Re: Circumcision- Boys - Poll
Posted 1/22/2010 5:22:37 PM by MrsS2005


Posted by Goldi0218

Im looking at the poll. The numbers are high in favor of circumcision. I am sure that it is not accurate, but I still wonder.

I'd also be curious to know, that for those women who have had their sons circumcised for religious reasons (or for those who would have it done for religious reasons if they ever have a son) find themselves in a quandary over this. Do you just do it because it is just what is done? Do you question your faith? Do you consult a Rabbi (assuming you are Jewish)?

I think we all do what we feel comfortable with for our own reasons. I am comfortable with the religious aspect of a bris and circumcision. I never saw it as unnecessary, barbaric or painful. A baby boy cries at his bris because he is cold. I grew up with this ritual and in my close circle of family and friends, it is just done. again, I have never known a Jewish male to be upset with this. Every Jewish male I know with a male child has had it done for them as well.


I'm Jewish, but DH isn't. DS will be raised Jewish. Once DS was born, DH made it quite clear that he had a huge issue with it. Neither of us liked the idea of doing something that would cause pain to DS. I felt that it was important to do b/c of my religion, but I was also upset thinking that DS would be in pain. I'm sure a lot of it also had to do with being very hormonal at the time and the fact that DS spent a few days in the NICU. I just wanted to protect him from any type of pain. I cried when I brought him into the room and neither DH nor I stayed for the circumcision. From what I was told, DS did very well. He was very upset shortly after the ceremony, but we eventually calmed him down.

If DH was the sole person making the decision, he either would've chosen for DS to not be circumcised or would've had it done in the hospital when DH wouldn't really be aware exactly when the procedure was being done.
Print Post      Close Window