*2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

yes, i want to know what happens with this...

Posted 5/8/11 2:52 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Kahuna
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

497 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

No, this is not right. You have a case of insurance fraud. Call the doctor AND the insurance company.

FTR, for a "regular adult cleaning" (D1110) I give my hygienists 60 minutes. They do radiographs if needed, periodontal probing, scale (that's what scalers are for), polish, fluoride varnish if needed, oral cancer check, and homecare education. If they did all that in 25 minutes, I'd be angry. You can not do quality adequate prophies in 25/30 minutes. Offices that are prophy mills do this, they are driven by the insurance dollars.


Scaling and root-planing

Carol Tekavec, RDH

The new ADA Current Dental Terminology CDT-3 lists a revised description and a new code number for perio scaling. D4341-Periodontal Scaling and Root-Planing, per quadrant, is described as involving "instrumentation of the crown and root surfaces of the teeth to remove plaque and calculus from these surfaces. It is indicated for patients with periodontal disease and is therapeutic, not prophylactic, in nature.

"Root-planing is the definitive procedure designed for the removal of cementum and dentin that is rough and/or permeated by calculus or contaminated with toxins or micro-organisms. Some soft-tissue removal occurs. This procedure may be used as a definitive treatment in some stages of periodontal disease and/or as a part of presurgical procedures in others."

The description revision involves the words "and/or" in the last sentence. In the CDT-2, the word used was simply "and." While the revision is not considerable, it does highlight the dual nature of perio scaling and root-planing. "Perio scaling and root-planing" are both a final treatment and a pretreatment, depending on the condition of each patient and his or her acceptance of referral care.

More and more dentists and hygienists are using periodontal scaling and root-planing as treatments to help patients control their periodontal disease. Unfortunately, many offices also run into insurance-benefit problems. While most indemnity carriers cover D4341, restrictions and requirements for payment are abundant. Some of these are:

* Many carriers have a "minimum-tooth" eligibility for full-quadrant benefits to apply. Most require at least five involved teeth per quadrant. (If fewer than five teeth need root-planing, the quadrant can be reported as a fraction. For example; 4/5 of a quadrant for four teeth, 3/5 of a quadrant for three teeth, etc.)

* Most carriers want to have an American Academy of Periodontology case Type written on the claim form. Procedures falling under Case Type III-Moderate Periodontitis through Case Type V-Refractory Periodontitis, usually are considered for benefits.

* Detailed, progressive charting of probing depths, recession, bleeding, mobility, and furcations are important. When an office can document several visits where probing depths have deepened and/or other conditions have worsened, the insurance carrier can verify a current disease condition. One probing appointment can reveal that periodontal disease has occurred. Carriers increasingly want documentation of an existing and ongoing disease process.

* Probing depths should be combined with information showing "loss of attachment." For example, this means that a tooth demonstrating 2mm of recession and 4mm pockets actually has a 6mm "loss of attachment." Most carriers will not pay a benefit for teeth with pocket depths or loss of attachment of less than 5mm.

* Payment for D4341 usually is based on four separate quadrants, once every two years. Some carriers increase the time requirement to four quadrants only once every 36 months.

* "Time spent" may be a requirement. Many carriers will pay a better benefit for a one- - or, at the most - a two-quadrant procedure performed at one appointment. A lower benefit is paid toward a full-mouth or four-quadrant procedure accomplished in one day. If a patient requires a full-mouth, four-quadrant treatment for whatever reason, the office should provide a written narrative indicating the amount of time spent on each quadrant. (Insurance carriers usually expect a minimum of 45-50 minutes per quadrant.)

* Currently, "gross scaling" in advance of D4341 is not believed to be routinely appropriate. Gross scaling is an incomplete scaling. Some healing and resolution of tissues is likely over incompletely removed deposits, but adequate resolution is not possible. Subsequent manipulation of the tissues for "fine scaling" may cause pain, lacerations of the sulcus, and possible disruption of the attachment apparatus. Code D4355-Full Mouth Debridement to Enable Comprehensive Periodontal Evaluation and Diagnosis, prior to D4341, may be appropriate in certain isolated cases. However, it is not considered to be a viable, routine, "standard-of-care" treatment modality. Current thinking indicates that D4341-Periodontal Scaling and Root-Planing should be utilized as a first treatment, rather than a second or "final" scaling treatment.

Carol Tekavec, RDH, is the author of a new insurance-coding manual, co-designer of a dental chart, and a national lecturer with the ADA Seminar Series. Contact her at (800) 548-2164 or at www.steppingstonetosuccess.com.

Posted 5/8/11 3:04 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by Kahuna




thank you very much. it's all code D4341 (4 times) on my bill. and it's def. not what was done, nor what was done last year. after I get this sorted out it's time to find a new dentist.

i will keep everyone posted and thanks to all.

Posted 5/8/11 3:38 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

I have met life also I am covered for a cleaning everyb6 months. The dentist should have told u what they were doing. I would call them, maybe they submitted it wrong...

Posted 5/8/11 6:44 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by Kahuna

FTR, for a "regular adult cleaning" (D1110) I give my hygienists 60 minutes. They do radiographs if needed, periodontal probing, scale (that's what scalers are for), polish, fluoride varnish if needed, oral cancer check, and homecare education. If they did all that in 25 minutes, I'd be angry. You can not do quality adequate prophies in 25/30 minutes. Offices that are prophy mills do this, they are driven by the insurance dollars.





Chat Icon Chat Icon Absolutely!

Posted 5/9/11 7:02 AM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Call the dentist and explain - it sounds like they miscoded (although they would've done it both times since you have had it 2x in the past 24 months...)

Message edited 2011-05-09 11:53:33.403000.

Posted 5/9/11 11:52 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

bump for update...

Posted 5/10/11 11:39 AM
 

MrsSpring
I'm a lucky mama

Member since 1/10

7585 total posts

Name:
L

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

how did they bill it out last time you got it done?
i think you need a new dentist.
i had problems when i went for sonos the dr claims i got a consult when i did not. there was no way i was paying for something i didnt get.
they def messed with the wrong person on this one.

Posted 5/10/11 11:53 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by MrsSpring

how did they bill it out last time you got it done?
i think you need a new dentist.
i had problems when i went for sonos the dr claims i got a consult when i did not. there was no way i was paying for something i didnt get.
they def messed with the wrong person on this one.



they billed the same thing last time - but the thing was, i didn't even notice because the insurance covered everything...

Posted 5/10/11 12:09 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by Bearcat

****UPDATE:
Just spoke with dentist's office. When I called, I gave my name and she said "oh, yes... I'm going to put you on hold" - like she was expecting my call...

Anyway she claims that she goes through this with patients all the time, and that there are 2 different procedures that fall under one code (D4341) - perio scaling and root planing. According to her, I had the scaling done, and this is still submitted to insurance under D4341, even though I did not have root planing. She said the dentist does scaling routinely with every prophy and it's always submitted this way, it just happens that my insurance plan doesn't cover it more than 1x every 24 months. Most insurance plans apparently cover it more frequently.

She offered me a "professional courtesy" of half off.

I told her I would speak with metlife and get back to her. I'm still not convinced.

Thoughts? For those of you in the field, do you do scaling with every appointment AND submit it to ins. under D4341 perio scale & root planing?

thank you!!!! you have all been so helpful!

ETA: i told her my ins. co asked if they were taking numbers, etc. and she oh yes we sent those over when they asked for them and the x-rays .... i didn't have x-rays... and i thought the number thing was part of the root planing (which she acknowledged i didn't have...)???!!
________________________________





they are scamming.

From the 2011 CDT book
4321 ".....It Is indicated for patients with periodontal disease and is therapeutic, not prophylactic in nature...."
So if they took measurements and your pockets were more than 4 mm YOU HAVE PERIODONTAL DISEASE and that should have been heavily discussed with you.
Additionally you can not do "just the scaling" part. ADA codes cannot be broken down ala carte.
All of the dental professionals that responded here are in agreement that 4 quads of scaling & root planing CANNOT be performed in 25 minutes effectively.
Ask them to email of fax you the periodontal charting(the measurements)
It makes sense that Metlife won't pay it, because if you had perio treatment (scaling & Root planing) last year the expectation is that you would become a perio maintenance patient and be seen 3 or 4 times per year by the hygienist. Regardless of what insurance companies think is appropriate treatment, your dentist still has a legal obligation to acquire your informed consent.
The professional courtesy is trying to make you feel better and not pursue it, but that's bullsh*t. I cannot believe the doctor did not get on the phone and explain to you why you needed the procedure. For his staff member to say "he scales everyone" doesn't make it better.

Message edited 2011-05-10 12:23:46.577000.

Posted 5/10/11 12:16 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by KellyFG

Posted by Bearcat

****UPDATE:
Just spoke with dentist's office. When I called, I gave my name and she said "oh, yes... I'm going to put you on hold" - like she was expecting my call...

Anyway she claims that she goes through this with patients all the time, and that there are 2 different procedures that fall under one code (D4341) - perio scaling and root planing. According to her, I had the scaling done, and this is still submitted to insurance under D4341, even though I did not have root planing. She said the dentist does scaling routinely with every prophy and it's always submitted this way, it just happens that my insurance plan doesn't cover it more than 1x every 24 months. Most insurance plans apparently cover it more frequently.

She offered me a "professional courtesy" of half off.

I told her I would speak with metlife and get back to her. I'm still not convinced.

Thoughts? For those of you in the field, do you do scaling with every appointment AND submit it to ins. under D4341 perio scale & root planing?

thank you!!!! you have all been so helpful!

ETA: i told her my ins. co asked if they were taking numbers, etc. and she oh yes we sent those over when they asked for them and the x-rays .... i didn't have x-rays... and i thought the number thing was part of the root planing (which she acknowledged i didn't have...)???!!
________________________________





they are scamming.

From the 2011 CDT book
4321 ".....It Is indicated for patients with periodontal disease and is therapeutic, not prophylactic in nature...."
So if they took measurements and your pockets were more than 3 or 4 mm YOU HAVE PERIODONTAL DISEASE and that should have been heavily discussed with you.
Additionally you can not do "just the scaling" part. ADA codes cannot be broken down ala carte.
All of the dental professionals that responded here are in agreement that 4 quads of scaling & root planing CANNOT be performed in 25 minutes effectively.
Ask them to email of fax you the periodontal charting(the measurements)
It makes sense that Metlife won't pay it, because if you had perio treatment (scaling & Root planing) last year the expectation is that you would become a perio maintenance patient and be seen 3 or 4 times per year by the hygienist. Regardless of what insurance companies think is appropriate treatment, your dentist still has a legal obligation to acquire your informed consent.
The professional courtesy is trying to make you feel better and not pursue it, but that's bullsh*t. I cannot believe the doctor did not get on the phone and explain to you why you needed the procedure. For his staff member to say "he scales everyone" doesn't make it better.



i argued politely with her that it couldn't possibly be the same code etc. and she insisted that they do it all the time and then she said she didn't want to "go back and forth" with me.
she also said she has to deal with this ALL the time with patients, explaning it, and it's very frustrating....

i don't get how you can bill "scaling" that's part of a routine cleaning, and "root planing" that is obviously more extensive, under the SAME code. i said that to her and she told me thats how it is. i told her that's not what my ins. co. said, and she said well "that's the insurance game."

i'm really frustrated...

Posted 5/10/11 12:24 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

I've been in the field since I was 14. I was an asst for 7 years and practicing hygienist 11 years now. It's a total CROCK!!! They are insurance coding for profit! I am at work now and I just asked our receptionist who has been in the field for 20 plus years and she agrees....SCAM Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/10/11 1:10 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by Bearcat

Posted by KellyFG

Posted by Bearcat

****UPDATE:
Just spoke with dentist's office. When I called, I gave my name and she said "oh, yes... I'm going to put you on hold" - like she was expecting my call...

Anyway she claims that she goes through this with patients all the time, and that there are 2 different procedures that fall under one code (D4341) - perio scaling and root planing. According to her, I had the scaling done, and this is still submitted to insurance under D4341, even though I did not have root planing. She said the dentist does scaling routinely with every prophy and it's always submitted this way, it just happens that my insurance plan doesn't cover it more than 1x every 24 months. Most insurance plans apparently cover it more frequently.

She offered me a "professional courtesy" of half off.

I told her I would speak with metlife and get back to her. I'm still not convinced.

Thoughts? For those of you in the field, do you do scaling with every appointment AND submit it to ins. under D4341 perio scale & root planing?

thank you!!!! you have all been so helpful!

ETA: i told her my ins. co asked if they were taking numbers, etc. and she oh yes we sent those over when they asked for them and the x-rays .... i didn't have x-rays... and i thought the number thing was part of the root planing (which she acknowledged i didn't have...)???!!
________________________________





they are scamming.

From the 2011 CDT book
4321 ".....It Is indicated for patients with periodontal disease and is therapeutic, not prophylactic in nature...."
So if they took measurements and your pockets were more than 3 or 4 mm YOU HAVE PERIODONTAL DISEASE and that should have been heavily discussed with you.
Additionally you can not do "just the scaling" part. ADA codes cannot be broken down ala carte.
All of the dental professionals that responded here are in agreement that 4 quads of scaling & root planing CANNOT be performed in 25 minutes effectively.
Ask them to email of fax you the periodontal charting(the measurements)
It makes sense that Metlife won't pay it, because if you had perio treatment (scaling & Root planing) last year the expectation is that you would become a perio maintenance patient and be seen 3 or 4 times per year by the hygienist. Regardless of what insurance companies think is appropriate treatment, your dentist still has a legal obligation to acquire your informed consent.
The professional courtesy is trying to make you feel better and not pursue it, but that's bullsh*t. I cannot believe the doctor did not get on the phone and explain to you why you needed the procedure. For his staff member to say "he scales everyone" doesn't make it better.



i argued politely with her that it couldn't possibly be the same code etc. and she insisted that they do it all the time and then she said she didn't want to "go back and forth" with me.
she also said she has to deal with this ALL the time with patients, explaning it, and it's very frustrating....

i don't get how you can bill "scaling" that's part of a routine cleaning, and "root planing" that is obviously more extensive, under the SAME code. i said that to her and she told me thats how it is. i told her that's not what my ins. co. said, and she said well "that's the insurance game."

i'm really frustrated...



Call her back and flat out tell her you suspect fraud and you will call your insurance company about it.

Posted 5/10/11 1:15 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

The description for D1110 states, "A dental prophylaxis performed on transitional or permanent dentition that includes scaling and/or polishing procedures to remove coronal plaque, calculus, and stains." The previous definition (CDT-3) stated, "A dental prophylaxis performed on transitional or permanent dentition which includes scaling and polishing procedures to remove coronal plaque, calculus, and stains. Some patients may require more than one appointment or one extended appointment to complete a prophylaxis. Document need for additional time or appointments."


Send this explanation back with their bill and tell them to drop the charges or you will report them immediately!! A general prophylaxis includes scaling already!! I am soooo mad for you!!
Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-05-10 13:57:28.037000.

Posted 5/10/11 1:55 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

This story keeps getting more infuriating! Insurance is NOT a game, actually it's very serious business governed under federal law and in the last few years dentists in various states have actually been convicted of insurance fraud and sent to jail.
I highly suggest you contact the NYS office of professions, I FMd you that info the other day.
When you are ready, let me know what area you are in and I will recommend an office to you that will not play these games.
I really would LOVE to get my hands on this dentist right now. This is the exact reason why dentists are mandated to take an ethics course now, a few bad apples will spoil the whole bunch!

Posted 5/10/11 2:06 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Thank you everyone, again - truly appreciate all the advice. I am going to call my ins co and tell them about the conversation I had with the receptionist. After that the next step will be writing a letter (should I put it on my letterhead or is that too obnoxious?) citing to the definitions of the treatment as well as what the receptionist told me on the phone and perhaps also what the insurance company says (if applicable).



Posted 5/10/11 2:13 PM
 

MrsBurtch525
Year for change!

Member since 1/09

6017 total posts

Name:
Taryn

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

That is a load of bull! Don't let them scam you over this and that is exactly what they are doing, even if they "say" you had the scaling done there is NO WAY it can properly be done within 25-30 minutes so regardless they are trying to scam you out of money or trying to get paid for shotty work...fight it to the bitter end! Def find a new dentist....call the insurance and explain what she said to you, what you know you had done and see what they can advise you to do. And for that receptionist to say "she wouldn't go back and forth with you" was very unprofessional. Offices who do crap like this just infuriate me! How i would love to give them a piece of my dental mind....

Posted 5/10/11 4:10 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

I just hung up the phone with ins. co.
Rep was not happy.
He wants me to send back the EOB from this year and last with a notation of what wasn't provided and they will send me some forms to open an investigation.

I told him that I was informed by dentist office that ins co requested documentation and that the dentist's office sent it over but still denied the claim. Asked him if he could verify that. He plainly said "no... we did not request anything from them at all."
I'm like "so she lied" and he's like "well... yeah."

Nice.

Posted 5/10/11 4:36 PM
 

Kahuna
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

497 total posts

Name:

Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by KellyFG

This story keeps getting more infuriating! Insurance is NOT a game, actually it's very serious business governed under federal law and in the last few years dentists in various states have actually been convicted of insurance fraud and sent to jail.
I highly suggest you contact the NYS office of professions, I FMd you that info the other day.
When you are ready, let me know what area you are in and I will recommend an office to you that will not play these games.
I really would LOVE to get my hands on this dentist right now. This is the exact reason why dentists are mandated to take an ethics course now, a few bad apples will spoil the whole bunch!



Kelly is right. You need to contact the NYS Dental Board also. Dentists and staffs who play "insurance games" need to be caught and punished. Their fraudulent billing and treatment costs everyone.

Posted 5/10/11 4:37 PM
 

FreeButterfly
hum...

Member since 5/05

6263 total posts

Name:

Re: *2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

I swear dentists are worse then used car salesmen

Posted 5/10/11 4:40 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: *2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by FreeButterfly

I swear dentists are worse then used car salesmen



Not all of them!

Posted 5/10/11 4:46 PM
 

Kahuna
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

497 total posts

Name:

Re: *2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by FreeButterfly

I swear dentists are worse then used car salesmen



Excuse me?!

Actually, 99% of us are ethical individuals. We care about our patients and our staff. But like ALL professions, we have our shysters.

Posted 5/10/11 5:06 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: *2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by Kahuna

Posted by FreeButterfly

I swear dentists are worse then used car salesmen



Excuse me?!

Actually, 99% of us are ethical individuals. We care about our patients and our staff. But like ALL professions, we have our shysters.



just like lawyers Chat Icon

Posted 5/10/11 5:14 PM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: *2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by Kahuna

Posted by FreeButterfly

I swear dentists are worse then used car salesmen



Excuse me?!

Actually, 99% of us are ethical individuals. We care about our patients and our staff. But like ALL professions, we have our shysters.



I can attest to the shysters... I had a dentist tell me I had 3 cracked fillings that needed to be replaced. That was over 5 years ago and since then I have been to 2 different dentists who were unable to find anything wrong with my fillings. Scary what some people will try to get away with. Chat Icon

To the OP, I hope you take action and not only get the charges taken away completely, but have this office looked at for their billing practices.

Posted 5/10/11 5:25 PM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: *2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

They know what they did, this is how they make money.

They know if what can be done and how much would be covered by insurance.

With this type of practice, i would look to switch dentist.

Posted 5/10/11 6:25 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can we go to the dentist for a cleaning in 3rd Trimester? Cookiegobbler 2/15/07 6 Pregnancy
OK now my dentist is in on this TTC thing. Goldi0218 12/11/06 2 TTC
Great ped. dentist! MM2004 10/10/06 7 Parenting
Do you ever feel like you are getting ripped off by your dentist? MrsPorkChop 10/9/06 33 Families Helping Families ™
anyone go to the dentist and get a cavity filled? nancygrace 9/25/06 8 Pregnancy
How often are you supposed to go to the dentist? KPtoys 8/31/06 6 Families Helping Families ™