Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I think you should sit with both of them to see if they can come to an agreement and figure out a solution. Have them work it out.

Message edited 2013-04-30 14:01:03.330000.

Posted 4/30/13 2:00 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mrsm-2011
He is my world!

Member since 6/12

3009 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Can't you sit them both down and tell them they requested the same vacation and you will have to deny one of them unless one of them can come up with a different vacation date?

Posted 4/30/13 2:00 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by forevermylilgirls

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.



that changes my vote- you have your policy backing you up and she's doing it to incite trouble- I'd deny her request



My policy actually backs the sh*t stirrer (lol) since she's the one with seniority.



but does she have written justification for her request. what is the reason for her picking those weeks all of a sudden?



It's a summer vacation request. She said her nephew is going to Guyana and she wants to go with him.



ugh this is tricky but since she has senority as per your policy she should get it. Do I think she should..no I think Sup B should



My sentiments exactly! Thanks for all the input!

Posted 4/30/13 2:00 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by mrsm-2011

Can't you sit them both down and tell them they requested the same vacation and you will have to deny one of them unless one of them can come up with a different vacation date?



I think this is what I'm going to do. I'm OK with them overlapping 1 week, but I can't have them overlap two weeks. It's too much of a burden on the office.

Thanks everyone!

Posted 4/30/13 2:02 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by mrsm-2011

Can't you sit them both down and tell them they requested the same vacation and you will have to deny one of them unless one of them can come up with a different vacation date?



I think this is what I'm going to do. I'm OK with them overlapping 1 week, but I can't have them overlap two weeks. It's too much of a burden on the office.

Thanks everyone!



I agree. Just sit them both down.

Posted 4/30/13 2:03 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

go by policy, BUT I'd maybe give B the heads up right away not to book anything on the assumption she will be having the same two weeks. She may have already booked something expecting the time bc it's what she's always had.

Posted 4/30/13 2:04 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I'm a sup and in this case I would do the following- I would see if maybe they can slightly change their weeks- one goes out a week earlier and the other a week later- but that way they would be out a week concurrently.

If that's a no- then the less senior person would unfortunately have to change it

To be honest, if the senior person always requests it, I am not sure why less senior person would even look at that time for a vacay.



Exactly this.

Take the emotion out of it and follow policy. Let them know that the requests came in together and that they cannot have the same time off. Ask if either will volunteer to change and if not you will only approve one. The end. Do not get sucked into the drama.

Posted 4/30/13 2:13 PM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by mrsm-2011

Can't you sit them both down and tell them they requested the same vacation and you will have to deny one of them unless one of them can come up with a different vacation date?



I think this is what I'm going to do. I'm OK with them overlapping 1 week, but I can't have them overlap two weeks. It's too much of a burden on the office.

Thanks everyone!



Yeah that's what I would do, too. I just hope they are both adult enough to compromise! Chat Icon

Posted 4/30/13 2:19 PM
 

Eunyboo
<3

Member since 7/12

4376 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I'm a sup and in this case I would do the following- I would see if maybe they can slightly change their weeks- one goes out a week earlier and the other a week later- but that way they would be out a week concurrently.

If that's a no- then the less senior person would unfortunately have to change it




Same here.. I'm a sup and this is exactly what I would do.

Posted 4/30/13 2:20 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by halfbaked

Yeah that's what I would do, too. I just hope they are both adult enough to compromise! Chat Icon



That's the problem with these two. They love the drama.

Posted 4/30/13 2:22 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by halfbaked

Yeah that's what I would do, too. I just hope they are both adult enough to compromise! Chat Icon



That's the problem with these two. They love the drama.



well too bad for one of them then..

Posted 4/30/13 2:25 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by halfbaked

Yeah that's what I would do, too. I just hope they are both adult enough to compromise! Chat Icon



That's the problem with these two. They love the drama.



they want to act like kids, treat them like kids- no one gets it. But I'm evil like that- you shouldn't have to stress this ridiculous situation- they are grown adults and should work it out or suffer.

Posted 4/30/13 2:26 PM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by halfbaked

Yeah that's what I would do, too. I just hope they are both adult enough to compromise! Chat Icon



That's the problem with these two. They love the drama.



I figured. We've had the same dilemma here in my office, but we've always done it by whoever puts in for it first. If they both refuse to budge, you're going to have to go by policy, however wrong it seems to be.

Posted 4/30/13 2:27 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Aries14

It sounds like your policy would give it to Sup A but Sup B is the one who takes the same two weeks every year?

In this case I would overlook the policy this one time and allow Sup B to take her weeks. She's been taking those weeks for 12 YEARS! Sounds like Sup A is just being a jerk, imo. And Sup A knows Sup B takes those 2 weeks - I think the right thing for her to do is pick different weeks. We aren't talking about a random same week off request (bc then I would go with the policy and give it to Sup A) this has been done for the last 12 years... I bet Sup B already even has hers plans done since its her "usual time".
But you should probably talk to both of them and see what sup A has planned. But I would def be more inclined to give to Sup B



I completly agree.

If A doing to Chat Icon then its nasty. I would not reward that behavior.

Normally I would say that you SHOULD follow the policy, HOWEVER, I think that since ...

WAIT!!!!!

B gets it. B gets the weeks. If she has been taking the weeks for 12 years then, INDIRECTLY she told you first! You knew the day she got bak, LAST YEAR that she would take the same weeks, this year.

If she told you first, then she gets it.

Thats it. The same weeks for 12 years is your notice.


Easy decision now.

Posted 4/30/13 2:53 PM
 

femalej
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/11

833 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

i would give it to Supervisor B since her request has "superiority", meaning that its the SAME TIME each year. that is not nice for Supervisor A to put in for the same break. sorry.

if i were Supervisor A, and you came and explained the situation (unless it was a family wedding or another serious commitment like that), i would get it and understand.

Posted 4/30/13 3:14 PM
 

femalej
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/11

833 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Paramount
B gets the weeks. If she has been taking the weeks for 12 years then, INDIRECTLY she told you first! You knew the day she got bak, LAST YEAR that she would take the same weeks, this year.

If she told you first, then she gets it.

Thats it. The same weeks for 12 years is your notice.
.



yup! this is what i was trying to say!

Posted 4/30/13 3:16 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by femalej

Posted by Paramount
B gets the weeks. If she has been taking the weeks for 12 years then, INDIRECTLY she told you first! You knew the day she got bak, LAST YEAR that she would take the same weeks, this year.

If she told you first, then she gets it.

Thats it. The same weeks for 12 years is your notice.
.



yup! this is what i was trying to say!



Totally agree!

Posted 4/30/13 3:18 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by mrsm-2011

Can't you sit them both down and tell them they requested the same vacation and you will have to deny one of them unless one of them can come up with a different vacation date?



I think this is what I'm going to do. I'm OK with them overlapping 1 week, but I can't have them overlap two weeks. It's too much of a burden on the office.

Thanks everyone!




I think this is your best option, I hope it works out for you and them.

Keep us posted, I'm curious to see how this works out!

Posted 4/30/13 3:35 PM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Karen

Posted by femalej

Posted by Paramount
B gets the weeks. If she has been taking the weeks for 12 years then, INDIRECTLY she told you first! You knew the day she got bak, LAST YEAR that she would take the same weeks, this year.

If she told you first, then she gets it.

Thats it. The same weeks for 12 years is your notice.
.



yup! this is what i was trying to say!



Totally agree!



I have to disagree. That's not what her department policy is. Her department policy goes by seniority and that's the way it should be really. You shouldn't bend the rules just because a situation you don't like arises. Unfortunately, emotions need to be taken out of the equation.

ETA: And if Supervisor A is as much of a sh!t stirrer as she sounds like, you can bet she'll go right over the OP's head and get her vacation time anyway. It happens in my office CONSTANTLY.

Message edited 2013-04-30 15:37:56.797000.

Posted 4/30/13 3:36 PM
 

IAMMRSBROWN
3 under 2!!!

Member since 10/10

2476 total posts

Name:
Carey

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Cant you say that Sup B already put her request in last week for the same two weeks she takes every year so Sup A needs to change?

Posted 4/30/13 3:36 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by halfbaked

Posted by Karen

Posted by femalej

Posted by Paramount
B gets the weeks. If she has been taking the weeks for 12 years then, INDIRECTLY she told you first! You knew the day she got bak, LAST YEAR that she would take the same weeks, this year.

If she told you first, then she gets it.

Thats it. The same weeks for 12 years is your notice.
.



yup! this is what i was trying to say!



Totally agree!



I have to disagree. That's not what her department policy is. Her department policy goes by seniority and that's the way it should be really. You shouldn't bend the rules just because a situation you don't like arises. Unfortunately, emotions need to be taken out of the equation.

ETA: And if Supervisor A is as much of a sh!t stirrer as she sounds like, you can bet she'll go right over the OP's head and get her vacation time anyway. It happens in my office CONSTANTLY.



I don't totally agree. What if B's time was already in before A requested it? B gets bumped because A has seniority? I don't think so. Seniority only comes into play if both people put their requests in at the same exact time.

And one could argue B's vacation went in first since she always takes the same two weeks.

Posted 4/30/13 3:57 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by halfbaked

Posted by Karen

Posted by femalej

Posted by Paramount
B gets the weeks. If she has been taking the weeks for 12 years then, INDIRECTLY she told you first! You knew the day she got bak, LAST YEAR that she would take the same weeks, this year.

If she told you first, then she gets it.

Thats it. The same weeks for 12 years is your notice.
.



yup! this is what i was trying to say!



Totally agree!



I have to disagree. That's not what her department policy is. Her department policy goes by seniority and that's the way it should be really. You shouldn't bend the rules just because a situation you don't like arises. Unfortunately, emotions need to be taken out of the equation.

ETA: And if Supervisor A is as much of a sh!t stirrer as she sounds like, you can bet she'll go right over the OP's head and get her vacation time anyway. It happens in my office CONSTANTLY.



I dont know... I feel like that has to be some bend to that "policy". I mean, if they have both been working at the company for 12+ years and one happen to start a few months before - that means Sup A gets EVERYTHING handed to her first? That doesnt really seem fair either. I look at it like this, in that case Sup A can take every holiday off, christmas, thanksgiving, etc. every.single.year and sup B would NEVER be able to get those days off just bc this "policy" (which she said was NOT a company policy - just a department one). I just dont think it's so clear cut to say that senority rules on EVERY situation. One of them being a situation like this that this person -who for the last 12 years probably had to always work around Sup A bc of this rule- now gets told that her one vacation that she takes the same time every year has to be canceled bc sup A just decided she wants to go away that date?
I'm sorry but I would be more affraid of Sup B going over my head and complaining to higher up. And since this is not a COMPANY WIDE policy - I bet she would win this agruement

Posted 4/30/13 4:00 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I would follow my policy. The person with seniority gets it first.

I would also change the policy to whoever asks for it first & then by seniority going forward.

I don't agree that Employee A should never be able to take those 2 weeks off because Employee B has done it for the past 12 years.

If you opt for the meeting, I disagree that you should be giving anyone a heads up about the topic before it is presented.

Message edited 2013-04-30 16:55:11.797000.

Posted 4/30/13 4:51 PM
 

imagin916
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1826 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

I manage a department of 15 people. I have 2 supervisors that report directly to me. The 2 supervisors (both grown women 50-60yo) have a sort of sibling relationship - one minute they love each other, the next they're not speaking. Drives me nuts but it is what it is.

I do not allow them to take vacation at the same time because they need to cover for each other when one is out. I approve vacation based on seniority and we have a written departmental policy about it. However, our company as a whole doesn't have a written policy about it.

Supervisor A has slight seniority over Supervisor B. Supervisor B requests the same two weeks in August every year, and has been doing so for the last 12 years. Supervisor A has historically taken 2 weeks in July. However, this year she has requested the same two weeks that Supervisor B always takes.

What do I do??



The way we did it where I used to work is the same in terms of seniority, but the same person cannot take the same week of vacation the following year if someone else requests it, so that its fair for people who are less senior. If this rule wasn't in place, nobody would get any vacation in the summer because of how many employees there are. If the senior person requests the week and nobody else wants it than they can take it again, but if there are other requests, the next senior person who requested it gets it.

Edited to add: this was written in the union policy, although I know your place isn't union, this policy could work anywhere

Message edited 2013-04-30 17:00:29.137000.

Posted 4/30/13 4:54 PM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Karen

I don't totally agree. What if B's time was already in before A requested it? B gets bumped because A has seniority? I don't think so. Seniority only comes into play if both people put their requests in at the same exact time.

And one could argue B's vacation went in first since she always takes the same two weeks.



They were submitted at the same time.

ETA: And that's a different policy- first come, first served.

Message edited 2013-04-30 16:56:17.750000.

Posted 4/30/13 4:56 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3