Banning Bake Sales?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

I don't think it has to do with obesity as much as with the potential liability of allergens in those baked goods.

There is absolutely no way to regulate what is nut (or dairy) free and what isn't. And even if the mix used is nut-free, who's to say it didn't touch something else in the kitchen?

Posted 5/8/12 2:57 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Well... You all know how I feel about AJ eating crap. So I'm ok with this.

Our old daycare would not serve anything homemade. It had to be store bought due to contamination.

This school frowns upon unhealthy treats for celebration of life events but leaves it to the teacher's decision.

We have bake sales at our annual Fall festival and I let AJ have something there. I don't mind her eating sugary stuff just not every day or on a regular basis.

I know some moms think I'm 'mean' or just roll their eyes when I say we have no chocolate in the house, no cookies, no chips, no candy. But ya know what? She doesnt care. We've set up the habit. Her 'treat' is a tortilla (not my favorite considering...) but its not a candy bar or a cupcake. We all pick our battles.

I know obesity is an issue. I think it starts at home. You teach your children how to enjoy foods that happen to be healthy for them. Not to eat foods BECAUSE they are healthy but because they are fun, and yummy. But that's JMHO.

We raise money on silent auctions and other ways. We don't need cookies to make money for the PTA but if we do we limit it to once a year, outside school hours.

To tell a kid "no you can't have anything at the bake sale at school today" is a bit harsh. I mean you don't HAVE to have a cupcake at your office bake sale but to say you CANT have one is another story. If I can't have one, why bring them in? I have no problem with her buying one if its there. As far as cleanliness goes, again home cooked has its issues but I ate worse I'm sure. Gotta live and learn.

Posted 5/8/12 3:02 PM
 

LiveItUp
Love my babies!

Member since 8/11

4096 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

The district I used to work in has not allowed home baked goods for years, and I'm sure most districts on LI are the same. It's not so much about preventing obesity as it is about ensuring food safety and cleanliness. Even for student's birthdays, they may bring cupcakes or donuts if they want to, but they must be store bought. It's a matter of making sure that the food was prepared safely and hygienically. It's also because many students today have allergies to certain ingredients, so the teacher can just read the ingredients on the box to make sure they are safe for students with allergies.

Posted 5/8/12 3:08 PM
 

SHOPAHOLIC
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1712 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by LiveItUp

The district I used to work in has not allowed home baked goods for years, and I'm sure most districts on LI are the same. It's not so much about preventing obesity as it is about ensuring food safety and cleanliness. Even for student's birthdays, they may bring cupcakes or donuts if they want to, but they must be store bought. It's a matter of making sure that the food was prepared safely and hygienically. It's also because many students today have allergies to certain ingredients, so the teacher can just read the ingredients on the box to make sure they are safe for students with allergies.




I get why they might do this with allergies, but everything else is crazy to me. There is no way to insure the cleanliness of the store where the items are being bought
For example I was at Dunkin Donuts recently and saw an exterminator crouched down SPRAYING FOR BUGS by the cashiers feet. I ran out of there as fast as I could but people were just standing in line oblivious to what was going on.
Also store bought cupcakes have soooooooooooooo many preservatives so that they last longer. It is so much more unhealthy then most things baked at home IMHO. Chat Icon

Posted 5/8/12 3:15 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lululu

telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



Well, that's exactly my point. You can't always get what you want in life and kids need to learn that. Just because Jane got a cupcake, does not mean YOU get a cupcake. That's the exact reason why I feel parents need to step in and teach their child moderation.



Are you a parent yet? Moderation is one thing...but when it's a special treat that all the kids are eating and you tell your child NO.. not gonna work and it's NOT b/c the parent isn't teaching the child Moderation. It's a special treat...



No, I'm not a parent- that doesn't mean I've never told a child who was in my care no. A special treat once in awhile IS moderation. That's my point. And if you didn't want to them to purchase from the bake sale, then you don't send them in with money or you send them in with a special treat from your own home. There's always a compromise.

My other issue is if you take away all the bad choices and leave kids only the good stuff, that does not teach them to take responsibility for their actions. When they grow up, they'll just over indulge because finally they'll have the freedom to have all the things they were once denied at their fingertips. Things like this will just lead to a generation of obese adults who indulge in instant gratification at every turn.

ETA: Now if we're talking allergy reasons, that I might be able to understand. But because parents don't want to have to tell their kids no? Absolutely not.



I absolutely agree with everything you are saying.. just trying to tell a 2 year old that he cant have a cupcake that everyone else is having.. when in fact it's a treat that he rarely gets to have anyway.. is not easy NOR is it necessary.. KWIM.



Why is there a 2 year old at school? (And carrying cash?)

And I guess we just have to agree to disagree because I do agree that it's NOT easy to tell a child no, but it is necessary sometimes.

Message edited 2012-05-08 15:20:51.990000.

Posted 5/8/12 3:20 PM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Schools have vending machines, stores and bake sales. Kids are in school most of the day so yes they most likely eat some form of junk on occasion. However, eliminating bake sales from school is not going to eliminate obesity. Healthy eating habits begin and end at home. So whichever way you slice it, it's the role of the parent and not School Administration.

Posted 5/8/12 3:40 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by lululu

telling a child that they are not allowed to buy something that all the other kids are might not work.



Well, that's exactly my point. You can't always get what you want in life and kids need to learn that. Just because Jane got a cupcake, does not mean YOU get a cupcake. That's the exact reason why I feel parents need to step in and teach their child moderation.



Are you a parent yet? Moderation is one thing...but when it's a special treat that all the kids are eating and you tell your child NO.. not gonna work and it's NOT b/c the parent isn't teaching the child Moderation. It's a special treat...



No, I'm not a parent- that doesn't mean I've never told a child who was in my care no. A special treat once in awhile IS moderation. That's my point. And if you didn't want to them to purchase from the bake sale, then you don't send them in with money or you send them in with a special treat from your own home. There's always a compromise.

My other issue is if you take away all the bad choices and leave kids only the good stuff, that does not teach them to take responsibility for their actions. When they grow up, they'll just over indulge because finally they'll have the freedom to have all the things they were once denied at their fingertips. Things like this will just lead to a generation of obese adults who indulge in instant gratification at every turn.

ETA: Now if we're talking allergy reasons, that I might be able to understand. But because parents don't want to have to tell their kids no? Absolutely not.



I absolutely agree with everything you are saying.. just trying to tell a 2 year old that he cant have a cupcake that everyone else is having.. when in fact it's a treat that he rarely gets to have anyway.. is not easy NOR is it necessary.. KWIM.



Why is there a 2 year old at school? (And carrying cash?)

And I guess we just have to agree to disagree because I do agree that it's NOT easy to tell a child no, but it is necessary sometimes.

Daycare... and you just aren't understanding my point.. but that's ok...

Posted 5/8/12 3:41 PM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

They have not been allowed in my district for years. All NY districts are required to have a wellness plan. Ours specified how many calories, fat grams, sodium, ans sat. fat are allowed in food sold in schools. We were not able to sell home baked goods but could sell chips, rice crispy treats, fruit snacks, etc if they met the guidelines. Sometimes they would overlook it for a bake sale that was raising money for charity. But honestly, there are a ton of options within the limits as long as the serving size is small enough.Chat Icon

Posted 5/8/12 3:41 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

I don't care about the stuff at a bake sale being fattening- but I care more about the fact that it skeeves the SHIT out of me to eat food that other people who I do not know made.
I am no clean freak by any stretch of the imagination...but I just picture people licking their fingers as they frost something, or sneezing on it, etc
Chat Icon

I'm all for junk food- just prepackaged please! Chat Icon

Posted 5/8/12 4:23 PM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by dj13

The school district that I work in no longer has bake sales due to the rise of peanut allergies. I think that is why a lot of districts stopped them.



See this is I think a part of it. There are so many children with bad food allergies that I can see that they don't want the liability. The fact is that things don't come with ingredients when they are made at home so there is a huge chance a child might have a reaction. Luckily for us DD doesn't have a severe allergy but she has a few - in her preschool the parent for the day brings snack most of the time when it is made the parent can't tell the parents of the allergy children what is in it. I think that is probably pretty common.

I don't think an occasional bake sale is the problem. The school lunches are so unhealthy AND then it seems that there are always kids selling those large candy bars all over the place. Maybe they should sell flowers or something non foodwise instead and worry about healthier lunches rather than an occasional bake sale.

Posted 5/8/12 5:01 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

I just have to say..................not sure why everyone (not directing this at anyone on here in particular) is making such a big deal about what is served in the schools. The thing is, we had the SAME EXACT cr@p food (pizza, nuggets, burgers, fries) being served when I was a kid and NOBODY was fat. There was the one token chubby kid in the class but 98% of kids in school were an average healthy weight. I remember in JHS, there were kids who ate nothing but french fries and chocolate chip cookies EVERY day and they were thin.

The problem is NOT the food, it's the LACK of activity that kids have nowadays. When I was a kid in the 80's/90's we were outside ALL OF THE TIME. Morning, noon, and night we were outside running around, climbing, riding bikes, skating, etc, etc. Kids were out and about everywhere in the neighborhood and everyone was ACTIVE so that it didn't matter so much that you had a crap lunch because you were burning three times as many calories as you ate anyway.

And before anyone carries on about how times are different and it's so unsafe "out there" and kids can't go out and play I *personally* 100% disagree.

The neighborhood I grew up in (North Massapequa/Seaford) hasn't changed much since I was a kid. The only difference today from yesterday is that we have more access to info. In the 80's you couldn't log on to your computer and type in "child molester" and see a map of where they all lived BUUUUT they were still out there. On every block, in every town. But we were still ALLOWED out to play and be ACTIVE. The key to being healthy is being active and if our kids are trapped inside all day they aren't moving as much as they should.

Aside from that, back "in the day" parents parented. Moms cooked dinners. There was no eating out every night or grabbing fast food. Parents regulated what their kids watched and how long they played video games for. Parents encouraged their kids to be active, to go outside and play. Parents didn't give in to their child's every need and desire. They set limits. They set boundaries. They parented. But today, I feel like there is SO much lazy parenting. So many parents don't want to be bothered being responsible for anything, they want to blame everyone else for the problems they create with their kids and then they want someone else to fix them too.

I find this day and age disappointing. I miss the "good old days". DH and I were raised the same way and we STRONGLY believe in "kickin it old school". My DD has (and will always have) limits, bedtimes, routines, and boundaries. She won't be allowed to help herself to snack after snack, she will be served dinner and if she doesn't like it.......oh well, that's all she's getting, she will be limited on the computer and video games, she will be told NO and taught that life isn't fair (you don't always get your way or get what you want), and she will ALWAYS be encouraged to go outside and play and be a kid. She needs to move her body, to use her imagination, and to just be a kid! As a parent I feel like this is what she needs to be a healthy, happy, and productive child.

How my child turns out begins and ends with me. Simple as that. I won't ALLOW my DD to be a fat, lazy, cookie slobbering kid glued to the couch watching cr@p all day. It's just not happening.

Okay, rant over. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Again............this isn't directed at anyone on this thread. Just a general disgust with society as a whole. Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-05-08 17:34:23.897000.

Posted 5/8/12 5:31 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

I LOATH bakesales: they are nothing but trouble when they happen in school during school hours because someone always forgets to bring money, doesn't have enough money for what it is they really want or has a fight with someone who did have enough money to get what it was that THEY wanted but didn't have the money to buy.

I also really, really hate the idea of my children eating G'd knows what, made by G'd knows who G'd knows where...

So, I am all for banning those Bake Sales! I say ban them here in NY! saChat Icon

Posted 5/8/12 5:48 PM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Hofstra26



And before anyone carries on about how times are different and it's so unsafe "out there" and kids can't go out and play I *personally* 100% disagree.

The neighborhood I grew up in (North Massapequa/Seaford) hasn't changed much since I was a kid. The only difference today from yesterday is that we have more access to info. In the 80's you couldn't log on to your computer and type in "child molester" and see a map of where they all lived BUUUUT they were still out there. On every block, in every town.



YES!

I say this all the time.

Society hasn't suddenly become overcome with evil.

We just know so much more about the things that go on.

Years ago we were oblivious.

It's the Information Age, people! (Not directed at anyone in particular.)

(I also agree with the rest of what you said, but edited for space.)

Posted 5/8/12 7:07 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by DirtyBlonde

This isn't going to do anything for lowering the rates of childhood obesity.

Schools will ban bake sales but how many serve lunches devoid of nutrition (pizza's a vegetable y'all!!), have soda in vending machines and have reduced or nearly no physical education program?

Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Also soda is not in NYC schools but full sugar snapple is A OK!!!! Chat Icon

A kid does not get fat bc they buy a cupcake at the spring bake sale.

Allergies I can understand but to ban it for the purposes of the obesity epidemic is absurd. How about EDUCATING children and their parents on proper nutrition WITH the proceeds of the bake sale.

Posted 5/8/12 7:32 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Hofstra26

I just have to say..................not sure why everyone (not directing this at anyone on here in particular) is making such a big deal about what is served in the schools. The thing is, we had the SAME EXACT cr@p food (pizza, nuggets, burgers, fries) being served when I was a kid and NOBODY was fat. There was the one token chubby kid in the class but 98% of kids in school were an average healthy weight. I remember in JHS, there were kids who ate nothing but french fries and chocolate chip cookies EVERY day and they were thin.

The problem is NOT the food, it's the LACK of activity that kids have nowadays. When I was a kid in the 80's/90's we were outside ALL OF THE TIME. Morning, noon, and night we were outside running around, climbing, riding bikes, skating, etc, etc. Kids were out and about everywhere in the neighborhood and everyone was ACTIVE so that it didn't matter so much that you had a crap lunch because you were burning three times as many calories as you ate anyway.

And before anyone carries on about how times are different and it's so unsafe "out there" and kids can't go out and play I *personally* 100% disagree.

The neighborhood I grew up in (North Massapequa/Seaford) hasn't changed much since I was a kid. The only difference today from yesterday is that we have more access to info. In the 80's you couldn't log on to your computer and type in "child molester" and see a map of where they all lived BUUUUT they were still out there. On every block, in every town. But we were still ALLOWED out to play and be ACTIVE. The key to being healthy is being active and if our kids are trapped inside all day they aren't moving as much as they should.

Aside from that, back "in the day" parents parented. Moms cooked dinners. There was no eating out every night or grabbing fast food. Parents regulated what their kids watched and how long they played video games for. Parents encouraged their kids to be active, to go outside and play. Parents didn't give in to their child's every need and desire. They set limits. They set boundaries. They parented. But today, I feel like there is SO much lazy parenting. So many parents don't want to be bothered being responsible for anything, they want to blame everyone else for the problems they create with their kids and then they want someone else to fix them too.

I find this day and age disappointing. I miss the "good old days". DH and I were raised the same way and we STRONGLY believe in "kickin it old school". My DD has (and will always have) limits, bedtimes, routines, and boundaries. She won't be allowed to help herself to snack after snack, she will be served dinner and if she doesn't like it.......oh well, that's all she's getting, she will be limited on the computer and video games, she will be told NO and taught that life isn't fair (you don't always get your way or get what you want), and she will ALWAYS be encouraged to go outside and play and be a kid. She needs to move her body, to use her imagination, and to just be a kid! As a parent I feel like this is what she needs to be a healthy, happy, and productive child.

How my child turns out begins and ends with me. Simple as that. I won't ALLOW my DD to be a fat, lazy, cookie slobbering kid glued to the couch watching cr@p all day. It's just not happening.

Okay, rant over. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Again............this isn't directed at anyone on this thread. Just a general disgust with society as a whole. Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon ITA word for word. My husband & I have had this same conversation. We also plan to "kick it old school" when it comes to parenting.

Posted 5/8/12 7:55 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

I work at a high school and the clubs/teams were banned from having food sales during the day. It has NOTHING to do with cleanliness or obesity. It has to do with MONEY. Every dollar a kid spends on a brownie for the French club is a dollar they're not spending on lunch in the cafeteria. Our cafeteria sells made-to-order milkshakes and ice cream sundaes for lunch - starting 4th period at 9:30 AM, if I'm not mistaken. They ban bake sales during the school day but not after school. So they don't care about nutrition or healthy food... only about the money spent in the cafeteria.

Message edited 2012-05-08 20:16:47.460000.

Posted 5/8/12 8:13 PM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Hofstra26

I just have to say..................not sure why everyone (not directing this at anyone on here in particular) is making such a big deal about what is served in the schools. The thing is, we had the SAME EXACT cr@p food (pizza, nuggets, burgers, fries) being served when I was a kid and NOBODY was fat. There was the one token chubby kid in the class but 98% of kids in school were an average healthy weight. I remember in JHS, there were kids who ate nothing but french fries and chocolate chip cookies EVERY day and they were thin.

The problem is NOT the food, it's the LACK of activity that kids have nowadays. When I was a kid in the 80's/90's we were outside ALL OF THE TIME. Morning, noon, and night we were outside running around, climbing, riding bikes, skating, etc, etc. Kids were out and about everywhere in the neighborhood and everyone was ACTIVE so that it didn't matter so much that you had a crap lunch because you were burning three times as many calories as you ate anyway.




And before anyone carries on about how times are different and it's so unsafe "out there" and kids can't go out and play I *personally* 100% disagree.

The neighborhood I grew up in (North Massapequa/Seaford) hasn't changed much since I was a kid. The only difference today from yesterday is that we have more access to info. In the 80's you couldn't log on to your computer and type in "child molester" and see a map of where they all lived BUUUUT they were still out there. On every block, in every town. But we were still ALLOWED out to play and be ACTIVE. The key to being healthy is being active and if our kids are trapped inside all day they aren't moving as much as they should.

Aside from that, back "in the day" parents parented. Moms cooked dinners. There was no eating out every night or grabbing fast food. Parents regulated what their kids watched and how long they played video games for. Parents encouraged their kids to be active, to go outside and play. Parents didn't give in to their child's every need and desire. They set limits. They set boundaries. They parented. But today, I feel like there is SO much lazy parenting. So many parents don't want to be bothered being responsible for anything, they want to blame everyone else for the problems they create with their kids and then they want someone else to fix them too.

I find this day and age disappointing. I miss the "good old days". DH and I were raised the same way and we STRONGLY believe in "kickin it old school". My DD has (and will always have) limits, bedtimes, routines, and boundaries. She won't be allowed to help herself to snack after snack, she will be served dinner and if she doesn't like it.......oh well, that's all she's getting, she will be limited on the computer and video games, she will be told NO and taught that life isn't fair (you don't always get your way or get what you want), and she will ALWAYS be encouraged to go outside and play and be a kid. She needs to move her body, to use her imagination, and to just be a kid! As a parent I feel like this is what she needs to be a healthy, happy, and productive child.

How my child turns out begins and ends with me. Simple as that. I won't ALLOW my DD to be a fat, lazy, cookie slobbering kid glued to the couch watching cr@p all day. It's just not happening.

Okay, rant over. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Again............this isn't directed at anyone on this thread. Just a general disgust with society as a whole. Chat Icon




ITA 100%
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/8/12 8:21 PM
 

muffaboo
LIF Adult

Member since 12/10

3797 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

My district has a strict food policy. Bake sales are a huge no-no. Actually, food of any type is a no-no, besides lunch and snack time in lower grades.

Posted 5/8/12 8:39 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Bella01

Posted by rkl1130

I can see why they felt the need to ban bake sales - this country does have a huge overweight/obesity epidemic.

However, in many ways, I feel like doing something like this isn't really going to make a difference. I know I'll be flamed for this, but nutrition starts at home and proper eating habits are taught to kids. As a school, it is not their job to monitor kids' weight and I kinda find it unfair to those kids who don't have problems. I remember as a kid looking forward to bake sales and it makes me sad that my child might never know the fun it them.

I do completely understand where they are coming from but I also feel like we have to draw a line somewhere and next thing we know, there's going to mandatory weigh-in's everywhere.



I agree 100%. The parents should be accountable not the schools.



I like the old saying "it takes a village to raise a child".

Posted 5/8/12 8:51 PM
 

Babyaholic
Thankful

Member since 6/09

1459 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Hofstra26

I just have to say..................not sure why everyone (not directing this at anyone on here in particular) is making such a big deal about what is served in the schools. The thing is, we had the SAME EXACT cr@p food (pizza, nuggets, burgers, fries) being served when I was a kid and NOBODY was fat. There was the one token chubby kid in the class but 98% of kids in school were an average healthy weight. I remember in JHS, there were kids who ate nothing but french fries and chocolate chip cookies EVERY day and they were thin.

The problem is NOT the food, it's the LACK of activity that kids have nowadays. When I was a kid in the 80's/90's we were outside ALL OF THE TIME. Morning, noon, and night we were outside running around, climbing, riding bikes, skating, etc, etc. Kids were out and about everywhere in the neighborhood and everyone was ACTIVE so that it didn't matter so much that you had a crap lunch because you were burning three times as many calories as you ate anyway.

And before anyone carries on about how times are different and it's so unsafe "out there" and kids can't go out and play I *personally* 100% disagree.

The neighborhood I grew up in (North Massapequa/Seaford) hasn't changed much since I was a kid. The only difference today from yesterday is that we have more access to info. In the 80's you couldn't log on to your computer and type in "child molester" and see a map of where they all lived BUUUUT they were still out there. On every block, in every town. But we were still ALLOWED out to play and be ACTIVE. The key to being healthy is being active and if our kids are trapped inside all day they aren't moving as much as they should.

Aside from that, back "in the day" parents parented. Moms cooked dinners. There was no eating out every night or grabbing fast food. Parents regulated what their kids watched and how long they played video games for. Parents encouraged their kids to be active, to go outside and play. Parents didn't give in to their child's every need and desire. They set limits. They set boundaries. They parented. But today, I feel like there is SO much lazy parenting. So many parents don't want to be bothered being responsible for anything, they want to blame everyone else for the problems they create with their kids and then they want someone else to fix them too.

I find this day and age disappointing. I miss the "good old days". DH and I were raised the same way and we STRONGLY believe in "kickin it old school". My DD has (and will always have) limits, bedtimes, routines, and boundaries. She won't be allowed to help herself to snack after snack, she will be served dinner and if she doesn't like it.......oh well, that's all she's getting, she will be limited on the computer and video games, she will be told NO and taught that life isn't fair (you don't always get your way or get what you want), and she will ALWAYS be encouraged to go outside and play and be a kid. She needs to move her body, to use her imagination, and to just be a kid! As a parent I feel like this is what she needs to be a healthy, happy, and productive child.

How my child turns out begins and ends with me. Simple as that. I won't ALLOW my DD to be a fat, lazy, cookie slobbering kid glued to the couch watching cr@p all day. It's just not happening.




I agree.

Watch out. Big brother is taking over.

Posted 5/8/12 9:24 PM
 

LL514
LIF Adult

Member since 4/10

1901 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by DavaDay

I work at a high school and the clubs/teams were banned from having food sales during the day. It has NOTHING to do with cleanliness or obesity. It has to do with MONEY. Every dollar a kid spends on a brownie for the French club is a dollar they're not spending on lunch in the cafeteria. Our cafeteria sells made-to-order milkshakes and ice cream sundaes for lunch - starting 4th period at 9:30 AM, if I'm not mistaken. They ban bake sales during the school day but not after school. So they don't care about nutrition or healthy food... only about the money spent in the cafeteria.



This is for many reasons. A school cafeteria needs to be self sustaining. They need to make a profit so yes, the money is important. However, they also by law need to follow certain nutrition guidelines. So although your school may sell milk shakes they must also sell meals that satisfy the state and federal nutrition guidelines.

Posted 5/8/12 9:33 PM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Hofstra26

I just have to say..................not sure why everyone (not directing this at anyone on here in particular) is making such a big deal about what is served in the schools. The thing is, we had the SAME EXACT cr@p food (pizza, nuggets, burgers, fries) being served when I was a kid and NOBODY was fat. There was the one token chubby kid in the class but 98% of kids in school were an average healthy weight. I remember in JHS, there were kids who ate nothing but french fries and chocolate chip cookies EVERY day and they were thin.

The problem is NOT the food, it's the LACK of activity that kids have nowadays. When I was a kid in the 80's/90's we were outside ALL OF THE TIME. Morning, noon, and night we were outside running around, climbing, riding bikes, skating, etc, etc. Kids were out and about everywhere in the neighborhood and everyone was ACTIVE so that it didn't matter so much that you had a crap lunch because you were burning three times as many calories as you ate anyway.

And before anyone carries on about how times are different and it's so unsafe "out there" and kids can't go out and play I *personally* 100% disagree.

The neighborhood I grew up in (North Massapequa/Seaford) hasn't changed much since I was a kid. The only difference today from yesterday is that we have more access to info. In the 80's you couldn't log on to your computer and type in "child molester" and see a map of where they all lived BUUUUT they were still out there. On every block, in every town. But we were still ALLOWED out to play and be ACTIVE. The key to being healthy is being active and if our kids are trapped inside all day they aren't moving as much as they should.

Aside from that, back "in the day" parents parented. Moms cooked dinners. There was no eating out every night or grabbing fast food. Parents regulated what their kids watched and how long they played video games for. Parents encouraged their kids to be active, to go outside and play. Parents didn't give in to their child's every need and desire. They set limits. They set boundaries. They parented. But today, I feel like there is SO much lazy parenting. So many parents don't want to be bothered being responsible for anything, they want to blame everyone else for the problems they create with their kids and then they want someone else to fix them too.

I find this day and age disappointing. I miss the "good old days". DH and I were raised the same way and we STRONGLY believe in "kickin it old school". My DD has (and will always have) limits, bedtimes, routines, and boundaries. She won't be allowed to help herself to snack after snack, she will be served dinner and if she doesn't like it.......oh well, that's all she's getting, she will be limited on the computer and video games, she will be told NO and taught that life isn't fair (you don't always get your way or get what you want), and she will ALWAYS be encouraged to go outside and play and be a kid. She needs to move her body, to use her imagination, and to just be a kid! As a parent I feel like this is what she needs to be a healthy, happy, and productive child.

How my child turns out begins and ends with me. Simple as that. I won't ALLOW my DD to be a fat, lazy, cookie slobbering kid glued to the couch watching cr@p all day. It's just not happening.

Okay, rant over. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Again............this isn't directed at anyone on this thread. Just a general disgust with society as a whole. Chat Icon



i 100 percent agree

Posted 5/8/12 9:37 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

As the mom of a kid with severe food allergies, I'm totally ok with this.
I am so scared of him going to school because I won't be able to monitor everything that goes into his mouth.

Posted 5/8/12 9:39 PM
 

rsquared
Sweet P is here!

Member since 4/11

2026 total posts

Name:
R

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Can I just say that today one of my 2nd grade students, who is 110 lbs at the ripe old age of 8, came to school with a CAN OF PEPSI AND A LARGE BAG OF DORITOS...for snack. That is why these kids are fat. They eat garbage. A bake sale is the very tiniest tip of the iceburg.

I do see the allergy issue, however. Since my school has a high percentage of kids with peanut allergies, I get nervous with bake sales, even though we are supposed to be peanut-free. Its sad you have to think of that, but if Johnny's mom said the brownies have no nuts, but Timmy eats it and his throat closes....its the school's fault and my career at stake. I am not willing to risk my job and a kid's safety for a bake sale, so when my school has them, I provided another snack from a list that I have had all of the parent sign a form agreeing that I can give to the kids-so I can't be sued. Any food I give to them is off the list. I think for that reason schools are shying away from bake sales.

I think there are other ways to fundraise that don't have all of these issues, but a ban is not necessary.

Posted 5/8/12 10:34 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Banning Bake Sales?

Posted by Bella01

I think city schools banned them too because it was going on during lunch hour. It was part of the School Nutrition audit. I believe they cannot have them more than once a month.



My PTA sells icecream to our sudents twice per week...so I seriously doubt it.

Posted 5/8/12 11:05 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Law banning retail sales of puppies and kittens JessInCA 2/16/10 3 Pets
cross post: ADT door to door sales rose825 7/18/05 5 Home
ADT door to door sales rose825 7/18/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
What stores are having good sales right now?? neenie 7/15/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
Sales Account Executive Position Jennifer 7/9/05 1 Career
does anyone work in financial sales? Tany 6/30/05 0 Families Helping Families ™