Yay Or Nay
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Don't Ask Don't Tell....
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 | |
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy . lets not go where? Lets not address how ignorant the whole thought process is? make it into a nasty thread and making it personal. You said " Why when a viewpoint or an opinion that is stated by you is challenged, its suddenly someone elses opinion or just something you heard. This is why Im calling BS on the vast majority of what you say you agree with." I havent been in the military for many years but I keep in touch. I dont try to over talk anyone-I am the girl who listens to conversations but dont always try to interject. If you read my comments I dont have a problem with gays in the military--I did serve 8 years but I was surrounded by many who dont/have/ issues and of course we discussed it..so obviously if my viewpoint differes from theirs it would be what I overheard/their opinion. As i had edited above to say: You did not say that...you did not say "The opinion or viewpoint held by people in the military is", you said "I" |
|
Posted 9/22/10 1:36 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Oh my goodness!! I left for a couple of minutes and....drag queen?! |
|
Posted 9/22/10 1:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by heathergirl Melissa you're on a ROLL Sometimesmommy...I am so ...I have truly never seen such ignorance, backpeddling and misinformation. Apparently you live in a bubble.My sentiments exactly for many. Oh you're SO clever
|
|
Posted 9/22/10 1:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by heathergirl Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by heathergirl Melissa you're on a ROLL Sometimesmommy...I am so ...I have truly never seen such ignorance, backpeddling and misinformation. Apparently you live in a bubble.My sentiments exactly for many. Oh you're SO clever teeheehee. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 1:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by MangoMama Oh my goodness!! I left for a couple of minutes and....drag queen?! This thread has become ridiculous. Its ridiculous because everyone wants to be cookie cutter and not accept that opinions differ. My viewpoin tis from the military side--the one it would have affected. I am not speaking from the civilian side--The civilian me is indifferent (I live my life and dont get involved in others) But in the military I understood why others had an issue-it doesnt mean you condone just becuase you understand why a person's opinion may differ- This article is a bit humourous but it does represent some military and how they feel USMILITARY ARTICLE So at the end of the day its the internet and take or leave my opinion or any representations I pulled from others in my circle. Life goes on. ETA: If you truely want knowledge visit one of the military websites where you hear from active/retired military. You'll hear all sides--Alot of DADT support is not to be prejudiced but to protect. Because it is an atmosphere where weapons are a huge factor and if someone is a homophobe its a recipe for disaster. Message edited 2010-09-22 14:05:37.587000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 1:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by heathergirl Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by heathergirl Melissa you're on a ROLL Sometimesmommy...I am so ...I have truly never seen such ignorance, backpeddling and misinformation. Apparently you live in a bubble.My sentiments exactly for many. Oh you're SO clever I guess you were one of the many since you responded
|
|
Posted 9/22/10 1:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... I just have a few thoughts. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. Not sure what you mean but yeah I am right-- http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brandon-friedman/no-gay-soldiers-wont-be-a_b_176359.html link so it can be read easier DRAG its just one example--there are countless more...just visit some of th emilitary chat rooms. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. that makes it better then. if it is not your belief and you dont agree with it, why are you so steadfastly trying to defend the thought process? I dont care why they think it, its ignorant and no number of articles is going to get me to change my opinion and be understanding of ignorance. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. that makes it better then. if it is not your belief and you dont agree with it, why are you so steadfastly trying to defend the thought process? I dont care why they think it, its ignorant and no number of articles is going to get me to change my opinion and be understanding of ignorance. Its not about trying to get anyone to change their views-- I could care less if you do or not. But since I am one of the few military that post on this site its basically a means to say hey this is another side of the issue. You do with the info as you wish. Its just like the soldiers on trail for beating up a gay guy in GA. They chose to do that and they will face the consequences. Message edited 2010-09-22 14:45:50.070000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. that makes it better then. if it is not your belief and you dont agree with it, why are you so steadfastly trying to defend the thought process? I dont care why they think it, its ignorant and no number of articles is going to get me to change my opinion and be understanding of ignorance. Exactly, people used to think it was OK to treat humans like animals and force them to work for them, saying they owned them. Since people thought/said it was OK, does that mean it was? This is the same thing, one day we are all going to look back and think of how archaic DADT was. I hope it's one day soon. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Eh, I don't really care if a soldier cross-dresses off duty. It's not illegal and is likely a better way to diffuse stress than drugs and alchohol. I don't know of any stats but I am sure that people in all professions do it, gay and straight. And being gay does not automatically mean that someone cross dresses. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. that makes it better then. if it is not your belief and you dont agree with it, why are you so steadfastly trying to defend the thought process? I dont care why they think it, its ignorant and no number of articles is going to get me to change my opinion and be understanding of ignorance. i thought it was a pretty obvious devils advocate... at least she has first hand knowledge of how DADT really works |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. Not sure what you mean but yeah I am right-- http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brandon-friedman/no-gay-soldiers-wont-be-a_b_176359.html link so it can be read easier DRAG its just one example--there are countless more...just visit some of th emilitary chat rooms. Unless Ive completely misread the article, it is more or less making fun of people in the military who believe that gays are "harmful" and is tongue in cheek....so how are you right? It supports what we have been saying and not what you have been saying? Its say that there are no longer any substansive reasons, anything that isnt any less that a vague reason, to keep DADT in place and that its just predicated on fears and nothing concrete and is a dated policy. I also tend to not use the Huffington Post as my source of information on major issues. Message edited 2010-09-22 14:51:49.497000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... I was thinking the same thing |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. Not sure what you mean but yeah I am right-- http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brandon-friedman/no-gay-soldiers-wont-be-a_b_176359.html link so it can be read easier DRAG its just one example--there are countless more...just visit some of th emilitary chat rooms. Unless Ive completely misread the article, it is more or less making fun of people in the military who believe that gays are "harmful" and is tongue in cheek....so how are you right? It supports what we have been saying and not what you have been saying? Its say that there are no longer any substansive reasons, anything that isnt any less that a vague reason, to keep DADT in place and that its just predicated on fears and nothing concrete and is a dated policy. I also tend to not use the Huffington Post as my source of information on major issues. NO I use my life in the military and my experience. What I have seen, heard not a newspaper. And yes I said it was humorous because it is comical that people would assume all gays dressed in drag but its still relevant ebcasue commanding generals have the concern. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 2:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. Not sure what you mean but yeah I am right-- http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brandon-friedman/no-gay-soldiers-wont-be-a_b_176359.html link so it can be read easier DRAG its just one example--there are countless more...just visit some of th emilitary chat rooms. Unless Ive completely misread the article, it is more or less making fun of people in the military who believe that gays are "harmful" and is tongue in cheek....so how are you right? It supports what we have been saying and not what you have been saying? Its say that there are no longer any substansive reasons, anything that isnt any less that a vague reason, to keep DADT in place and that its just predicated on fears and nothing concrete and is a dated policy. I also tend to not use the Huffington Post as my source of information on major issues. NO I use my life in the military and my experience. What I have seen, heard not a newspaper. And yes I said it was humorous because it is comical that people would assume all gays dressed in drag but its still relevant ebcasue commanding generals have the concern. You never stated it was a humorous article. Your information is severely misguided. You just sound absolutely ridiculous. Nothing you are stating is making sense. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 3:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... I cant even refute all of the outrageous, ignorant comments I'm reading on here but it is pure and simple an arcane, discriminatory policy that needs to go. You also cant be a true "friend" to someone but disagree with such a huge part of their lifestyle. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 3:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by Salason I cant even refute all of the outrageous, ignorant comments I'm reading on here but it is pure and simple an arcane, discriminatory policy that needs to go. You also cant be a true "friend" to someone but disagree with such a huge part of their lifestyle. And by the way, WTH does "drag" even have to do with anything? Last time I checked the military had uniforms Yup, that pretty much sums it all up. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by AngnShaun Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. that makes it better then. if it is not your belief and you dont agree with it, why are you so steadfastly trying to defend the thought process? I dont care why they think it, its ignorant and no number of articles is going to get me to change my opinion and be understanding of ignorance. i thought it was a pretty obvious devils advocate... at least she has first hand knowledge of how DADT really works its not devils advocate, she has said herself, she has first hand experience and is trying to explain why some people in the military feel the way they do. We dont agree and are stating why we dont agree since the arguments presented to explain the other sides POV are purely based in ignorance, misinformation and fear. Message edited 2010-09-22 15:10:55.207000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by heathergirl Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. Not sure what you mean but yeah I am right-- http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brandon-friedman/no-gay-soldiers-wont-be-a_b_176359.html link so it can be read easier DRAG its just one example--there are countless more...just visit some of th emilitary chat rooms. Unless Ive completely misread the article, it is more or less making fun of people in the military who believe that gays are "harmful" and is tongue in cheek....so how are you right? It supports what we have been saying and not what you have been saying? Its say that there are no longer any substansive reasons, anything that isnt any less that a vague reason, to keep DADT in place and that its just predicated on fears and nothing concrete and is a dated policy. I also tend to not use the Huffington Post as my source of information on major issues. NO I use my life in the military and my experience. What I have seen, heard not a newspaper. And yes I said it was humorous because it is comical that people would assume all gays dressed in drag but its still relevant ebcasue commanding generals have the concern. You never stated it was a humorous article. Your information is severely misguided. You just sound absolutely ridiculous. Nothing you are stating is making sense. My information cant be misguided cause I was the one in the military--if anything its fact just like this article FACT Article The issue is you dont support DADT but cant understand how others can support it. I get that and thats fine. I am merely trying to give insight from the military viewpoint as one of the soldiers the DADT policy and other policies past or present. ETA: I thought I wrote her is some humor but I did not. I thought it. Sorry. Message edited 2010-09-22 15:13:09.497000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 3:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by MangoMama Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by Mici C Posted by sometimesmommy I think you will find that many soldiers will . I agree with your points. I think DADT comes from a place that wants to allow for equal rights by allowing gays to serve but I suspect it does not know how to handle if a flambouyantly gay person passes the asvab and want to join say --the marine corp in drag---clearly qualified but clearly a distraction--- At the end of the day all I care about is that everyone is safe and focused. As someone that claims to be a vet, you should know better that a uniform is a uniform and NOTHING can be changed or added to it. Really? Drag? Come on. Actually the gunnery seargent was discussing drag when soldiers were off duty so I should clarify. right. Not sure what you mean but yeah I am right-- http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brandon-friedman/no-gay-soldiers-wont-be-a_b_176359.html link so it can be read easier DRAG its just one example--there are countless more...just visit some of th emilitary chat rooms. Unless Ive completely misread the article, it is more or less making fun of people in the military who believe that gays are "harmful" and is tongue in cheek....so how are you right? It supports what we have been saying and not what you have been saying? Its say that there are no longer any substansive reasons, anything that isnt any less that a vague reason, to keep DADT in place and that its just predicated on fears and nothing concrete and is a dated policy. I also tend to not use the Huffington Post as my source of information on major issues. NO I use my life in the military and my experience. What I have seen, heard not a newspaper. And yes I said it was humorous because it is comical that people would assume all gays dressed in drag but its still relevant ebcasue commanding generals have the concern. relevant maybe, but not valid and thats the point. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 3:13 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6 7 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bill Proposed to abolish "don't ask, don't tell" policy | JenniferEver | 3/8/07 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Don & Other WWE Fans | nylisa | 6/7/05 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Don | Redhead | 6/1/05 | 10 | Sports |
| Don, Boosh, and all WWE fans | PrincessRose | 5/24/05 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Sorry Don | Redhead | 5/19/05 | 18 | Sports |
| Don & Other WWE Fans | nylisa | 5/17/05 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |














