BF vs. Formula IRL

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

BF vs. Formula IRL

I want to preface this by saying that I BF DS for 10 mos and have been BF DD so far for almost 7 mos. I do it b/c I have read it is the best thing - I do enjoy the extra bonding time but, I won't lie, it is a heck of a lot more difficult on my life and my body than FF would be. So sometimes I wonder...is it worth it?

So for my question - I know that all the research points to BF being better for the babies - for their immune systems and intelligence but, I am wondering from what you all have observed does this really hold true from real life observations? Excluding your own DC (b/c we all think our DC's are the best at everything) - do you see the BF babies you know as being smarter and healthier than the formula fed babies?

Posted 8/17/10 10:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I EBF at first, I supplemented later on to keep up with DS and I used formula only.

No, no difference for us! DS was just sick all the time in daycare. Me EBF at the time made no difference.


Honestly, I don't regret EBF. It was natural and it's the best.

But in term of practicality, formula was MUCH easier for me. I was in Heaven when I switched to supplementing.

Mostly because after I came back to work at 14 weeks PP, I had to BF DS twice a day and pump at work 3 times. Pump more after I had come home from work. I had to pump over 32 oz of milk per day to keep up with DS.

Posted 8/17/10 10:27 PM
 

MrsRivera
2 under 2...whew!!

Member since 2/07

9876 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I can only speak about my mom's experience with my sister and I.

My sister was born in the late 60s, when BF was considered taboo. She was exclusively FF.

When I came along 10 years later, my mom decided to BF me.

According to my mom, my sister had much more trouble in school than I did--she always said that my sister had to truly work her @ss off for every good grade that she got, whereas with me it came very naturally.

Can I directly attribute that to the whole BF/FF thing? Absolutely not.

I BF my DD for 10 months as well, but was not able to BF my DS because his latch was terrible, and with an 18 month-old in the house, it was impossible to find time to pump. He was only BF for 2 weeks.

I guess time will tell if there's a difference or not... Chat Icon

Posted 8/17/10 10:28 PM
 

chickiemom
LOVE my boys!!

Member since 10/09

1473 total posts

Name:
Leanne

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I BF but I think that science these days creates some pretty good formulas.. I just liked the idea of BFing and other benefits like its always available and don't have to stop playing to make a bottle...Chat Icon. I also had a c section and had a very hard time with that so BFing kind of helped me with it... BUT now at almost 4 months old andl not taking a dam bottle is a little fustrating...

One question I do have for you is... would you go straight to formula feeding your next dc or still try to BF again?

Posted 8/17/10 10:35 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

DH and I were both products of SAHMs. Neither one of us was in day care at all.

DH was BF'd. I was not.

According to MIL, he got sick a lot. I didn't.

I BF'd Abby as long as I could for almost 3 months. Once she got into day care she got sick ALL the time with so many ear infections that she ended up with tubes by the time she was 10 months old.

DH's IQ is 10 points higher than mine. HAD to be the BFingChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Pity they don't give IQ tests to 2 year olds or I'd sign Abby up for Pee Wee MENSA.

Im sorry. I know too many people who were not breast fed who are not sickly and are true geniuses.

Posted 8/17/10 10:43 PM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

hard to say- i don't know.
i BF"d DD til 10 months she never had formula- and i won't lie she was/is hardly ever sick..
I BFd DS til 7months and then went to formula til 11 months. he was sick all freaking winter BUT he was in daycare from months 4-11 and most of those illnesses were ear infections. i really don't know. i don't think DD is any smarter. she had a lot more words than DS has at a year but she didn't walk til 15 months and he walked 10.5 months. so i say it's more a gender thing in a way and i don't have all day anymore to teach words or read books to him like i did with her!

Posted 8/17/10 10:47 PM
 

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

We don't really know many babies IRL and certainly not at an age where you could make an assessment.

My DD is FF though - always has been - and FWIW, I took comfort in the fact that DH and I were both FF and are in great health, have impressive educational records (high test scores our entire lives, admitted to great schools, ivy league law degrees), and are pretty much unbeatable at Trivial Pursuit. My DH is by far the smartest person I know or have ever known - I don't think BF would've made him any more intelligent nor do I think FF had anything to do with his intelligence. At least anecdotally, I'm not really sure there's much of a relationship btw intelligence and health and BF. JMHO.

Posted 8/17/10 10:53 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

Posted by CucumberGirl

We don't really know many babies IRL and certainly not at an age where you could make an assessment.

My DD is FF though - always has been - and FWIW, I took comfort in the fact that DH and I were both FF and are in great health, have impressive educational records (high test scores our entire lives, admitted to great schools, ivy league law degrees), and are pretty much unbeatable at Trivial Pursuit. My DH is by far the smartest person I know or have ever known - I don't think BF would've made him any more intelligent nor do I think FF had anything to do with his intelligence. At least anecdotally, I'm not really sure there's much of a relationship btw intelligence and health and BF. JMHO.



"Anecdotally" gave me a headache.Chat Icon

Posted 8/17/10 10:59 PM
 

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

Posted by Goldi0218

Posted by CucumberGirl

We don't really know many babies IRL and certainly not at an age where you could make an assessment.

My DD is FF though - always has been - and FWIW, I took comfort in the fact that DH and I were both FF and are in great health, have impressive educational records (high test scores our entire lives, admitted to great schools, ivy league law degrees), and are pretty much unbeatable at Trivial Pursuit. My DH is by far the smartest person I know or have ever known - I don't think BF would've made him any more intelligent nor do I think FF had anything to do with his intelligence. At least anecdotally, I'm not really sure there's much of a relationship btw intelligence and health and BF. JMHO.



"Anecdotally" gave me a headache.Chat Icon



You should hear the vocabularies of some of my journalist friends... maybe if I had been BF I would've been able to compete with them Chat Icon

Posted 8/17/10 11:10 PM
 

Shelleybean11
Mommy of 2!

Member since 12/08

11013 total posts

Name:

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

Posted by itsbabytime

So sometimes I wonder...is it worth it?






It's absolutely worth it. It benefits the mother's health as well.

Posted 8/17/10 11:41 PM
 

OffWithHerHead23
Keep passing the open windows

Member since 10/06

3627 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I'm going to compare my 2 SILs. One BF her kids exclusively, one exclusively FF.

The one who bf kids are only "normal" sick... the occasional cold, ear infection, etc. The ff ones both have asthma (one severe to the point of hospitalization), ear tubes, etc. They are really what you would call "sickly" kids.

The bf ones are average in school. THe ff ones are both failing, and one may be left back.

Do I think all this has to do with bf vs. ff?? HELLS NO! It has MUCH more to do with lifestyle choices, parenting and coping skills, and simply the way you choose to raise your children, values, etc.

That being said, I exclusively BF my 3 kids and all of them are perfectly behaved geniuses who were never sick a day in their lives. So there ya go Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 8/17/10 11:57 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

DD #1 was EBF. I weaned her at 11mos. She has both food and environmental allergies.

DD#2 was also EBF, weaned at 14 months. No allergies.

We'll see about DS.Chat Icon

ETA: both caught colds at daycare just as easily as any other child. one thing that i noticed is we had zero ear infections in both girls. Mads got her very first ear infection when she was almost 3.

That said, my SIL's boys were both BFed to at least 8 months and both get ear infections quite frequntly.

Message edited 2010-08-18 02:14:33.150000.

Posted 8/18/10 2:11 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

From what I have seen, if a baby is very sick, BM does wonders.

For babies born healthy, and babies who don't get sick to often, it doesn't seem to matter either way from the babies I watched grow up.

eta: the studies that show long term effect on babies health are very vague. But there are also studies that show long term effect on mothers health. It seams that BF is really really good for womens health.
Heart Disease and Cancer, for some reason are at a much lower rate in women that BF. There are many other benefits to the mother.



Message edited 2010-08-18 06:51:22.463000.

Posted 8/18/10 6:43 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I breastfeed both children until 11 months & 8 months.

I don't see a difference between them & formula fed babies. One is sicker than most peers. One is more intelligent than most peers. I don't think breastfeeding made a difference.

But it was certainly a lot less expensive & helped me shed the babyweight fasterChat Icon

Posted 8/18/10 6:47 AM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

Personally I don't see this to hold true irl. DS was FF and in daycare and aside from the occassional cold was never sick and he is the smartest child I ever met Chat Icon

My brothers and I were all FF my oldest brother hated school and never did well, my middle brother was very smart and always did well without trying, I did good in school,buthad to put some effort in and none of us were sick a lot growing up. My twin nieces get straight A's - FF. My step nieces (2 of them)plus one biological all FF, all get straights A's.

My friends kids all EBF for a long time oldest very smart, middle works at it, youngest very smart.

Posted 8/18/10 6:48 AM
 

conigs25
So in love with this kid!

Member since 5/06

11197 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

Just using real life stuff i know which could mean SQUAT but here goes:

My DH was EBF for 1 yr and i was FF. I have been w/ him for almost 10 yrs and i have NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER seen him sick. He has never had a cold, an ear infection, NOTHING.

I on the other hand, get at LEAST 2 ear infections a yr, MANY colds and others.

Additionally, he was EXTREMELY successful in school. I on the other hand, EHHH

Posted 8/18/10 7:26 AM
 

sleepie76
enjoying every minute

Member since 12/07

3881 total posts

Name:

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

One thing I found interesting with DD, is she started daycare at 4 months and was EBF until 8 months.

The doctor & everyone warned me she will get sick often the first year.
She's never been sick, not once.
I find that weird and wonder if it has to do with the breastfeeding.

That said, my sister EBF all 4 of her children for 1 year. The middle child is allergic to EVERYTHING.

So I dont think it's the heal all they sell it as.

I did it because they say it's the best. Honestly, I didn't really find it a bonding experience. I didnt enjoy having my boobs always hanging out or someone attached to them all day long. I felt like something out of national geographic some days. I think FF is much easier.

Message edited 2010-08-18 07:34:31.830000.

Posted 8/18/10 7:31 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I am a believer that in general, BF babies are healthier at the time that they are being nursed. I don't know about later on.

I come from a huge family of non BF'ers. Ear infections, stomach viruses, flu seem to go around.

For Josh, he had roseola once and a fever once. No ear infections or runny nose. no loose stools. Then the asthma.
Thanks to facebook, I can see that almost every little boy on dh's side of the family has asthma. They start there treatments really young though, before 1.

I weaned at 18 mos. Josh had his first treatment at 18 mos. 5 days after weaning, never a respiratory issue, in distress in a hospital for days. Maybe nothing to do with each other, but I just don't think so.

My mom's group, mainly BF'ers, also never really speak of ear infections either.

Aside from everything else...I think it is incredible how it lowers our cancer rates. In the hospital, when nursing, feeling your body contract...that to me is enough to know that this is meant to be.

I am so happy that I bf since both kids were born with milk soy allergies. I could just alter my diet. I have no idea what is in milk free soy free formula. But I know exactly what is in my BM.

As far as smarter...yes it does make them smarter.
Jessie will be nursed till 2.Chat Icon BF children are so much more likely to become BF adults. To make free food, well yeah, that is crazy smart!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I don't really buy into that smarter business at all. I think every kid is gifted in their own way. It might not be on paper from a test, but their mind will excel somewhere else along the path.

eta: my 5.5 month old is dragged along everywhere! 2 playdates yesterday...she had a croup sounding cough one night...other then that, never even a runny nose yet.

Message edited 2010-08-18 07:52:52.250000.

Posted 8/18/10 7:51 AM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I don't think there is a diffference in intelligence or health - my mom bf me for 8 months and i have terrible allergies and i am sick a decent amount

my dh was bf for 2 years and he has some allergies but not sick often but when he is watch out

my ds is 10.5 months and i bf him - i do it more for me then him - i have a history of breast cancer so i wanted to lower my risk, safe money, and i hate washing bottle - so much easier in the middle of the night

Posted 8/18/10 8:52 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I was formula fed and had the constitution of an iron horse as a child. I NEVER got sick. my sister, also FF had continuous extremely high fevers of over 105.

to be honest, no one in my family breast fed and no one i really know did either, so I have nothing to compare it to.

I do know that my son has only had one or two slight colds since he's been born, even when I have been fairly ill and I have to credit that to the antibodies I am producing.

but as far as intelligence...I am not so sure. I think there has to be more to it.

and I think the mother's diet has to come into play as well. if you are a heatly eater and transfer those nutrients to your milk and to the child, combining that with the idea that BM is specifically designed for the needs of the child, I'd have to say regardless of IQ points and what not, it has to be better.

I mean, everything has a low, an average, and a high.

so while I don't think bf can take an "average" baby into the "high" catergory, I do think that all things considered, it can provide just a little bit more, and that is why I do it.

Posted 8/18/10 9:28 AM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

Honestly I don't think you can really say either way - b/c if you BF you can't say what they WOULD have been like if you formula fed and the reverse holds true too. There are so many variables - some people are just PRONE to be sick more often or have more allergies - so who is to say if a child is sick more often OR has say 3 food allergies that they wouldn't have been EVEN sicker or had say 5 food allergies if you hadn't BF.

I can't say if my girls are more intelligent or the same b.c I BF - but I will say that DD#2 has almost never been sick and DD#1 went her entire 1st year without getting sick - but once I stopped in the next few months she caught Roseola, Stomach flu and coxsackies. But then was healthy for almost another year. So maybe BFing DID help her - or she maybe just had bad luck.

I often hear kids who were in daycare are sick less often than kids who had SAHMs- but I know kids who were SAH kids who are almost never sick and others who attended daycare who were sick frequently.

Posted 8/18/10 9:31 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

My real life experience only dealing with immune systems:

All of my family's children, my cousins were formula fed, we are all healthy, no issues. Except, my aunt that has 6 children. She breastfed them all. 3 have ADD, 1 has diabetes, 1 has asthma, and the last baby has a hearing problem that causes her not to be able to be understood when she speaks, she is 5. ALL of her kids are constantly sick and have colds.

My kids are FF, and DS has had 1 cold in his 2 years on earth when he was 6 weeks old-but it was winter.

So, I have no problem giving my children formula, at all!

eta: For intelligence wise, my siblings and cousins for the most part were A and B students, some of my aunts kids go to summer school because they aren't passing class.

Message edited 2010-08-18 09:44:35.333000.

Posted 8/18/10 9:39 AM
 

summerBaby10
let's be nice

Member since 9/07

10208 total posts

Name:
Wifey

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I also don't really think you can accurately compare the two. I think it just comes down to who the child is & their genes.

I was FF & as a kid, I was never sick & it's the same now that I am an adult.
My brother was also FF & always sick as a dog.

In fact, when I was pregnant last winter during all of the flu craze, I opted out of getting the flu & swine flu vaccine because I was confident in my own immune system. I rode the lirr & bus everyday & sat next to sick people coughing & sneezing. Never even caught a sniffle, thank goodness.

Message edited 2010-08-18 09:56:42.293000.

Posted 8/18/10 9:55 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

My brother was BF
I was FF

My brother was/is CONSTANTLY sick. I used to be jealous how much time he used to get to spend at home Chat Icon They thought taking his tonsils out would help at one point, but it didn't. He catches EVERYTHING, anything. He even got the danged swine flu. He's like a walking petri dish waiting for the next strain to be tested.

I still only get sick once every two years ago so for about a week at tops. I do have other health issues to be sure, but most were caused by how I've lived my life (bad eating habits or physical trama). ETA, I never take the flu shot and I never get 'what's going around'.

Brother dropped out of HS but had a very high IQ. He was just lazy. He did however have to work for grade when he wanted them. Altho he quickly got his GED and Associates.

I graduated HS with honors and extra science/math. I'm still Phi Theta Kappa for College (I finally started to go back) But not to be rude or down talk my dear dear brother, he is not academically inclined. He is however much more musically inclined that I am. He can play literally dozens of instruments, where as I read non-stop and can memorize words, works and theories faster. I'm the problem solver he is the one that dresses up the problem with music to make it look less bad while not actually resolving it. haha

AJ was BF for 11 days then FF. I don't think it makes THAT big of a difference. I think its a rude and stupid, even ignorant, assumption to say BF are 'more intelligent' than their FF counter parts. Too many factors come into play. Where they are raised, how they are raised, what's available to them, etc.

I think BF is great and if you can do it, good for you. I wanted to BF because it was FREE! haha But I agree with another poster. Science has made FF so much more than just a 'substitute' to BF.

It upsets me that we are under so much pressure to BF. Not only are you pitied if you can't but its almost required that it be a medical reason why you can't, instead of a choice.

I don't think they could really have a control group that could accurately gauge life long intelligence or life long constitution.

That said, I say again that I think BF is great but I wish the pressure wasn't so high to do so.

Then again,........ what do I know? I'm FF! Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-08-18 10:07:47.850000.

Posted 8/18/10 10:06 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: BF vs. Formula IRL

I have 2 girlfriends, they have 4 children each, they both BF all of their children for a minimum of 6 months (and as much as a year).

One mom has very healthy kids who have never been really sick.

The other mom has kids who are sick ALL.THE.TIME. Pneumonia, hospitalizations, ear infections, failure to thrive... you name it, these kids probably had it.

Each of these moms have a DD the same age as my FF DD... my DD is bigger, stronger and healthier than the one who always has sick kids. All 3 of the girls are bright and appear to be advanced. I don't think BF or FF made a difference.

Message edited 2010-08-18 10:09:30.960000.

Posted 8/18/10 10:09 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Store Brand Formula? Denisemang 8/16/05 12 Parenting
Formula Coupons up for grabs MM2004 8/14/05 0 Parenting
Cheapest place to buy formula MM2004 8/4/05 24 Parenting
Can you buy formula in cases online? -Laurie- 7/24/05 6 Parenting
BTDT Moms: Powder vs. Ready-to-use formula steph4777 7/5/05 10 Parenting
Formula question... MommaG 6/1/05 3 Parenting