*2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

*2nd UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

****UPDATE #2:
I just hung up the phone with ins. co.
Rep was not happy.
He wants me to send back the EOB from this year and last with a notation of what wasn't provided and they will send me some forms to open an investigation.

I told him that I was informed by dentist office that ins co requested documentation and that the dentist's office sent it over but still denied the claim. Asked him if he could verify that. He plainly said "no... we did not request anything from them at all."
I'm like "so she lied" and he's like "well... yeah."

Nice.

****UPDATE:
Just spoke with dentist's office. When I called, I gave my name and she said "oh, yes... i'm going to put you on hold" - like she was expecting my call...

Anyway she claims that she goes through this with patients all the time, and that there are 2 different procedures that fall under one code (D4341) - perio scaling and root planing. According to her, I had the scaling done, and this is still submitted to insurance under D4341, even though I did not have root planing. She said the dentist does scaling routinely with every prophy and it's always submitted this way, it just happens that my insurance plan doesn't cover it more than 1x every 24 months. Most insurance plans apparently cover it more frequently.

She offered me a "professional courtesy" of half off.

I told her I would speak with metlife and get back to her. I'm still not convinced.

Thoughts? For those of you in the field, do you do scaling with every appointment AND submit it to ins. under D4341 perio scale & root planing?

thank you!!!! you have all been so helpful!

ETA: i told her my ins. co asked if they were taking numbers, etc. and she oh yes we sent those over when they asked for them and the x-rays .... i didn't have x-rays... and i thought the number thing was part of the root planing (which she acknowledged i didn't have...)???!!
________________________________



I made an appointment and went for a regular dental cleaning about 3 weeks ago. The last time I went was one year prior, in April 2010. I have MetLife Dental Insurance. Appointment took about 25 minutes, no x-rays (i'm pregnant) or anything, just a cleaning.

I pay my $20 copay. I get a bill today in the mail for $504.00 with a note on it - "insurance did not cover for scaling portion of cleaning." Attached is something from my ins co stating that "Perio scale and root pin" is covered once every 24 months, and I apparently had this done last april.

I'm livid. And I definitely don't have $500.

Is this typical??? Anyone know what "scaling" is? How do i know if this was even actually done??

What ticks me off to no end is that they know what ins. i have, and when I was last there. WHY would they do something that's not covered and not at least give me a heads up?


Any advice/opinions would be much appreciated! Thank you!

Message edited 2011-05-10 16:37:31.303000.

Posted 5/7/11 2:04 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

A scaling is definitely a lot more than a cleaning...

And if my memory serves me correctly you'd know you had it done....

Posted 5/7/11 2:07 PM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

While I completely understand where you are coming from and would be ticked as well, it's unfortunate but it's our responsibility to know what our insurance covers. You can definitely have them do a payment plan with you if you don't have all the money to give them right now. Chat Icon

Posted 5/7/11 2:08 PM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Call the dentist ASAP and raise hellll...DH went to the doctor a few weeks ago and had a similar experience, they charged him $350 for a lab test which he thought was covered under his medical plan. He called the Dr and complained to them for an hour and asked why they would send him to a lab when his insurance didn't cover that specific lab..the doctor deducted the cost from his bill and he didn't have to pay it.

Hopefully they will do the same..

Posted 5/7/11 2:23 PM
 

fight the future
Master of my domain.

Member since 3/10

2067 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

did they SAY to you 'okay i know you scheduled a cleaning but we'd like to perform this and that process if that's okay?'

????

because if not, i'd fight it.

and now i'm freaking out because i went for a cleaning this week and they did something that i THINK was scaling.

i kept telling the hygenist while i was there 'wow i dont think i've had this done before. this isn't how i remember a cleaning being?'

but they didn't say anything to me and i scheduled an appt for a cleaning only.

Posted 5/7/11 2:23 PM
 

JME78
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

3672 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

When I had scaling it was referred to as "scaling and root planing" - I had to get novocaine and it was a very intensive cleaning - they had to break it up into 2 visits.

I don't know if they refer to general cleaning as "scaling", but I would call your dentist and have them clarify the procedures.

I am no insurance expert but I can't imagine a dental insurance not covering a once yearly checkup/cleaning.

Message edited 2011-05-07 14:24:48.633000.

Posted 5/7/11 2:24 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

no they didn't say a word to me about what they were doing.

i certainly don't want to be a b!tch and pull the 'lawyer' card on them Chat Icon so i wanted to ask here if this is typical and get myself calmed before i do call them.

even if they did do something that wasn't covered, $504 seems like an astronomical amount of money when I paid my copay, and they received about $200 from my insurance company for the cleaning.

Posted 5/7/11 2:28 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by JME78

When I had scaling it was referred to as "scaling and root planing" - I had to get novocaine and it was a very intensive cleaning - they had to break it up into 2 visits.

I don't know if they refer to general cleaning as "scaling", but I would call your dentist and have them clarify the procedures.

I am no insurance expert but I can't imagine a dental insurance not covering a once yearly checkup/cleaning.



yes - the bill says 'perio scale and root pln" and i most certainly did not have novocaine. they did get paid from my insurance company for the cleaning.

Posted 5/7/11 2:30 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

My dentist does that as part of my regular cleaning. He asks if I want my gums numbed but I never do...it's just a little uncomfortable at certain moments but not at all painful.

Posted 5/7/11 3:04 PM
 

MrsKS
Thank You St. Gerard.....

Member since 12/09

8306 total posts

Name:
Kerri

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

sounds to me like the office is billing the insurance co for something that wasn't even done. therefore there shouldn't be a bill for it.

i'd DEF call the dentist office. Ask what the procedure is and have them explain it to you. Then say you didn't have that done (i'm really assuming that you didn't have it done) and would like to know why you are being billed for it. let them know you aren't paying it and to remove that from your records. you scheduled a cleaning only, not a scaling or whatever the other thing is and that's what is covered and that's what they were paid for. So they are paid for the services you received. end of story.

Posted 5/7/11 3:20 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

scaling is when they use almost a drill like thing to take plaque off your teeth..you'd be able to tell if they were doing it, because they "scrape" your teeth instead of just use a paste on them

id call

Posted 5/7/11 4:01 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Scaling and root planing is a periodontal treatment that should only be performed after a comprehensive perio evaluation. Did they measure your pockets and call out numbers? If you had scaling and root planing last year, this year you would need perio maintenance which is a cleaning designed for patients with periodontal problems or if you really had a lot going on because a year is too long in between appointments than you should have had a gross debridement, then another visit with a perio evaluation and after that diagnosis either scaling and root planing or a prophy.
Scaling and root planing is always done in at least two appointments, usually four. Insurance companies will NEVER pay for all four quadrants of the mouth in one visit and they also will not pay without the measurements I asked about and very often new xrays. It is not possible to scale and root plane a full mouth of teeth(which I assume you have) in 25 minutes.
There is a law of ethics in dentistry called informed consent and it does not sound like the dentist informed you, nor did you consent.
I would call the office and ask to speak to the dentist and tell him/her that you are very concerned about your bill and you are wondering why the treatment was not explained to you and why you were not ASKED if you wanted the more advanced treatment...if you receive any attitude or resistance, mention that you're going to call met life to tell them your concern.
IMO this is a REALLY big no no and I would be FURIOUS.
I have been in the dental field for a almost 25 years and I own a consulting firm that teaches dentists, hygienists and other dental professionals how to be Successful and how to run their practices. It really chaps my arse when I hear stories like this!

Posted 5/7/11 4:45 PM
 

MrsBurtch525
Year for change!

Member since 1/09

6017 total posts

Name:
Taryn

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

If you had a regular 25 minute cleaning i HIGHLY doubt they did ANY scaling, that requires a couple visits and anesthesia, call them up and def raise some hell for one that you wren't informed and for two, if you had a routine cleaning that took about 25 minutes and had no xrays there is no way that was scaling (that is usually 2 appointment for 2 quadrants at a time). I think they are trying to pull one over on you....or the hygienist wrote the wrong thing down that she did and the front desk sent that to insurance, who knows but DEF call and fight that....

KellyFG knows her stuff (glad she typed all that so i didn't have to...LOL!), i worked in a dental office as well and have helped hygienists when im not busy, there is no way you had scaling done, those appointments take like an hour....

Posted 5/7/11 6:02 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Yup. I just had this happen to me... Except the dental hygienist alerted me that he's also doing a scaling...

It cost me about 300.00 since my insurance only paid 80%

Posted 5/7/11 6:25 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by MrsBurtch525

If you had a regular 25 minute cleaning i HIGHLY doubt they did ANY scaling, that requires a couple visits and anesthesia,



no it doesn't... Takes about 30 minutes... no anesthesia. I just had one done.

Posted 5/7/11 6:26 PM
 

sunnyplus3
:)

Member since 11/05

8749 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by HeathKernandez

Posted by MrsBurtch525

If you had a regular 25 minute cleaning i HIGHLY doubt they did ANY scaling, that requires a couple visits and anesthesia,



no it doesn't... Takes about 30 minutes... no anesthesia. I just had one done.



I can agree with some patients not requiring anesthesia but a full mouth scaling simply cannot be done correctly in 30 minutes. You may have had a D4342 or scaling and root planing of 1-3 teeth at the time of prophy
If they did tell you they performed 4 quadrants of scaling and root planing and your insurance is paying 80%, look closely at your explanation of benefits from your insurance company. The usual "game" that is played is the scaling and root planing will be submitted as two different dates of service(which btw is insurance fraud) but that will usually get the claim paid. Patients are usually so happy when their insurance benefit pays well that the don't notice the dates on the EOB.

ETA:I just re-read and realized the total fee you and your insurance company paid.
I cannot believe that any patient would be comfortable in paying over $1000 for 30 minutes of any service. That is highway robbery. Great dental hygienists "produce" $200-$250 per hour....this means the hygienist in your office produces over $1000. Some dentists don't produce $1000 per hour.
Something is very wrong with that on so many levels.

Message edited 2011-05-07 18:47:13.283000.

Posted 5/7/11 6:38 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

I have metlife dental....

they cover a "regular" cleaning, xrays....

you'd be getting charged on things outside that, like cavities, periodontist work, etc.

Posted 5/7/11 6:41 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

A prophylaxis(code 1110 is a "regular cleaning" and not the same thing as a scaling and root planing. Almost all patients need to had novacaine for a sc/rp and like Kelly said it's done a mutliple appts. It is done to treat periodontal disease. This all should have been explained to you. I inform my patients with everything I do and the reasons I do it. Call up the office and tell them you are aware what a sc\rp is and that the tx was NOT done. If they fail to clear the charge threaten to report them. It sounds like they are coding to make a profit through the ins company.

Posted 5/7/11 7:49 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

thank you so much for all of your reponses and particularly those of you in the dental field. they made a point of telling me what great shape my teeth are in etc, etc. periodonal disease or anything along those lines was NEVER mentioned. i was also very careful to mention that i'm pregnant so they didn't take x-rays or anything like that. i would think if i required some sort of advanced treatment they would have mentioned it.

they billed for all 4 perio scale & root plane on the same date of service. based on the descriptions you all gave, i definitely didn't have this service done last year either. i'm just so aggravated over this and i hate to think this way but suppose i didn't question it and just paid it? I guess they bank on people doing that?
ugh.

Posted 5/7/11 8:00 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by HeathKernandez

Posted by MrsBurtch525

If you had a regular 25 minute cleaning i HIGHLY doubt they did ANY scaling, that requires a couple visits and anesthesia,



no it doesn't... Takes about 30 minutes... no anesthesia. I just had one done.

. You had your whole mouth done in 30 mins with no anethesia?? If so, run don't walk away from your office. Its not being done correctly. A general prophylaxis should take that amount of time. A sc\rp should be done over the course of several appts and 98% of the time we give novacaine because we have to access the roots of the teeth. Its like accessing between a nail and a cuticle. Pretty painful...

Posted 5/7/11 8:00 PM
 

danielle3203
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

1446 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

this happened to DH last year. we have the worst dental ins ever. well they go and do all this work (knowing what ins we have) and dont clear it with them, and he gets a bill in the mail for $1800.

he was not happy at all, esp since they messed up and didnt clear it.

Posted 5/7/11 10:43 PM
 

Blazesyth
*yawn*

Member since 5/05

8129 total posts

Name:

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by Bearcat

i'm just so aggravated over this and i hate to think this way but suppose i didn't question it and just paid it? I guess they bank on people doing that?
ugh.



Some doctors do this unfortunately. I had a few doctors that I gave my insurance info to, but they wouldnt submit to it and would just send a bill. I would have to call them and tell them to bill the insurance info they already had on file for me.

Every single time I went to that company the same thing would happen. Bill and not go thru insurance. I would have to call for each and every bill. I'm sure there are plenty of folks that just pay without looking.

Posted 5/7/11 11:19 PM
 

MommyofG
just the girls

Member since 5/05

9461 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

I am hoping someone entered the wrong insurance code. Def call them. Although a scaling and root planning can be done on 1 to 3 teeth in all 4 quardrants in 30 minutes. a full quardrant more like 45 minutes to an hour and some type of numbing agent whether novacaine or a gel.
you said its been a year and you are pregnant. if you had inflammation most pregnant women get pregnancy gingivitis and a year is too long too. sounds like you probably had a gross debridement. the deep scaling and root planning they have to probe tell you the numbers they are getting, document them, send them to insurance company wait for approval and have you come back for treatment.
but most of all you are suppose to consent and sign a consent form for treatment to be done, they go over billing and out of pocket expenses too.
all you have to say is that you did not consent to a scaling and root planning and this is the first you are hearing about it from the bill you received , end of story. at that point they will realize their mistake and you will not have to pay. good luck.

Posted 5/8/11 3:01 AM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

Posted by MommyofG

I am hoping someone entered the wrong insurance code. Def call them. Although a scaling and root planning can be done on 1 to 3 teeth in all 4 quardrants in 30 minutes. a full quardrant more like 45 minutes to an hour and some type of numbing agent whether novacaine or a gel.
you said its been a year and you are pregnant. if you had inflammation most pregnant women get pregnancy gingivitis and a year is too long too. sounds like you probably had a gross debridement. the deep scaling and root planning they have to probe tell you the numbers they are getting, document them, send them to insurance company wait for approval and have you come back for treatment.
but most of all you are suppose to consent and sign a consent form for treatment to be done, they go over billing and out of pocket expenses too.
all you have to say is that you did not consent to a scaling and root planning and this is the first you are hearing about it from the bill you received , end of story. at that point they will realize their mistake and you will not have to pay. good luck.



thanks for the advice. the bill says scale & root pln - 4+ per quad - i am thinking this means 4+ teeth per quad? and this item is on the bill x4.

Posted 5/8/11 9:52 AM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill

u def did not have scaling done and if u did it was a shitttty version of one..

for a scaling to be done,usually the doc during a checkup sees u have perio issues..measures the pockets(u should have heard numbers being called out)..3 per tooth..nd then tells u u need scaling

in the office i worked at for many years when a patient needed a scaling it was done in 4 visits..one quadrant of the mouth per visit...each visit took 30 minutes and some had general anest. but everyone had topical ointment on the gums to numb them at least...all depended how bad the gums were

firt thing i would do is call ur insurance and ask what was put down

second..this si what they did last april also?it was 25 min as well?

third i would def call the doc and raise hell..

1.for not telling u what was being done
2.for claiming they did all that in only 25 minutes
3.for not letting u know it would be covered..in my office we always had a ins check before and if something was not covered they knew beforehand


please keep us posted ..i am so curious

Posted 5/8/11 12:50 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can we go to the dentist for a cleaning in 3rd Trimester? Cookiegobbler 2/15/07 6 Pregnancy
OK now my dentist is in on this TTC thing. Goldi0218 12/11/06 2 TTC
Great ped. dentist! MM2004 10/10/06 7 Parenting
Do you ever feel like you are getting ripped off by your dentist? MrsPorkChop 10/9/06 33 Families Helping Families ™
anyone go to the dentist and get a cavity filled? nancygrace 9/25/06 8 Pregnancy
How often are you supposed to go to the dentist? KPtoys 8/31/06 6 Families Helping Families ™