Did you circumcise you DS?
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Circumcision- Boys - Poll
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll it's very common now to NOT do it - |
|
Posted 1/22/10 3:45 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll DS is circumcised.. DH made the call. I couldn't be the one to say 'yes'. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 4:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by EricaAlt We had it done. Mason did cry, I had to leave the room. After, he slept... like a baby. No problems. I went down to thank everyone and "yenta" with the pple there. If my 2nd (eventually) is a boy I will do the sameOMG I would never be able to do this! and I would never be able to leave him this is such a tough decision for me
|
|
Posted 1/22/10 4:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by maybesoon Posted by EricaAlt We had it done. Mason did cry, I had to leave the room. After, he slept... like a baby. No problems. I went down to thank everyone and "yenta" with the pple there. If my 2nd (eventually) is a boy I will do the sameOMG I would never be able to do this! and I would never be able to leave him this is such a tough decision for meOh, believe me it's hard. The main reason he cried was b/c they took his clothes off. I should've stated that immediatly. I was one week PP and was still recovering from a tough c-section. I left b/c I couldn't watch my son get circumsized. DH, FIL, my father, etc were all there making sure it's ok. As I said, the Mohel also did my DH and he doesn't remember. I walked into the kitchen for a moment and came back immediatly. Mason stopped crying by the time I got in there. I can't even watch him get shots! I NEVER want to see him hurt. Like I said... I brought him upstairs after and he was already sleeping and fine. No one that came for the Bris came upstairs to bother us and I came down when I knew he was fine and sleeping for a bit. My mother and MIL took turns staying in the room with him just when I came to talk to everyone, |
|
Posted 1/22/10 4:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll I don't know anything about feelings or differences...no idea...but I do know that the "sleeve" plays an active role in solo activities. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 4:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by Janice I don't know anything about feelings or differences...no idea...but I do know that the "sleeve" plays an active role in solo activities. Yes! And one of the main reasons I argued against it to my DH is that I've heard of the frenulum (a part that is cut off during a circumcision) referred to as the male "c litoris"
|
|
Posted 1/22/10 4:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by katiebug Posted by MrsP747 I remember I posted this when I was on pregnancy, so I just searched and found it! I was just reading the Nov 08 issue if Parents magazine and they published that two new studies show that circumcision reduces a boy's future risk of HIV by 65% and HPV by 36%. We were already set on circumcision before reading this but it was nice perk!! I believe these studies were conducted in Sub Saharan Africa, so the results are skewed being that there is a huge problem with HIV infections and sanitation. I definitely took these studies with a big grain of salt. To me, they aren't even logical. How do we know the circumcised vs. intact groups were exposed to HIV at the same rate? Also, they have VERY different sexual practices down there, and many of the women are circumcised, which may increase their chances of HIV transmission. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 4:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll My dh wanted both his son's done. I agreed. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 4:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by Goldi0218 Im looking at the poll. The numbers are high in favor of circumcision. I am sure that it is not accurate, but I still wonder. I'd also be curious to know, that for those women who have had their sons circumcised for religious reasons (or for those who would have it done for religious reasons if they ever have a son) find themselves in a quandary over this. Do you just do it because it is just what is done? Do you question your faith? Do you consult a Rabbi (assuming you are Jewish)? I think we all do what we feel comfortable with for our own reasons. I am comfortable with the religious aspect of a bris and circumcision. I never saw it as unnecessary, barbaric or painful. A baby boy cries at his bris because he is cold. I grew up with this ritual and in my close circle of family and friends, it is just done. again, I have never known a Jewish male to be upset with this. Every Jewish male I know with a male child has had it done for them as well. I'm Jewish, but DH isn't. DS will be raised Jewish. Once DS was born, DH made it quite clear that he had a huge issue with it. Neither of us liked the idea of doing something that would cause pain to DS. I felt that it was important to do b/c of my religion, but I was also upset thinking that DS would be in pain. I'm sure a lot of it also had to do with being very hormonal at the time and the fact that DS spent a few days in the NICU. I just wanted to protect him from any type of pain. I cried when I brought him into the room and neither DH nor I stayed for the circumcision. From what I was told, DS did very well. He was very upset shortly after the ceremony, but we eventually calmed him down. If DH was the sole person making the decision, he either would've chosen for DS to not be circumcised or would've had it done in the hospital when DH wouldn't really be aware exactly when the procedure was being done. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 5:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Message edited 2011-11-28 22:18:46.037000. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 5:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll DS is circumcised. It was never a question, we are jewish and this is what we do. I was not in the room when it took place ( this is customary). DS cried for a half a second and it was over. I came and got him to BF him and he slept for several hours afterward. It's a joyful time for us, not a barbaric practice, part of a covenant |
|
Posted 1/22/10 5:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin strictly from a male point of view. i have had a few friends that aren't and every single one of them wish their parents had done it for them as babies. this is the face they say a lot of the women they've been with have made and to them it's embarrassing and awkward.they were teased as kids etc. i have never met a man who was that wished they weren't. but every guy i knew who isn't wishes they were. i'm just sayin'. we don't have a son but if we ever do he will be. I must admit, I made the face the 2 times I stumbled upon an uncircumcized pishy
|
|
Posted 1/22/10 6:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by EricaAlt Posted by Goldi0218 Im looking at the poll. The numbers are high in favor of circumcision. I am sure that it is not accurate, but I still wonder. I'd also be curious to know, that for those women who have had their sons circumcised for religious reasons (or for those who would have it done for religious reasons if they ever have a son) find themselves in a quandary over this. Do you just do it because it is just what is done? Do you question your faith? Do you consult a Rabbi (assuming you are Jewish)? I think we all do what we feel comfortable with for our own reasons. I am comfortable with the religious aspect of a bris and circumcision. I never saw it as unnecessary, barbaric or painful. A baby boy cries at his bris because he is cold. I grew up with this ritual and in my close circle of family and friends, it is just done. again, I have never known a Jewish male to be upset with this. Every Jewish male I know with a male child has had it done for them as well. I didn't think twice when it came to Mason's Bris. I don't question my faith at all. No, I'm not super religious either, but DH and I strongly believe in our heritage and where we came from. That said... no question or 2nd guessing. We had it done. After, he slept... like a baby. No problems. I went down to thank everyone and "yenta" with the pple there. If my 2nd (eventually) is a boy I will do the sameITA...I am Jewish and DH is catholic but we are raising our DC Jewish so DS had a bris also. It is something that means a lot of me and my family to honor and respect these traditions. Was it hard to watch, yes (we stayed although I had to turn my head when they actually did it), did DS cry, a little bit (they gave him a drop of wine so he was loopy-it was very funny). In fact me and my DH cried more then he did. I do have to say I am also sort of relieved to be having a girl this time and not have to go through it again since it was very emotional. Also, even if we weren't raising DS to be Jewish, he still would have had a circumcision in the hospital b/c it is what DH would have wanted. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 6:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll My ds is snipped. I left it up to dh and since he is Jewish he opted for it. Ds didn't even cry. He was only gone a couple minutes and came back happy and hungry. Not a tear in sight. The ob did a great job. We have had no problems at all. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 6:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Ds is not circumsized. I didn't see a reason for it. He's 9 months. I haven't had to give him any extra care, he's had no issues & he's certainly not unclean. I just couldn't bear the thought of putting him through pain for something I don't personally see as necessary. DH fought me a little, but gave in in the end. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 7:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll My DS is. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 8:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin i have never met a man who was that wished they weren't. but every guy i knew who isn't wishes they were. i'm just sayin'. We've met... I'm just sayin'... Every kid that I know that teased another boy about his 'junk' was then teased for staring at another guy..... it's just not something guys make a point of, at least everywhere that I've ever been. Message edited 2010-01-22 20:42:32.907000. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 8:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by Dani922 Ds is not circumsized. I didn't see a reason for it. He's 9 months. I haven't had to give him any extra care, he's had no issues & he's certainly not unclean. I just couldn't bear the thought of putting him through pain for something I don't personally see as necessary. DH fought me a little, but gave in in the end. Same here.. we did not get DS circumsized. After speaking to our doctors, doing research, I was told it really is not medically necessary. We decided not too and are very happy with our decision. We felt the same about not putting him through pain for something that is really not necessary, whether they remember the pain or not. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 8:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll
Message edited 2011-11-28 22:16:44.307000. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 9:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin strictly from a male point of view. i have had a few friends that aren't and every single one of them wish their parents had done it for them as babies. this is the face they say a lot of the women they've been with have made and to them it's embarrassing and awkward.they were teased as kids etc. i have never met a man who was that wished they weren't. but every guy i knew who isn't wishes they were. i'm just sayin'. we don't have a son but if we ever do he will be. I get that this is your experience.. but I'll share my own. I know at least 2 cut men who wish they were not. I married one of them. I don't really have a lot of intimate conversations about foreskins with my male relatives.. but I do know that my father opted not to circumcize my brother and my brother opted not to circumcize his sons. I know my 20 something nephews are in tact and honestly I hate to acknowledge that both of them seem to have a little too much sexual success with women. One of them is a father - he opted not to cut his child. I'd think that if they experienced a great deal of teasing or sexual rejection the men in my family might at some point have said "We need to start snipping the peeps!" I mean - everyone wants their kid to be better than they are. I am SURE there are plenty of guys who have run across rejection because they are uncut - but there are plenty who have seen this face because they are super tiny, bent like a banana or shaped funny even though they are cut. I'm positive their are guys who have been teased by their friends for having a sheath.. but probably more have been teased for having a mole on their azz, an outie belly button, out of control pubes or stretch marks from too much Taco Bell. I teach my kids to have confidence in who they are and accepting of what they are - foreskins and all. Hopefully that is enough to let stupid insults roll off their back the same way I hope moronic taunts about their pointy ears or knock knees will.I know - I sound super defensive - right? I'm not really. I just want to put it out there that YES there are some guys who wish they were when they weren't.. but that's certainly not ALL men. I think most men who are confident and comfortable with themselves aren't too terribly concerned about people who don't find their parts aesthetically displeasing!
|
|
Posted 1/22/10 9:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll
Message edited 2011-11-28 22:15:52.203000. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 9:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Our son is and not for religious reasons. I know 2 guys who had nothing but issues and ended up being circumcised when they were adults, I didn't want to take the chance of DS having to go through that. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 10:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll For the ladies who answered my question, thank you. My thoughts were that yes, it is just something we do and though I am sure there is some amount of discomfort, it is not like performing open-heart surgery without an anesthetic. Most often, the babies cry because they are cold and NOT because they in a great deal of pain. During the circumcision part of the bris, they are sucking on a small piece of wine-soaked gauze and within minutes after, they are asleep. (No it is not enough wine to become intoxicated). Message edited 2010-01-22 22:20:42.053000. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 10:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Both my sons were circumsized at birth. I never thought twice about it. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 10:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll I saw DS soon after Circ and he was fine...wasn't crying for any length of time that wasn't the norm for him. We didn't do it for religious, more like hygieinic reasons. There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 10:36 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moms of boys....when can I give my DS a real bath after a circumcision? | missrock | 4/27/09 | 2 | Parenting |
| Newborn boys - question regarding circumcision | Diana1215 | 10/21/09 | 14 | Parenting |
| Question for mom's who have boys- re: circumcision | pnbplus1 | 9/30/09 | 13 | Parenting |
| Moms of boys - circumcision question | MrsR | 7/9/09 | 28 | Parenting |
| Moms of boys: Spinoff to circumcision | pharmcat2000 | 2/17/09 | 5 | Parenting |
| Moms of boys....circumcision related..UPDATE | Ang-Rich | 6/7/07 | 5 | Parenting |













No problems. I went down to thank everyone and "yenta" with the pple there. If my 2nd (eventually) is a boy I will do the same





this is the face they say a lot of the women they've been with have made and to them it's embarrassing and awkward.







