Re: I cannot even believe how I'm crying...
Posted 3/11/2009 8:22:51 PM by lipglossjunky73


Posted by Shelly

I don't watch the show. But I do have a comment about this post. Please don't flame me about this. Its just an honest opinion.

I once fell in the street in a cross-walk right when the light was changing to green. Three people lifted me up and carried me to safety- offering to call 911. I was fine. When I was knocked into at Penn Station and my foot fell in teh gap while I was 7 months pregnant, many people helped me. I do have faith in the goodness of people.

Regarding the homeless situation, its so sad. My heart does break everytime I see someone on the street. But living in the city for 11 years, you do get a little numb to it.

When I first moved here, I tried to give every homeless person I saw money. I was just a student and realized I just coudln't do that. There are so many people asking for money. I certainly can't help them all. When I offered a homeless man my diet coke and some food (I was bringing it to school), he turned me down. I've heard people begging for money for a metrocard to get home and when I offer them a swipe from my unlimited- they turn me down (this happened last month). Its the money they want, not to get home. And frankly, some people are dangerous- that goes for homeless or not. Now I'm sure there are plenty of people who would be greatful for what I coudl offer, but there are many that aren't. Some are addicts looking to score. Some are scammers. And some are genuninely asking for help. Its hard to know the difference.

There is a church where I often see people sleeping outside. Whenever I have extra food from an event, I always bring it there. If I saw someone fall, that would be one thing. But honestly, I see homeless people sleeping often, and I figure they are just sleeping. I've seen people sleeping on the subway, in Penn Station, on the street, etc... Its hard to know if someone is sick, or just sleeping. Honestly, if I called 911 everyone I thought I saw someone sleeping on the street, I think I would get in trouble. Not to mention- what happens when you do call 911 and it turns out they don't need medical attention and were just asleep? Is it better or worse?

Its very sad, I know. I wish there was more I can do. Before DD I served food at a shelter from time to time, and when DD is older, I expect to resume it with her helping me. While its sad, I think good people, like me, sometimes just don't know what to do.



I always offer them food. If they come to me saying they haven't eaten and are starving, i tell them to come with me to a deli. 9 times out of 10, they turn down my offer.
Print Post      Close Window