Did you circumcise you DS?
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Circumcision- Boys - Poll
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] | |
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by LittleBlueBug I saw DS soon after Circ and he was fine...wasn't crying for any length of time that wasn't the norm for him. We didn't do it for religious, more like hygieinic reasons. There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. I definitely respect everyone's choices for their child, and I am not trying to start drama, but there are reasons not too, and to say that is really not true. It is no longer necessary according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, it is not medically necessary, and most doctors I have spoken to say this. I just think that you should do your research before posting something like that. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 10:47 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by LittleBlueBug There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. Its called smegma, and women have it also. |
|
Posted 1/22/10 11:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll DS is circumcised |
|
Posted 1/23/10 6:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll My DS is! I left the decision up to someone who deals with one on a daily basis. I'm talking about DH of course Message edited 2010-01-23 08:24:26.413000. |
|
Posted 1/23/10 8:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by pisces36 Posted by LittleBlueBug I saw DS soon after Circ and he was fine...wasn't crying for any length of time that wasn't the norm for him. We didn't do it for religious, more like hygieinic reasons. There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. I definitely respect everyone's choices for their child, and I am not trying to start drama, but there are reasons not too, and to say that is really not true. It is no longer necessary according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, it is not medically necessary, and most doctors I have spoken to say this. I just think that you should do your research before posting something like that. I'm not trying to start drama either, but nothing that LittleBlueBug posted was incorrect...there IS a substance that builds up and even thought it is perfectly normal, that CAN be one of HER reasons to have had it done. And just like it isn't "necessary" by the AAP, it isn't "necessary" to not get it done either... TBH, I did it for hygienic reasons as well, and I have no issue with that, just because someone does and chooses not to circ their son, doesn't mean I or another poster should get flamed for that reason
|
|
Posted 1/23/10 8:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by MrsP747 Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin strictly from a male point of view. i have had a few friends that aren't and every single one of them wish their parents had done it for them as babies. this is the face they say a lot of the women they've been with have made and to them it's embarrassing and awkward.they were teased as kids etc. i have never met a man who was that wished they weren't. but every guy i knew who isn't wishes they were. i'm just sayin'. we don't have a son but if we ever do he will be. I must admit, I made the face the 2 times I stumbled upon an uncircumcized pishy I have never stumbled upon one but I think that would be my reaction as well....so I can definitely see Kevins point
|
|
Posted 1/23/10 9:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by KateDevine Posted by pisces36 Posted by LittleBlueBug I saw DS soon after Circ and he was fine...wasn't crying for any length of time that wasn't the norm for him. We didn't do it for religious, more like hygieinic reasons. There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. I definitely respect everyone's choices for their child, and I am not trying to start drama, but there are reasons not too, and to say that is really not true. It is no longer necessary according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, it is not medically necessary, and most doctors I have spoken to say this. I just think that you should do your research before posting something like that. I'm not trying to start drama either, but nothing that LittleBlueBug posted was incorrect...there IS a substance that builds up and even thought it is perfectly normal, that CAN be one of HER reasons to have had it done. And just like it isn't "necessary" by the AAP, it isn't "necessary" to not get it done either... TBH, I did it for hygienic reasons as well, and I have no issue with that, just because someone does and chooses not to circ their son, doesn't mean I or another poster should get flamed for that reason I am not flaming anyone? I just stated that the AAP is stating as well as dr's that it is not necessary. I agree there is a substance and that is not what I was referencing. I NEVER start drama on this site, ever and I have been a member for the last four-five years. I was stating a fact, that's all, sorry you took it as me flaming someone- We can all agree to disagree, to me it was not necessary and that was confirmed by the AAP and other DR's that it is not necessary. I don't understand why I can't state my opinion towards someone else's comments without it looking like I am flaming someone? Am I not allowed to state the facts? I said in the beginning that everyone is allowed to do what they want with their own children. Sorry you took it that way. |
|
Posted 1/23/10 10:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by KateDevine Posted by pisces36 Posted by LittleBlueBug I saw DS soon after Circ and he was fine...wasn't crying for any length of time that wasn't the norm for him. We didn't do it for religious, more like hygieinic reasons. There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. I definitely respect everyone's choices for their child, and I am not trying to start drama, but there are reasons not too, and to say that is really not true. It is no longer necessary according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, it is not medically necessary, and most doctors I have spoken to say this. I just think that you should do your research before posting something like that. I'm not trying to start drama either, but nothing that LittleBlueBug posted was incorrect...there IS a substance that builds up and even thought it is perfectly normal, that CAN be one of HER reasons to have had it done. And just like it isn't "necessary" by the AAP, it isn't "necessary" to not get it done either... TBH, I did it for hygienic reasons as well, and I have no issue with that, just because someone does and chooses not to circ their son, doesn't mean I or another poster should get flamed for that reason I'm not trying to start..but the substance is called, smegma, and we as women get it as well. And I'm sure none of us have a problem keeping ourselves clean, so I'm not sure why everyone thinks boys (and eventually men) are incapable of this. It kind of bothers me that people will think my sons are dirty, and thats not even the case! My older son (3) is retractable, and all we have to do is pull it back real quick in the tub (no soap) and swish it around. |
|
Posted 1/23/10 10:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by imthekevinofcindyandkevin strictly from a male point of view. i have had a few friends that aren't and every single one of them wish their parents had done it for them as babies. this is the face they say a lot of the women they've been with have made and to them it's embarrassing and awkward.they were teased as kids etc. i have never met a man who was that wished they weren't. but every guy i knew who isn't wishes they were. i'm just sayin'. we don't have a son but if we ever do he will be. I must admit, I made the face the 2 times I stumbled upon an uncircumcized pishy I have, dated someone who wasn't and like Kevin stated, HE wishes that his parents had made the choice to do it. He was teased constantly for it and for other reasons as well. -if I have boys, DH and I had decided we would. I look at DH for this, being he knows more than I do and respect what he wants as well. In the end, to each their own! You do or dont for your own reasons and that is how it should be.
Message edited 2010-01-23 10:16:23.260000. |
|
Posted 1/23/10 10:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by KateDevine Posted by pisces36 Posted by LittleBlueBug I saw DS soon after Circ and he was fine...wasn't crying for any length of time that wasn't the norm for him. We didn't do it for religious, more like hygieinic reasons. There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. I definitely respect everyone's choices for their child, and I am not trying to start drama, but there are reasons not too, and to say that is really not true. It is no longer necessary according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, it is not medically necessary, and most doctors I have spoken to say this. I just think that you should do your research before posting something like that. I'm not trying to start drama either, but nothing that LittleBlueBug posted was incorrect...there IS a substance that builds up and even thought it is perfectly normal, that CAN be one of HER reasons to have had it done. And just like it isn't "necessary" by the AAP, it isn't "necessary" to not get it done either... TBH, I did it for hygienic reasons as well, and I have no issue with that, just because someone does and chooses not to circ their son, doesn't mean I or another poster should get flamed for that reason I'm not trying to start..but the substance is called, smegma, and we as women get it as well. And I'm sure none of us have a problem keeping ourselves clean, so I'm not sure why everyone thinks boys (and eventually men) are incapable of this. It kind of bothers me that people will think my sons are dirty, and thats not even the case! My older son (3) is retractable, and all we have to do is pull it back real quick in the tub (no soap) and swish it around. I never said it was dirty at all, but that can be one of her reasons, KWIM?
|
|
Posted 1/23/10 10:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll maybe the kids were teased because it used to be that in this country most of the boys were circumcised... right now as someone stated a lot of parents choose not to do it so I dont think it is going to be a huge issue when our kids grow up... |
|
Posted 1/23/10 11:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll Posted by LittleBlueBug I saw DS soon after Circ and he was fine...wasn't crying for any length of time that wasn't the norm for him. We didn't do it for religious, more like hygieinic reasons. There is a substance that can build up on the foreskin, and there is no reason not to IMO. Do you wash inside and around your DC's ears? The creases under his neck? Between his toes? These are all places were "substances can build up." Removing a part of your child's body because he'll have to be taught how to keep it clean doesn't really make sense to me. Hygeine would've been an issue when circumcision became popular in the US in the early 1900's, but it's no longer a valid reason in the day and age of daily baths and showers! And actually, the foreskin is meant to protect the glans of the penis - like an eyelid does for an eye! - preserving its sensitivity. If you google history of circumcision, you'll find that a major reason for the introduction of the procedure was to prevent masturbation, because without the foreskin, the head of the penis becomes dry and less sensitive. As for sexual pleasure - there are probably only a handful of men who have experience of both. But I can tell you, as a woman who has experience of both, it's a lot easier on MY wrist, so I'm sure the same is true for men
|
|
Posted 1/23/10 11:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll We didn't. None of the men in DH's family are, and none of them wish they were. |
|
Posted 1/23/10 12:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll I finally got around to answer this post. In your situation, I probably wouldn't do at all. My son is circumcised for religious reasons ONLY. |
|
Posted 1/23/10 9:46 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moms of boys....when can I give my DS a real bath after a circumcision? | missrock | 4/27/09 | 2 | Parenting |
| Newborn boys - question regarding circumcision | Diana1215 | 10/21/09 | 14 | Parenting |
| Question for mom's who have boys- re: circumcision | pnbplus1 | 9/30/09 | 13 | Parenting |
| Moms of boys - circumcision question | MrsR | 7/9/09 | 28 | Parenting |
| Moms of boys: Spinoff to circumcision | pharmcat2000 | 2/17/09 | 5 | Parenting |
| Moms of boys....circumcision related..UPDATE | Ang-Rich | 6/7/07 | 5 | Parenting |















this is the face they say a lot of the women they've been with have made and to them it's embarrassing and awkward.




There were huge debates in our family and a very difficult process for me to finally come up with a solution, but we are Jews and we ARE raising out children Jewish so we had a proper bris and that's that. If we weren't and we had to do it in a hospital, not with a mohel, there was no way I would have had it done.