America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/07/americas-10-most-segregated-cities_n_845092.html?icid=maing-grid7%7Cmain5%7Cdl12%7Csec1_lnk3%7C54790#s261024&title=10_NassauSuffolk_New

Anyone care to discuss? Are you surprised at the cities mentioned? Do you think it's a problem? or are people making a big deal out of nothing? Interested in hearing opinions if anyone isn't afraid to do so? Is there anything that can be done for Long Island to be less segregated.

For me I totally expected to see Long Island on the list, but was surprised that it was #10. I somehow thought it was worse than this. This makes me feel a little better that we are just one city away from completly missing the list. I generally see race get thrown in when discussing towns her on Long Island and I generally don't participate. Having a son here on LI, I want desperately for him to experience diversity outside of his family. Only time will tell as we have no plans on leaving.

Posted 4/7/11 8:34 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I saw this list a bit earlier, and I was shocked that Long Island was number 10. I really thought it was going to be in the top 5.

I do think it's sad, and I think the separation causes many problems that just do not exist in this degree elsewhere. That being said, I have no suggestion as to how to fix it. I absolutely do not think that merely changing attitudes is enough. Racial segregation is a problem so deeply rooted in this land mass, that I really don't know what the solution is.

Posted 4/7/11 8:44 PM
 

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I live in Milwaukee, Wisconsin and I knew that we were going to be pretty high on this list--turns out we're #2. Chat Icon Terrible.

Posted 4/7/11 8:46 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Not suprised. Diversity was the #1 reason I moved out of LI.

Posted 4/7/11 8:53 PM
 

AngnShaun
Sisters

Member since 1/10

21015 total posts

Name:
Ang

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

im not surprised that LI was on it... i am surprised about Detroit, St. Louis & NY

Posted 4/7/11 8:57 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Really? It doesn't make me feel better at all that we are 10 considering it's not a true "city" as some of the others mentioned. I do find it interesting though that most of the cities listed were in the north as opposed to the south...

Posted 4/7/11 8:58 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I don't know how something like this can be repairedChat Icon

Posted 4/7/11 9:03 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I'm a little surprised actually. I'm from Bay Shore, my husband is from Canarsie, Brooklyn... Our areas were/are pretty diverse. I don't know about the others mentioned.

Posted 4/7/11 9:06 PM
 

sunnygirl
loving life

Member since 1/07

5413 total posts

Name:
D

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

i cant speak for li too much cause i dont live there but from what i know not too surprised and new york city if it means all the boroughts doesn't surprise me one bit, yes there are a few diverse neighborhoods but i think the majority of neighborhoods are very much one culture/race and not diverse at all

Posted 4/7/11 9:24 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by sunnygirl

i cant speak for li too much cause i dont live there but from what i know not too surprised and new york city if it means all the boroughts doesn't surprise me one bit, yes there are a few diverse neighborhoods but i think the majority of neighborhoods are very much one culture/race and not diverse at all



That's a good point. I was thinking NYC was one of the most divese areas but in my mind i was thinking of Manhattan, but you are right, Queens, brooklyn, bronx and staten Island do not have much diveristiy as I thought.

Posted 4/7/11 9:27 PM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

The article is flawed and uses flawed research. They don't define cities or metropolis, which means many "cities " were excluded..also they focus on blacks vs whites- what about Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, Indians, etc? Also, zero discussion of the fact that socioeconomic disparities are really the driving force between segregated neighborhoods, not race.

Also I don't think the title is good. Most people like to live with people just like them, it doesn't mean they are racist or despise neighbors of other nationalities. After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?

Posted 4/7/11 10:10 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I'm not surprised. There were very few "minorities" where I grew up. I now live in Manhattan and it seems to be worse...It makes me very sad to honestChat Icon

Posted 4/7/11 10:11 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by BatGirl9910
After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?



Umm, WHAT?!

1) Not everyone puts their child in their avatar.

2) How can you know what race someone is by what they are posting. There is no way to know what the races are on here.

I was with you until this part.

Message edited 2011-04-07 22:23:23.473000.

Posted 4/7/11 10:22 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

This is why I want to get the eff off of LI!

I want my Son to be in a more diverse community. I want him to grow up knowing and appreciating all different races/cultures, etc.

Posted 4/7/11 10:25 PM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by MamaLeen

Posted by BatGirl9910
After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?



Umm, WHAT?!

1) Not everyone puts their child in their avatar.

2) How can you know what race someone is by what they are posting. There is no way to know what the races are on here.

I was with you until this part.




Relax, the comment was made tongue in cheek..the point is that the article is flawed precisely because only a few empirical observations are being made based on limited data. There is a lot of diversity on LIF but it's easy to assume only whites are posting because the avatars (of those who choose to post themselves or their babies) tend to white as well. This just proves my point.

Posted 4/7/11 10:25 PM
 

snowprincess
My happy babies

Member since 3/06

3428 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I am not surprised by log island but i am surprised boston is not on the list


you can see in history when exctly whites pulled out of the boston district - when separate but equal was declared unconsitutioal - it is a very white city but whites are the minority in the public school and the schools are in terrible shape except for the test schools

Posted 4/7/11 10:26 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by BatGirl9910

Posted by MamaLeen

Posted by BatGirl9910
After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?



Umm, WHAT?!

1) Not everyone puts their child in their avatar.

2) How can you know what race someone is by what they are posting. There is no way to know what the races are on here.

I was with you until this part.




Relax, the comment was made tongue in cheek..the point is that the article is flawed precisely because only a few empirical observations are being made based on limited data. There is a lot of diversity on LIF but it's easy to assume only whites are posting because the avatars (of those who choose to post themselves or their babies) tend to white as well. This just proves my point.



First don't tell me to relax. Chat Icon Thanks.

It is funny how you picked apart a study and the details but then make a broad generalization about the avatars here as if it is the truth.

Oh and you know what happens when you assume, right?

Posted 4/7/11 10:27 PM
 

acm1899
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

1085 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by BatGirl9910

The article is flawed and uses flawed research. They don't define cities or metropolis, which means many "cities " were excluded..also they focus on blacks vs whites- what about Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, Indians, etc? Also, zero discussion of the fact that socioeconomic disparities are really the driving force between segregated neighborhoods, not race.

Also I don't think the title is good. Most people like to live with people just like them, it doesn't mean they are racist or despise neighbors of other nationalities. After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?



I wouldn't say the article is flawed, but more often than not, when articles like this are published they don't really state what the parameters for the statistics are.

First of all, "Nassau-Suffolk" is not even city, so I don't know how that got thrown in there. I'm sure that when they say 'metropolitan city' there is some sort of minimum population that they are referring to.

Also, I'm trying to figure out how NYC is NOT a diverse city. Chat Icon Yes, there are neighborhoods which are predominantly one race or culture. But I can think of a bunch in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx which are very mixed...even Manhattan. I mean, are they talking about an entire city or just some neighborhoods? It's very unclear. And by the way, a neighborhood being all white, or all black, or all Chinese is not necessarily a bad thing. Have they ever thought that some groups want to live with one another? It doesn't mean that they don't include others, it just means some ethnicities tend to flock together for a various number of reasons. The real problem is when groups are purposely kept out of certain areas for whatever...but that is a totally different discussion.

If you think about it, metropolitan cities, by their very nature, by the very fact that they generally offer more opportunities than smaller cities or towns, will always have more diversity than any smaller town can probably offer.

Posted 4/7/11 10:38 PM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by acm1899

Posted by BatGirl9910

The article is flawed and uses flawed research. They don't define cities or metropolis, which means many "cities " were excluded..also they focus on blacks vs whites- what about Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, Indians, etc? Also, zero discussion of the fact that socioeconomic disparities are really the driving force between segregated neighborhoods, not race.

Also I don't think the title is good. Most people like to live with people just like them, it doesn't mean they are racist or despise neighbors of other nationalities. After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?



I wouldn't say the article is flawed, but more often than not, when articles like this are published they don't really state what the parameters for the statistics are.

First of all, "Nassau-Suffolk" is not even city, so I don't know how that got thrown in there. I'm sure that when they say 'metropolitan city' there is some sort of minimum population that they are referring to.

Also, I'm trying to figure out how NYC is NOT a diverse city. Chat Icon Yes, there are neighborhoods which are predominantly one race or culture. But I can think of a bunch in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx which are very mixed...even Manhattan. I mean, are they talking about an entire city or just some neighborhoods? It's very unclear. And by the way, a neighborhood being all white, or all black, or all Chinese is not necessarily a bad thing. Have they ever thought that some groups want to live with one another? It doesn't mean that they don't include others, it just means some ethnicities tend to flock together for a various number of reasons. The real problem is when groups are purposely kept out of certain areas for whatever...but that is a totally different discussion.

If you think about it, metropolitan cities, by their very nature, by the very fact that they generally offer more opportunities than smaller cities or towns, will always have more diversity than any smaller town can probably offer.



Exactly, when I saw Nassau-Suffolk, my first reaction was "*** - these arent cities, they are suburbs of NYC...?!"...then i saw NYC was another category..which surprises me because NYC is as diverse as it gets!! Sure you have little ethnic enclaves like Little Italy, Chinatown, Spanish Harlem - but groups of people gravitate toward those areas because they want to be around neighbors who are culturally or economically similar to them...The only instance of outright racism I heard was DH's ex co-worker (old italian guy) who moved out of Richmond Hill, Queens to Amityville because he was "tired of seeing my block becoming full of Guyanese and Indians all over.."

And to address the PP on the black baby avatar remark, I actually don't need to assume because the majority of the LIF boards ARE populated by certain demographics more than others..I am not saying its right or wrong, it is what it is..I dont need to assume anything - this 1 thread is a perfect example:

http://www.lifamilies.com/chat/topic-418600-2.html

Out of 43 LIF posters on that thread, only FOUR identified themselves as non-caucasian (Indian/Trinidadian/African American). Oh, and take a look at the avatars too...

Posted 4/7/11 10:44 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by acm1899

Posted by BatGirl9910

The article is flawed and uses flawed research. They don't define cities or metropolis, which means many "cities " were excluded..also they focus on blacks vs whites- what about Asians, Hispanics, Muslims, Indians, etc? Also, zero discussion of the fact that socioeconomic disparities are really the driving force between segregated neighborhoods, not race.

Also I don't think the title is good. Most people like to live with people just like them, it doesn't mean they are racist or despise neighbors of other nationalities. After all, look at LIF and the predominant folks who are posting in this board for proof of this, when was the last time you saw a black baby avatar on here?



I wouldn't say the article is flawed, but more often than not, when articles like this are published they don't really state what the parameters for the statistics are.

First of all, "Nassau-Suffolk" is not even city, so I don't know how that got thrown in there. I'm sure that when they say 'metropolitan city' there is some sort of minimum population that they are referring to.

Also, I'm trying to figure out how NYC is NOT a diverse city. Chat Icon Yes, there are neighborhoods which are predominantly one race or culture. But I can think of a bunch in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx which are very mixed...even Manhattan. I mean, are they talking about an entire city or just some neighborhoods? It's very unclear. And by the way, a neighborhood being all white, or all black, or all Chinese is not necessarily a bad thing. Have they ever thought that some groups want to live with one another? It doesn't mean that they don't include others, it just means some ethnicities tend to flock together for a various number of reasons. The real problem is when groups are purposely kept out of certain areas for whatever...but that is a totally different discussion.

If you think about it, metropolitan cities, by their very nature, by the very fact that they generally offer more opportunities than smaller cities or towns, will always have more diversity than any smaller town can probably offer.



I didnt read the blurb, maybe i should. but I think when they said segregrated, they mean separated, whether by physical or economic division.

And batgirl, Im sure you'd be pleasantly suprised at the diversity on this board. these are things you cant assume by looking at a bunch of 1/2 inch pictures.

Posted 4/7/11 10:45 PM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by cateyemm

Posted ...

Posted by ...

............

And batgirl, Im sure you'd be pleasantly suprised at the diversity on this board. these are things you cant assume by looking at a bunch of 1/2 inch pictures.



Oh I know that!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I find it amusing that it struck someone the wrong way, when it was meant more as a sarcastic response than anything else...Well thats the internet for ya!

I think its time to create a poll asking about LIF's nationality/racial backgrounds...I would love to see the results!Chat Icon


Posted 4/7/11 10:51 PM
 

MrsG823
Just call me Mommy.

Member since 1/11

5570 total posts

Name:
S

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I do not think the article is trying to say NYC is not diverse it is saying as a city it is still segregated. I think there is some truth to this...been to China town lately? Same goes for the outer boroughs...I live in the Bronx and it is VERY segregated. When I first moved here I was questioned a lot by friends and some family then when I told them exactly where I was living they were like OH that is not really the Bronx Chat Icon My address says Bronx. The segregation bothers me but I agree with the poster who said it is likely due to socioeconomic circumstances. Sad but true even in 2011.

Posted 4/7/11 10:52 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by BatGirl9910

Posted by cateyemm

Posted ...

Posted by ...

............

And batgirl, Im sure you'd be pleasantly suprised at the diversity on this board. these are things you cant assume by looking at a bunch of 1/2 inch pictures.



Oh I know that!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I find it amusing that it struck someone the wrong way, when it was meant more as a sarcastic response than anything else...Well thats the internet for ya!

I think its time to create a poll asking about LIF's nationality/racial backgrounds...I would love to see the results!Chat Icon



Just dont be upset with the results. Since Nassau/Suffolk are in the top 10, LIF might reflect a lack of diversity. That said, growing up in LI, I found a LOT of diversity but it was, like confirmed in the article, segregated.

Now if it was QueensFamilies.com, we'd have a different story Chat Icon
This is who lives on the floor of my apt buidling- a bangledeshi family of four; a french family; a mexican dad and german mom with the cutest little baby bug (who looks white btw); an older gay gentleman from Ireland; and a caucasian girl and her dominican husband. Chat Icon


Posted 4/7/11 10:56 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

I'm not surprised. The neighborhoods both here and in the city are, for the most part, very separate. There were very few minorities in my HS growing up. And when I lived in Brooklyn, you could literally see where one race/culture ended and where the other began. It's crazy!

I definately think there is more tolerance for other races/cultures here in NY compared to down south. I went to school down there, and I was uncomfortable with the segregation down there. It was weird.

ETA I worked in sales in Brooklyn. I had about 6 zip codes. Boro Park (hasidic jew), Sunset Park (half latin american, some chinese), Bayridge (italian), Dyker Heights (italian), and a little of Bensonhurst (italian and russian). Didn't do much business in Boro Park.

Message edited 2011-04-07 23:05:07.667000.

Posted 4/7/11 10:59 PM
 

acm1899
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

1085 total posts

Name:

Re: America's 10 Most Segregated Cities

Posted by cateyemm

I didnt read the blurb, maybe i should. but I think when they said segregrated, they mean separated, whether by physical or economic division.



I get what they mean by segregated, but check this out, these are figures off of Wikipedia for the 2000 Census (I guess the 2010 Census #'s aren't available yet)

These are Demographics for Manhattan & NYC (5 boros) by major race/ethnicity:

Foreign-born 29.4% & 35.9%
White 54.4% & 44.7%
Black 17.4% & 26.6%
Asian 9.4% & 9.8%
Hispanic (of any race) 27.2% & 27.0%

I'm sure that by 2010 the numbers are skewed even higher for Hispanic and Asian. Explain to me where the diversity is missing. (Not you, but the article)
Again, if you look at individual neighborhoods you will definitely find areas that are homogeneous, but as a whole NYC is about as diverse as it gets.

Edited for spelling

Message edited 2011-04-07 23:02:33.803000.

Posted 4/7/11 11:00 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
America's Next Top Model Janice 10/12/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
America's Next Top Model KaRiSsA 9/28/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Only in America Elbee 9/21/05 5 Families Helping Families ™
Iron Chef America - with Chicken NASP09 8/5/05 0 Dining In or Out
America's Riskiest Real Estate - Nassau/Suffolk #2 Leeners 8/4/05 14 Home
Does anyone use America's Choice diapers or wipes? LIMOMx2 7/30/05 8 Parenting