Question---what is the right thing to do?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Question---what is the right thing to do? My friend's dog (a pit mix) bit another dog at a dog park the other day. I feel that my friend can't handle her dog, but that's another story. The dog wasn't on a leash. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 11:12 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? That is sooo wrong. Everything about the scenario sounds like she's to blame. I wouldn't even hesitate to pay that money. She's very lucky they are only looking for her to cover the vet bills and not escalating this. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Question---what is the right thing to do? You aren't wrong... she is. Yes, she should pay the vet bill. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 12:49 PM
|
|
|
Question---what is the right thing to do? If her dog instigated the fight and the other dog was the only dog that was damaged then yes, she should pay the vet bill and be grateful that is all they are asking for. But if the dog was dominating and bullying her dog and the owners didn't step in to separate the dogs, then they should pay their own bills. If her dog was the sole aggressor then I do think she is in the wrong and that ignoring them may push them to escalate the incident. It could get very bad for her dog. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by Traysee If her dog instigated the fight and the other dog was the only dog that was damaged then yes, she should pay the vet bill and be grateful that is all they are asking for. But if the dog was dominating and bullying her dog and the owners didn't step in to separate the dogs, then they should pay their own bills. If her dog was the sole aggressor then I do think she is in the wrong and that ignoring them may push them to escalate the incident. It could get very bad for her dog. In all honesty, most pit rescue groups do not encourage bully breeds to be at dog parks at all. Bully breeds as well as many many other types and temperaments of dogs, would do better with steady play dates with dogs they know, where their place in the pack is worked out. Putting them in a constant state of having to "hammer out" who has the higher ranking in the pack and territory disputes is just asking for trouble. I actually feel that way about all dogs in dog parks but especially for bully breeds. Going to a dog park you do accept responsibility that it's go at your own risk. Dog fights will probably break out, especially with dogs that don't know each other or when you add new dogs into an already established group of dogs. I could not agree with this more. We don't take our pit to dog parks anymore- actually, we only ever went to ones that were empty of all but us and our two dogs, but someone came in after us and there was an incident- a fight between my pit and a german shepherd. No one was hurt, not even a scratch, but I don't ever want to be put in a position like that again. Our pit gets along GREAT with my parents dogs and my neighbor's dogs, but she definitely is dominant and I'm afraid of what would happen in a dog park where she's off leash and out of my control. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 2:37 PM
|
|
|
Question---what is the right thing to do? You know you just reminded me... as an add on to what I have already said same sex dogs, especially female dogs, are least likely to get along and at a dog park you don't have control over who is going to be at the park. Message edited 2013-04-30 14:51:13.790000. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 2:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by racheK My friend's dog (a pit mix) bit another dog at a dog park the other day. I feel that my friend can't handle her dog, but that's another story. The dog wasn't on a leash. The owners of the other dog contacted her and asked her to pay for the $500 vet bill. I think she should pay this, she told me about it but didn't like my response when I told her that she should pay it. She is now ignoring the request. Am I wrong? Shouldn't she pay for vet bill? She is wrong for ignoring it. She is a disrespectful disgusting excuse for a dog owner. I would be BESIDE myself if my dog bit another, and would go out of my way to make ure the others expenses are covered. 1. Because its the rightthing to do. 2. She is going to have her a$$ sued. So pay now pay later plus court costs. She is disgusting. How she can ignore another dogs suffering.....I feel bad for HER dog. ETA: With the caveat of above posts if her dog was bullied....But to not even answer the other person? She WILL answer in court no matter who was to blame. Message edited 2013-04-30 15:25:59.373000. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? are you suggesting dog parks in general are not a good idea or dog parks for Pit bulls? |
|
Posted 4/30/13 6:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Oy. She needs to pay the vet bill. She could face some serious, serious issues FOR HER DOG, not just for her, if she doesn't. We don't take Ozzie to the dog park anymore ever after one incident where he was the aggressor. I stepped in before any damage was done but we just avoid dog parks and unknown dogs completely. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 6:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? She absolutely should pay. Would she like to get sued, b/c if she gives them a hard time, they may just try to sue her. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 6:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Right. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 9:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Your friend is 100% to blame and should absolutely pay the vet bill. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 10:41 PM
|
|
|
Question---what is the right thing to do? I assume if the owners of the dog contacted her they swapped information, what did she think would happen exactly when she did this? A phone call saying all's good with their dog? Of course they would be expecting her to foot the bill, it's her negligence. |
|
Posted 4/30/13 11:06 PM
|
|
|
Question---what is the right thing to do? I am saying dog parks in general are not a good idea, unless you are setting up a small playgroup at a dog park with the same dogs all the time. |
|
Posted 5/1/13 10:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Dog parks are absolutely beneficial to all dog breeds. There have been many studies done on the subject and it was because of the proven benefits that NYC created off leash in Parks that did not have a fenced dog park. All breeds if socialized well and early will get along with other dogs. They do not become territorial as they do with their own back yards, also they are exposed to more situations and therefore do not get startled and frightened as much, most fights and bites happen from a dogs fear when the fight or flight instinct kicks in. |
|
Posted 5/1/13 11:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? She should not ignore this because if she does the person could sue for the money and demand the dog be put down. |
|
Posted 5/1/13 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by ttnkidz Dog parks are absolutely beneficial to all dog breeds. There have been many studies done on the subject and it was because of the proven benefits that NYC created off leash in Parks that did not have a fenced dog park. All breeds if socialized well and early will get along with other dogs. They do not become territorial as they do with their own back yards, also they are exposed to more situations and therefore do not get startled and frightened as much, most fights and bites happen from a dogs fear when the fight or flight instinct kicks in. While of course you are entitled to your opinion the facts are conclusive that dog parks are a good idea for all dogs and communities. Sorry but I am a bit passionate on this subject. Anyone who has gone to Prospect Park on a Saturday morning and seen the hundreds of dogs interacting would be amazed. Yeah but that's assuming the dogs in question are socialized...I'm in favor of dog parks but its def not for every dog |
|
Posted 5/1/13 11:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by SLPlady1984 Posted by ttnkidz Dog parks are absolutely beneficial to all dog breeds. There have been many studies done on the subject and it was because of the proven benefits that NYC created off leash in Parks that did not have a fenced dog park. All breeds if socialized well and early will get along with other dogs. They do not become territorial as they do with their own back yards, also they are exposed to more situations and therefore do not get startled and frightened as much, most fights and bites happen from a dogs fear when the fight or flight instinct kicks in. While of course you are entitled to your opinion the facts are conclusive that dog parks are a good idea for all dogs and communities. Sorry but I am a bit passionate on this subject. Anyone who has gone to Prospect Park on a Saturday morning and seen the hundreds of dogs interacting would be amazed. Yeah but that's assuming the dogs in question are socialized...I'm in favor of dog parks but its def not for every dog While I don't think dog parks are bad for all dogs, they are most certainly NOT good for ALL dogs either. Dogs can absolutely become territorial at a dog park, either of its owner or of the space - if they are there first and another dog comes in, the first dog can most definitely become territorial. While I am not anti-dog park for every dog, it is a very sweeping generalization to say they are GOOD for all dogs. Further, as the above poster said, not all dogs ARE socialized well or early. We rescued a dog who was no longer a puppy and though he is a complete doll, we are working hard to undo his early negligent socialization. Dog parks DO NOT work for my dog, unless he is there alone. He becomes VERY territorial/protective/possessive of me and the space. Sweeping generalizations in either direction are problematic. Bottom line - if you go to a dog park, you assume liability for your dog's behavior in that space. |
|
Posted 5/1/13 11:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by SLPlady1984 Posted by ttnkidz Dog parks are absolutely beneficial to all dog breeds. There have been many studies done on the subject and it was because of the proven benefits that NYC created off leash in Parks that did not have a fenced dog park. All breeds if socialized well and early will get along with other dogs. They do not become territorial as they do with their own back yards, also they are exposed to more situations and therefore do not get startled and frightened as much, most fights and bites happen from a dogs fear when the fight or flight instinct kicks in. While of course you are entitled to your opinion the facts are conclusive that dog parks are a good idea for all dogs and communities. Sorry but I am a bit passionate on this subject. Anyone who has gone to Prospect Park on a Saturday morning and seen the hundreds of dogs interacting would be amazed. Yeah but that's assuming the dogs in question are socialized...I'm in favor of dog parks but its def not for every dog I think that comes down to the owners though. The blame shouldn't necessarily be placed on the dogs for being, well, dogs. |
|
Posted 5/1/13 11:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Agreed that you should always take responsibility for your dog. |
|
Posted 5/1/13 2:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by halfbaked That is sooo wrong. Everything about the scenario sounds like she's to blame. I wouldn't even hesitate to pay that money. She's very lucky they are only looking for her to cover the vet bills and not escalating this. ITA |
|
Posted 5/1/13 9:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by ttnkidz There is no downside in trying to get your dog socialized I have not seen dogs become territorial over a dog park space, there are too many other dog scents to have them claim ownership. Your dog is claiming ownership of you. In a dog park owners should always be paying attention to where and what their dog is doing, this enables you to potentially preempt any issues. Here's the issue... Large amounts of dog owners don't educate themselves on training, dog psychology, what the early warning signs of an impending struggle for dominance look like, and use the term "socializing" as an all-around excuse to ignore all of these things. All you need to do is go on a Saturday afternoon and count the number of owners who stay close to their dogs with a watchful eye, getting ready to respond to the hint of a bad situation. In my experience at Blydenburgh park in Hauppauge, most of the owners stand together drinking coffee bs'ing rather than paying attention. Their dogs don't listen when their names are yelled from 200 feet away. I've seen this every time I went, to all different parks, and when I had my arm bitten by a Mastiff while handling my own dog, that sealed the deal for me and we never went back. One of my dogs gets humped every time we go to any dog park because he's submissive and other dogs are always dominating him. With the humper's owners standing by letting it happen or saying a weak "Don't do that" because they see I'm paying attention. Hell, the last time I went to Blydenburgh, there was a dog in the park that had a huge collar on with the words DO NOT PET stitched into it in red. That's really a good candidate for a dog park? Riiiiight.To summarize... dog owners are largely irresponsible when it comes to real training and dog psychology and they are ruining dog parks for everyone. It doesn't surprise me at all about the original poster's friend because I've heard that cop out "They are animals" so many times as an excuse not to be responsible for their dog's actions. In a perfect world, all dog parks would only be frequented by responsible owners and (truly) socialized, well trained, stable dogs and I'd stand by dog parks 100%. That is never going to happen so I stick to playdates instead. |
|
Posted 5/2/13 7:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? I re-read my post and it sounds really negative so here's a caveat... If dog parks were monitored by trained professionals that could ask owners to leave if they are not doing what they should be doing, I'd totally go to that park. |
|
Posted 5/2/13 7:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by gdubs Your friend is 100% to blame and should absolutely pay the vet bill. Even though neither of my dogs would ever bite someone I still wouldn't let them off leash... you honestly just never know.
|
|
Posted 5/5/13 6:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question---what is the right thing to do? Posted by ttnkidz Dog parks are absolutely beneficial to all dog breeds. There have been many studies done on the subject and it was because of the proven benefits that NYC created off leash in Parks that did not have a fenced dog park. All breeds if socialized well and early will get along with other dogs. They do not become territorial as they do with their own back yards, also they are exposed to more situations and therefore do not get startled and frightened as much, most fights and bites happen from a dogs fear when the fight or flight instinct kicks in. No, not true. I have yet to come across ONE pit bull rescue that would agree with your statement about dog parks OR socialization. Dog aggression is a GENETIC TRAIT of these dogs. Granted any dog can be dog aggressive, but this is a genetic trait bred in over generations. Traysee is 100% correct with everything she already pointed out, including age of maturity being when problems begin to arise. But because dog aggression has been bred in as a genetic trait, it can turn on at any time. Many bully breed dogs are dog selective, so they will enjoy some dogs, but not others, and even dogs they used to tolerate may fall out of favor at some point. Dog parks are not recommended for bully breeds/pit bull type dogs or ANY OTHER DOG for which dog aggression has been bred into the lines for generations (this would include Akitas, Dobermans, Rottweilers and other "bully" breeds). The recommendation I have read over and over and over from numerous rescue and advocacy groups is supervised play dates with known dog friends and at least 1 person per dog, and both should have knowledge of how to break up a dog fight. Part of the problem with dog parks is that you couple this predisposition for dog aggression with owners who don't know how to properly read canine behavior (because many folks think their dog being friendly with humans automatically translates to dog friendly) and it's a recipe for disaster. The OP's friend is a testament to this and one of the irresponsible people who give pit bull type dogs a bad name. More than likely, she failed to recognize her dog's body language and step in before it became a bite situation. It's great to be passionate on a subject, but you should be accurate in your assessments as well. Just because you have seen some peaceful days on Sunday mornings in Prospect Park doesn't mean that universally all dogs can, will or even should, benefit from dog parks. Not all dogs belong in dog parks, and any dog who is dog selective or aggressive should never be in a dog park, especially one with untrained persons. Period. It does a great disservice to all dogs when irresponsible owners bring dogs that shouldn't be there in the first place. To the OP: Your friend needs to pay the bill and learn how to be a responsible dog owner and especially a responsible pit bull type dog owner. |
|
Posted 5/5/13 8:55 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sleeping question--am I doing the right thing? | MrsRivera | 1/2/09 | 4 | Parenting |
| One more thing--Metformin question | MrsRivera | 12/17/07 | 5 | Infertility |
| XPOST - Provera Question - weird thing going on | Hofstra26 | 12/7/07 | 0 | TTC |
| Taking Provera - weird thing going on....have question | Hofstra26 | 12/7/07 | 3 | Infertility |
| One more question- the nose bulb thing | dm24angel | 7/17/07 | 8 | Parenting |
| Question about Bahamas-Dolphin thing | CowgirlChick97 | 4/12/07 | 3 | Travel & Vacations |














Riiiiight.
