Yay Or Nay

Forum Opinion Poll
Yay 36 29.03%
Nay 83 66.94%
Other--please explain 5 4.03%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Opinions?

Message edited 2010-09-21 17:37:06.900000.

Posted 9/21/10 5:36 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

to me, anyone who vows to protect our country at all costs - including his or her life - i could care less if they are gay or not. doesn't matter to me at all.

that being said, and not saying I agree with this, but I have heard the "other side" from military members who say that they agree it needs to be fixed, but what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.

also - some war enemies that we have and their cultures/religions are super anti-gay... that could be a cause of concern, also.

Message edited 2010-09-21 17:41:24.830000.

Posted 9/21/10 5:41 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

but also, I don't get why at any job or career field, do you have to announce your sexuality.

I never walked into any job I have had and said, "Hey, I'm >>>>>>>, and I'm a hetero." It's no one's business *what* you are.

Posted 9/21/10 5:42 PM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by speakthetruth

what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.

also - some war enemies that we have and their cultures/religions are super anti-gay... that
could be a cause of concern, also.




This made me Chat Icon Their reasoning is really just their way of trying to rationalize ignorance and hatred.

Do these same people believe that women should not be in the military? In many parts of the world, women are thought to be weak. What about certain religions that are hated in parts of the world?

As for the question at hand, I voted nay.

Message edited 2010-09-21 17:53:54.633000.

Posted 9/21/10 5:53 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Nay - their sexual orientation has nothing to do with how they defend our country.

IMO it seems only fair since all extra curricular affairs by heterosexual married officers aren't questioned.


Posted 9/21/10 5:59 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by speakthetruth

to me, anyone who vows to protect our country at all costs - including his or her life - i could care less if they are gay or not. doesn't matter to me at all.

that being said, and not saying I agree with this, but I have heard the "other side" from military members who say that they agree it needs to be fixed, but what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.

also - some war enemies that we have and their cultures/religions are super anti-gay... that could be a cause of concern, also.




This is the worst reasoning I've ever heard supporting DADT. [And ETA that I know it's not necessarily the view of the poster I quoted -- but that poster brought it up.]

Don't Ask Don't Tell allows gays in the military. It just doesn't allow openly gay people to serve. In other words, the military is prohibited from trying to ascertain and reveal if members (or applicants) are gay and gay people are expected to stay in the closet if they are in the military. And very few of my gay male friends are "feminine."

As for being feminine equaling weakness to the enemy... Well, we allow women in the military... So Chat Icon Plus, what about lesbians? And how exactly would the "enemy" taking our soldiers hostage know the soldier was gay or straight? It's not like the soldier would be wearing lavender fatigues and a rainbow flag on his uniform.

The express reasoning of the policy is that "it would create an unacceptable risk to the high standards of morale, good order and discipline, and unit cohesion that are the essence of military capability" (which, FTR, I also reject).

I've also heard (and FTR also reject) the argument that is prevents hate crimes and hazing in the military.

Message edited 2010-09-21 18:11:20.290000.

Posted 9/21/10 6:06 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by speakthetruth

but also, I don't get why at any job or career field, do you have to announce your sexuality.

I never walked into any job I have had and said, "Hey, I'm >>>>>>>, and I'm a hetero." It's no one's business *what* you are.



You shouldn't have to. But you also shouldn't be forced to hide it -- under the penalty that you will lose your job if you "demonstrate a propensity or intent to engage in homosexual acts."

You don't have to declare your sexuality to join the military -- Don't Ask Don't Tell prohibits the government from asking people that question. You just have to hide it (and well) if you want to stay in the military.

Posted 9/21/10 6:08 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Lets face it these men ( lets just say men for the sake of my statement, I know there are gay women fighting too ) are not walking around dressed like Klinger for goodness sake. If they are risking their lives so my kid can grow up in a somewhat safe country who the hell cares if they are doing Tom, D ick and Harry?

Posted 9/21/10 6:16 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by speakthetruth

but what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.




Ok- but I don't see the connection to DADT. Looking feminine and being gay aren't the same.

Anyway, I am a big nay on this.

Posted 9/21/10 6:18 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by speakthetruth

but what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.




Ok- but I don't see the connection to DADT. Looking feminine and being gay aren't the same.

Anyway, I am a big nay on this.




wait wait wait...let's not forget..I wrote that I didn't agree with it, just surmising what viewpoints I have heard from military members, even those who are pro-gay marriage and such

i don't care either way. I myself have a sister who is in the military and a lesbian. She is a Captain.

Posted 9/21/10 6:21 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by speakthetruth

but what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.




Ok- but I don't see the connection to DADT. Looking feminine and being gay aren't the same.

Anyway, I am a big nay on this.




wait wait wait...let's not forget..I wrote that I didn't agree with it, just surmising what viewpoints I have heard from military members, even those who are pro-gay marriage and such

i don't care either way. I myself have a sister who is in the military and a lesbian. She is a Captain.



I stand corrected. Sorry. Chat Icon

Posted 9/21/10 6:23 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by speakthetruth

but what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.




Ok- but I don't see the connection to DADT. Looking feminine and being gay aren't the same.

Anyway, I am a big nay on this.




wait wait wait...let's not forget..I wrote that I didn't agree with it, just surmising what viewpoints I have heard from military members, even those who are pro-gay marriage and such

i don't care either way. I myself have a sister who is in the military and a lesbian. She is a Captain.



I stand corrected. Sorry. Chat Icon



no worries.Chat Icon

Posted 9/21/10 6:23 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

The reason DADT is in place is for unit cohesion and to deter any form of hazing, or distraction from the mission. (Atleast this is what I was told in basic training)

Posted 9/21/10 9:51 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

I find it archaic, discriminatory, and ridiculous.

So nay.

Posted 9/21/10 10:09 PM
 

justmefornow
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/08

859 total posts

Name:
n

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by CookieMomster

The reason DADT is in place is for unit cohesion and to deter any form of hazing, or distraction from the mission. (Atleast this is what I was told in basic training)



Yes, a distraction for homophobics. Definitely a nay for me, it's ridiculous, I don't understand how anyone can support it.

Posted 9/21/10 10:12 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

There have been gay soldiers in the military for thousands of years. DADT doesn't prevent homosexuals from being in the military, so I don't see how it can help team cohesion, since there are still gay soldiers side by side with you, fighting to save your life, and the lives and freedoms of your family. The only thing is, they can't talk about who they love and are fighting for, whereas other soldiers can..... I don't see any logic in it at all....

Posted 9/22/10 7:39 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

I just find this whole thing laughable. What makes straight soldiers think they are so damn hot that the gay ones want them all that much. I think they need to get over themselves, do what they are being respectfully paid to do and SHUT UP! Geez. Yeah I am that simple in thought on this topic. I mean I am not attracted to every man I see, why should a gay soldier (male or female) be.

Posted 9/22/10 9:07 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

this subject really pisses me off, i will just say who you F has nothing to do with serving in the armed forces.

Posted 9/22/10 9:15 AM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by GoldenRod

There have been gay soldiers in the military for thousands of years. DADT doesn't prevent homosexuals from being in the military, so I don't see how it can help team cohesion, since there are still gay soldiers side by side with you, fighting to save your life, and the lives and freedoms of your family. The only thing is, they can't talk about who they love and are fighting for, whereas other soldiers can..... I don't see any logic in it at all....


Because they are not distracted by thinking if X stares too long in the community shower then they are interested and proceeds to shoot that person with their M-16 when on a mission. friendly fire in the military is not always friendly. Especially in the Marine Corps.

Message edited 2010-09-22 09:31:08.530000.

Posted 9/22/10 9:30 AM
 

MissMeliss
Love my kids

Member since 11/08

1424 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by DiamondGirl

I find it archaic, discriminatory, and ridiculous.

So nay.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/22/10 9:32 AM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by MissMeliss

Posted by DiamondGirl

I find it archaic, discriminatory, and ridiculous.

So nay.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree, I pray that by the time my Son is old enough that I have to explain these things they are in the past. This is modern day prejudice and we have been through this before, can't we just LEARN from our past mistakes AMERICA?!!?!?

Worry about yourself, nobody else!!

Posted 9/22/10 9:44 AM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....


Worry about yourself, nobody else!!
Although I agree with the rest of your quote. I must say the last part unfortunately doesnt hold true in the military. We do have to worry about everybody else. We are a unit, a team, a family and a weak link can get someone killed if they are distracted. SO its not a cut and dry issue.

Message edited 2010-09-22 09:51:04.917000.

Posted 9/22/10 9:50 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by sometimesmommy

Posted by GoldenRod

There have been gay soldiers in the military for thousands of years. DADT doesn't prevent homosexuals from being in the military, so I don't see how it can help team cohesion, since there are still gay soldiers side by side with you, fighting to save your life, and the lives and freedoms of your family. The only thing is, they can't talk about who they love and are fighting for, whereas other soldiers can..... I don't see any logic in it at all....


Because they are not distracted by thinking if X stares too long in the community shower then they are interested and proceeds to shoot that person with their M-16 when on a mission. friendly fire in the military is not always friendly. Especially in the Marine Corps.



They can think that now, so I don't see the difference..... there's nothing preventing someone who is gay from being in the military, showering with everyone, and sleeping in the same tent with everyone. It happens every single day, and the military is working very well. The Marines has plenty of gay soldiers right now.

There's also nothing stopping a racist from shooting a racial minority on a mission.... there are just as many extreme racists as homophobics, so I don't buy this defense.

People who hate others for an arbitrary reason will always find a reason to hate.

Posted 9/22/10 9:52 AM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by sometimesmommy

Posted by GoldenRod

There have been gay soldiers in the military for thousands of years. DADT doesn't prevent homosexuals from being in the military, so I don't see how it can help team cohesion, since there are still gay soldiers side by side with you, fighting to save your life, and the lives and freedoms of your family. The only thing is, they can't talk about who they love and are fighting for, whereas other soldiers can..... I don't see any logic in it at all....


Because they are not distracted by thinking if X stares too long in the community shower then they are interested and proceeds to shoot that person with their M-16 when on a mission. friendly fire in the military is not always friendly. Especially in the Marine Corps.



They can think that now, so I don't see the difference..... there's nothing preventing someone who is gay from being in the military, showering with everyone, and sleeping in the same tent with everyone. It happens every single day, and the military is working very well. The Marines has plenty of gay soldiers right now.

There's also nothing stopping a racist from shooting a racial minority on a mission.... there are just as many extreme racists as homophobics, so I don't buy this defense.

People who hate others for an arbitrary reason will always find a reason to hate.


I agree with you. I dont support homosexuality but I do have homosexual friends (in fact we are discussing it in the office right now)

There are gays in the military. Definitely. Majority of the soldiers I know wouldnt have a problem however I also know a significant amount who do and thats where the DADT policy comes into play. I have seen people come out first hand and their unit/squad knew/suspected and it was a non issue but I have also seen on one of my deployments where it didnt go too well. A few good men comes to mind.

Posted 9/22/10 10:02 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....

when talking to some ex military and current they all said the same thing. The people with the problems are typically the ones never exposed to homosexuality. The midwestern boys and the kids from the real south. The girls I know said women don't seem to have that much of an issue with each other unless they are a bully lesbian.

But these "bully" trainees still have issues with race such as anyone who is hispanic decent or african american. So the real problem is being a hateful person which works when your shooting your weapon in a war but not when your becoming a unit.

The don't ask, don't tell helps so that your not a target but if your gay and not a good actor your going to be spotted (that is what they all said) and either way your going to get some form of crap for it. Until the person dishing out the b/s learns that your the unit along with them and they need you just as much as you need them.

I still think its ridiculous to have the policy, if your a target of hate then it should be reported to your senior officer and it should be dealt with just the same if your a target of hate due to race.

Posted 9/22/10 10:04 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Bill Proposed to abolish "don't ask, don't tell" policy JenniferEver 3/8/07 13 Families Helping Families ™
Don & Other WWE Fans nylisa 6/7/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
Don Redhead 6/1/05 10 Sports
Don, Boosh, and all WWE fans PrincessRose 5/24/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
Sorry Don Redhead 5/19/05 18 Sports
Don & Other WWE Fans nylisa 5/17/05 14 Families Helping Families ™