Do you know about DHA recommendations for infant formula?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes - chose a specific brand 12 13.19%
Yes - but didn't know about different levels in formula 16 17.58%
No 31 34.07%
Don't really care 32 35.16%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

You have posted this about Similac before and while I respect your opinion, I still give my son Similac.

To be honest, the slight and I mean SLIGHT difference in DHA amounts in Similac and Enfamil is not enough to make me change formula's when my son is comfortable with what is given to him. From what I understand, there is generally more DHA in formula now a days than in breastmilk. I dont think these tiny amounts are going to make a drastic change in his brain development.

I was not breast fed as a baby and I was fed Similac and back than there was no DHA and I think I'm pretty damn smart Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 3:27 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Ophelia

this thread if totally OUT OF CONTROL.

I have never seen a ruder group of people...actually, a ruder few.

some of you need to take it down a notch. she was giving some information and asked a question. no need to jump down her throat or accuse her of kick backs or even demand that she answer you.

you don't like or appreciate the info, MOVE ALONG or debate it NICELY.

I am not even the OP and I had my *** bitchslap face on.



I have to disagree. I feel the OP was worded in such a way that caused alarm with many of the mothers on here. Implying that feeding your child a particular formula was somehow doing them a disservice. And i have a problem with that.
Especially when the person posting the information has a history of saying negative things about that particular formula.

There is already a lot of guilt associated with formula feeding as it is, no need to make mothers feel even worse about their choice.

Posted 1/18/10 3:28 PM
 

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Ophelia

this thread if totally OUT OF CONTROL.

I have never seen a ruder group of people...actually, a ruder few.

some of you need to take it down a notch. she was giving some information and asked a question. no need to jump down her throat or accuse her of kick backs or even demand that she answer you.

you don't like or appreciate the info, MOVE ALONG or debate it NICELY.

I am not even the OP and I had my *** bitchslap face on.



the op started a bit of chaos regarding formula. some children do well with similac and thats the only formula that works with them - no reason to make people feel guilty to feed their children what works for them.
To even SUGGEST our peds dont care what we feed our children is outright irresponsible

Posted 1/18/10 3:29 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Palebride

Posted by Ophelia

this thread if totally OUT OF CONTROL.

I have never seen a ruder group of people...actually, a ruder few.

some of you need to take it down a notch. she was giving some information and asked a question. no need to jump down her throat or accuse her of kick backs or even demand that she answer you.

you don't like or appreciate the info, MOVE ALONG or debate it NICELY.

I am not even the OP and I had my *** bitchslap face on.



I have to disagree. I feel the OP was worded in such a way that caused alarm with many of the mothers on here. Implying that feeding your child a particular formula was somehow doing them a disservice. And i have a problem with that.
Especially when the person posting the information has a history of saying negative things about that particular formula.

There is already a lot of guilt associated with formula feeding as it is, no need to make mothers feel even worse about their choice.




I don't think the OP can help how someone would internalize something.

the post above this one seemed to explain why she is not too worried without resorting to insults, showing that it can be done.

dissention is one thing...going balls deep into a poster b/c you don't like what she says is another.

Posted 1/18/10 3:30 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Palebride

Posted by Ophelia

this thread if totally OUT OF CONTROL.

I have never seen a ruder group of people...actually, a ruder few.

some of you need to take it down a notch. she was giving some information and asked a question. no need to jump down her throat or accuse her of kick backs or even demand that she answer you.

you don't like or appreciate the info, MOVE ALONG or debate it NICELY.

I am not even the OP and I had my *** bitchslap face on.



I have to disagree. I feel the OP was worded in such a way that caused alarm with many of the mothers on here. Implying that feeding your child a particular formula was somehow doing them a disservice. And i have a problem with that.
Especially when the person posting the information has a history of saying negative things about that particular formula.

There is already a lot of guilt associated with formula feeding as it is, no need to make mothers feel even worse about their choice.




I don't think the OP can help how someone would internalize something.

the post above this one seemed to explain why she is not too worried without resorting to insults, showing that it can be done.

dissention is one thing...going balls deep into a poster b/c you don't like what she says is another.




I also don't think anyone on here was exceptionally rude in their responses to the OP. I think she put information out there and people responded. I've seen waaaaay ruder discussion on this board in the past!

Posted 1/18/10 3:32 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by WNA01

Posted by Ophelia

this thread if totally OUT OF CONTROL.

I have never seen a ruder group of people...actually, a ruder few.

some of you need to take it down a notch. she was giving some information and asked a question. no need to jump down her throat or accuse her of kick backs or even demand that she answer you.

you don't like or appreciate the info, MOVE ALONG or debate it NICELY.

I am not even the OP and I had my *** bitchslap face on.



the op started a bit of chaos regarding formula. some children do well with similac and thats the only formula that works with them - no reason to make people feel guilty to feed their children what works for them.
To even SUGGEST our peds dont care what we feed our children is outright irresponsible



I didn't read any of her posts like that at all...suggesting peds don't care etc.

the fact is, Similac serves the purpose..her point is WHY are they essentially "jipping" people..and I think it's a good point.

no one should feel GUILTY about anything. if you like similac GOOD...don't switch..write them a letter.

I did the same thing with Enfamil and their use of corn syrup. they gave me an answer I can live with.

I am not going to roast someone over the coals for pointing out to me that there is something in my formula I don't necessarily like.

I think it's unfair.

Posted 1/18/10 3:32 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Palebride




I also don't think anyone on here was exceptionally rude in their responses to the OP. I think she put information out there and people responded. I've seen waaaaay ruder discussion on this board in the past!

I am only about 12 weeks in so I haven't seen it this bad...though I've heard about it Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 3:34 PM
 

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.




to me this suggests our peds dont care or are concerned about our childrens nutrition

Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 3:35 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Palebride




I also don't think anyone on here was exceptionally rude in their responses to the OP. I think she put information out there and people responded. I've seen waaaaay ruder discussion on this board in the past!



I am only about 12 weeks in so I haven't seen it this bad...though I've heard about it Chat Icon



Ok...here's what you do. Create a thread about how hard it is to be either a SAHM, or a mom with a FT job. Doesn't matter which one. Then...imply (don't say it outright) that the other side is easier.

Or, ask for opinions on breastfeeding in public.

Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 3:36 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by WNA01

Posted by hdrd0411

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.




to me this suggests our peds dont care or are concerned about our childrens nutrition

Chat Icon



I read that and I didn't "get" that from it...

I don't think she is arguing that your child will be stupid from this difference in DHA levels.

what I think she is arguing is that similac is blatantly less than the other brands, but costs the same or more...making more profit over all.

Posted 1/18/10 3:37 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

Nope...I said the recommendation is .2% and that Good Start and Enfamil contain .3% Never did I say the recommendation was .3%.

Similac is off by .5%....if the recommendation was .15 then I would not bat my eye but the recommendation is clearly .2%. You know whats not off by .5%...Similac's Kirkland brand- which has .3% (just like enfamil and goodstart)

If Mead Johnson is making a recommendation of .3% then that is there issue...I go with the ADA and other experts at .2%.



for the record .2-.15=.05, not .5

Posted 1/18/10 3:39 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Everyone needs to do their own research for everything! Don't go by one poster's information.

At first when looking back at past posts I right away thought she is getting a kickback or is really a pharmaceutical rep but whatever. I don't think that is rudeChat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 3:39 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I guess the DHA thing was never pushed by either of my docs (OB or Ped)... my OB never once mentioned that I take a DHA supp- and if it were that important- why isn't it included in the prenatals already?

Also- I saw a specialist- one of the top docs in fetal medicine, and he never ONCE mentioned that I take a DHA supp but insisted that I take 1000 mg of calicium above & beyond what was in the prenatal..

So I guess it never occured to me to question it.

Regarding the OP- I wasn't aware that any levels of DHA were recommended and thought it was just another "marketing ploy" to differentiate one formula brand from the next.

Posted 1/18/10 3:44 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Boy, I read this post from start to finish, and just cant help but stick my 2 cents in. First i just dont know why the hospital and my pediatrician put DS on Similac if it didnt have the recommened level. I find it interesting though that my little booklet that I got from my pediatrician to keep track of DS' appts and immunizations is put out by Similac, so perhaps my pediatrician is getting a bigger "kick back" for pushign Similac than other formulaChat Icon That being said, DS is doing fabulous on the similac sensitive rs. I was concerned with the corn syrup issue but my baby is growing, smiling, happy and has no more gas issues. I will however address it with my pediatrician at his next appt and she what she has to say about all of this. I do appreciate OP pointing out the DHA issue so I can be informed. On the flip side, I personally think the "well MY formula never had it and I turned out ok" response is a bit niave as its the same one that my mom uses when I bring up her cigarette habit....I smoked with both you and your brother and neither of you have asthma....my doctor told me that wine during pregnancy made for a happy baby....blah blah blahChat Icon Ok..I'm done

Posted 1/18/10 3:45 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

There are no proper levels of DHA. There are just recomendations by various groups but then there are those other groups that say too much DHA is a bad thing.

The FDA does not have to approve formula.

Posted 1/18/10 3:56 PM
 

ruby
you rang?

Member since 6/08

5573 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by WNA01

Posted by hdrd0411

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.




to me this suggests our peds dont care or are concerned about our childrens nutrition

Chat Icon



I didn't take that that way at all. I think it's a matter of wording is all, I don't think she meant that they don't care, I think what she's trying to say is that pediatrician's focus is not DHA and nutrition and I would agree, does it mean they don't care about my DS's nutritional habits, no....but it's probably not going to be their strong suit either. If I had severe issues with my DS's nutrition I'd ask for a nutrionist referral as I know that just because my ped is a dr. that does not mean she knows nearly everything there is to know about nutrition.

Posted 1/18/10 4:00 PM
 

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by WNA01

Posted by hdrd0411

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.




to me this suggests our peds dont care or are concerned about our childrens nutrition

Chat Icon



I read that and I didn't "get" that from it...

I don't think she is arguing that your child will be stupid from this difference in DHA levels.

what I think she is arguing is that similac is blatantly less than the other brands, but costs the same or more...making more profit over all.




Please re-read her first sentence again and see she specifcally says SHE DOES NOT THINK PEDS ARE NOT THAT CONCERNED WITH DHA OR NUTRITION AND ARE MORE CONCERNED WITH ETC....



Posted 1/18/10 4:03 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

OK..

I think we should just put an end to this post. I mean now I am getting corrected on math .05 vs .5....saying that I think ped's don't care about your kids, etc. and some of my quotes are getting blown out of proportion. I again never stated that the recommendation was 3%, but meaning that Good Start and Enfamil met the 2% recommendation at levels of 3%.


In a nutshell...I was just suprised that some moms from my class didn't know about this and wanted some information to help educate moms.

As far as formula goes - all babies will grow on formula, babies grew on carnation evaporated milk and sugar 40 years ago, but I think the goal of all formula companies is to make a formula as close to breastmilk as possible, with the ingredients they feel are the best.

With that I am done.

Thank you Ophelia for defending me...I appreciate you putting my post into the perspective it was ment.

And PS.

Posted 1/18/10 4:03 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

If you know all the facts, what information are you trying to get from us for your class? I don't understand?Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 4:05 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

I wanted to know if Mom's knew about DHA recommendations and if was something important to them.

Posted 1/18/10 4:08 PM
 

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

I wanted to know if Mom's knew about DHA recommendations and if was something important to them.

Ok

Posted 1/18/10 4:09 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

I wanted to know if Mom's knew about DHA recommendations and if was something important to them.



Just a friendly suggestion....next time you're searching for information like that, I'd try to make the question as unbiased as possible. Your original post seemed horribly slanted against Similac formula. And that is sure to ruffle some feathers.

The question you stated right here is direct, to the point, and if that's what you're looking for, that's really all you need.
Chat Icon

Posted 1/18/10 4:11 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

Posted by hdrd0411

OK..

I think we should just put an end to this post. I mean now I am getting corrected on math .05 vs .5....saying that I think ped's don't care about your kids, etc. and some of my quotes are getting blown out of proportion. I again never stated that the recommendation was 3%, but meaning that Good Start and Enfamil met the 2% recommendation at levels of 3%.




You corrected my math initially where I said that Similac was only .05% off from the recommended limit and you said it is not, it is .5%...you also said if it was only .05% you wouldnt be concerned over such a negligible difference.....that is a VERY important point to clairfy.

"Similac is off by .5%....if the recommendation was .15 then I would not bat my eye but the recommendation is clearly .2%."

You also did say "I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition."

Posted 1/18/10 4:18 PM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

hdrd0411 - I appreciate what you are saying. I actually just took my pre-natal with DHA while reading this long post.

It is quite funny how people react because I didn't take offense to anything you read. I am actually taking note about this part:

Posted by hdrd0411

Why I feel Enfamil is the closest to BM:

Breastmilk is a ratio of whey to caesin - whey predominent around 60 to 40 for the first 6mths. (mature breastmilk is 80/20 - similar to cow's milk)

Enfamil is 60/40 - whey/caesin
Similac is 48/52 - whey/caesin
Good Start is 100% whey



I find this very important because I BF'd my son and supplemented with Similac for 2 months before he was started whole milk. I also find it interesting that we transition to milk at 12 months but DHA is still very beneficial during that year until they are 2. (This is new news to me I will be sure to reseach infant/toddler brain development).

As far as your comment:

Posted by hdrd0411

I don't think pediatricians are that concerned about DHA and nutrition. Pediatricians have sooo much on their plate already with vaccines, growth issues, swine/seasonal flu that I don't think it is on the forefront of their mind. DOn't get angry, just be informed.



I have to agree and even for OB's. When I started my prenatals (2nd PG) I asked for Duet w/DHA and was told by my OB that prenatals are no different that any other vitamin except for the extra iron and folic acid. SHe specifically said not to be fooled by DHA because there was no proof associated to brain development in the baby (my Doc is shared by MANY woman on this site). My previous Dr sweared by DHA and took Omega 3 every day, we joked about the burp.

As far as babies are concerned, I think this post is extrememly informative and maybe I am not offended by it because I don't have "formula feeding guilt". I have to say this is the first post I have seen in a long time where the saying "breast is best" was stated so it was only a matter of time before your information was attacked because that statement must hurt people.

I think it is small minded to say you should be weary of other's feelings when posting your information because everyone of us believes in something someone else may not approve or like. If BFing doesn't work for this next child I will be sure to look into enfamil a little further. TY

Posted 1/18/10 4:37 PM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: Do Mom's know this information re: formula?

As a first time dad, watching DD who is now 10 months transform pretty much overnight is an amazing process..

I use similac and really not worried about "recommended" DHA. Why, because its a study. I'm sure there are other factors that were non considered or factored.

My DD now 10 months I think it way to smart for her self. Her learning is always been quick and she understands the majority of that is taught on her. Her personality is outstanding and I wouldn't raise her any differently.

Seems the OP wanted to state a fact, then following posters replied that I want to switch and my study is better, etc...

Do what you feel best for your DC and move on. If something is not working, you will try something else. Every kid will be different. The more effort you put into something, the more you will get out of it.

Just because your kid has all the DHA in the world, doesn't mean he will be a future president. Sure, so studies shows that Japeneses are smart. Well, they are smart for other reasons besides DHA.

As for trusting Ped's, I trust my Ped before we had DD. And now that DD is her, i trust her even more. DD cares so much about development, nutrition, milestones, etc...

Posted 1/18/10 4:39 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Mom's who tried BFing and now use formula brownie 7/28/09 6 Parenting
HELP! New mom needs help with formula Squirl1003 6/11/09 4 Parenting
Mom's who BF and also supplement with formula.... MelToddJulia 8/25/08 25 Parenting
EDITED Q-Way tmi q for mom's of 7-9 mo olds - formula fed diaper q itsbabytime 5/2/08 6 Parenting
Mom's using Canned Formula - watch CBS2 news at 5 adeline27 12/5/07 8 Parenting
mom's with children on soy formula alex7-2 2/9/07 6 Parenting