WWYD? long!

Posted By Message

anonymous20
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

1248 total posts

Name:

WWYD? long!

WWYD regarding this situation

we have 2 people that we want as Godparents (always thought these 2 people would be it never thought of backups, etc)

then we found out that my church says that at least one Godparent has to have made all 3 sacraments and the other has to be of a Christian religion and they could be the witness

One of our choices (my childhood bff) is not catholic (lutheran) and the other only made bap & communion (you need to also make confirmation as well to be a God parent)

So either of our choices can be the witness but neither can 'truly' be God parent bc neither made all 3 sacraments

the church doesn't ask for proof of making the sacraments

So my question is, would you try to find someone else to be the Godparent that has made all 3 sacraments and use one of our choices of Godparents as our witness or just go w/our 2 choices since the church will not check (each of our choices are equally as important to me and dh so it's so hard to pick one over the other, kwim?) we feel these are the best people for our LO

i have asked family and friends what to do about this and i have gotten such mixed answers--some say yes-without a 2nd thought and others say that one of our choices has made 2 sacraments so that they are, in other words 'Catholic' enough.....i have one friend who said she is picking her bro who has made all 3 sacraments and doesn't even believe in GOD...so im like at least my choice w/2 sacraments believes in GOD!!

i am so torn--i don't want to be dishonest to the Church but at the same time I feel like i should pick the 2 people that r the best fit for my LO
so sorry this was so long and thanks for reading this
WWYD?

Posted 1/9/11 8:35 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: WWYD? long!

Well, in lying to the church, you are really asking the godparent to be dishonest as well, and they may not want to be, KWIM? Maybe check with them and get an opinion.

I am the witness for my niece, and while the church never asked for proof (DH is catholic and is the godfather), they asked me point blank, and I wouldn't lie. So I am a witness.

Posted 1/9/11 8:38 PM
 

jlk51496
Mom of 3 - YIKES! =)

Member since 10/09

6758 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: WWYD? long!

can you ask another church that doesn't need all those requirements??

Posted 1/9/11 8:41 PM
 

Mrs-Boop
My Babies

Member since 5/05

4956 total posts

Name:
Jaime

Re: WWYD? long!

Is the one that did not receive confirmation willing to take the required steps to receive it?

Even if after the fact.

I have heard if you promise to fufill the requirements to receive confirmation, they will allow it, with the understanding that when it is offered(class and stuff is only offered at certain time of year) you will complete the requirements to receive it.

I have also heard of people making a donation to the church and things being overlooked (sounds bad, but have heard of it done 3 separate times).

Posted 1/9/11 8:48 PM
 

anonymous20
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

1248 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD? long!

yes, the person is willing to take the class after the fact but i know how we all get caught up in life and get busy so i hope that they would truly follow throught w/it..it would make me feel so much better doing things'backwards'!

some of the other people ive mentioned it to didn't even know that one person needed all 3 sacraments; others said that they were Godparents and they didn't make all 3 and weren't even asked at Church or by the kids parents if they did or not, and yet others said that they aren't even very religious but still got their kids baptised

idk, i really want these 2 people but i don't like being dishonest even though these are the 2 best choices for my LO

Im nervous to ask the church bc i don't want them turning around saying that i can't have these 2 people or asking for proof just in case i decide to go the dishonest route
i really want this church bc it's whre i attended my whole life and got married

Posted 1/9/11 9:13 PM
 

Mrs-Boop
My Babies

Member since 5/05

4956 total posts

Name:
Jaime

Re: WWYD? long!

Why not trying to call the church annonymously and asking them what their policy is on godparents and what is required of them, if they need any paperwork.

Posted 1/10/11 1:03 PM
 

anonymous20
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

1248 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD? long!

Posted by Mrs-Boop

Why not trying to call the church annonymously and asking them what their policy is on godparents and what is required of them, if they need any paperwork.


their policy is that one Godparent needs to have made all 3 sacraments and they don't need any paperwork for proof

Posted 1/10/11 7:32 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD? long!

Message edited 2012-01-01 13:25:45.403000.

Posted 1/10/11 7:46 PM
 

MelissaZB
LIF Infant

Member since 6/09

193 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: WWYD? long!

I was in the same situation. I wanted it to be my step-sister and DH's brother. However, my step-sister never had her confirmation and DH's brother is Episcopalian. Lying was never an option for me. I explained the situation to my step-sister, and made my cousin the god-mother.

Posted 1/10/11 8:10 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
okay, another WWYD... I find this odd... Kara 10/3/07 32 Home
WWYD? Neighbors dog left out in rain...I am so upset Goobster 9/11/07 19 Pets
WWYD? Buyers and realtors, a question. greenfreak 9/5/07 7 Home
WWYD? about the hotel we stayed at on my vacation DanaRenee 5/1/07 4 Travel & Vacations
WWYD? Etiquette related. greenfreak 4/19/07 31 Families Helping Families ™
xpost: old bff comes out of the wood worx wwyd? need some more opinions Nicole728 1/7/07 10 Families Helping Families ™