|
WWYD? long!
Posted 1/9/2011 8:35:54 PM by anonymous20 WWYD regarding this situation we have 2 people that we want as Godparents (always thought these 2 people would be it never thought of backups, etc) then we found out that my church says that at least one Godparent has to have made all 3 sacraments and the other has to be of a Christian religion and they could be the witness One of our choices (my childhood bff) is not catholic (lutheran) and the other only made bap & communion (you need to also make confirmation as well to be a God parent) So either of our choices can be the witness but neither can 'truly' be God parent bc neither made all 3 sacraments the church doesn't ask for proof of making the sacraments So my question is, would you try to find someone else to be the Godparent that has made all 3 sacraments and use one of our choices of Godparents as our witness or just go w/our 2 choices since the church will not check (each of our choices are equally as important to me and dh so it's so hard to pick one over the other, kwim?) we feel these are the best people for our LO i have asked family and friends what to do about this and i have gotten such mixed answers--some say yes-without a 2nd thought and others say that one of our choices has made 2 sacraments so that they are, in other words 'Catholic' enough.....i have one friend who said she is picking her bro who has made all 3 sacraments and doesn't even believe in GOD...so im like at least my choice w/2 sacraments believes in GOD!! i am so torn--i don't want to be dishonest to the Church but at the same time I feel like i should pick the 2 people that r the best fit for my LO so sorry this was so long and thanks for reading this WWYD? |