Re: *UPDATE* - Help - Does this seem right - re: dentist bill
Posted 5/10/2011 1:15:29 PM by CrankyPants


Posted by Bearcat


Posted by KellyFG


Posted by Bearcat

****UPDATE:
Just spoke with dentist's office. When I called, I gave my name and she said "oh, yes... I'm going to put you on hold" - like she was expecting my call...

Anyway she claims that she goes through this with patients all the time, and that there are 2 different procedures that fall under one code (D4341) - perio scaling and root planing. According to her, I had the scaling done, and this is still submitted to insurance under D4341, even though I did not have root planing. She said the dentist does scaling routinely with every prophy and it's always submitted this way, it just happens that my insurance plan doesn't cover it more than 1x every 24 months. Most insurance plans apparently cover it more frequently.

She offered me a "professional courtesy" of half off.

I told her I would speak with metlife and get back to her. I'm still not convinced.

Thoughts? For those of you in the field, do you do scaling with every appointment AND submit it to ins. under D4341 perio scale & root planing?

thank you!!!! you have all been so helpful!

ETA: i told her my ins. co asked if they were taking numbers, etc. and she oh yes we sent those over when they asked for them and the x-rays .... i didn't have x-rays... and i thought the number thing was part of the root planing (which she acknowledged i didn't have...)???!!
________________________________





they are scamming.

From the 2011 CDT book
4321 ".....It Is indicated for patients with periodontal disease and is therapeutic, not prophylactic in nature...."
So if they took measurements and your pockets were more than 3 or 4 mm YOU HAVE PERIODONTAL DISEASE and that should have been heavily discussed with you.
Additionally you can not do "just the scaling" part. ADA codes cannot be broken down ala carte.
All of the dental professionals that responded here are in agreement that 4 quads of scaling & root planing CANNOT be performed in 25 minutes effectively.
Ask them to email of fax you the periodontal charting(the measurements)
It makes sense that Metlife won't pay it, because if you had perio treatment (scaling & Root planing) last year the expectation is that you would become a perio maintenance patient and be seen 3 or 4 times per year by the hygienist. Regardless of what insurance companies think is appropriate treatment, your dentist still has a legal obligation to acquire your informed consent.
The professional courtesy is trying to make you feel better and not pursue it, but that's bullsh*t. I cannot believe the doctor did not get on the phone and explain to you why you needed the procedure. For his staff member to say "he scales everyone" doesn't make it better.



i argued politely with her that it couldn't possibly be the same code etc. and she insisted that they do it all the time and then she said she didn't want to "go back and forth" with me.
she also said she has to deal with this ALL the time with patients, explaning it, and it's very frustrating....

i don't get how you can bill "scaling" that's part of a routine cleaning, and "root planing" that is obviously more extensive, under the SAME code. i said that to her and she told me thats how it is. i told her that's not what my ins. co. said, and she said well "that's the insurance game."

i'm really frustrated...



Call her back and flat out tell her you suspect fraud and you will call your insurance company about it.
Print Post      Close Window