Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I manage a department of 15 people. I have 2 supervisors that report directly to me. The 2 supervisors (both grown women 50-60yo) have a sort of sibling relationship - one minute they love each other, the next they're not speaking. Drives me nuts but it is what it is.

I do not allow them to take vacation at the same time because they need to cover for each other when one is out. I approve vacation based on seniority and we have a written departmental policy about it. However, our company as a whole doesn't have a written policy about it.

Supervisor A has slight seniority over Supervisor B. Supervisor B requests the same two weeks in August every year, and has been doing so for the last 12 years. Supervisor A has historically taken 2 weeks in July. However, this year she has requested the same two weeks that Supervisor B always takes.

What do I do??

Posted 4/30/13 1:35 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Did Supervisor B already ask and have her request approved?

Posted 4/30/13 1:38 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I would give it to the person who requested it first.

Message edited 2013-04-30 13:39:56.923000.

Posted 4/30/13 1:39 PM
 

BklynBabe12
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/12

561 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Ahh thats tricky!!

Did Supervisor B put her request in yet? If she did, then I'd grant her first.

But, if your department has the rule of seniority first then Supervisor A gets the vacation first. Supervisor B can go higher and see if her vacation time can overrule this effect.

Posted 4/30/13 1:39 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Who requested it first?

Posted 4/30/13 1:39 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by ali120206

Did Supervisor B already ask and have her request approved?



They both just gave me their requests because all summer vacation requests must be in to me by April 30th.

Posted 4/30/13 1:40 PM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

There's only one way to handle this!

Rock, Paper, Scissor! Chat Icon

Tough call. Who requested first? I think I would feel inclined to give it to the person who has always taken those 2 weeks.

Posted 4/30/13 1:41 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

so they both requested it at the same time?

Posted 4/30/13 1:41 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?

Posted 4/30/13 1:42 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I'm a sup and in this case I would do the following- I would see if maybe they can slightly change their weeks- one goes out a week earlier and the other a week later- but that way they would be out a week concurrently.

If that's a no- then the less senior person would unfortunately have to change it

To be honest, if the senior person always requests it, I am not sure why less senior person would even look at that time for a vacay.

Posted 4/30/13 1:43 PM
 

Lara&Aidansmommy
For mom i miss u ETC ILOVEU

Member since 3/07

13921 total posts

Name:
ETC I LOVE YOU

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by forevermylilgirls

I would give it to the person who requested it first.




Yep I agree.

Posted 4/30/13 1:45 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.

Posted 4/30/13 1:45 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

To be honest, if the senior person always requests it, I am not sure why less senior person would even look at that time for a vacay.



The LESS senior person is the one that always takes the weeks in question.

Posted 4/30/13 1:46 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.



that changes my vote- you have your policy backing you up and she's doing it to incite trouble- I'd deny her request

Posted 4/30/13 1:46 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Will you get flack if you give it to the person who always takes those weeks?

Posted 4/30/13 1:48 PM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.



that changes my vote- you have your policy backing you up and she's doing it to incite trouble- I'd deny her request



I agree.

Would they know that they both requested it at the same time? If not you could always tell her the other one requested first.

Posted 4/30/13 1:50 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I would give it to the person who always goes those same weeks. Sup A is trying to start something.

Posted 4/30/13 1:52 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

In that case, I would give it to Sup B then.

Posted 4/30/13 1:52 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.



that changes my vote- you have your policy backing you up and she's doing it to incite trouble- I'd deny her request



My policy actually backs the sh*t stirrer (lol) since she's the one with seniority.

Posted 4/30/13 1:53 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.



that changes my vote- you have your policy backing you up and she's doing it to incite trouble- I'd deny her request



My policy actually backs the sh*t stirrer (lol) since she's the one with seniority.



but does she have written justification for her request. what is the reason for her picking those weeks all of a sudden?

Posted 4/30/13 1:54 PM
 

dianadrw
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

2092 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by forevermylilgirls

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.



that changes my vote- you have your policy backing you up and she's doing it to incite trouble- I'd deny her request



My policy actually backs the sh*t stirrer (lol) since she's the one with seniority.



but does she have written justification for her request. what is the reason for her picking those weeks all of a sudden?



It's a summer vacation request. She said her nephew is going to Guyana and she wants to go with him.

Posted 4/30/13 1:55 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

It sounds like your policy would give it to Sup A but Sup B is the one who takes the same two weeks every year?

In this case I would overlook the policy this one time and allow Sup B to take her weeks. She's been taking those weeks for 12 YEARS! Sounds like Sup A is just being a jerk, imo. And Sup A knows Sup B takes those 2 weeks - I think the right thing for her to do is pick different weeks. We aren't talking about a random same week off request (bc then I would go with the policy and give it to Sup A) this has been done for the last 12 years... I bet Sup B already even has hers plans done since its her "usual time".
But you should probably talk to both of them and see what sup A has planned. But I would def be more inclined to give to Sup B

Posted 4/30/13 1:57 PM
 

ThreeforTea
Girls just want to have fun..

Member since 5/12

7482 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

Posted by dianadrw

Posted by forevermylilgirls

doesn't Sup A know that Sup B takes those weeks every year? Why would Sup A put in for the same weeks?



Because she's a little bit of a sh*t stirrer.



that changes my vote- you have your policy backing you up and she's doing it to incite trouble- I'd deny her request



My policy actually backs the sh*t stirrer (lol) since she's the one with seniority.



but does she have written justification for her request. what is the reason for her picking those weeks all of a sudden?



It's a summer vacation request. She said her nephew is going to Guyana and she wants to go with him.



ugh this is tricky but since she has senority as per your policy she should get it. Do I think she should..no I think Sup B should

Posted 4/30/13 1:58 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

I would give them a choice. Work it out among the two of them, or no one gets approved for those dates.Chat Icon

Posted 4/30/13 1:59 PM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: Approving someone's vacation request-WWYD?

Maybe sit down with them and tell them since they both requested the same weeks, you are willing to split 1 week each between them, and they have to pick another week, either before or after those 2 weeks in question? I know B always takes the same vacation weeks, but maybe A thinks its not fair that she always gets those weeks off and wants off then too? I am not sure what A is thinking just trying to put some logic behind it lol...

Posted 4/30/13 1:59 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3