When would you start older DD in Kindergarten

Forum Opinion Poll
when she is first eligible 27 81.82%
I would hold her back a year 6 18.18%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted By Message

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

WWYD--delaying kindergarten

I know this has come up in general before, but was hoping for some opinions on this situation.

My daughters are 13 months apart, but one is dec, 1 is jan. Where we live, they would be 2 years apart in school. I really want them 1 year apart because they are very close, and 2 years apart in school will make a big difference. Also, I much prefer sending my daughter off to college at 18 as opposed to 17. To me, I think that year is important in terms of responsibility.

I am a late November bday. I did great academically, but I bet socially, I may have done better if I was older. I can't be sure if it was just my personality (I was a shy kid) or if it was my age.

Financially, it would be easier to send DD to K when she is eligible. But, in the long run, is saving that money really worth it?

WWYD?

Posted 10/26/11 1:06 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Hmmm - I think that if she wasn't ready for it then I would hold her back.

I would not hold her back to only keep her one grade from her sister. They will most likely have different friends anyway.

Long term, you will less time with the two of them in college at once.

Posted 10/26/11 1:10 PM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

No offense meant. But I would not hold back a child for the reasons you have listed.

If socially, or academically she was not ready, then I would. But not b/c you want certain things for her.

Posted 10/26/11 1:14 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

I would hold back the Dec 1st child UNLESS she was extremely social and seemed like she needed to be in kindergarten. I see some of the younger kids in DD's class and to me they seem so much more "babyish" for want of a better term than the kids that are already 5 and older.

BUT its a decision only you can make as you know your child.

Good luckChat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 1:16 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Honestly, no - for the reasons you listed, I would not hold her back.

I am not sure I understand your reasoning - why is 2 years apart in school such a big deal?

Posted 10/26/11 1:16 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

I would never hold a child a child back. I am 12/26 bday my ds is mid September. He is going when he is supposed to. I was 17 when I finished my first semester in college. Socially I was behind,mainly bc i was the last one of my friends to DTD. I hope my ds is the same wayChat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 1:19 PM
 

twobabies
Praying

Member since 7/05

9662 total posts

Name:
Mrs. Honeybee

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

my kids are 20 months apart. My dd is a late november bday as well. I sent her as soon as she was eligible. She was ready in all aspects. Technically my dc could have been only a year apart in school as well (they are two). I say if your dc is ready. Do it. Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 1:21 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by Straightarrow

No offense meant. But I would not hold back a child for the reasons you have listed.

If socially, or academically she was not ready, then I would. But not b/c you want certain things for her.



Agree. DD is one of the youngest in her class as was I (both November babies). I liked that I graduated at 17. I also didn't feel socially younger than my older peers. I wouldn't hold her back for the reasons you stated.

Posted 10/26/11 1:24 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by Karen

Honestly, no - for the reasons you listed, I would not hold her back.

I am not sure I understand your reasoning - why is 2 years apart in school such a big deal?



It's not that 2 years is a big deal. It's that it doesn't reflect what they are. They are really just about 1 year apart. They are intellectually and socially very similar right now. You would never look at them or be around them and see kids that are 2 years apart. I'm worried that them being 2 years apart in school would change them to seem 2 years apart. I'm not even sure it matters if it does--it's just a forced change in their relationship that doesn't reflect reality. Does that make any sense?

Posted 10/26/11 1:27 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

In this circumstance, I would never hold a child back for any of those reasons listed,esp re the closeness of your two children. I dont think that is fair to the older child honestly. Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 1:59 PM
 

ABCiverson
<3 my family

Member since 1/06

7465 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

I would only hold back if she wasn't ready. My girls are 14 months apart(4 and 5 years old now) and they will be 2 grades apart too. My oldest is 5 and just started kindergarten this year and was beyond ready. I couldn't imagine holding her back. I actually feel bad for my 4 year old daughter because I feel like she is up to par with with my 5 year old and I hate that she won't be starting school next year.

I graduated when I was 17 so thats not a worry for me.

Posted 10/26/11 2:05 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by mamabear

Posted by Karen

Honestly, no - for the reasons you listed, I would not hold her back.

I am not sure I understand your reasoning - why is 2 years apart in school such a big deal?



It's not that 2 years is a big deal. It's that it doesn't reflect what they are. They are really just about 1 year apart. They are intellectually and socially very similar right now. You would never look at them or be around them and see kids that are 2 years apart. I'm worried that them being 2 years apart in school would change them to seem 2 years apart. I'm not even sure it matters if it does--it's just a forced change in their relationship that doesn't reflect reality. Does that make any sense?



I wouldn't do it for the reasons you listed. If anything, you holding one back so they can be only 1 yr apart in school is a "forced change" since you are in essence taking things into your own hands and changing their timelines. It's not about relecting what they are (about what, 13 months apart) but about reflecting WHO they are. If your DD is ready for kindergarten at age 4, you should send her and do what it best for HER without regard to the fact that your other DD will be 2 yrs behind in school. They are each their own person, and don't need to be only 1 yr apart in school. I think you should think about what it is that really bothers you and what you fear happening, if your one DD starts at age 4. Once you understand what is truly motivating you, then make a decision based solely on what is best for your child.

As for starting college at 17 vs 18, 18 yr olds can still be immature. 1 yr may or may not change that. You are trying to control too much and they haven't even grown up yet.

Posted 10/26/11 2:09 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by Goobster

In this circumstance, I would never hold a child back for any of those reasons listed,esp re the closeness of your two children. I dont think that is fair to the older child honestly. Chat Icon



fair? i'm trying to do what's in her best interest, it's just hard to know what that is in advance.

Posted 10/26/11 2:09 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by mamabear

Posted by Karen

Honestly, no - for the reasons you listed, I would not hold her back.

I am not sure I understand your reasoning - why is 2 years apart in school such a big deal?



It's not that 2 years is a big deal. It's that it doesn't reflect what they are. They are really just about 1 year apart. They are intellectually and socially very similar right now. You would never look at them or be around them and see kids that are 2 years apart. I'm worried that them being 2 years apart in school would change them to seem 2 years apart. I'm not even sure it matters if it does--it's just a forced change in their relationship that doesn't reflect reality. Does that make any sense?



Makes prefect sense, my kids are 20 months apart. If I held my mid sept born child back they would only be one year apart. For some reason it really bugs mevthey will be 2 years apart in school, I really wish they were gonna be one year apart.

Posted 10/26/11 2:34 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by mamabear

Posted by Goobster

In this circumstance, I would never hold a child back for any of those reasons listed,esp re the closeness of your two children. I dont think that is fair to the older child honestly. Chat Icon



fair? i'm trying to do what's in her best interest, it's just hard to know what that is in advance.



But none of the reasons you listed seem to be in her best interest, IMO. I am just being honest. It seems you are more concerned about what you think will be an issue, which you really have no clue what the future holds.

I personally see no difference b/w an 18 year old and a 17 year old going to college. None at all, re a persons maturity and decision making skills.

And the only other real issue you seemed to be concerned with is the fact that your two children are close right now, but you fear they will not be if they are 2 years apart in school. You dont know if this will effect their relationship, but IMO, even if it did, thats just the way things go. I dont think its fair to hold a child from moving on, changing, and growing as school will do to a child, to keep a relationship the way it currently exists. Thats why I used the word fair.

Posted 10/26/11 2:39 PM
 

SRM12
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/11

711 total posts

Name:
Samantha

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

No. Not in your situation. those are NOT good reasons to delay kindergarten.

Posted 10/26/11 2:41 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by pnbplus1

Posted by mamabear

Posted by Karen

It's not about relecting what they are (about what, 13 months apart) but about reflecting WHO they are. If your DD is ready for kindergarten at age 4, you should send her and do what it best for HER without regard to the fact that your other DD will be 2 yrs behind in school. They are each their own person, and don't need to be only 1 yr apart in school. I think you should think about what it is that really bothers you and what you fear happening, if your one DD starts at age 4. Once you understand what is truly motivating you, then make a decision based solely on what is best for your child.

As for starting college at 17 vs 18, 18 yr olds can still be immature. 1 yr may or may not change that. You are trying to control too much and they haven't even grown up yet.



See- but who they are, at least right now is the same as what they are. if anything, they seem much closer than kids even one year apart. My little one would probably be ready for kindergarten a year early. But she misses the cut off by 8 days, whereas my older one just makes the cut off. If we lived in most other places, they would be one year apart. It's not that I'm trying to manipulate things or holding one back to benefit the other. Cut offs are arbitrary and vary from location to location. I'm trying to put blinders on to the calendar year and cut offs and see where my kids belong. Then trying to figure out how/if I should do that, or if I should just stick with the "rules" of this particular location.


Posted 10/26/11 2:44 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

My birthday is December 21st and I entered Kindergarten early. . .I would have been really upset if my parents held me back.

I always thrived, was top of my class, even Valedictorian of my elementary school . . . if I had been a year behind in graduating, and for other milestones - I think I would have noticed and been upset.

Also, I think having a little distance is better - having your own friends, not sharing boys, that kind of thing Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 2:47 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by mamabear

See- but who they are, at least right now is the same as what they are. if anything, they seem much closer than kids even one year apart. My little one would probably be ready for kindergarten a year early. But she misses the cut off by 8 days, whereas my older one just makes the cut off. If we lived in most other places, they would be one year apart. It's not that I'm trying to manipulate things or holding one back to benefit the other. Cut offs are arbitrary and vary from location to location. I'm trying to put blinders on to the calendar year and cut offs and see where my kids belong. Then trying to figure out how/if I should do that, or if I should just stick with the "rules" of this particular location.



Since your youngest only misses the cut off by 8 days, I would rather see her tested and push her "ahead" (assuming she is ready) than hold the other one back.

No matter what the cut-off, some kids will make it and some won't.

Message edited 2011-10-26 14:59:01.557000.

Posted 10/26/11 2:50 PM
 

ddunne2
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Doreen

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

I would base it on the child and she is ready to go, she should go. It is what it is...there will always be the kids that just make and just miss the cutoffs. Here in OH the cutoff is Sept 30, so my two oldest kids are both October birthdays, so they both miss the cutoff by days. To me it felt wierd growing up in NY when the cutoff was Dec, but that is what they feel helps students do the best, so I didn't try to test son to enter early.

My 3rd is a July birthday so she'll start what will feel like a whole year earlier than her siblings and be a younger child in the class.

Unless there are real academic or social reasons to delay, I would not.

Posted 10/26/11 2:59 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by mamabear

Posted by Goobster

In this circumstance, I would never hold a child back for any of those reasons listed,esp re the closeness of your two children. I dont think that is fair to the older child honestly. Chat Icon



fair? i'm trying to do what's in her best interest, it's just hard to know what that is in advance.



i totally get what you are saying but by the time she is in middle/high school, she might want the larger seperation ... her own friends etc.

coming from a twin who shared everything her entire life Chat Icon the 2 year difference is not a bad thing. it will give them room to grow independantly Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/11 3:01 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

My boys are 2 years apart and I want them to experience things seperately. I like that they have different friends, interests etc.

Posted 10/26/11 3:09 PM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: WWYD--delaying kindergarten

Posted by maymama

Posted by mamabear

Posted by Goobster

In this circumstance, I would never hold a child back for any of those reasons listed,esp re the closeness of your two children. I dont think that is fair to the older child honestly. Chat Icon



fair? i'm trying to do what's in her best interest, it's just hard to know what that is in advance.



i totally get what you are saying but by the time she is in middle/high school, she might want the larger seperation ... her own friends etc.

coming from a twin who shared everything her entire life Chat Icon the 2 year difference is not a bad thing. it will give them room to grow independantly Chat Icon



that is helpful to know. thank you!

Posted 10/26/11 3:47 PM