Montauk Hotels....
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Montauk Hotels.... where do you recommend..on the beach? |
|
Posted 7/26/19 1:45 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by Diane where do you recommend..on the beach? Thanks Most of the stuff on the beach are motels...there's no chains or anything |
|
Posted 7/26/19 1:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by Straightarrow Posted by Diane where do you recommend..on the beach? Thanks Most of the stuff on the beach are motels...there's no chains or anything is there anyplace that you would recommend then? |
|
Posted 7/26/19 2:09 PM
|
|
|
Montauk Hotels.... Royal Atlantic - it is nothing fancy by a long shot, but clean, great location, and the rooms have a little kitchenette |
|
Posted 7/26/19 3:00 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by chilltocam Royal Atlantic - it is nothing fancy by a long shot, but clean, great location, and the rooms have a little kitchenette I don't think anything out there is fancy to be honest. They renovated a few of the usual dumps and now they charge like $900 a night in the high season for those. The others are 1960s dumps for like $400 a night. It's insanity. |
Posted 7/26/19 4:09 PM
|
|
|
Montauk Hotels.... We love the Beachcomber. We’ve stayed there 3 years in a row, same week, and there were so many of the same families that we see every year. It’s like a reunion. It has private beach access right across the street. |
|
Posted 7/26/19 4:33 PM
|
|
|
Montauk Hotels.... Atlantic Terrace and Montauk Blue would be my choices. But, I think the hotels are insanely priced for what they are out there! |
|
Posted 7/29/19 9:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by NervousNell I don't think anything out there is fancy to be honest. They renovated a few of the usual dumps and now they charge like $900 a night in the high season for those. The others are 1960s dumps for like $400 a night. It's insanity. I don't get the appeal of Montauk personally. I stayed out there several years ago and was SO disappointed with the motel that we paid top dollar for. I don't know if we just didn't know where to go but there didn't seem to be anything to do out there. I know people love it so maybe it's just not my type of vacation. |
|
Posted 7/30/19 8:51 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by Sparrow Posted by NervousNell I don't think anything out there is fancy to be honest. They renovated a few of the usual dumps and now they charge like $900 a night in the high season for those. The others are 1960s dumps for like $400 a night. It's insanity. I don't get the appeal of Montauk personally. I stayed out there several years ago and was SO disappointed with the motel that we paid top dollar for. I don't know if we just didn't know where to go but there didn't seem to be anything to do out there. I know people love it so maybe it's just not my type of vacation. Montauk is nice if you are a big beach person but IMO only for a few days. I can't spend a week out there, there's really not much to do for more than a few days. It's nice and relaxing and beachy, but again I can only do that for a few days. BUT my biggest issue out there is the hotels. I am a hotel snob and I can't stay in a dump. And I especially can't stay in a dump when I am paying the price I would pay to stay at the Ritz anywhere else. I know they renovated a few, but those are now like $800 and up a NIGHT in the summer and I'm not sure how great they even are. I just can't do it. |
Posted 7/31/19 7:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by NervousNell Posted by Sparrow Posted by NervousNell I don't think anything out there is fancy to be honest. They renovated a few of the usual dumps and now they charge like $900 a night in the high season for those. The others are 1960s dumps for like $400 a night. It's insanity. I don't get the appeal of Montauk personally. I stayed out there several years ago and was SO disappointed with the motel that we paid top dollar for. I don't know if we just didn't know where to go but there didn't seem to be anything to do out there. I know people love it so maybe it's just not my type of vacation. Montauk is nice if you are a big beach person but IMO only for a few days. I can't spend a week out there, there's really not much to do for more than a few days. It's nice and relaxing and beachy, but again I can only do that for a few days. BUT my biggest issue out there is the hotels. I am a hotel snob and I can't stay in a dump. And I especially can't stay in a dump when I am paying the price I would pay to stay at the Ritz anywhere else. I know they renovated a few, but those are now like $800 and up a NIGHT in the summer and I'm not sure how great they even are. I just can't do it. You might be better off trying to rent a house if you're a hotel snob. The houses are way nicer than the motels. My opinion is obviously going to be different because my parents bought a house out there when I was 6 and I spent every summer there, but Montauk is the best. It's been a little ruined by people, but it's still my little piece of heaven and I can't wait to go out at the end of August for a week. But I do agree you have to be a big beach person, we spend 6-8 hours a day at the beach. |
|
Posted 7/31/19 10:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by NervousNell Posted by Sparrow Posted by NervousNell I don't think anything out there is fancy to be honest. They renovated a few of the usual dumps and now they charge like $900 a night in the high season for those. The others are 1960s dumps for like $400 a night. It's insanity. I don't get the appeal of Montauk personally. I stayed out there several years ago and was SO disappointed with the motel that we paid top dollar for. I don't know if we just didn't know where to go but there didn't seem to be anything to do out there. I know people love it so maybe it's just not my type of vacation. Montauk is nice if you are a big beach person but IMO only for a few days. I can't spend a week out there, there's really not much to do for more than a few days. It's nice and relaxing and beachy, but again I can only do that for a few days. BUT my biggest issue out there is the hotels. I am a hotel snob and I can't stay in a dump. And I especially can't stay in a dump when I am paying the price I would pay to stay at the Ritz anywhere else. I know they renovated a few, but those are now like $800 and up a NIGHT in the summer and I'm not sure how great they even are. I just can't do it. I agree with this. We actually went camping at Hither Hills last year, and I said it was the best $35 a night "hotel" we had. I would never pay the prices for what the hotels are out there. Plus there is like NOTHING to do in Montauk other than the beach. So if it rains, you are screwed. |
|
Posted 7/31/19 10:33 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by Straightarrow Posted by NervousNell Posted by Sparrow Posted by NervousNell I don't think anything out there is fancy to be honest. They renovated a few of the usual dumps and now they charge like $900 a night in the high season for those. The others are 1960s dumps for like $400 a night. It's insanity. I don't get the appeal of Montauk personally. I stayed out there several years ago and was SO disappointed with the motel that we paid top dollar for. I don't know if we just didn't know where to go but there didn't seem to be anything to do out there. I know people love it so maybe it's just not my type of vacation. Montauk is nice if you are a big beach person but IMO only for a few days. I can't spend a week out there, there's really not much to do for more than a few days. It's nice and relaxing and beachy, but again I can only do that for a few days. BUT my biggest issue out there is the hotels. I am a hotel snob and I can't stay in a dump. And I especially can't stay in a dump when I am paying the price I would pay to stay at the Ritz anywhere else. I know they renovated a few, but those are now like $800 and up a NIGHT in the summer and I'm not sure how great they even are. I just can't do it. You might be better off trying to rent a house if you're a hotel snob. The houses are way nicer than the motels. My opinion is obviously going to be different because my parents bought a house out there when I was 6 and I spent every summer there, but Montauk is the best. It's been a little ruined by people, but it's still my little piece of heaven and I can't wait to go out at the end of August for a week. But I do agree you have to be a big beach person, we spend 6-8 hours a day at the beach. We spent a week out there every summer from the time I was like 8 until I was a teen too so I do get it . I have a lot of great memories from out there and I am a total beach person so I do get the appeal. Unfortunately while i can spend 8 hours at the beach, easily, DH gets antsy after a few hours so it's not ideal for us personally for more than a few days. It's funny though because as much as I loved it out there as a kid, I still remember thinking what a dump the hotel was back in the 80s and even back then it was expensive for the time for what it was. I agree, a house would probably be a much better option. |
Posted 7/31/19 11:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Posted by chilltocam Royal Atlantic - it is nothing fancy by a long shot, but clean, great location, and the rooms have a little kitchenette This would be my pick too. We stayed here last year for a few days while we attended a wedding Montauk and I happened to really like it. It's a great location - within walking distance to everything and right on the beach (the Atlantic side, not the sound). We had an oceanfront room and it was nothing special, but it was clean and waking up to the sound of the ocean and being able to sit out on the balcony and be basically ON the beach was very nice. It has its own restaurant and a tiki/beach bar that plays music. One night we walked the beach and walked right over to a bar (forget the name) that was on the water. Right next door to Royal Atlantic is the Montauk Blue Hotel, which is similar - I think slightly nicer rooms, but no restaurant or beach bar. I preferred the Royal Atlantic, but both are nice. |
|
Posted 8/1/19 3:04 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Montauk Hotels.... Looks like the Atlantic Terrace was bought and is now called the Marram and was supposed to open to guests this summer- not sure if it did yet. |
Posted 8/1/19 4:21 PM
|
|
|
Montauk Hotels.... if you're looking for overpriced luxury - gurneys. our room was nothing special and we went in the off season, but lots of amenities. |
|
Posted 8/2/19 10:34 AM
|
|
|
Montauk Hotels.... Sun and Sound. It's on the sound side, and the beach is a 3 minute walk. My family has been staying there since I was a kid. We love it |
|
Posted 8/3/19 12:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Montauk Hotels.... We stayed at the Surf club, right on the beach. This was 9 years ago though, it was a very nice place then. |
|
Posted 8/7/19 10:10 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| montauk hotels...with no mini. or ideally no min.? | msrsfeb | 3/3/12 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Need recs for Montauk deep sea fishing and hotels... | Jenn627 | 5/4/09 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Anyone know of any Pet friendly cottages or hotels in Montauk? | MommyofG | 3/2/06 | 2 | Pets |
| Any good deals on Montauk hotels this time of year? | Scotty-CassidysMom | 1/28/06 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Hotels in Montauk.. | Pooka | 9/30/07 | 18 | Travel & Vacations |
| Pleae help with Montauk/Hamptons Hotels or inns | secretbabymaker | 7/13/07 | 6 | Travel & Vacations |






