Is it lying?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes 11 14.10%
No 67 85.90%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Do you think it's lying?

Posted By Message

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Do you think it's lying?

I saw this on another board and thougt it was interesting.

Do you think it's lying when you talk to your kids about things like Santa, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy, etc.?

Posted 3/26/07 10:35 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think it's lying?

I'll start. I don't think it's lying, and I never thought when I found out the truth that my parents were lying to me.

I feel like it's a part of the innocence of childhood. Just like when kids think cartoon characters are real or when Sarah and I "eat" the food she made in her play kitchen or have a pretend tea party. I like to encourage her imagination and love when she "calls" DH or a grandparent from her play phone.

Posted 3/26/07 10:38 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think it's lying?

No. It's just a part of growing up. Kind of like a right of passage.

Posted 3/26/07 10:41 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Do you think it's lying?

I think we all agree on this one Chat Icon
It's all part of the magic of childhood.

and even if it was lying, some lies are good liesChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/26/07 10:47 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by anna

I think we all agree on this one Chat Icon



That's what I would have said, but more than half of the 100+ posts to the question on the other board were really heated comments on how it's lying, it's wrong to deceive your child, blah, blah. I was shocked.

Posted 3/26/07 10:51 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by CathyB

Posted by anna

I think we all agree on this one Chat Icon



That's what I would have said, but more than half of the 100+ posts to the question on the other board were really heated comments on how it's lying, it's wrong to deceive your child, blah, blah. I was shocked.



oh goodness, I gotta look for that post.
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/26/07 10:59 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think it's lying?

I think its lying- but I also don't think its a big deal. I fully intend to teach Jordana about the tooth fairy (Santa and Easter bunny are not applicable for us).

I also don't think its SO wrong to deceive your child for something like this. Childhood is so short these days, let them have as many years of innocence as possible.

Posted 3/26/07 11:03 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think it's lying?

I don't consider it lying. I agree its just a part of childhood.

Posted 3/27/07 12:06 AM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Do you think it's lying?

yep - it's lying. (because obviously none of it is true)

but - under the circumstances, little white lies like these are acceptable. like alot of you have said, it's a rite of passage, and part of childhood, so it's all good! Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/07 12:30 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by MrsERod

yep - it's lying. (because obviously none of it is true)

but - under the circumstances, little white lies like these are acceptable. like alot of you have said, it's a rite of passage, and part of childhood, so it's all good! Chat Icon



I agree. I take a page from Francis P. Church’s NY Sun article, "Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus." It's the spirit behind the holidays, the magic. It is as real as my childhood belief that I was magic.

I have answered the question, "Is Santa Claus real?" with "When I was a kid, he was. He came through our chimney and left me the Tree Top Family Treehouse...and, at the time, it was the world's BEST toy"

Posted 3/27/07 5:39 AM
 

CJC25
I luv My Daughter

Member since 9/05

1192 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Do you think it's lying?

My best friend growing up was a jehovah witness and she would tell me all the time there is no such thing it is a lie. I would just tell her she was Jealous. I don't believe it is a lie. I think it is more of a fairy tale. When they get old enough to understand I will tell them the truth, but for now I will continue to let them believe, You are only a kid once and those are the greatest memories.

Posted 3/27/07 6:39 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Just speaking from my own experience.... it still bothers me, 20 some-odd years later that my mom lied to me about Santa, where presents came from, and some of the other "fairy tales" parents tell kids. I still question what else my mom lied to me about. I am definitely not telling anyone not to do it, and I am going to teach my DC not to ruin other kids holidays by telling them the "truth", but I refuse to tell my kids that a big fat guy in a red suit comes down the chimney ("But Daddy, we don't have a chimney"...) and leaves presents. I want them to understand that we pay for the presents, so they can't just wish for things and get them. I'm not saying I won't ever "stretch the truth" around my kids, I just want to save that trick for things I need it for (ie, Daddy, when did you have your first drink, when did you have se*, etc, etc.... Chat Icon ..... "Uh... When I was married and over 21, and you should too...." Chat Icon Chat Icon )

I consider Santa similar to religion or politics. I have my beliefs, other people have their beliefs, and I am not going to judge anyone on what they believe, but I am going to do what I believe is right, and I will do everything I can to teach my DC that not everyone believes the same things that we do, and that's OK.
Flame away....

Posted 3/27/07 7:28 AM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by monkeybride

No. It's just a part of growing up. Kind of like a right of passage.



I agree

Posted 3/27/07 7:29 AM
 

IrishTracy
Believe!!

Member since 5/05

15167 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: Do you think it's lying?

It's not lying if you believe & I do!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/07 8:03 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Nope, I think it's doing something that's essential to raising a curious, happy, well-adjusted child - encouraging their imagination. It's no different than role-playing, acting, etc...

Posted 3/27/07 8:05 AM
 

ddunne2
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Doreen

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by Bxgell2

Nope, I think it's doing something that's essential to raising a curious, happy, well-adjusted child - encouraging their imagination. It's no different than role-playing, acting, etc...



I agree. Soon enough the real world will be upon our children and I think it is a shame not to give them a childhood full of fun, excitement and joy by having traditions that revolve around Santa, Easter Bunny, etc...(if applicable, obviously).

My SIL told my nephew that there was no Santa, etc and I think it is sad. Sure it is technically lying, but I've met very few people that feel they were deceived by their parents for these lies. I would be sad if I was told there was no Santa before I figured it out myself. I can't wait to hide Easter egss for Jack this year. Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/07 8:58 AM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Do you think it's lying?

I don't think so. I think you are teaching them how to use their imagination. Too many kids grow up too quickly. It's nice to have them believe in magic and magical things.

As a matter of fact, this past Christmas, which was Steven's first, I almost started to believe in Santa again. Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/07 9:47 AM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by GoldenRod

Just speaking from my own experience.... it still bothers me, 20 some-odd years later that my mom lied to me about Santa, where presents came from, and some of the other "fairy tales" parents tell kids. I still question what else my mom lied to me about. I am definitely not telling anyone not to do it, and I am going to teach my DC not to ruin other kids holidays by telling them the "truth", but I refuse to tell my kids that a big fat guy in a red suit comes down the chimney ("But Daddy, we don't have a chimney"...) and leaves presents. I want them to understand that we pay for the presents, so they can't just wish for things and get them. I'm not saying I won't ever "stretch the truth" around my kids, I just want to save that trick for things I need it for (ie, Daddy, when did you have your first drink, when did you have se*, etc, etc.... Chat Icon ..... "Uh... When I was married and over 21, and you should too...." Chat Icon Chat Icon )

I consider Santa similar to religion or politics. I have my beliefs, other people have their beliefs, and I am not going to judge anyone on what they believe, but I am going to do what I believe is right, and I will do everything I can to teach my DC that not everyone believes the same things that we do, and that's OK.
Flame away....



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

But I wont flame ya,Chat Icon, because this is the FIRST post that Im not in agreement with what you say. I think all of your responses are always well thought out (as a parent), respectful of others (as a dad and hubby) and always admirable.
So I was just shocked to hear this response.
Hey, whatever works for you and your family... but youre taking that magic away
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

NO hard feelings, I respect your opinion, but maybe we can still change your mind! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/07 9:52 AM
 

MrsSchwags
Soccer Baseball Lax Mom

Member since 10/05

11240 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Do you think it's lying?

i don't think its lying. They are able to see a santa or easter bunny when they go to the mall. There are decorations with these "imaginary" figures on them.

It is part of childhood. Its a wonderful experience to watch them get excited over what "santa" or whoever left.

As mentioned, kids grow up so fast, that if we can keep them innocent a little longer maybe all these horror stories out there with what is going on with young teens will change.

Posted 3/27/07 10:08 AM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Do you think it's lying?

I think of Santa and the Easter Bunny as fairt tales. We won't be doing it though. Even if we were actively raising them in my religion, I would tell them what Christmas and Easter are really about. I would want my kids to know the holidays were about Jeuss, not some mythical bunny bringing you a basket

Posted 3/27/07 10:10 AM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by greeneyes361708

I think of Santa and the Easter Bunny as fairt tales. We won't be doing it though. Even if we were actively raising them in my religion, I would tell them what Christmas and Easter are really about. I would want my kids to know the holidays were about Jeuss, not some mythical bunny bringing you a basket



I think you can have a good combo of both as we did/do.
At Christmas time, we sang Happy Birthday to Jesus, we always thank Jesus for random things throughout the day..
and we also thank Santa for the cool gifts, I dont see one as having to replace the other.

Posted 3/27/07 10:12 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by anna

Posted by GoldenRod

Just speaking from my own experience.... it still bothers me, 20 some-odd years later that my mom lied to me about Santa, where presents came from, and some of the other "fairy tales" parents tell kids. I still question what else my mom lied to me about. I am definitely not telling anyone not to do it, and I am going to teach my DC not to ruin other kids holidays by telling them the "truth", but I refuse to tell my kids that a big fat guy in a red suit comes down the chimney ("But Daddy, we don't have a chimney"...) and leaves presents. I want them to understand that we pay for the presents, so they can't just wish for things and get them. I'm not saying I won't ever "stretch the truth" around my kids, I just want to save that trick for things I need it for (ie, Daddy, when did you have your first drink, when did you have se*, etc, etc.... Chat Icon ..... "Uh... When I was married and over 21, and you should too...." Chat Icon Chat Icon )

I consider Santa similar to religion or politics. I have my beliefs, other people have their beliefs, and I am not going to judge anyone on what they believe, but I am going to do what I believe is right, and I will do everything I can to teach my DC that not everyone believes the same things that we do, and that's OK.
Flame away....



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

But I wont flame ya,Chat Icon, because this is the FIRST post that Im not in agreement with what you say. I think all of your responses are always well thought out (as a parent), respectful of others (as a dad and hubby) and always admirable.
So I was just shocked to hear this response.
Hey, whatever works for you and your family... but youre taking that magic away
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

NO hard feelings, I respect your opinion, but maybe we can still change your mind! Chat Icon Chat Icon



Thanks for your response. I appreciate you letting me know that I'm not babbling nonsense most of the time... Chat Icon I try to be considerate of everyone else, and I really do put thought into pretty much every post I make. I also take a lot of good information from a lot of other posters here.

We still celebrate Christmas and Easter, and DS is aware of Santa, so I don't think I'm depriving him of "Christmas", but we treat Santa similar to Bob the Builder or Dora. He's "real" in the fact that you can see him on TV or in some movies, but he doesn't actually fly around the world in a sleigh. I also mentioned that I am not "lying" about Santa because of my own experience growing up. I know that most kids figure out the Santa thing on their own, but it really bothered me when I was young, and I still think about it once in a while decades later. I don't want to risk doing that to my DC. I may be totally wrong, but it's just what I've experienced, and believe in at this point, so I can only work off of what I think is right for my family. I am in no means going to try to change anyone else, since I don't see any real harm in letting kids believe what their parents want them to believe.

Although, Mickey Mouse *is* real.... I saw him and shook his hand, and so did DS .... Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/07 10:23 AM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by GoldenRod

Although, Mickey Mouse *is* real.... I saw him and shook his hand, and so did DS .... Chat Icon



HAHHHHHHHHHH LOVED THAT response! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

THERE.
YOu got my respect back just for that one last comment Chat Icon Chat Icon

YOu make all valid points. esp if it's based on your own personal experience and you want to relay the experience to your kids.

PS. We're going to see Mickey in a few months, should we tell him you say hello? Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/27/07 10:33 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by anna

Posted by GoldenRod

Although, Mickey Mouse *is* real.... I saw him and shook his hand, and so did DS .... Chat Icon



HAHHHHHHHHHH LOVED THAT response! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

THERE.
YOu got my respect back just for that one last comment Chat Icon Chat Icon

YOu make all valid points. esp if it's based on your own personal experience and you want to relay the experience to your kids.

PS. We're going to see Mickey in a few months, should we tell him you say hello? Chat Icon Chat Icon



I'm sure he misses me, so certainly.... and don't forget Pluto, too... Chat Icon I don't stop by their house as often as I'd like, and they haven't responded to my invites to come to my house..... Maybe next year, I'll invite them in person; email is just so impersonal.... Chat Icon

Image Attachment(s):
Posted 3/27/07 12:55 PM
 

WoodIAm
My Boys!

Member since 5/05

5498 total posts

Name:
JoAnne

Re: Do you think it's lying?

Posted by Bxgell2

Nope, I think it's doing something that's essential to raising a curious, happy, well-adjusted child - encouraging their imagination. It's no different than role-playing, acting, etc...



Well said!

Posted 3/27/07 1:04 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Low Lying Placenta ? kat813 5/4/06 5 Pregnancy
Lying on a police report DDB336 4/21/06 10 Families Helping Families ™
Are my eyes lying? No Lost post? Kirsten 2/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Bassinet sleeping and lying flat kimmie 1/19/06 3 Parenting
I'm getting tired of the government lying Ren 11/16/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Lying spinoff Redhead 9/28/05 24 Families Helping Families ™