Banning Bake Sales?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by racheK

Posted by Linda1003

A bit off topic but if these schools are SOOO concerned with the obseity rate and health of children.. how about they start in their OWN cafeterias!!!

The school lunches are HORRIBLE in most schools in this country!! Start there and THEN ban your precious bake sales!!

SUCH HYPOCRITES!!!!!(the schools i mean) Chat Icon Chat Icon



I am not a parent but I do participate in a lunchtime reading program in a nearby NYC public school. The third-grader I read to weekly has one choice of lunch each day (I go on Mondays) and she either has Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers (very greasy), or a cheeseburger. Really???? I agree, school lunches need to change drastically!



ITS' REALLY SAD!! and my dacare tried to do healthy lunches.. but to get quick and mass product.. she cant find a turkey burger patty that will work for the school.. Chat Icon

Posted 5/8/12 12:59 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

liadorbs
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

1221 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by SnickNNick

Posted by Beth


plus the whole clean kitchen thing grosses me out- my Mom was a teacher and she never ate what parents baked for this reason



So do you also not eat anything anyone else bakes? For example, if someone brought cookies into work? Just wondering.

...



I don't eat anything home-made unless I know EXACTLY where they came from and I totally trust the person.

(And I'm a big baker too, I just brought cupcakes in to work this morning.)



Posted 5/8/12 1:02 PM
 

JP826
=)

Member since 9/06

10903 total posts

Name:
Me!! All about ME!

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

They want to ban bake sales? How about they ban the overpriced candy sales they send my kid home with. The more expensive candy they sell, the better the prize they get. What message is THAT sending?

Posted 5/8/12 1:14 PM
 

dj13
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

311 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

The school district that I work in no longer has bake sales due to the rise of peanut allergies. I think that is why a lot of districts stopped them.

Posted 5/8/12 1:14 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

I don't think having a treat once in a while is a big deal. I think the whole systems and everyone involved needs to check what they are doing - schools/parents/doctors and friends.

DS is only 4. His daycare gives lunch. Its usually kid friendly food prepared by a deli/pizza place. He has sandwiches and pasta type.

I send him in with fruit for his AM snack and something "junkier" for his PM snack, usually fruit snacks or gold fish.

One parent sent her daughter in with a fully lunch - pop tarts, oreo cookies and potatoe chips. I don't think that is healthy at all. The teachers commented how unhealthy it was and they were going to talk to the parents - not sure what came of it.

I will say that DS would rather have, and on many occassions has, had fruit insted of cake, including his own birthday party.

It needs to start at home and be followed thru at school and it needs to start young.

Posted 5/8/12 1:16 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by lilqtny

I am glad they are banned. I would not be comfortable with my children, if I had any, buying something prepared in possible unclean conditions in somebody elses home.

Also, childhood obesity is out of control and while there are other ways to attack it, I think we need to attack it in every way we can.



This is so ridiculous. As if a bake sale once in a while is going to make your child obese. There is just no personal accountability anymore and people wonder why kids today don't feel accountable for their actions when they do something wrong.

As for the comment about eating something prepared in someone's house - have you heard about some of the things that go on in restaurants? Nasty stuff sometimes, even in finer establishments as hard as that can be for some to believe.

If you don't want it, don't eat it and if you don't want your kid to eat it, ask them not to. This is just as ridiculous as trying to ban the ice-cream truck.

Posted 5/8/12 1:28 PM
 

HeyJude
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

820 total posts

Name:
p

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

It is more scary than ridiculous to me, Big Brother stepping in, acting like they know best.

How about telling your kids no-don't buy anything. Don't want to participate, then don't send your kid in with money.

For people who don't eat anything prepared by others, do you eat out at restaurants? I have worked in the food industry, let me tell you-it is not a sterile environment!

Posted 5/8/12 1:31 PM
 

DumpsterBaby
My compass when I'm lost

Member since 5/11

2210 total posts

Name:
My anchor when I get tossed

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by DirtyBlonde

This isn't going to do anything for lowering the rates of childhood obesity.

Schools will ban bake sales but how many serve lunches devoid of nutrition (pizza's a vegetable y'all!!), have soda in vending machines and have reduced or nearly no physical education program?

Chat Icon



Yup.

Posted 5/8/12 1:35 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Doesn't bother me. I'm sure they'll find another way to make my kid participate in begging for money.

Posted 5/8/12 1:43 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Childhood obesity is clearly a big problem.

Bake sales aren't the cause of childhood obesity.

Banning bake sales won't do a think to help kids learn about nutrition.

I'd rather see a lesson taught on nutrition, including how having "treats" in moderation is ok (pigging out is not), and having a bake sale where each kid can buy and eat one treat, and maybe buy one to take home for family to share that night.

And then the next month, or however often something special is done, I'd like to see a field trip to a farmer's market where they learn about different fruits and veggies, and how they help your body, etc.

Parents who monitor this stuff won't have a kid spending their whole allowance on brownies at a bake sale and eating them in secret. Parents who dont care problem already have 10 cookies in their kid's lunchbox.

As for the cleanliness factor--that's person by person. I can't go around living in a bubble. I'm grossed out by many things that have to do with food/food preparation, but I don't change what I do. (for the most part...I do avoid certain places I think are really dirty.) Almost every place of food prep has a bit of a gross factor or something I can't control. I don't think one cupcake from a bake sale is gonna make me or my kid really sick.

Posted 5/8/12 1:45 PM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Fine with me. I already told my DD not to eat other people's lunch or baked goods except what I sent or a select group of kids goodies. Not everyone is clean. Also I want her eating healthy so Im all for it.

Posted 5/8/12 1:47 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Linda1003

A bit off topic but if these schools are SOOO concerned with the obseity rate and health of children.. how about they start in their OWN cafeterias!!!

The school lunches are HORRIBLE in most schools in this country!! Start there and THEN ban your precious bake sales!!

SUCH HYPOCRITES!!!!!(the schools i mean) Chat Icon Chat Icon



My school has a snack shop and sell crap!!!!! Cookies, chips etc and my kids will buy 3 bags (they should at least be limited) the food is ehhh some of it is not the best (mozzarella sticks for example) This is NYC

To add Im not against the banning of bake sales for several reasons
1. Allergies
2. I can not trust where the food was made and by who (did they wash hands etc) I personally will not eat anything a parent has made.
3. Let the parents decide what their kid eats for lunch. They do not need addition crap. Many kids will go and buy the cupcake and eat that before they eat their lunch. I see my students do it all the time!!

Posted 5/8/12 1:48 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Beth

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lilqtny

I am glad they are banned. I would not be comfortable with my children, if I had any, buying something prepared in possible unclean conditions in somebody elses home.

Also, childhood obesity is out of control and while there are other ways to attack it, I think we need to attack it in every way we can.



I don't mean to single you out, but as a parent, couldn't you just tell your child no, you can't buy something at the bake sale, I'll pack you a snack? I just don't know since when it is the school's job to monitor a child's weight/health.

.



I am not parent- but I was a kid...and I can't see how this wouldn't work

I kind of agree with banning bake sale- childhood obesity is way out of control, kids have allergies and are getting type 2 diabetes in record numbers

we have to draw the line somewhere-

plus the whole clean kitchen thing grosses me out- my Mom was a teacher and she never ate what parents baked for this reason



I agree with Beth on all points. Especially the grossness factor. Who knows if these people washed their hands before baking? who knows that their kitchen is clean? the thought of it grosses me out and depending on the grade, telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.

Posted 5/8/12 1:55 PM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by DirtyBlonde

This isn't going to do anything for lowering the rates of childhood obesity.

Schools will ban bake sales but how many serve lunches devoid of nutrition (pizza's a vegetable y'all!!), have soda in vending machines and have reduced or nearly no physical education program?

Chat Icon



Exactly...a ton of crap in vending machines and school stores don't just sell clothes and books...they also sell ice cream, snickers and doritos!!

Posted 5/8/12 1:59 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

I don't care either way. We only have like 4 per year and they are for after school activities. (dances, bingo night, etc..)

Posted 5/8/12 2:02 PM
 

ArmyOfBabies
Growing older but not up

Member since 7/07

4427 total posts

Name:
Jeri

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Sorry, but bakesale cupcakes don't cause obese children. The parents cause obese children by what they feed them at home.

A cupcake at school is probably not the worst thing they'll eat. Whatever they are getting at home is most likely waaaay worse.

Also it's not just what they're eating. Kids these days don't stay out running around with their friends like we did when we were kids.

Why should everyone else be punished, essentially, for some people's lazy parenting.

Down with the ban on bakesales!!!!

Posted 5/8/12 2:12 PM
 

SHOPAHOLIC
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1712 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by lululu

Posted by Beth

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lilqtny

I am glad they are banned. I would not be comfortable with my children, if I had any, buying something prepared in possible unclean conditions in somebody elses home.

Also, childhood obesity is out of control and while there are other ways to attack it, I think we need to attack it in every way we can.



I don't mean to single you out, but as a parent, couldn't you just tell your child no, you can't buy something at the bake sale, I'll pack you a snack? I just don't know since when it is the school's job to monitor a child's weight/health.

.



I am not parent- but I was a kid...and I can't see how this wouldn't work

I kind of agree with banning bake sale- childhood obesity is way out of control, kids have allergies and are getting type 2 diabetes in record numbers

we have to draw the line somewhere-

plus the whole clean kitchen thing grosses me out- my Mom was a teacher and she never ate what parents baked for this reason



I agree with Beth on all points. Especially the grossness factor. Who knows if these people washed their hands before baking? who knows that their kitchen is clean? the thought of it grosses me out and depending on the grade, telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



So if your child is in school and someone brings cupcakes in for a birthday, you tell your kids not to take one? Really?

Do you not ever go out to eat? I'm sure there are a lot more unsanitary things going on in restaurant kitchens.

Posted 5/8/12 2:24 PM
 

ArmyOfBabies
Growing older but not up

Member since 7/07

4427 total posts

Name:
Jeri

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by SHOPAHOLIC

Posted by lululu

Posted by Beth

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lilqtny

I am glad they are banned. I would not be comfortable with my children, if I had any, buying something prepared in possible unclean conditions in somebody elses home.

Also, childhood obesity is out of control and while there are other ways to attack it, I think we need to attack it in every way we can.



I don't mean to single you out, but as a parent, couldn't you just tell your child no, you can't buy something at the bake sale, I'll pack you a snack? I just don't know since when it is the school's job to monitor a child's weight/health.

.



I am not parent- but I was a kid...and I can't see how this wouldn't work

I kind of agree with banning bake sale- childhood obesity is way out of control, kids have allergies and are getting type 2 diabetes in record numbers

we have to draw the line somewhere-

plus the whole clean kitchen thing grosses me out- my Mom was a teacher and she never ate what parents baked for this reason



I agree with Beth on all points. Especially the grossness factor. Who knows if these people washed their hands before baking? who knows that their kitchen is clean? the thought of it grosses me out and depending on the grade, telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



So if your child is in school and someone brings cupcakes in for a birthday, you tell your kids not to take one? Really?

Do you not ever go out to eat? I'm sure there are a lot more unsanitary things going on in restaurant kitchens.



I agree. I've worked in restaurants and those kitchens (and the people working in them) are definitely worse than any personal kitchen I've ever seen.

ETA Spelling

Message edited 2012-05-08 14:29:28.727000.

Posted 5/8/12 2:28 PM
 

AScottWolf
I <3 our squish!

Member since 11/10

2237 total posts

Name:
Adriana

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

eh.. I'm kind of in the middle of this.

One one hand, I can see a school banning bake sales because of allergy reasons and to try to make a whole overhaul of their nutrition trends.

But, I agree that it's not going to stop or prevent childhood obesity. But like everyone else said, things need to start at home. Parents know their kids better then teachers, and if they teach them good eating habits "for them" then it will be fine.

I remember my kindergarden teacher yelling at me when I was little (back in the 80's) because I brought in cookies (5) as a snack instead of something healthy. She didn't allow me to eat them and I came home and told my mom who proceeded to go up to the school and tear my teacher a new one. I was a VERY picky eater and my mom's reasoning was, "It's better to have my daughter eat 5 cookies then eat nothing at all." FOR ME, that's what I had to do to maintain my weight when I was little. It shouldn't be the teachers or administrators decision what I eat.

If your kid's school is having a bake sale great! Just teach your kid a little control. This is the same thing as those parents in Brooklyn who wanted to ban Mr. Softie from their area. Who does that! It's Mr. Softie! I still jump inside when I hear his music!! lol

Posted 5/8/12 2:29 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by lululu

telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



Well, that's exactly my point. You can't always get what you want in life and kids need to learn that. Just because Jane got a cupcake, does not mean YOU get a cupcake. That's the exact reason why I feel parents need to step in and teach their child moderation.

Posted 5/8/12 2:30 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lululu

telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



Well, that's exactly my point. You can't always get what you want in life and kids need to learn that. Just because Jane got a cupcake, does not mean YOU get a cupcake. That's the exact reason why I feel parents need to step in and teach their child moderation.



Are you a parent yet? Moderation is one thing...but when it's a special treat that all the kids are eating and you tell your child NO.. not gonna work and it's NOT b/c the parent isn't teaching the child Moderation. It's a special treat...

Posted 5/8/12 2:38 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lululu

telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



Well, that's exactly my point. You can't always get what you want in life and kids need to learn that. Just because Jane got a cupcake, does not mean YOU get a cupcake. That's the exact reason why I feel parents need to step in and teach their child moderation.



Are you a parent yet? Moderation is one thing...but when it's a special treat that all the kids are eating and you tell your child NO.. not gonna work and it's NOT b/c the parent isn't teaching the child Moderation. It's a special treat...



No, I'm not a parent- that doesn't mean I've never told a child who was in my care no. A special treat once in awhile IS moderation. That's my point. And if you didn't want to them to purchase from the bake sale, then you don't send them in with money or you send them in with a special treat from your own home. There's always a compromise.

My other issue is if you take away all the bad choices and leave kids only the good stuff, that does not teach them to take responsibility for their actions. When they grow up, they'll just over indulge because finally they'll have the freedom to have all the things they were once denied at their fingertips. Things like this will just lead to a generation of obese adults who indulge in instant gratification at every turn.

ETA: Now if we're talking allergy reasons, that I might be able to understand. But because parents don't want to have to tell their kids no? Absolutely not.

Message edited 2012-05-08 14:44:37.847000.

Posted 5/8/12 2:42 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by AScottWolf

eh.. I'm kind of in the middle of this.

One one hand, I can see a school banning bake sales because of allergy reasons and to try to make a whole overhaul of their nutrition trends.

But, I agree that it's not going to stop or prevent childhood obesity. But like everyone else said, things need to start at home. Parents know their kids better then teachers, and if they teach them good eating habits "for them" then it will be fine.



This I agree with.

Posted 5/8/12 2:42 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lululu

telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



Well, that's exactly my point. You can't always get what you want in life and kids need to learn that. Just because Jane got a cupcake, does not mean YOU get a cupcake. That's the exact reason why I feel parents need to step in and teach their child moderation.



Are you a parent yet? Moderation is one thing...but when it's a special treat that all the kids are eating and you tell your child NO.. not gonna work and it's NOT b/c the parent isn't teaching the child Moderation. It's a special treat...



No, I'm not a parent- that doesn't mean I've never told a child who was in my care no. A special treat once in awhile IS moderation. That's my point. And if you didn't want to them to purchase from the bake sale, then you don't send them in with money or you send them in with a special treat from your own home. There's always a compromise.

My other issue is if you take away all the bad choices and leave kids only the good stuff, that does not teach them to take responsibility for their actions. When they grow up, they'll just over indulge because finally they'll have the freedom to have all the things they were once denied at their fingertips. Things like this will just lead to a generation of obese adults who indulge in instant gratification at every turn.

ETA: Now if we're talking allergy reasons, that I might be able to understand. But because parents don't want to have to tell their kids no? Absolutely not.



I absolutely agree with everything you are saying.. just trying to tell a 2 year old that he cant have a cupcake that everyone else is having.. when in fact it's a treat that he rarely gets to have anyway.. is not easy NOR is it necessary.. KWIM.

Posted 5/8/12 2:49 PM
 

moonmist09
Thank you, St. Gerard!

Member since 2/11

5043 total posts

Name:
Antonella

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

growing up, we went to Catholic School and I think we only ever had a bake sale once.

Growing up, my mom would never let me eat anything from anyone else's home. It kind of stuck with me because even now, i won't eat anything any else brings in. I'm a big baker but i don't bring anything in either because i don't know if people will feel the same way i do.

I totally agree with the previous posts that some restaurants are dirtier than any personal kitchen. However, especially now-a-days with all of these establishments being given a grade, it reassures us into thinking the restaurant is cleaner. I don't think any of us actually go to a restaurant to eat and think about how dirty the kitchen is. Doesn't make this ok or make the earlier line of thinking better but it just is what it is with me...

I don't think banning a bake sale every so often will help children lose weight or will help the fight with obesity and its related diseases. My mom works ina grade school pucliv school in Queens and they removed all of the vending machines in that particular school. I remember hearing that in my old catholic high school, they also removed the vending machines. not sure if this is something that is done selectively or not.

However, like everyone else has said, Basic parenting begins at home. If your child is overweight, don't point a finger at the school cafeteria because in all liklihood, your not feeding your child correctly at home.

Posted 5/8/12 2:53 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Law banning retail sales of puppies and kittens JessInCA 2/16/10 3 Pets
cross post: ADT door to door sales rose825 7/18/05 5 Home
ADT door to door sales rose825 7/18/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
What stores are having good sales right now?? neenie 7/15/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
Sales Account Executive Position Jennifer 7/9/05 1 Career
does anyone work in financial sales? Tany 6/30/05 0 Families Helping Families ™