Yay Or Nay

Forum Opinion Poll
Yay 36 29.03%
Nay 83 66.94%
Other--please explain 5 4.03%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted By Message
Pages: << 4 5 6 [7]

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by Porrruss

Posted by sometimesmommy

Posted by staceyums81

It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately...


Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on.



Thank goodness this wasn't the case when the Civil Rights Movement was happening while the Vietnam War was going on.... could you imagine if those discussions had been put off just because of a war?



Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 8:38 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by sometimesmommy

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by sometimesmommy

Posted by staceyums81

It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately...


Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on.



Why do you feel that way?


Because soldiers are at war. And if the policy is lifted the military has said they still have to work out housing, displays of affection, etc. That needs to be hammered out before a change is made.

The general (General Amos)nominated to head the Marine Corps told a Senate committee that he believes responses from Marines on repealing the "don't ask, don't tell" policy have been mostly negative so far.

Marines are the frontline and the core of the military so this has to be well thought out if there is a "suspected" widespread negativity.



Thats a valid reason not to implement a change right now... but not why the President and Congress cant come to an agreement about making a change now

Posted 9/22/10 8:51 PM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by AngnShaun

Posted by sometimesmommy

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by sometimesmommy

Posted by staceyums81

It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately...


Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on.



Why do you feel that way?


Because soldiers are at war. And if the policy is lifted the military has said they still have to work out housing, displays of affection, etc. That needs to be hammered out before a change is made.

The general (General Amos)nominated to head the Marine Corps told a Senate committee that he believes responses from Marines on repealing the "don't ask, don't tell" policy have been mostly negative so far.

Marines are the frontline and the core of the military so this has to be well thought out if there is a "suspected" widespread negativity.



Thats a valid reason not to implement a change right now... but not why the President and Congress cant come to an agreement about making a change now


But its the sentiment shared by those who govern the troops who are deployed now in hot spots. So if they have that fear and they are leading our family members/friends, loved ones it should hold some stock.

Marine Corps Commandant Gen. James T. Conway was very vocal and so is Gen. Amos but they back peddal when on record cause they want to keep their jobs---

"If Congress introduces a bill to repeal the ban, they will discuss it with the chain of command. If Congress changes the law, they will follow the law. "

The troops watch the news and once congress makes a decision next comes WHEN will changes happen/take effect. Its a logical concern troops may have so i can see the Sr. Brass points.

one of the articles:





Article

Message edited 2010-09-22 21:19:09.077000.

Posted 9/22/10 9:08 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

but what about the recently lifted ban during wartime that women can now serve on subs?

What about the ban lifted during the Gulf War that allowed women to fly fighter planes?

Those were two bans lifted during wartime?

Posted 9/22/10 9:30 PM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by eddiesmommy

but what about the recently lifted ban during wartime that women can now serve on subs?

What about the ban lifted during the Gulf War that allowed women to fly fighter planes?

Those were two bans lifted during wartime?


Subs have to do with deployment so they can rotate deployments and its limited disruption since they choose who gets assigned where. Same with women and fighter planes --you are talking about a small number of women in comparison. For example, in the Corp roughly 5-6% are WMs so both bans were not on the same scale as this one would.

Also for teh sub issue specifically-few NAVY actually in comparison voiced objections. Barring women reduced their pool of candidates.

If you ever visit a basic training base you will see there are significantly more men than women.

This ruling affects the ENTIRE milatary, male and female, there are religious concerns, homophobia etc so a much larger scale.

Message edited 2010-09-22 21:58:53.183000.

Posted 9/22/10 9:53 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

But his opinion does differ from The President, the Defense Secretary and the Joint Chiefs Chairman, who if I understand correctly is the highest ranking military official.

So while I understand his concerns, have the above named not also considered the repercussions of the repeal? I would think that they too would have taken all that into account when forming their opinions and stance on the repeal?

Posted 9/22/10 9:57 PM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by eddiesmommy

But his opinion does differ from The President, the Defense Secretary and the Joint Chiefs Chairman, who if I understand correctly is the highest ranking military official.

So while I understand his concerns, have the above named not also considered the repercussions of the repeal? I would think that they too would have taken all that into account when forming their opinions and stance on the repeal?



Its more than one person and most are from the Marine Corps from what I have read on CNN, ABC, Washington post, Reuters etc . And most are actively in combat not safe like Our President, Gates etc but leading currently deployed troops or retired combatants. I can understand why most opposition to DADT actually comes from the Corp because they have the WORSE living conditons normally so homophobia is a REAL issue.

Its mostly corp top brass unoffcially opposing the DADT and FTR Obama's military views was his weak point for me.

It comes down to votes. So something that may be the wrong choice can pass if it gets enough votes. Its that time of year....

Also...
Defense Secretary Robert Gates and Navy Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, have said they support repeal of the ban, though they favored the completion of the Pentagon review first.

The review, including a survey of military personnel attitudes on the issue, is scheduled to be finished in December.

I bet you will find if the ban is lifted..there will be more issues that come up when troops are deployed if living conditions are not addressed.

Message edited 2010-09-22 22:24:46.787000.

Posted 9/22/10 10:16 PM
 
Pages: << 4 5 6 [7]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Bill Proposed to abolish "don't ask, don't tell" policy JenniferEver 3/8/07 13 Families Helping Families ™
Don & Other WWE Fans nylisa 6/7/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
Don Redhead 6/1/05 10 Sports
Don, Boosh, and all WWE fans PrincessRose 5/24/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
Sorry Don Redhead 5/19/05 18 Sports
Don & Other WWE Fans nylisa 5/17/05 14 Families Helping Families ™