| Posted By |
Message |
| Pages:
1 [2] |
KennysMommy
Never knew LOVE like it before
 Member since 3/10 2640 total posts
Name: Danielle
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
Posted by Shelleybean11
Posted by itsbabytime
So sometimes I wonder...is it worth it?
It's absolutely worth it. It benefits the mother's health as well.
I agree. My OB told me that BFing actually helps "mature" your breasts and the risk of breast cancer SIGNIFICANTLY drops after 6 months of BFing. Many people don't know that. For that reason alone, it's worth it.
|
Posted 8/18/10 10:14 AM
|
| |
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
|
LoriH
There's no place like home
 Member since 8/07 4110 total posts
Name: Lori
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
I BF DD#1 for the first three weeks with quite a bit of supplementing. For MANY reasons BFing did not work out for me the first time around. She is now two and extremely bright, hit all of her milestones early and is hardly ever sick. She is also on the thinner side, since another myth is formula fed babies are more likely to be obese.
I am currently EBF DD#2, she is only six weeks but it is working out way better for me this time around. I haven't had to supplement at all and have a ton of frozen milk. Although I have no idea how they will compare in intelligence, immune systems and weight going forward, I can say that in many ways I find breastfeeding to be easier. No bottle to prepare or heat in the middle of the night. Less bottles to clean (I pump and DH gives her an 11pm bottle.) Less gas and constipation.
Whenever I hear about these studies about breasfed vs formula fed babies in regard to intelligence and immunity, I can't help but wonder if all the factors are equal. Are the formula fed babies and breastfed babies from the same socioeconomic class, same genetic predisposition to diseases etc? Not disputing that breastmilk is the most natural and pure food for baby and best in most cases but there in much more that goes into intelligence, immunity and childhood obesity.
|
Posted 8/18/10 10:22 AM
|
| |
|
shiv
Twinsanity!!
 Member since 5/07 4747 total posts
Name: Shiv
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
It's hard to compare since each child is so different but I'll give the example of me and my little sister:
I was the 4th child in my family and was BF for 1 1/2 years. I have severe allergies- to almost every environmental element, animals and some foods and I have asthma. I was ALWAYS sick growing up. I was average/below average in grammar and high school but did very well in college- only because I worked my arse off to do well.
My sister was the 5th child in my family and only BF for 2 months. She was NEVER sick as a child. She is one of the smartest people I know and her great grades in school came easy for her.
So, we contradict everything they say about the benefits of BFing on a child.
However, I strongly felt the need to BF my son- I wanted that bonding time with him. Since I'm a FTWM, I wanted him to have something with me that he couldn't have with anyone else. And it's the most organic and healthy food for your child. It was so hard in the beginning but I cherish it now!
Message edited 2010-08-18 10:34:16.670000. |
Posted 8/18/10 10:30 AM
|
| |
|
maybesoon
LIF Adult
Member since 9/09 5981 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
I exc. pumped for DS 1 and went straight to form for DS 2.
Ds 1 Has seasonal allergies, I thought a benefit of BM were no allergies. he gets sick just as often as FF children (if not more!). He is not any smarter than my FF friends babies ( actually he is behind most of them in speech )
He has always been very much underweight. he had colic, acid reflux, so much gas, always crying. I see no benefits at all w/ DS1.
I swore I would not bother BF my second child. my Second baby went straight to form. has no belly issues what so ever! he is not sneezing right now , where DS 1 is bc of allergy season. he has a much better weight (50%) and seems like he knows exactly what is going on (he is only 3 months old tho LOL)
so far my conclusion is all the tears and lost sleep during pumping for DS 1 was totally not worth it, I don't think there is a difference at all. there is a sudden push For BF that was not there 10 years ago. in 10 yrs from now it will be formula all the way bc opinions always change.
I should add DH and I were both FF. DH is very very smart, and never ever sick. I am smart, but not like him, and get sick easily. I don't think it has anything to do w/ BF vs FF
Message edited 2010-08-24 14:52:10.517000. |
Posted 8/24/10 2:48 PM
|
| |
|
Linda1003
love my 2 boys
 Member since 8/08 10923 total posts
Name: Linda
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
My sister breastfed her 3 boys.. they all have allergies (seasonal).. they get sick with colds just as much as ff kids. Her first is a genius but the other two are totally on point for their age. So no I don't see a difference at this point. they actually kept getting my FF baby sick last winter!!
|
Posted 8/24/10 2:55 PM
|
| |
|
MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3
 Member since 1/06 19197 total posts
Name: Michelle
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
DD is 18.5 months old.
She was FF, although I did attempt to BF, it didn't work for us and by 6 weeks old she was on FF.
(knock on wood) rarely ever sick. She is in daycare 2 days a week.
She is also highly intelligent for her age. Yes, I know I'm her mommy and I would say that regardless, but even her teachers and others who observe her see that intellectually she is ahead of alot of other kids her age.
My son who was born last week, we went straight to FF. I didn't even attempt to BF. It's just not for me.
With that said, one of my SIL only EBF. Her kids were never on a bottle (even a BM bottle) and she BF all kids until age 2. She still nurses her youngest (same age as my DD) once per day. Her kids are ALWAYS sick. The oldest is the only one in school (he's 6).
Message edited 2010-08-24 15:23:30.280000. |
Posted 8/24/10 3:20 PM
|
| |
|
NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..
 Member since 11/09 54921 total posts
Name: ..being a mommy and being a wife!
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
By reading these responses it seems there really isnt' a correlation between how often children get sick and if they were BF or FF. It seems it can go either way.
I don't have much experience with it- all I know is my sister and I were FF and we were NEVER sick. To this day I have an immune system like gold.
In terms of my DD- she is FF and the Dr is so happy with how she is gaining weight. My cousin's baby has been back and forth to the ped so much in his first weeks of life- becuase he is just not gaining weight on the breast milk and is actually losing weight so the ped was concerned.
I don't know... it seems like there are good and bad results with both...
|
Posted 8/24/10 3:26 PM
|
| |
|
Peainapod
Peanuts are here!
 Member since 1/09 13591 total posts
Name: Diana
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
Both my brother and I were FF babies. HE's a farking genius when it comes to math, history, computers, etc. Im smart in other ways, but not on his level. (common sense wise through my brother is a little lost..LOL).
Mom was SAHM so we werent in daycare, but even with all our school years we were hardly ever sick. CHicken pox, maybe strep here and there..but we had perfect attendance awards most years. We both excelled in school in various subjects.
I FF DS ..he wouldnt latch, they started him on the bottle in the hospital right out of the gate..LOL..my milk didnt come in for whatever reason.
Im not sure if I buy that BF babies are that much smarter than FF babies. I think thats all genetics.
I was upset about not BFing in the beginning but FF really was the best thing for me and my personal situation.
|
Posted 8/24/10 3:27 PM
|
| |
|
Bops
My 3 wishes
 Member since 12/07 13625 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
Both my kids for the most part were FF ( I pumped w/ DS for 8 weeks and maybe 3 weeks for DD and supplemeted with formula)
Whether it be luck or what, I don't know but knock wood....I can count on one hand how many times my DS has been sick in almost 5 years and my DD has been sick once in 19 months....
My nephew (who is almost 3 and still gets BM)- I can't even begin to count how many times he has been sick...Granted, he is is daycare part-time however but my DS has been in part-time pre-k as well since age 3...
I have a few friends who exclusively BF with the same issues as far as illness, so who knows??
Of-course I think they are all geniouses
|
Posted 8/24/10 3:30 PM
|
| |
|
Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink
 Member since 12/05 13341 total posts
Name: J
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
DS1 EBF until 14 months DS2 EBF and is almost 10 months - still going
No clue if BF has given my children an "edge" intellectually. I think DS1 is a smart cookie, but again, no idea if that has anything to do with him being BF'd.
As far as health, I do believe, or at least hope, that BM has helped my boys out along the way. They certainly get sick, but DS1 had the swine flu when DS2 was a NB. DS2 never got it and we lived in 2 rooms of our house at the time b/c we were dormering.
And recently, DS1 had coxsackie and DS2 did not get it.
In my mind, I believe that my being exposed to these illnesses in our household, and then nursing Colin gives him an advantage against the illness.
Again, who knows. But I have to believe there is some reason why I'm doing this Lately pumping - I get next to nothing. And my right nipple bleeds - a lot. It hurts like H E LLL and I can't seem to "repair" it. And DH says, "you have to stop using that side" But I keep going b/c I think I'm doing something great for my child but have no proof of this
|
Posted 8/24/10 3:46 PM
|
| |
|
itsbabytime
LIF Adult
Member since 11/05 9644 total posts
Name: Me
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
Thanks for all the responses ladies - All very interesting! I agree with what others have posted that it IS really hard to do a REAL comparison b/c there are SO many other factors that affect the health,intelligence etc. of our children!
I'll answer my own question -
DS was BF until 10 months (EBF until about 7 and then started adding in some formula). He NEVER got sick until two weeks after I completely stopped BF. But, maybe that was a coincidence. To this day he is not sick often at all. As far as intelligence it's probably too early to tell but he's been way ahead with everything - and was extremely verbal very early on (sent. by 18 mos) etc.
DD is 7 mos. She was EBF until 6.5 mos and now gets some formula and I am considering weaning off BF for a number of reasons which is what prompted this post.. She has never been sick and, with her, its a whole different ballgame b/c I have another child at home - we have all been sick around her and she has yet to get sick. But, again, I'm not sure if its a coincidence. So far she has been doing everything she should be at or before schedule but, again, I think its a little early to guage intelligence
But, I also know MOSTLY FF fed babies and kids and some of them are as healthy as DS and DD and some get sick all the time. Some are as "smart," some not so much. So does it all really matter? Don't know!
ETA: So far both DS and DD do not have any allergies at all.
Message edited 2010-08-24 15:49:33.483000. |
Posted 8/24/10 3:48 PM
|
| |
|
hazeleyes33
LIF Adult
 Member since 5/05 13060 total posts
Name: Ginger
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
Both my kids were FF. Both are smart and both never (knock on wood) get sick.
|
Posted 8/24/10 3:48 PM
|
| |
|
Palebride
I am an amazing bakist
 Member since 5/05 13673 total posts
Name: Lori
|
Re: BF vs. Formula IRL
Lily was FF and has never had an ear infection, and aside from an occasional cold, has never really been sick.
|
Posted 8/24/10 4:22 PM
|
| |
|
| Pages:
1 [2] |