America's 10 Most Segregated Cities
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by BatGirl9910 Posted by acm1899 Posted by BatGirl9910 The article is flawed and uses flawed research. They don't define cities or metropolis, which means many "cities " were excluded..also they focus on blacks vs whites- what about Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, Indians, etc? Also, zero discussion of the fact that socioeconomic disparities are really the driving force between segregated neighborhoods, not race. Also I don't think the title is good. Most people like to live with people just like them, it doesn't mean they are racist or despise neighbors of other nationalities. After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here? I wouldn't say the article is flawed, but more often than not, when articles like this are published they don't really state what the parameters for the statistics are. First of all, "Nassau-Suffolk" is not even city, so I don't know how that got thrown in there. I'm sure that when they say 'metropolitan city' there is some sort of minimum population that they are referring to. Also, I'm trying to figure out how NYC is NOT a diverse city. Yes, there are neighborhoods which are predominantly one race or culture. But I can think of a bunch in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx which are very mixed...even Manhattan. I mean, are they talking about an entire city or just some neighborhoods? It's very unclear. And by the way, a neighborhood being all white, or all black, or all Chinese is not necessarily a bad thing. Have they ever thought that some groups want to live with one another? It doesn't mean that they don't include others, it just means some ethnicities tend to flock together for a various number of reasons. The real problem is when groups are purposely kept out of certain areas for whatever...but that is a totally different discussion.If you think about it, metropolitan cities, by their very nature, by the very fact that they generally offer more opportunities than smaller cities or towns, will always have more diversity than any smaller town can probably offer. Exactly, when I saw Nassau-Suffolk, my first reaction was "*** - these arent cities, they are suburbs of NYC...?!"...then i saw NYC was another category..which surprises me because NYC is as diverse as it gets!! Sure you have little ethnic enclaves like Little Italy, Chinatown, Spanish Harlem - but groups of people gravitate toward those areas because they want to be around neighbors who are culturally or economically similar to them...The only instance of outright racism I heard was DH's ex co-worker (old italian guy) who moved out of Richmond Hill, Queens to Amityville because he was "tired of seeing my block becoming full of Guyanese and Indians all over.." And to address the PP on the black baby avatar remark, I actually don't need to assume because the majority of the LIF boards ARE populated by certain demographics more than others..I am not saying its right or wrong, it is what it is..I dont need to assume anything - this 1 thread is a perfect example: http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-418600-2.html Out of 43 LIF posters on that thread, only FOUR identified themselves as non-caucasian (Indian/Trinidadian/African American). Oh, and take a look at the avatars too... Aren't you doing the same thing you are criticizing the study for by using a thread of 43 posters as evidence for your argument?
Message edited 2011-04-07 23:09:08.703000. |
|
Posted 4/7/11 11:06 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Here's the actual study. |
|
Posted 4/7/11 11:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by acm1899 Posted by cateyemm I didnt read the blurb, maybe i should. but I think when they said segregrated, they mean separated, whether by physical or economic division. I get what they mean by segregated, but check this out, these are figures off of Wikipedia for the 2000 Census (I guess the 2010 Census #'s aren't available yet) These are Demographics for Manhattan & NYC (5 boros) by major race/ethnicity: Foreign-born 29.4% & 35.9% White 54.4% & 44.7% Black 17.4% & 26.6% Asian 9.4% & 9.8% Hispanic (of any race) 27.2% & 27.0% I'm sure that by 2010 the numbers are skewed even higher for Hispanic and Asian. Explain to me where the diversity is missing. (Not you, but the article) Again, if you look at individual neighborhoods you will definitely find areas that are homogeneous, but as a whole NYC is about as diverse as it gets. Edited for spelling What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white. |
|
Posted 4/7/11 11:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by JAAMS Posted by BatGirl9910 Posted by acm1899 Posted by BatGirl9910 The article is flawed and uses flawed research. They don't define cities or metropolis, which means many "cities " were excluded..also they focus on blacks vs whites- what about Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, Indians, etc? Also, zero discussion of the fact that socioeconomic disparities are really the driving force between segregated neighborhoods, not race. Also I don't think the title is good. Most people like to live with people just like them, it doesn't mean they are racist or despise neighbors of other nationalities. After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here? I wouldn't say the article is flawed, but more often than not, when articles like this are published they don't really state what the parameters for the statistics are. First of all, "Nassau-Suffolk" is not even city, so I don't know how that got thrown in there. I'm sure that when they say 'metropolitan city' there is some sort of minimum population that they are referring to. Also, I'm trying to figure out how NYC is NOT a diverse city. Yes, there are neighborhoods which are predominantly one race or culture. But I can think of a bunch in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx which are very mixed...even Manhattan. I mean, are they talking about an entire city or just some neighborhoods? It's very unclear. And by the way, a neighborhood being all white, or all black, or all Chinese is not necessarily a bad thing. Have they ever thought that some groups want to live with one another? It doesn't mean that they don't include others, it just means some ethnicities tend to flock together for a various number of reasons. The real problem is when groups are purposely kept out of certain areas for whatever...but that is a totally different discussion.If you think about it, metropolitan cities, by their very nature, by the very fact that they generally offer more opportunities than smaller cities or towns, will always have more diversity than any smaller town can probably offer. Exactly, when I saw Nassau-Suffolk, my first reaction was "*** - these arent cities, they are suburbs of NYC...?!"...then i saw NYC was another category..which surprises me because NYC is as diverse as it gets!! Sure you have little ethnic enclaves like Little Italy, Chinatown, Spanish Harlem - but groups of people gravitate toward those areas because they want to be around neighbors who are culturally or economically similar to them...The only instance of outright racism I heard was DH's ex co-worker (old italian guy) who moved out of Richmond Hill, Queens to Amityville because he was "tired of seeing my block becoming full of Guyanese and Indians all over.." And to address the PP on the black baby avatar remark, I actually don't need to assume because the majority of the LIF boards ARE populated by certain demographics more than others..I am not saying its right or wrong, it is what it is..I dont need to assume anything - this 1 thread is a perfect example: http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-418600-2.html Out of 43 LIF posters on that thread, only FOUR identified themselves as non-caucasian (Indian/Trinidadian/African American). Oh, and take a look at the avatars too... Aren't you doing the same thing you are criticizing the study for using a thread of 43 posters as evidence for your argument? I was about to ask the same thing myself! |
|
Posted 4/7/11 11:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by Mici C What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white. Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim? Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin. |
|
Posted 4/7/11 11:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities I am sort of surprised NYC is on this list |
|
Posted 4/7/11 11:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by acm1899 Posted by Mici C What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white. Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim? Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin. I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white... And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc. |
|
Posted 4/7/11 11:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by WhatNow Posted by acm1899 Posted by Mici C What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white. Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim? Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin. I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white... And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc. I think this is all very well said. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 12:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Native Detroiter here... I opened the link and skipped ahead to #1 knowing we'd be there. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 12:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by WhatNow Posted by acm1899 Posted by Mici C What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white. Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim? Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin. I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white... And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc. I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all. Message edited 2011-04-08 00:15:51.917000. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 12:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities What about Juneau, Alaska. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 7:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by acm1899 Posted by cateyemm I didnt read the blurb, maybe i should. but I think when they said segregrated, they mean separated, whether by physical or economic division. I get what they mean by segregated, but check this out, these are figures off of Wikipedia for the 2000 Census (I guess the 2010 Census #'s aren't available yet) These are Demographics for Manhattan & NYC (5 boros) by major race/ethnicity: Foreign-born 29.4% & 35.9% White 54.4% & 44.7% Black 17.4% & 26.6% Asian 9.4% & 9.8% Hispanic (of any race) 27.2% & 27.0% I'm sure that by 2010 the numbers are skewed even higher for Hispanic and Asian. Explain to me where the diversity is missing. (Not you, but the article) Again, if you look at individual neighborhoods you will definitely find areas that are homogeneous, but as a whole NYC is about as diverse as it gets. Edited for spelling The point is that the fact that there is a distribution of races in the city doesn't equal diversity. You allude to different neighborhoods being homogeneous as an afterthought, but the fact is that diversity means neighborhoods that are mixed. If each neighborhood is homogeneous, that is a lack of diversity. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 7:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by WhatNow And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc. I don't disagree with you that people want to live next to their own. When we were looking for a place to live I really wanted to live where there were "some" african americans in the area. We live in Holbrook and while there aren't many aa, I love living here. The problem is when not only that you want to live next to your "own kind", its when you absolutely don't want to live with anyone else that isn't your kind. To the pp post about black avatars babies, I think you overlooked mine.
Message edited 2011-04-08 08:07:13.310000. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 8:05 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by lovemyfamily88 Posted by WhatNow Posted by acm1899 Posted by Mici C What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white. Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim? Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin. I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white... And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc. I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all. I don't think that's racist. It's like me saying I'd rather live in an italian neighborhood over a chinese or russian. I'm italian. I like italian food. I like italian bakeries. I fit in better there. I have nothing against chinese or russians. We all have different traditions and food. Is Italy racist against France because a bunch of italians live there? |
|
Posted 4/8/11 8:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by emilylives Posted by acm1899 Posted by cateyemm I didnt read the blurb, maybe i should. but I think when they said segregrated, they mean separated, whether by physical or economic division. I get what they mean by segregated, but check this out, these are figures off of Wikipedia for the 2000 Census (I guess the 2010 Census #'s aren't available yet) These are Demographics for Manhattan & NYC (5 boros) by major race/ethnicity: Foreign-born 29.4% & 35.9% White 54.4% & 44.7% Black 17.4% & 26.6% Asian 9.4% & 9.8% Hispanic (of any race) 27.2% & 27.0% I'm sure that by 2010 the numbers are skewed even higher for Hispanic and Asian. Explain to me where the diversity is missing. (Not you, but the article) Again, if you look at individual neighborhoods you will definitely find areas that are homogeneous, but as a whole NYC is about as diverse as it gets. Edited for spelling The point is that the fact that there is a distribution of races in the city doesn't equal diversity. You allude to different neighborhoods being homogeneous as an afterthought, but the fact is that diversity means neighborhoods that are mixed. If each neighborhood is homogeneous, that is a lack of diversity. But that is not the case in NYC. I live in NYC. I have eyes. I walk the streets. I see what's going on. Every neighborhood is not segregated. Does every single neighborhood have to be diverse in order for the city to be called diverse? If that's the case then diversity exists nowhere in this country. The article should have also published what it considers to be the least segregated cities. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by babybug631 Posted by lovemyfamily88 Posted by WhatNow I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white... And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc. I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all. I don't think that's racist. It's like me saying I'd rather live in an italian neighborhood over a chinese or russian. I'm italian. I like italian food. I like italian bakeries. I fit in better there. I have nothing against chinese or russians. We all have different traditions and food. Is Italy racist against France because a bunch of italians live there? Agreed, the context of her 'own kind' comment was def not racist. It's not like she said "Go and live with your own kind." Some people feel more comfortbale living amongst people who share a similar culture, similar beliefs, similar background. That does not make them racist. Message edited 2011-04-08 08:55:33.943000. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 8:54 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities At first I was surprised to see some of the cities mentioned, but when you think about it it makes sense. Take NYC for example, during the work hours it is an extremely diverse city but after 5 everyone goes back to their neighborhoods. I am from Queens and although we are "diverse" there are many more communities are that central to one particular race/culture vs everyone living together. Ex: Jackson Heights, Corona : Latin ; Flushing - Asian & Indian; Jamaica, Hollis: AA; Richmond Hill: West Indian. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:06 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by MySunshine At first I was surprised to see some of the cities mentioned, but when you think about it it makes sense. Take NYC for example, during the work hours it is an extremely diverse city but after 5 everyone goes back to their neighborhoods. I am from Queens and although we are "diverse" there are many more communities are that central to one particular race/culture vs everyone living together. Ex: Jackson Heights, Corona : Latin ; Flushing - Asian & Indian; Jamaica, Hollis: AA; Richmond Hill: West Indian. I don't think this means that other people are not welcomed to live there, but the majority happens to be of a specific ethnicity. To the PP that mentioned "lack of black babies".... you are right in that this is a predominantly board for White woman from LI, but there are other people that are here. I don't have a picture posted and that does not take away from the fact that I am Latina. We can't always judge by what the avatars say. ITA with every word. Especially the last two paragraphs. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities not at all suprised actually.. I expected Detroit to be up there.. and its actually #1.. I was there for a conference last year for a couple of days and I sensed a bit of it. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by babybug631 Posted by lovemyfamily88 Posted by WhatNow Posted by acm1899 Posted by Mici C What is considered foreign-born? Half of my family were born outside the US, yet they are white. Even if they are white, a foreign born person is still someone who emigrated to this country and would be considered 'diverse'. A person can be born in Norway and be ethnically 'white' however they are still culturally different, kwim? Diversity is not just about the color of someone's skin. I am glad someone said that. It's not all about color. I hate it when people use the word 'white' and sweep absolutely everyone under that term. I am a Jewish girl born and raised in Russia and my neighbor is an Irish Catholic from Ohio. Are we as different from each other as can be? Apparently not because hey, as per census bureau, we are both white... And to address the OP: I honestly don't see the big deal with this situation. People like to live next to their own kind. There is NOTHING wring with that. We are currently contemplating moving out of NY and the first thing I want to know about the area is if there is a Russian Jewish community in a potential location. The instinct to stay next to one's own kind is the reason we have wonderfully colorful and culturally rich places like Jackson Heights, Little Italy, China Town, etc. I'm sorry but your "own kind" comment is such a racist thing to say. I don't agree with you at all. I don't think that's racist. It's like me saying I'd rather live in an italian neighborhood over a chinese or russian. I'm italian. I like italian food. I like italian bakeries. I fit in better there. I have nothing against chinese or russians. We all have different traditions and food. Is Italy racist against France because a bunch of italians live there? Maybe racist wasn't the right word. Just to be clear I do not feel the poster who I quoted is racist, I just feel that that segregated mentality leads to many issues. I didn't like the own kind comment because I am also Russian/Jewish. My husband is German/Catholic. I heard a comment from someone prior to getting married, that I should stick with my own kind. I hate that mentality and to me its wrong. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Someone actually said to my DH a few years back, "I live in ...., the only all white town left on Long Island." |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Since when do we compare entire counties to cities? |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by snowprincess I am not surprised by log island but i am surprised boston is not on the list you can see in history when exctly whites pulled out of the boston district - when separate but equal was declared unconsitutioal - it is a very white city but whites are the minority in the public school and the schools are in terrible shape except for the test schools Same thing happened in Detroit. White flight to the burbs left Detroit with a horrible tax base and now today middle-class African Americans are getting out of there asap. Leaving Detroit school dealing with a graduation rate that is in the teens |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by jerseypanda Someone actually said to my DH a few years back, "I live in ...., the only all white town left on Long Island." I can't remember what town he said he lived in. And he said it to DH as if he were PROUD of it! Little did he know that my DH has african american and native american in his background (he looks completely white) and he was completely offending my DH. He just walked away and rolled his eyes. It wasn't even worth it to DH to get into it with this guy. I come across encounters like this ALL the time.. I look white but i'm hispanic.. ;/ I'm not surprised by this list and just by reading some of the threads we've had in the past on this forum alone, it's clear that that is how it is here. |
|
Posted 4/8/11 9:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities Posted by MySunshine To the PP that mentioned "lack of black babies".... you are right in that this is a predominantly board for White woman from LI, but there are other people that are here. We can't always judge by what the avatars say. ITA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|
Posted 4/8/11 10:12 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| America's Next Top Model | Janice | 10/12/05 | 10 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| America's Next Top Model | KaRiSsA | 9/28/05 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Only in America | Elbee | 9/21/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Iron Chef America - with Chicken | NASP09 | 8/5/05 | 0 | Dining In or Out |
| America's Riskiest Real Estate - Nassau/Suffolk #2 | Leeners | 8/4/05 | 14 | Home |
| Does anyone use America's Choice diapers or wipes? | LIMOMx2 | 7/30/05 | 8 | Parenting |



Yes, there are neighborhoods which are predominantly one race or culture. But I can think of a bunch in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx which are very mixed...even Manhattan. I mean, are they talking about an entire city or just some neighborhoods? It's very unclear. And by the way, a neighborhood being all white, or all black, or all Chinese is not necessarily a bad thing. Have they ever thought that some groups want to live with one another? It doesn't mean that they don't include others, it just means some ethnicities tend to flock together for a various number of reasons. The real problem is when groups are purposely kept out of certain areas for whatever...but that is a totally different discussion.













