Re: Montauk Hotels....
Posted 7/31/2019 10:28:10 AM by Straightarrow


Posted by NervousNell


Posted by Sparrow


Posted by NervousNell

I don't think anything out there is fancy to be honest.
They renovated a few of the usual dumps and now they charge like $900 a night in the high season for those.
The others are 1960s dumps for like $400 a night.
It's insanity.




I don't get the appeal of Montauk personally. I stayed out there several years ago and was SO disappointed with the motel that we paid top dollar for. I don't know if we just didn't know where to go but there didn't seem to be anything to do out there.

I know people love it so maybe it's just not my type of vacation.



Montauk is nice if you are a big beach person but IMO only for a few days.
I can't spend a week out there, there's really not much to do for more than a few days.
It's nice and relaxing and beachy, but again I can only do that for a few days.
BUT my biggest issue out there is the hotels. I am a hotel snob and I can't stay in a dump. And I especially can't stay in a dump when I am paying the price I would pay to stay at the Ritz anywhere else.
I know they renovated a few, but those are now like $800 and up a NIGHT in the summer and I'm not sure how great they even are.
I just can't do it.



You might be better off trying to rent a house if you're a hotel snob. The houses are way nicer than the motels.

My opinion is obviously going to be different because my parents bought a house out there when I was 6 and I spent every summer there, but Montauk is the best. It's been a little ruined by people, but it's still my little piece of heaven and I can't wait to go out at the end of August for a week.

But I do agree you have to be a big beach person, we spend 6-8 hours a day at the beach.
Print Post      Close Window