Re: Do you think it's lying?
Posted 3/27/2007 10:23:23 AM by GoldenRod


Posted by anna


Posted by GoldenRod

Just speaking from my own experience.... it still bothers me, 20 some-odd years later that my mom lied to me about Santa, where presents came from, and some of the other "fairy tales" parents tell kids. I still question what else my mom lied to me about. I am definitely not telling anyone not to do it, and I am going to teach my DC not to ruin other kids holidays by telling them the "truth", but I refuse to tell my kids that a big fat guy in a red suit comes down the chimney ("But Daddy, we don't have a chimney"...) and leaves presents. I want them to understand that we pay for the presents, so they can't just wish for things and get them. I'm not saying I won't ever "stretch the truth" around my kids, I just want to save that trick for things I need it for (ie, Daddy, when did you have your first drink, when did you have se*, etc, etc.... Chat Icon ..... "Uh... When I was married and over 21, and you should too...." Chat Icon Chat Icon )

I consider Santa similar to religion or politics. I have my beliefs, other people have their beliefs, and I am not going to judge anyone on what they believe, but I am going to do what I believe is right, and I will do everything I can to teach my DC that not everyone believes the same things that we do, and that's OK.
Flame away....



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

But I wont flame ya,Chat Icon, because this is the FIRST post that Im not in agreement with what you say. I think all of your responses are always well thought out (as a parent), respectful of others (as a dad and hubby) and always admirable.
So I was just shocked to hear this response.
Hey, whatever works for you and your family... but youre taking that magic away
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

NO hard feelings, I respect your opinion, but maybe we can still change your mind! Chat Icon Chat Icon



Thanks for your response. I appreciate you letting me know that I'm not babbling nonsense most of the time... Chat Icon I try to be considerate of everyone else, and I really do put thought into pretty much every post I make. I also take a lot of good information from a lot of other posters here.

We still celebrate Christmas and Easter, and DS is aware of Santa, so I don't think I'm depriving him of "Christmas", but we treat Santa similar to Bob the Builder or Dora. He's "real" in the fact that you can see him on TV or in some movies, but he doesn't actually fly around the world in a sleigh. I also mentioned that I am not "lying" about Santa because of my own experience growing up. I know that most kids figure out the Santa thing on their own, but it really bothered me when I was young, and I still think about it once in a while decades later. I don't want to risk doing that to my DC. I may be totally wrong, but it's just what I've experienced, and believe in at this point, so I can only work off of what I think is right for my family. I am in no means going to try to change anyone else, since I don't see any real harm in letting kids believe what their parents want them to believe.

Although, Mickey Mouse *is* real.... I saw him and shook his hand, and so did DS .... Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window