Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll
Posted 1/22/2010 6:34:22 PM by bayla


Posted by EricaAlt


Posted by Goldi0218

Im looking at the poll. The numbers are high in favor of circumcision. I am sure that it is not accurate, but I still wonder.

I'd also be curious to know, that for those women who have had their sons circumcised for religious reasons (or for those who would have it done for religious reasons if they ever have a son) find themselves in a quandary over this. Do you just do it because it is just what is done? Do you question your faith? Do you consult a Rabbi (assuming you are Jewish)?

I think we all do what we feel comfortable with for our own reasons. I am comfortable with the religious aspect of a bris and circumcision. I never saw it as unnecessary, barbaric or painful. A baby boy cries at his bris because he is cold. I grew up with this ritual and in my close circle of family and friends, it is just done. again, I have never known a Jewish male to be upset with this. Every Jewish male I know with a male child has had it done for them as well.



I didn't think twice when it came to Mason's Bris. I don't question my faith at all. No, I'm not super religious either, but DH and I strongly believe in our heritage and where we came from.
That said... no question or 2nd guessing. We had it done. After, he slept... like a baby. Chat Icon No problems. I went down to thank everyone and "yenta" with the pple there. If my 2nd (eventually) is a boy I will do the same



ITA...I am Jewish and DH is catholic but we are raising our DC Jewish so DS had a bris also. It is something that means a lot of me and my family to honor and respect these traditions.
Was it hard to watch, yes (we stayed although I had to turn my head when they actually did it), did DS cry, a little bit (they gave him a drop of wine so he was loopy-it was very funny). In fact me and my DH cried more then he did. I do have to say I am also sort of relieved to be having a girl this time and not have to go through it again since it was very emotional.
Also, even if we weren't raising DS to be Jewish, he still would have had a circumcision in the hospital b/c it is what DH would have wanted.
Print Post      Close Window