Re: Don't Ask Don't Tell....
Posted 9/21/2010 6:06:40 PM by Kara


Posted by speakthetruth

to me, anyone who vows to protect our country at all costs - including his or her life - i could care less if they are gay or not. doesn't matter to me at all.

that being said, and not saying I agree with this, but I have heard the "other side" from military members who say that they agree it needs to be fixed, but what if you're taken hostage (or taking hostages yourself) and you're a man and super feminine? it can sometimes come across as a "weakness" to the enemy, as wrong as that sounds.

also - some war enemies that we have and their cultures/religions are super anti-gay... that could be a cause of concern, also.




This is the worst reasoning I've ever heard supporting DADT. [And ETA that I know it's not necessarily the view of the poster I quoted -- but that poster brought it up.]

Don't Ask Don't Tell allows gays in the military. It just doesn't allow openly gay people to serve. In other words, the military is prohibited from trying to ascertain and reveal if members (or applicants) are gay and gay people are expected to stay in the closet if they are in the military. And very few of my gay male friends are "feminine."

As for being feminine equaling weakness to the enemy... Well, we allow women in the military... So Chat Icon Plus, what about lesbians? And how exactly would the "enemy" taking our soldiers hostage know the soldier was gay or straight? It's not like the soldier would be wearing lavender fatigues and a rainbow flag on his uniform.

The express reasoning of the policy is that "it would create an unacceptable risk to the high standards of morale, good order and discipline, and unit cohesion that are the essence of military capability" (which, FTR, I also reject).

I've also heard (and FTR also reject) the argument that is prevents hate crimes and hazing in the military.
Print Post      Close Window