Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by nrthshgrl

I would also change the policy to whoever asks for it first & then by seniority going forward.

I don't agree that Employee A should never be able to take those 2 weeks off because Employee B has done it for the past 12 years.




I agree with BOTH of these sentiments.

I definitely would change the policy, too. But I agree, just because she's had it in the past, doesn't mean she automatically gets it now.

Posted 4/30/13 4:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Aries14

I dont know... I feel like that has to be some bend to that "policy". I mean, if they have both been working at the company for 12+ years and one happen to start a few months before - that means Sup A gets EVERYTHING handed to her first? That doesnt really seem fair either. I look at it like this, in that case Sup A can take every holiday off, christmas, thanksgiving, etc. every.single.year and sup B would NEVER be able to get those days off just bc this "policy" (which she said was NOT a company policy - just a department one). I just dont think it's so clear cut to say that senority rules on EVERY situation. One of them being a situation like this that this person -who for the last 12 years probably had to always work around Sup A bc of this rule- now gets told that her one vacation that she takes the same time every year has to be canceled bc sup A just decided she wants to go away that date?
I'm sorry but I would be more affraid of Sup B going over my head and complaining to higher up. And since this is not a COMPANY WIDE policy - I bet she would win this agruement



Perhaps that's the way it is in your company, but in my office a rule is a rule is a rule and that's the way it should be IMO. I don't necessarily agree with this particular rule, but it's there none the less and should be followed accordingly. Bending a rule is still breaking it. In my company, there is no doubt in my mind Supervisor A would win (if they escalated it), even if it is only a department policy. Though, chances are, they would change the rule after this instance.

Message edited 2013-04-30 17:02:09.167000.

Posted 4/30/13 5:01 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by ali120206

Did Supervisor B already ask and have her request approved?



They both just gave me their requests because all summer vacation requests must be in to me by April 30th.



If this is the case I would go by the book, the one with more seniority gets it even though it isn't her usual vacation time, it is the only fair way IMO and given their off/on relationship I doubt they will be flexible and even if they are could change their minds since they are hot and cold w/eachother so I would follow policy so no questions can be asked.

Posted 4/30/13 5:20 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by halfbaked

Posted by nrthshgrl

I would also change the policy to whoever asks for it first & then by seniority going forward.

I don't agree that Employee A should never be able to take those 2 weeks off because Employee B has done it for the past 12 years.




I agree with BOTH of these sentiments.

I definitely would change the policy, too. But I agree, just because she's had it in the past, doesn't mean she automatically gets it now.



I agree with this. Just because she always takes those weeks doesn't mean someone else shouldn't be able to. Maybe she really has something those two weeks. I think you have to go with company policy or have them discuss it with each other. I would approve one week for each and ask them to work out the other week

Posted 4/30/13 5:45 PM
 

rsquared
Sweet P is here!

Member since 4/11

2026 total posts

Name:
R

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Cage fight?

Posted 4/30/13 7:50 PM
 

Watever143
LIF Adult

Member since 12/10

1537 total posts

Name:

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

In my job with have a cut off datre also and if that was me at a job the person with the more senority gets it

Posted 4/30/13 8:02 PM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

My office is very similar. It is first come first serve, but if two people pick the same week, it becomes the more senior person's week.

It happened to me 2 years ago, and again last year as the LESS senior person. Now I just make my plans around the other person

Posted 4/30/13 8:13 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by halfbaked

Posted by nrthshgrl

I would also change the policy to whoever asks for it first & then by seniority going forward.

I don't agree that Employee A should never be able to take those 2 weeks off because Employee B has done it for the past 12 years.




I agree with BOTH of these sentiments.

I definitely would change the policy, too. But I agree, just because she's had it in the past, doesn't mean she automatically gets it now.



Right that would be like the same person getting the day after Thanksgiving off every single year and no on else has a chance.

Posted 4/30/13 8:14 PM
 

schmora15
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2476 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Aries14

It sounds like your policy would give it to Sup A but Sup B is the one who takes the same two weeks every year?

In this case I would overlook the policy this one time and allow Sup B to take her weeks. She's been taking those weeks for 12 YEARS! Sounds like Sup A is just being a jerk, imo. And Sup A knows Sup B takes those 2 weeks - I think the right thing for her to do is pick different weeks. We aren't talking about a random same week off request (bc then I would go with the policy and give it to Sup A) this has been done for the last 12 years... I bet Sup B already even has hers plans done since its her "usual time".
But you should probably talk to both of them and see what sup A has planned. But I would def be more inclined to give to Sup B



This.

Posted 4/30/13 8:14 PM
 

AllyMally
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/13

881 total posts

Name:
Alyson

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Go by seniority. Yea I get that sup B always takes x weeks off, but that doesn't mean she is always going to get it off nor does it mean it's her vacation time. Yea sure she may have made plans, but if that's the case why wait until the day of to submit the request? Sup A may be an assshole for doing this, but seniority rules. If you bend here others will expect it as well. This is about vacation time. Do you really want to bend on this and not something else?

Posted 4/30/13 8:26 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by halfbaked

Posted by Karen

I don't totally agree. What if B's time was already in before A requested it? B gets bumped because A has seniority? I don't think so. Seniority only comes into play if both people put their requests in at the same exact time.

And one could argue B's vacation went in first since she always takes the same two weeks.



They were submitted at the same time.

ETA: And that's a different policy- first come, first served.



I am really on the fence about this hearing the other side.

Technically though, someone submitted "first". I doubt they both ran to her desk at the same time.

I am confused though with seniority over first-come, first serve. Let's say I request a week in August for a cruise and it's approved. I book the cruise and all is good. A month later, someone with more seniority requests that same week, am I now screwed and have to cancel my plans??

Message edited 2013-04-30 20:50:50.713000.

Posted 4/30/13 8:46 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I have no advice but I hate seniority based vacation picks. It just sucks. Especially nowadays where most places are understaffed due to the economy and there's more work to share and therefore most people can't be off on the same days because of it.
I've worked in places where no one could take a day off from April - sept because of "seniority".
It absolutely sucks. Lol

Posted 4/30/13 9:10 PM
 

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

So what happened with this? Chat Icon

Posted 5/6/13 12:03 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

And THIS is why I put my vacation in for the entire year in January!!! LOL My November vacation has been on the books since Feb.

Id say shame on Sup B for not getting hers in earlier.

Problem is I would think she has the same two weeks off for a good reason and if she’s travelling too, what can you do really?

We’ve had cases here where two ppl literally booked trips then put it on the calendar. That was unpleasant!

Bottom line though (here anyway) is seniority rules, only second to first come first served. So glad I’m not in management anymore!
Chat Icon

Posted 5/6/13 12:36 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by LINewbie

So what happened with this? Chat Icon



First of all....thank you to everyone that responded. It was incredibly helpful.

So here's what happened - it was a lot less dramatic than I anticipated, thankfully.

I sat both of them down last Friday to go over all of the summer vacation requests that came in from the rest of the staff. (All of the summer vacation requests have to be in by April 30th - it's just the nature of our business.) So after we finished going over those requests I brought up their requests. I told them they both requested the same weeks. Supervisor A, the one who never takes vacation in August, immediately said she could take vacation at a different time. Honestly, I was shocked.

Posted 5/6/13 12:42 PM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

good, glad it worked out and that A did not give you much trouble!

Posted 5/6/13 12:43 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

wow!!!

Posted 5/6/13 12:50 PM
 

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Very good to hear, glad it worked out for everyone!

Posted 5/6/13 1:09 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I'm glad to hear your update & then A is being reasonable. I hope B appreciates it.

Also if you do opt to change the policy to first come, first serve, have them submit it via email. It's time stamped.

Message edited 2013-05-06 15:10:31.780000.

Posted 5/6/13 3:09 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

great update! glad it went so smoothly!

Posted 5/6/13 3:19 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

glad it worked out but I am still confused as to how Sup A didn't know that those were the same weeks that B always put in for. Don't get that part.

Posted 5/6/13 3:27 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

+1 for humanity! (and sanity)

Glad it worked out.

Posted 5/6/13 3:40 PM
 

lululu
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

9511 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

My mom is going to have this same problem this year. We are planning a family trip at the same time her coworker typically takes vacation. My mom has seniority. Honestly, if she were denied a vacation that she put in for first, solely on the basis that that person takes it every year, I would be so mad. our family trip can not be rescheduled, and that other person isn't entitled to take those weeks every year just because she always has. Ironically, it happens to be the second to last week in august. MANY people take those weeks off. I think you need to give it to the person that asked first.

Posted 5/6/13 5:42 PM
 

evenedan
Need a little sunshine

Member since 9/05

3843 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Nevermind... Just saw the update. Glad it worked out.

Message edited 2013-05-07 09:43:30.503000.

Posted 5/7/13 9:40 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]