Yay Or Nay
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Don't Ask Don't Tell....
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7 | |
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by heathergirl Posted by CookieMomster I would just like to point out that not ALL soldiers are homophobic. I have seen first hand homophobia comes from people who have never known someone who's gay. My DH is in the military and is no form HOMOPHOBIC by ANY standards. I hate when people use this blanket statement. I don't think anyone thinks ALL soldiers are homophobic. There are homophobic soldiers and ther are not. The point is that NO ONE should EVER be discriminated against based on sexual orientation. It should NEVER EVER have to be discussed. Sexual orientation has NOTHING to do with their ability to soldier and protect our country. It is an arcane and deplorable practice and it absolutely boggles me that people honestly think this is OK. I could be wrong... but I thought the whole point of DADT was to pretect the people that are homosexual from the people that are homophobic.... The people that tend to be the ones that are responsible for the hate crimes... |
|
Posted 9/22/10 4:42 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by AngnShaun Posted by heathergirl Posted by CookieMomster I would just like to point out that not ALL soldiers are homophobic. I have seen first hand homophobia comes from people who have never known someone who's gay. My DH is in the military and is no form HOMOPHOBIC by ANY standards. I hate when people use this blanket statement. I don't think anyone thinks ALL soldiers are homophobic. There are homophobic soldiers and ther are not. The point is that NO ONE should EVER be discriminated against based on sexual orientation. It should NEVER EVER have to be discussed. Sexual orientation has NOTHING to do with their ability to soldier and protect our country. It is an arcane and deplorable practice and it absolutely boggles me that people honestly think this is OK. I could be wrong... but I thought the whole point of DADT was to pretect the people that are homosexual from the people that are homophobic.... The people that tend to be the ones that are responsible for the hate crimes... Yes BUT Gay people don't see it that way. Its basically telling them "Hide what you are, don't ask and don't tell, so the jerkoffs that are so intolerante and ignorant won't hurt you." |
|
Posted 9/22/10 4:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by Otherme Posted by Karma It is truly amazing to me how people on this site seem to really get their "kicks" so to speak from finding drama where there once was none. this is a highly sensitive topic.. people are discussing it and trying to rationalize either side of it. how is that drama? what's the point of even posting a comment like that? Sometimesmommy posted her opinion and viewpoint. Just because its not popular doesn't mean that other posters should demand that she explain herself, call her a liar, and give her That's just being rude and instigating drama. From what I have seen here sometimesmommy was respectfully stating her POV, and there was no need for the sarcasm and calling her ignorant.
Message edited 2010-09-22 16:51:22.230000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 4:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by AngnShaun Posted by heathergirl Posted by CookieMomster I would just like to point out that not ALL soldiers are homophobic. I have seen first hand homophobia comes from people who have never known someone who's gay. My DH is in the military and is no form HOMOPHOBIC by ANY standards. I hate when people use this blanket statement. I don't think anyone thinks ALL soldiers are homophobic. There are homophobic soldiers and ther are not. The point is that NO ONE should EVER be discriminated against based on sexual orientation. It should NEVER EVER have to be discussed. Sexual orientation has NOTHING to do with their ability to soldier and protect our country. It is an arcane and deplorable practice and it absolutely boggles me that people honestly think this is OK. I could be wrong... but I thought the whole point of DADT was to pretect the people that are homosexual from the people that are homophobic.... The people that tend to be the ones that are responsible for the hate crimes... yes-Its to protect from Social homophobia..one specific branch--shall remain nameless has a huge problem. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 4:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by Karma Posted by Otherme Posted by Karma It is truly amazing to me how people on this site seem to really get their "kicks" so to speak from finding drama where there once was none. this is a highly sensitive topic.. people are discussing it and trying to rationalize either side of it. how is that drama? what's the point of even posting a comment like that? Sometimesmommy posted her opinion and viewpoint. Just because its not popular doesn't mean that other posters should demand that she explain herself, call her a liar, and give her That's just being rude and instigating drama. From what I have seen here sometimesmommy was respectfully stating her POV, and there was no need for the sarcasm and calling her ignorant.I agree with you... but you cant deny that your initial post was the pot calling the kettle black... it was an obvious shyt stirring post and not necessary! |
|
Posted 9/22/10 4:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by AngnShaun Posted by Karma Posted by Otherme Posted by Karma It is truly amazing to me how people on this site seem to really get their "kicks" so to speak from finding drama where there once was none. this is a highly sensitive topic.. people are discussing it and trying to rationalize either side of it. how is that drama? what's the point of even posting a comment like that? Sometimesmommy posted her opinion and viewpoint. Just because its not popular doesn't mean that other posters should demand that she explain herself, call her a liar, and give her That's just being rude and instigating drama. From what I have seen here sometimesmommy was respectfully stating her POV, and there was no need for the sarcasm and calling her ignorant.I agree with you... but you cant deny that your initial post was the pot calling the kettle black... it was an obvious shyt stirring post and not necessary! That's is probably true, but I really didn't mean it that way. I just feel like some people on here walk a fine line between debating and bullying. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 4:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by Karma Posted by Otherme Posted by Karma It is truly amazing to me how people on this site seem to really get their "kicks" so to speak from finding drama where there once was none. this is a highly sensitive topic.. people are discussing it and trying to rationalize either side of it. how is that drama? what's the point of even posting a comment like that? Sometimesmommy posted her opinion and viewpoint. Just because its not popular doesn't mean that other posters should demand that she explain herself, call her a liar, and give her That's just being rude and instigating drama. From what I have seen here sometimesmommy was respectfully stating her POV, and there was no need for the sarcasm and calling her ignorant.Thank you. I understand it is a sensitive topic. I get it and I feel bad that I stooped to that level later in the post
|
|
Posted 9/22/10 5:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by heathergirl Posted by AngnShaun Posted by heathergirl Posted by CookieMomster I would just like to point out that not ALL soldiers are homophobic. I have seen first hand homophobia comes from people who have never known someone who's gay. My DH is in the military and is no form HOMOPHOBIC by ANY standards. I hate when people use this blanket statement. I don't think anyone thinks ALL soldiers are homophobic. There are homophobic soldiers and ther are not. The point is that NO ONE should EVER be discriminated against based on sexual orientation. It should NEVER EVER have to be discussed. Sexual orientation has NOTHING to do with their ability to soldier and protect our country. It is an arcane and deplorable practice and it absolutely boggles me that people honestly think this is OK. I could be wrong... but I thought the whole point of DADT was to pretect the people that are homosexual from the people that are homophobic.... The people that tend to be the ones that are responsible for the hate crimes... Yes BUT Gay people don't see it that way. Its basically telling them "Hide what you are, don't ask and don't tell, so the jerkoffs that are so intolerante and ignorant won't hurt you." If this is the case, then I really think the military needs to do something (what? I don't know) about those harrassing people for sexual orientation, race, religion, anything. The hate should NOT be tollerated in the military. There is no time for that immature BS when trying to protect the country. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 5:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....
|
|
Posted 9/22/10 5:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... For the record, as I have stated before, people, myself included, said things directed AT sometimesmommy bc she began her posts with "I". Had she said, "In my experience, I have found that their are people in the military that think...." It certainly would have changed the direction of the conversation. We would have responded "those people" instead of "you". |
|
Posted 9/22/10 5:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by speakthetruth Like I stated before, my sister is a retired Major (not Captain as I thought - I just asked my Dad today to confirm) and she is a lesbian. just a little chuckle, I read this initially as "My sister is a retired major, not a Captain and I asked my dad today to confirm, and she is a lesbian" |
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by speakthetruth Like I stated before, my sister is a retired Major (not Captain as I thought - I just asked my Dad today to confirm) and she is a lesbian. just a little chuckle, I read this initially as "My sister is a retired major, not a Captain and I asked my dad today to confirm, and she is a lesbian"
|
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... I don't know, as far as I go, I have had friends who were slutty or childish, and I didn't understand or support it, but I still supported our friendship, if that makes sense. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by eddiesmommy For the record, as I have stated before, people, myself included, said things directed AT sometimesmommy bc she began her posts with "I". Had she said, "In my experience, I have found that their are people in the military that think...." It certainly would have changed the direction of the conversation. We would have responded "those people" instead of "you". When she did repost and say (on more than one occasion) it wasnt her opinion but that of people she knows, we took the opinion of "those" people to task. As for the gay friends thing, which was completely unrelated and unprompted, she opened that can of worms. I still dont think these are good friends of hers bc there is no way, based on my experiences that you could have a close and tight friendship with someone who you dont support or understand, so I stand by my comment calling that portion "BS, at least in part" sorry rude is rude regadless of I, they whatever and I stand by that. Eta: I was going to be jumped on regardless but certain people. This is not a new debate. I don't know most IRL so .............. Message edited 2010-09-22 18:24:55.577000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by eddiesmommy For the record, as I have stated before, people, myself included, said things directed AT sometimesmommy bc she began her posts with "I". Had she said, "In my experience, I have found that their are people in the military that think...." It certainly would have changed the direction of the conversation. We would have responded "those people" instead of "you". When she did repost and say (on more than one occasion) it wasnt her opinion but that of people she knows, we took the opinion of "those" people to task. As for the gay friends thing, which was completely unrelated and unprompted, she opened that can of worms. I still dont think these are good friends of hers bc there is no way, based on my experiences that you could have a close and tight friendship with someone who you dont support or understand, so I stand by my comment calling that portion "BS, at least in part" sorry rude is rude regadless of I, they whatever and I stand by that. People were heated and opinionated. Its a sensitive topic. It would not have been directed AT you, and at the collective you instead had you clearly said it was not YOUR opinion, but the opinion of those you knew. As for whether if it is was at the collective you, and still rude, Im OK with that bc I have no tolerance for ignorance. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by speakthetruth I don't know, as far as I go, I have had friends who were slutty or childish, and I didn't understand or support it, but I still supported our friendship, if that makes sense. Like you can have polygamist friend and not agree with their lifestyle, but still love them. I think as far as slutty or childish, those are personality traits and not who the person IS, KWIM? As for as polygamists, I dont know any, but I would think if I couldnt support someone 100% and their lifestyles choices, unconditionally, then Im not being the best friend I can be, and therefore cannot be a truly good friend bc Im only loving 80% of them, KWIM? Thats why I said I think you can certainly be acquaintances with someone who is gay but dont support, but I dont think you can truly be a good friend. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... I think it's an outdated policy. I understand that it does allow homosexual men & women to serve in the military, but why should they have to hide their true identity to do so? I am grateful & in admiration of ANYONE who leaves their family & puts themself in harms way to fight for my safety & the safety of my family. That is an honorable sacrifice whether the loved ones they are leaving are of the same or opposite sex. I cannot imagine how it's fair for someone to go off & fight for our country & then have to work to hide such a major part of their identity from those around them. Can they never speak of a SO or show photographs? How sad. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by Dani922 I think it's an outdated policy. I understand that it does allow homosexual men & women to serve in the military, but why should they have to hide their true identity to do so? I am grateful & in admiration of ANYONE who leaves their family & puts themself in harms way to fight for my safety & the safety of my family. That is an honorable sacrifice whether the loved ones they are leaving are of the same or opposite sex. I cannot imagine how it's fair for someone to go off & fight for our country & then have to work to hide such a major part of their identity from those around them. Can they never speak of a SO or show photographs? How sad. As for the reasons it's in place? While I understand the theory the military has that has been shared by PP posters with military knowledge, I think it's outdated. It's like giving people an excuse to continue being prejudiced & ignorant about homosexuality. I know that there are probably parts of the country that may not be as liberal & accepting as our area, but why should the government be, in a way, catering to their ignorance? Allowing DADT to continue is almost supporting that ignorance. As for some other theories posted previously, well, i doubt removing DADT is going to cause an increase in military members showing up umm... flamboyantly dressed . I was under the impression that there is a required uniform. Just because someone is homosexual doesn't mean they will be any less respectful of military code or take their job any less seriously. I understand that there is the "issue" of sharing sleeping quarters & showers, but again, ignorance. DADT for this purpose just fuels homphobia & gives it the freedom to continue. So what if the guy next to you is attracted to men? It doesn't mean he's going to be attracted to YOU & if he is, it doesn't mean anything is expected of you! It doesn't mean he's going to jump you or hurt you or "infect" you in some way. I could care less if a lesbian was looking at me or attracted to me. How does that hurt me honestly? So for me- NAY! It's just allowing homophbia & prejudice to continue. very well said!
|
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately... |
|
Posted 9/22/10 6:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by staceyums81 It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately... Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 7:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by staceyums81 It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately... Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on. Why do you feel that way? |
|
Posted 9/22/10 7:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by staceyums81 It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately... Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on. Thank goodness this wasn't the case when the Civil Rights Movement was happening while the Vietnam War was going on.... could you imagine if those discussions had been put off just because of a war? Message edited 2010-09-22 20:24:30.223000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 8:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by Porrruss Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by staceyums81 It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately... Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on. Thank goodness this wasn't the case when the Civil Rights Movement was going on while the Vietnam War was going on.... could you imagine if those discussions had been put off just because of a war?
|
|
Posted 9/22/10 8:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by sometimesmommy Posted by staceyums81 It's a violation of civil rights and should be abolished immediately... Its also something that Congress and the president shouldnt be discussing when there is a war going on. Why do you feel that way? Because soldiers are at war. And if the policy is lifted the military has said they still have to work out housing, displays of affection, etc. That needs to be hammered out before a change is made. The general (General Amos)nominated to head the Marine Corps told a Senate committee that he believes responses from Marines on repealing the "don't ask, don't tell" policy have been mostly negative so far. Marines are the frontline and the core of the military so this has to be well thought out if there is a "suspected" widespread negativity. Message edited 2010-09-22 20:30:07.890000. |
|
Posted 9/22/10 8:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell.... Posted by GinaR Posted by Dani922 I think it's an outdated policy. I understand that it does allow homosexual men & women to serve in the military, but why should they have to hide their true identity to do so? I am grateful & in admiration of ANYONE who leaves their family & puts themself in harms way to fight for my safety & the safety of my family. That is an honorable sacrifice whether the loved ones they are leaving are of the same or opposite sex. I cannot imagine how it's fair for someone to go off & fight for our country & then have to work to hide such a major part of their identity from those around them. Can they never speak of a SO or show photographs? How sad. As for the reasons it's in place? While I understand the theory the military has that has been shared by PP posters with military knowledge, I think it's outdated. It's like giving people an excuse to continue being prejudiced & ignorant about homosexuality. I know that there are probably parts of the country that may not be as liberal & accepting as our area, but why should the government be, in a way, catering to their ignorance? Allowing DADT to continue is almost supporting that ignorance. As for some other theories posted previously, well, i doubt removing DADT is going to cause an increase in military members showing up umm... flamboyantly dressed . I was under the impression that there is a required uniform. Just because someone is homosexual doesn't mean they will be any less respectful of military code or take their job any less seriously. I understand that there is the "issue" of sharing sleeping quarters & showers, but again, ignorance. DADT for this purpose just fuels homphobia & gives it the freedom to continue. So what if the guy next to you is attracted to men? It doesn't mean he's going to be attracted to YOU & if he is, it doesn't mean anything is expected of you! It doesn't mean he's going to jump you or hurt you or "infect" you in some way. I could care less if a lesbian was looking at me or attracted to me. How does that hurt me honestly? So for me- NAY! It's just allowing homophbia & prejudice to continue. very well said!ITA... except for one thing i disagree with... Prejudice and Homophobia will still be there regardless if DADT is there or not... |
|
Posted 9/22/10 8:27 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 3 4 5 [6] 7 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bill Proposed to abolish "don't ask, don't tell" policy | JenniferEver | 3/8/07 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Don & Other WWE Fans | nylisa | 6/7/05 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Don | Redhead | 6/1/05 | 10 | Sports |
| Don, Boosh, and all WWE fans | PrincessRose | 5/24/05 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Sorry Don | Redhead | 5/19/05 | 18 | Sports |
| Don & Other WWE Fans | nylisa | 5/17/05 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |












That's just being rude and instigating drama. From what I have seen here sometimesmommy was respectfully stating her POV, and there was no need for the sarcasm and calling her ignorant.




very well said!


