felt so bad for her, and couldn't believe people could do something like that.



Can I ask why you would feel more comfortable going up to a homeless woman vs man? Is it that if something goes wrong you can "take em'"? I mean me personally, I would be nervous given both situations. If in fact they did have a mental disorder, you wouldnt be fighting with this "little" person...you would be fighting with their mental disorder. To me that is much more frightening...KWIM...

Posted 3/11/09 1:50 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by MST9106

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by PrincessP


I dont think its just about the Booze...
There could be some MAJOR issues that brought that person to the street.



I don't understand what you mean? do you mean major issues for their homelessness? or major issues they have that would prevent people from helping???

sorry, I am not all there today.



Mental issue is one of those things. I mean I'm sorry, as an everyday commuter on the MTA subway, I would most likely just call the cops or alert the booth clerk, but I would not go up to them...I'm sorry but thats just me. I've seen waaay too many things for me to risk my safety like that.

On the other hand, I did help a woman the other on the platform who passed out and crashed her skull on the ground...I ran and alerted the booth clerk to call the ambulance and then a bunch of us stayed with her until the ambulance came.



but you are saying you would AT LEAST call the cops. the people observed in the show didn't even bother doing that.

that is the difference.

I don't think anyone should put their life on the line if they are afraid...anything can happen.

but a simple phone call...there is no reason or excuse not to make that, ESPECIALLY if another person is essentially begging for help for the person in distress.

Posted 3/11/09 1:51 PM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Im sorry, there are too many crazies in NY, so ppl are skeptical. One time there was a guy who looked liek a bum but I guess he was a drunk - my then 15 yr old cousin gave him a bag of chips she didnt want. he thre the bag at her and cursed out saying he wasnt a bum. And than there was the guy who was askign the lady for the time before he pushed her into the subway. Sorry to say, but You dont know what people are capable of - especially in NYC.

However, you can call 911 or get the cops. And I didnt watch the episode so I dont know where they did this experiment.

Posted 3/11/09 1:52 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

This episode really made me ashamed of people!!! Between the homeless guy and the sorority girls??? I was saddened by the empathy.

Posted 3/11/09 4:45 PM
 

MichLiz213
Life is Good!

Member since 7/07

7979 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

I'm not diminishing the importance of helping a person in need at all, but I wonder how much editing was done on the show. I think the show is there to invoke a rection out of people and make a statement about our society. Maybe it's because DH works in editing (for radio, not television), or maybe I'm being naive. But I wonder if there were more people coming to help than actually shown (or at least I hope).

I would help someone in a heartbeat, but if I were by myself or it was at night, I would probably be more cautious (like calling 911 instead of going right up to the person first).

I think a lot of people don't help because they are afraid of getting involved. Remember The Incredibles when he saves the man and winds up injuring him and the guy sues? That's happened before IRL (recently on the news, it was a man who saved someone from a car accident and the victim sued him for his injuries), as sad as that is.

Message edited 2009-03-11 17:17:30.583000.

Posted 3/11/09 5:16 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by PrincessP

Can I ask why you would feel more comfortable going up to a homeless woman vs man? Is it that if something goes wrong you can "take em'"? I mean me personally, I would be nervous given both situations. If in fact they did have a mental disorder, you wouldnt be fighting with this "little" person...you would be fighting with their mental disorder. To me that is much more frightening...KWIM...



I said I would probably help but I would of course assess the situation to determine if there was any risk before going to help. But yes I guess I just feel safer around women.

Posted 3/11/09 6:39 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

I am not saying that if a homeless person is passed out in the street that you should run up to them and get down and in their face to see if they need help, but to walk by and not even call 911, especially if someone is ASKING YOU to call 911 for the person, that is, in my opinion, is a person who just has no heart.
I don't think giving homeless people money and food as you pass by them has anything to do with this issue at all. It has to do with someone who is obviously injured, sick or hurt in the street and not even calling 911. It doesn't take a personal conversation and close contact with someone to do the right thing by calling an ambulance. That's what saddens me. If you are so numb to homelessness that you walk past someone who could be dying in the street, then you need to learn to have some compassion and social responsibility because it's just an excuse.

Posted 3/11/09 8:19 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by Shelly

I don't watch the show. But I do have a comment about this post. Please don't flame me about this. Its just an honest opinion.

I once fell in the street in a cross-walk right when the light was changing to green. Three people lifted me up and carried me to safety- offering to call 911. I was fine. When I was knocked into at Penn Station and my foot fell in teh gap while I was 7 months pregnant, many people helped me. I do have faith in the goodness of people.

Regarding the homeless situation, its so sad. My heart does break everytime I see someone on the street. But living in the city for 11 years, you do get a little numb to it.

When I first moved here, I tried to give every homeless person I saw money. I was just a student and realized I just coudln't do that. There are so many people asking for money. I certainly can't help them all. When I offered a homeless man my diet coke and some food (I was bringing it to school), he turned me down. I've heard people begging for money for a metrocard to get home and when I offer them a swipe from my unlimited- they turn me down (this happened last month). Its the money they want, not to get home. And frankly, some people are dangerous- that goes for homeless or not. Now I'm sure there are plenty of people who would be greatful for what I coudl offer, but there are many that aren't. Some are addicts looking to score. Some are scammers. And some are genuninely asking for help. Its hard to know the difference.

There is a church where I often see people sleeping outside. Whenever I have extra food from an event, I always bring it there. If I saw someone fall, that would be one thing. But honestly, I see homeless people sleeping often, and I figure they are just sleeping. I've seen people sleeping on the subway, in Penn Station, on the street, etc... Its hard to know if someone is sick, or just sleeping. Honestly, if I called 911 everyone I thought I saw someone sleeping on the street, I think I would get in trouble. Not to mention- what happens when you do call 911 and it turns out they don't need medical attention and were just asleep? Is it better or worse?

Its very sad, I know. I wish there was more I can do. Before DD I served food at a shelter from time to time, and when DD is older, I expect to resume it with her helping me. While its sad, I think good people, like me, sometimes just don't know what to do.



I always offer them food. If they come to me saying they haven't eaten and are starving, i tell them to come with me to a deli. 9 times out of 10, they turn down my offer.

Posted 3/11/09 8:22 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

Posted by prncss

I am not saying that if a homeless person is passed out in the street that you should run up to them and get down and in their face to see if they need help, but to walk by and not even call 911, especially if someone is ASKING YOU to call 911 for the person, that is, in my opinion, is a person who just has no heart.
I don't think giving homeless people money and food as you pass by them has anything to do with this issue at all. It has to do with someone who is obviously injured, sick or hurt in the street and not even calling 911. It doesn't take a personal conversation and close contact with someone to do the right thing by calling an ambulance. That's what saddens me. If you are so numb to homelessness that you walk past someone who could be dying in the street, then you need to learn to have some compassion and social responsibility because it's just an excuse.


Most people probably didnt see this episode so its harder to say the exacts of what you would do...
Until now, I didnt realize you said they were ASKED to make that phone call. I wouldnt have had to even be ASKED bc I would automatically call but givven that they were ASKED ...then yes they are being irresponsible. I dont mind the phone call. I just mind going in their face.

Posted 3/11/09 8:25 PM
 

luvsbob4603
To a healthy 2013

Member since 5/05

21840 total posts

Name:
To a brand new year to a healthier me

Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...

I remember a long time ago when i was in the city with my family i went out to eat and i had leftovers i did not want to bring it on the train so i gave a homeless guy the rest of my food, He was very happy. If i saw someone Homeless or not i would help them, Even if it's to make a call to 911.

Posted 3/11/09 10:35 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I can't believe I wasted six months with a crying baby.... yankinmanc 12/7/08 3 Parenting
I can't believe I am crying because I am leaving my OBGYN practice JerseyMamaOf3 10/24/07 10 Parenting
OMG... can't believe this one MrsBumbleb 3/24/06 7 Parenting
OMG, couldn't believe my ears... AndreaLMT 3/21/06 25 Parenting
can you believe... beena 3/19/06 17 Families Helping Families ™
I believe my Shower is this weekend.. CJC25 3/17/06 2 Pregnancy