America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I am surprised LI doesn't trump NYC in a way, but at the same time, while NYC SEEMS diverse because so many different cultures live in the same town, in a way, it is not because the communities do tend to have one or two cultures and are not so mixed overall. That's my experience anyway after living and working in many different neighborhoods in Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Posted 4/8/11 10:19 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





oh stop, shes not being racist. Racist is when you believe your race is superior to others, or when you are intolerant of people with different cultural backgrounds. She didnt say or imply she was any of those things. She meant "own kind" like Im Italian and Irish, so when speaking to me, she would mean say Little Italy, there is a big greek population in Astoria, so they are with people like themselves, the same kind of people, other greeks. I hardly believe she meant it to be racist, but such is LIF.

Posted 4/8/11 10:27 AM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I completely agree. I just wonder how many people that did that survey answered 'white' instead of foreign born.

Posted 4/8/11 10:29 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by memi7206

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





oh stop, shes not being racist. Racist is when you believe your race is superior to others, or when you are intolerant of people with different cultural backgrounds. She didnt say or imply she was any of those things. She meant "own kind" like Im Italian and Irish, so when speaking to me, she would mean say Little Italy, there is a big greek population in Astoria, so they are with people like themselves, the same kind of people, other greeks. I hardly believe she meant it to be racist, but such is LIF.



ITA

Posted 4/8/11 10:33 AM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





Curious, where do you live and what's your background? There is nothing racist about what she said. She was explaining why areas are the way they are.

Posted 4/8/11 10:39 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I don't think the idea of people living near their "own kind" is racist at all.

It's just how neighborhoods wind up sometimes.

When I think of areas of NYC -- I think of what ethnic groups tend to live there. The 5 boroughs are pretty segregated in their ethnic makeup. I mean why do we have locations like Chinatown, Little Italy, Spanish Harlem, etc.? Because history has showed that so many people migrated to the area that they know there are tons of people that are similar to them. It doesn't mean that those who choose to do this are racist per se.

Posted 4/8/11 10:42 AM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by BatGirl9910

The article is flawed and uses flawed research. They don't define cities or metropolis, which means many "cities " were excluded..also they focus on blacks vs whites- what about Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, Indians, etc? Also, zero discussion of the fact that socioeconomic disparities are really the driving force between segregated neighborhoods, not race.

Also I don't think the title is good. Most people like to live with people just like them, it doesn't mean they are racist or despise neighbors of other nationalities. After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?




Great points ! ITA!

Posted 4/8/11 10:46 AM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by memi7206

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





oh stop, shes not being racist. Racist is when you believe your race is superior to others, or when you are intolerant of people with different cultural backgrounds. She didnt say or imply she was any of those things. She meant "own kind" like Im Italian and Irish, so when speaking to me, she would mean say Little Italy, there is a big greek population in Astoria, so they are with people like themselves, the same kind of people, other greeks. I hardly believe she meant it to be racist, but such is LIF.



Chat Icon Thank you, Memi, and everyone else who took my post for exactly what it is.

Human desire to be closer to their "own kind" hardly equals "racism", I am quite surprised it would even occur to anyone to draw that kind of conclusion from my words.

People feel more comfortable with those who have things in common with them, and it has much more to do with culture and tradition than race.

That's how cultural communities are born: you come to this country, scared, unsure, not speaking a word of English, not knowing where to buy bread and coffee (the kind you used to have at home), not knowing where your children will go to school, if and where you will find work. It's a very, VERY scary feeling! So, what do you do? You turn to your own kind! Not because you hate everyone else! Because your "own kind", having gone through exactly the same thing you are going through right now, will UNDERSTAND and provide help and moral support. It's as simple as that.

Posted 4/8/11 10:50 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I am a white Jew and I live on LI but guess what? I may be the only one of "my kind" on my block. I was the only one of "my kind" before I bought my house and my neighborhood was predominantly white - mostly Irish or Italian Catholic families and Indian families as well. Not too long ago, I ran into a person in a bakery while having coffee and when we realized we were from the same neighborhood, she could rattle of the homes of the Jews in a 5 block radius of her house because there were so few. We were identified by the menorah in our window at Chanukah time. It left me with a rather unsettling feeling. I embrace diversity, but to be honest, I would like Abby and Jeremy to have friends that they can do their Hebrew school homework with and I make no apologies for it.

Message edited 2011-04-08 11:03:16.980000.

Posted 4/8/11 11:02 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I'm shocked that New York is on there - what, as number 3??

And to the poster who mentioned Bay Ridge as being Italian, it used to be an Irish neighborhood before it was Italian (back when the Irish and Italians didn't mix in public Chat Icon ) ... now it's Irish, Italian and Middle Eastern..

I've lived in Brooklyn all my life... I've never not lived near people who spoke several different languages and came from all different places.. When I was small my father used to point out the different languages people were speaking on the street just so I'd notice the differences. I don't get it.

You can't tell what my kids are by looking at them and I'm sure they'll encounter lots of ignorance over time since they're both pale with dirty blond hair but are half Puerto Rican..

And like so many others have said, Nassau-Suffolk isn't a city!

Posted 4/8/11 11:08 AM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by memi7206

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





oh stop, shes not being racist. Racist is when you believe your race is superior to others, or when you are intolerant of people with different cultural backgrounds. She didnt say or imply she was any of those things. She meant "own kind" like Im Italian and Irish, so when speaking to me, she would mean say Little Italy, there is a big greek population in Astoria, so they are with people like themselves, the same kind of people, other greeks. I hardly believe she meant it to be racist, but such is LIF.



Chat Icon Thank you, Memi, and everyone else who took my post for exactly what it is.

Human desire to be closer to their "own kind" hardly equals "racism", I am quite surprised it would even occur to anyone to draw that kind of conclusion from my words.

People feel more comfortable with those who have things in common with them, and it has much more to do with culture and tradition than race.

That's how cultural communities are born: you come to this country, scared, unsure, not speaking a word of English, not knowing where to buy bread and coffee (the kind you used to have at home), not knowing where your children will go to school, if and where you will find work. It's a very, VERY scary feeling! So, what do you do? You turn to your own kind! Not because you hate everyone else! Because your "own kind", having gone through exactly the same thing you are going through right now, will UNDERSTAND and provide help and moral support. It's as simple as that.



Please read the comment i made this morning. I was in no way saying you were racist. That was the wrong term to use.

Posted 4/8/11 11:09 AM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by Mici C

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





Curious, where do you live and what's your background? There is nothing racist about what she said. She was explaining why areas are the way they are.



I made another comment this morning which answers your question.

Posted 4/8/11 11:10 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





It's only racist when a "white" person says it. But when every other race or culture want to live where their culture is predominant, then it's ok.Chat Icon

Posted 4/8/11 11:14 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Please read the comment i made this morning. I was in no way saying you were racist. That was the wrong term to use.




There's a big difference between someone making an ignorant statement about how you should "stick with your own kind" in terms of dating/marriage and just the general idea that there are some people who prefer to live among the same kind of people that are of their ethnic background.

Try not to take this as a personal thing based on what has happened to you before. They are 2 different things. You have to admit that in terms of where people choose to live, particularly in a lot of areas in NYC, certain ethnic groups gravitate to neighborhoods that contain the same nationalities. It's just how people have grown comfortable, particularly when they are immigrants here coming for the first time. They wind up being in an area that is full of those who speak their language and have others who understand their experience here as an immigrant.

Posted 4/8/11 11:15 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by Goobster

It's only racist when a "white" person says it. But when every other race or culture want to live where their culture is predominant, then it's ok.Chat Icon




See I'm only going by nationalties not by "race". There are certain areas that I think of when I think of Russian, Italian, Irish, Korean, Middle Eastern, etc. neighborhoods. That has nothing to do with being racist at all. It's just how it winds up. When you are in some parts of the city, you will see the signs change from one language to another because of the ethnic make-up of the neighborhood. That is not isolated to the color of skin at all.

Posted 4/8/11 11:17 AM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by babybug631

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by acm1899

Posted by Mici C

What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white.



Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim?

Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin.



I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white...Chat Icon Chat Icon

And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc.



I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all.





I don't think that's racist. It's like me saying I'd rather live in an italian neighborhood over a chinese or russian. I'm italian. I like italian food. I like italian bakeries. I fit in better there. I have nothing against chinese or russians. We all have different traditions and food.

Is Italy racist against France because a bunch of italians live there?



Maybe racist wasn't the right word. Just to be clear I do not feel the poster who I quoted is racist, I just feel that that segregated mentality leads to many issues.

I didn't like the own kind comment because I am also Russian/Jewish. My husband is German/Catholic. I heard a comment from someone prior to getting married, that I should stick with my own kind. I hate that mentality and to me its wrong.




I agree. It really all comes down to tolerance. Blending traditions is a great thing.

Posted 4/8/11 11:33 AM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by MrsPJB2007

Posted by lovemyfamily88

Please read the comment i made this morning. I was in no way saying you were racist. That was the wrong term to use.




There's a big difference between someone making an ignorant statement about how you should "stick with your own kind" in terms of dating/marriage and just the general idea that there are some people who prefer to live among the same kind of people that are of their ethnic background.

Try not to take this as a personal thing based on what has happened to you before. They are 2 different things. You have to admit that in terms of where people choose to live, particularly in a lot of areas in NYC, certain ethnic groups gravitate to neighborhoods that contain the same nationalities. It's just how people have grown comfortable, particularly when they are immigrants here coming for the first time. They wind up being in an area that is full of those who speak their language and have others who understand their experience here as an immigrant.





Its not 2 different things in my opinion.
This comment was also made to me because i was moving out of my "russian" neighborhood to a "American" part of long island.
Basically this person thinks that since i am Russian (I am a 1st generation American) I should live amongst only Russians. Sticking to my own kind. Its just not right in my oinion.
Im sorry but this is America. We are all Americans. If i wanted to only live amongst Russians i would move to Russia.

Posted 4/8/11 11:34 AM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by eroxgirl

I'm shocked that New York is on there - what, as number 3??

And to the poster who mentioned Bay Ridge as being Italian, it used to be an Irish neighborhood before it was Italian (back when the Irish and Italians didn't mix in public Chat Icon ) ... now it's Irish, Italian and Middle Eastern..

I've lived in Brooklyn all my life... I've never not lived near people who spoke several different languages and came from all different places.. When I was small my father used to point out the different languages people were speaking on the street just so I'd notice the differences. I don't get it.

You can't tell what my kids are by looking at them and I'm sure they'll encounter lots of ignorance over time since they're both pale with dirty blond hair but are half Puerto Rican..

And like so many others have said, Nassau-Suffolk isn't a city!



But in Brooklyn, people shop together (ie Century 21, 86th street). But the neighborhoods are very separate. However, there is a lot of tolerance. DH grew up in Bay Ridge and has always been exposed to different races and religions. Despite the fact that his immediate neighborhood was italian/irish.

Posted 4/8/11 11:40 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by lovemyfamily88



Its not 2 different things in my opinion.
This comment was also made to me because i was moving out of my "russian" neighborhood to a "American" part of long island.
Basically this person thinks that since i am Russian (I am a 1st generation American) I should live amongst only Russians. Sticking to my own kind. Its just not right in my oinion.
Im sorry but this is America. We are all Americans. If i wanted to only live amongst Russians i would move to Russia.




Well like I said, I think you are internalizing something that is not quite the same. But I guess that's how I see it.

My grandmother was an American citizen, because she was born in Puerto Rico. But she didn't speak more than 20 words of English.

Because of this, when she moved to New York, she picked an area in the Bronx that she knew was predominantly full of Puerto Rican/Hispanics. It was easier for her to live there because she was around those who spoke her language and were the same as her.

Does that make her a racist? No of course not. She had no problem with other races at all. She just preferred to live among fellow Latinos.

You're right, in America we are all Americans. In a perfect utopian society, there would be no segregated neighborhoods and everyone would live happily amongst each other. But in reality, that just isn't how it always is, and it doesn't always have to be because of racism.

Someone who comes from another country and chooses to live in a neighborhood because they know it's full of others from that nation/background...does not mean they are trying for some ethnic superiority or something. It just has happened that way through the decades since the early years of this nation.

Posted 4/8/11 11:42 AM
 

lovemyfamily88
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/10

641 total posts

Name:
????

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by MrsPJB2007

Posted by lovemyfamily88



Its not 2 different things in my opinion.
This comment was also made to me because i was moving out of my "russian" neighborhood to a "American" part of long island.
Basically this person thinks that since i am Russian (I am a 1st generation American) I should live amongst only Russians. Sticking to my own kind. Its just not right in my opinion.
Im sorry but this is America. We are all Americans. If i wanted to only live amongst Russians i would move to Russia.




Well like I said, I think you are internalizing something that is not quite the same. But I guess that's how I see it.

My grandmother was an American citizen, because she was born in Puerto Rico. But she didn't speak more than 20 words of English.

Because of this, when she moved to New York, she picked an area in the Bronx that she knew was predominantly full of Puerto Rican/Hispanics. It was easier for her to live there because she was around those who spoke her language and were the same as her.

Does that make her a racist? No of course not. She had no problem with other races at all. She just preferred to live among fellow Latinos.

You're right, in America we are all Americans. In a perfect utopian society, there would be no segregated neighborhoods and everyone would live happily amongst each other. But in reality, that just isn't how it always is, and it doesn't always have to be because of racism.

Someone who comes from another country and chooses to live in a neighborhood because they know it's full of others from that nation/background...does not mean they are trying for some ethnic superiority or something. It just has happened that way through the decades since the early years of this nation.




I think you are 100% right and I agree with you that its not racism and i regret using that word. I just think that ideally we should all live together and learn from each others cultures. I was lucky enough to go to a very diverse high school and had friends from many different cultures. I learned so much from my friends and i hope the same for my children.

Posted 4/8/11 12:03 PM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by lovemyfamily88


I think you are 100% right and I agree with you that its not racism and i regret using that word. I just think that ideally we should all live together and learn from each others cultures. I was lucky enough to go to a very diverse high school and had friends from many different cultures. I learned so much from my friends and i hope the same for my children.



It doesn't just happen here. There are many countries that are segregated as well. I totally get what you are saying and yes there are intolerant people that do in fact say things like that person did before you were married.

Posted 4/8/11 12:11 PM
 

memi7206
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2355 total posts

Name:
Due Dec 29th!!!!!

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by MrsPJB2007

Posted by lovemyfamily88



Its not 2 different things in my opinion.
This comment was also made to me because i was moving out of my "russian" neighborhood to a "American" part of long island.
Basically this person thinks that since i am Russian (I am a 1st generation American) I should live amongst only Russians. Sticking to my own kind. Its just not right in my oinion.
Im sorry but this is America. We are all Americans. If i wanted to only live amongst Russians i would move to Russia.




Well like I said, I think you are internalizing something that is not quite the same. But I guess that's how I see it.

My grandmother was an American citizen, because she was born in Puerto Rico. But she didn't speak more than 20 words of English.

Because of this, when she moved to New York, she picked an area in the Bronx that she knew was predominantly full of Puerto Rican/Hispanics. It was easier for her to live there because she was around those who spoke her language and were the same as her.

Does that make her a racist? No of course not. She had no problem with other races at all. She just preferred to live among fellow Latinos.

You're right, in America we are all Americans. In a perfect utopian society, there would be no segregated neighborhoods and everyone would live happily amongst each other. But in reality, that just isn't how it always is, and it doesn't always have to be because of racism.

Someone who comes from another country and chooses to live in a neighborhood because they know it's full of others from that nation/background...does not mean they are trying for some ethnic superiority or something. It just has happened that way through the decades since the early years of this nation.




well said.

In your personal case, that person was probably a racist.

In the comment made here by the poster, she wasnt being racist, she just meant that people with similar/same ethnic/cultural backgrounds tend to stick together for a variety of reason. Its all how its used and she didnt use it in a racist manner, whereas in your instance he did.

Posted 4/8/11 12:26 PM
 

Moehick
Ready for the sun!

Member since 5/05

30339 total posts

Name:
Properly perfect™

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I teach in NYC and it is no way diverse. My schools ethnic makeup, as well as many of my friends schools, are made up of a maximum of two ethnic groups. The city has a few integrated areas but the majority of neighborhoods are segragated.

Posted 4/8/11 5:16 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by Moehick

I teach in NYC and it is no way diverse. My schools ethnic makeup, as well as many of my friends schools, are made up of a maximum of two ethnic groups. The city has a few integrated areas but the majority of neighborhoods are segragated.



But the thing is it is NOT segregation as in people are "told" where they can and cannot live. Either they CHOOSE where to live or they live where they live based on income and cost of living/transportation issues, job, family, etc. So either way, there is no way around that so it is what it is. I don't see why people make such a big deal about it.

Posted 4/8/11 5:52 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities



It's only racist when a "white" person says it. But when every other race or culture want to live where their culture is predominant, then it's ok.Chat Icon [/QUOTE\
__________________________________
Good point!

Message edited 2011-04-08 18:01:36.637000.

Posted 4/8/11 6:00 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
America's Next Top Model Janice 10/12/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
America's Next Top Model KaRiSsA 9/28/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Only in America Elbee 9/21/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Iron Chef America - with Chicken NASP09 8/5/05 0 Dining In or Out
America's Riskiest Real Estate - Nassau/Suffolk #2 Leeners 8/4/05 14 Home
Does anyone use America's Choice diapers or wipes? LIMOMx2 7/30/05 8 Parenting