Re: I have a question about Jehovahs witnesses...
Posted 12/17/2008 10:21:08 AM by Kara
Posted by maybebaby
Posted by JennZ
Posted by 5ofClubs
I think they should contribute. You are not asking them to celebrate or change religions for gosh sake. You are just asking for some money for a gift to recognize her DC's teacher on a job well done thus far and for her Holiday!!
And, her child is not aware of gift giving and celebrating. So why should she have to give anything?
*playing devils advocate*
She said she would do an appreciation gift, just not revolving around the holiday. To ask someone to change or alter their religion is wrong.
I really don't see it as asking anyone to alter their religion!
I do not celebrate hanukkah. I am christian. But in a heartbeat I would give money to get a hanukkah gift for a teacher who was jewish. That was my point. It does NOT make me jewish to give to another who is...
But YOUR religion doesn't forbid celebrating holidays / birthdays and giving gifts for these things.
Honestly, I see where this mother is coming from. I think it's pretty obvious that this IS a holiday gift for the teacher no matter what you call it. Yes, it's to show appreciation for the teacher, but it's also pretty directly related to the fact that the holidays are this time of year, as opposed to say an end of year present.
|