Re: Question---what is the right thing to do?
Posted 5/5/2013 8:55:43 PM by tara73


Posted by ttnkidz

Dog parks are absolutely beneficial to all dog breeds. There have been many studies done on the subject and it was because of the proven benefits that NYC created off leash in Parks that did not have a fenced dog park. All breeds if socialized well and early will get along with other dogs. They do not become territorial as they do with their own back yards, also they are exposed to more situations and therefore do not get startled and frightened as much, most fights and bites happen from a dogs fear when the fight or flight instinct kicks in.





No, not true. I have yet to come across ONE pit bull rescue that would agree with your statement about dog parks OR socialization. Dog aggression is a GENETIC TRAIT of these dogs. Granted any dog can be dog aggressive, but this is a genetic trait bred in over generations. Traysee is 100% correct with everything she already pointed out, including age of maturity being when problems begin to arise. But because dog aggression has been bred in as a genetic trait, it can turn on at any time. Many bully breed dogs are dog selective, so they will enjoy some dogs, but not others, and even dogs they used to tolerate may fall out of favor at some point.

Dog parks are not recommended for bully breeds/pit bull type dogs or ANY OTHER DOG for which dog aggression has been bred into the lines for generations (this would include Akitas, Dobermans, Rottweilers and other "bully" breeds). The recommendation I have read over and over and over from numerous rescue and advocacy groups is supervised play dates with known dog friends and at least 1 person per dog, and both should have knowledge of how to break up a dog fight.

Part of the problem with dog parks is that you couple this predisposition for dog aggression with owners who don't know how to properly read canine behavior (because many folks think their dog being friendly with humans automatically translates to dog friendly) and it's a recipe for disaster. The OP's friend is a testament to this and one of the irresponsible people who give pit bull type dogs a bad name. More than likely, she failed to recognize her dog's body language and step in before it became a bite situation.

It's great to be passionate on a subject, but you should be accurate in your assessments as well. Just because you have seen some peaceful days on Sunday mornings in Prospect Park doesn't mean that universally all dogs can, will or even should, benefit from dog parks. Not all dogs belong in dog parks, and any dog who is dog selective or aggressive should never be in a dog park, especially one with untrained persons. Period. It does a great disservice to all dogs when irresponsible owners bring dogs that shouldn't be there in the first place.

To the OP: Your friend needs to pay the bill and learn how to be a responsible dog owner and especially a responsible pit bull type dog owner.

Print Post      Close Window